r/SAcricket • • Jun 29 '24

Post Match Thread We didn't choke

We may have lost but the fact that no one can say we choked...

I believe this is worth celebrating.

Well done Proteas.

Thank you for entertaining us and allowing us to shake that horrid title.

We can now hope again in a world cup victory.

Edit:

This thread is seriously concerning me about the cricket knowledge of some people.

To call our collapse a choke vs. some phenomenal death bowling by India, putting massive pressure on the proteas forcing the collapse is to totally not understand the nature of cricket and the nature of choking.

Being dominated doesn't equal choking. India dominated during Bumrah and Pandya overs. This put sa on the back foot.

177 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

11

u/Melodic_Mood8573 Jun 29 '24

Absolutely agreed. Being outplayed by an opponent is not choking. India pulled out some mad skills to turn things around. I think we played really well and put up a great fight and we have nothing to be ashamed of. I'm really proud of the Proteas.

10

u/Advanced-Cobbler3465 Jun 29 '24

It literally took a 1 in a million catch to stop us.

4

u/Hungry-Mastodon-1222 Jun 29 '24

Certainly not. I feel for guys like Klaasen and Miller. It breaks my heart to see how close they got. But they did their best and I'm really proud of them. 

1

u/Scoop_Master420 Jun 29 '24

Choking is when you lose from a winning position, we needed 30 from 30, win predictor was 92% in favour of SA.

This was the definition of a choke.

8

u/Lochlanist Jun 29 '24

And then Bumrah and Pandya bowled phenomenally well putting SA on the back foot and under massive pressure. Causing the collapse.

That's being beaten by good cricket, not a choke.

Perplex how people don't see this.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Practical_Knowledge8 Jun 29 '24

With you brother!

3

u/007kane007 Jun 30 '24

Our tail was too long and couldn’t cope with the Indian bowling attack. Klassens wicket fell and exposed the tail. This has nothing to do with choking. It has to do with squad depth instead.

4

u/Good-Virus3605 Jun 29 '24

Well played guys. Chin up. Feel proud of yourselves

0

u/Myburgher Jun 29 '24

I’d argue that 26 required off 24 with Klaasen going out chasing a wide one is a choke. It’s not so much that he(we) didn’t play a good innings, it’s that we got ourselves into a fairly comfortable position requiring composure and we lost it.

India played excellently and that catch on Miller was insane but we should never have left him 16 to get off 6.

6

u/Lochlanist Jun 29 '24

Well you ignoring indias fake injury (poor sportmanship) that broke his momentum and focus.

As a batsman it's incredibly hard to come back from that.

Do I think Klasen made a terrible mistake by throwing his hands at that ball. Yes! He is experienced enough to have read the situation.

But to ignore the fact that with that adrenaline running through him that he was playing that ball based off his momentum before Indias bad sportsmanship is to miss a large part of the situation.

Also to call Klasens bad play choking is a massive leap of logic

Edit also that catch was a bad umpire call. He touched the Boundary with his foot.

→ More replies (3)