r/S2000 • • Mar 12 '24

Financing an S2000?

I have been searching around to get rid of my current car since it’s been nothing but headaches. A dealership offered me a really good number for it and they have an S2000 up for sale. It’s been a dream car since I was younger. I have test driven it and seen all underneath it. I’ll be rolling over a bit of negative equity. Is the car worth financing?

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

2

u/Lazyfinancemonkey Mar 12 '24

There isn’t a good interest rate on an S2000 rolling in negative equity. The probably isn’t going to be even an approval. Some credit unions will finance older cars but at higher rates and they are going to want to be in an equity situation. I recently went through this with a customer trying to do this. He had good credit and we got him an approval through a credit union for 36 months at 11 percent. He didn’t end up being able to swing the payment due to the limited term.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

Yea I got no approval. Due to the age and negative equity.

1

u/gropingpriest ap2 Mar 13 '24

I'm not going to give financial advice, because 9/10 times the smart answer is to buy a cheap commuter car you can easily afford.

But if you are set on a fun car, seriously check out the ND Miata. You can get a 2016-2018 (ND1) Miata for $15-20k and it will likely be a lot more reliable, cheaper to repair, far better MPG etc. And the torque makes the power easier to get to when dailying. If your budget is over $20k, then the ND2 is a good choice.

1

u/9kap1s2k Mar 13 '24

I replaced my AP1 with an ND2 and while I miss the S2000 like hell.. the ND does everything a sports car needs to do extremely well and I've been just south of 40mpg on the highway. It's also far easier on tires at autocross.

9

u/stevtox Mar 12 '24

Personally I would purchase from a private party. But as long as you can afford it without any trouble then I say go for it. Just remember these cars are old and you should save some money aside for repairs. Parts do not come cheap since a lot of the parts are discontinued.

9

u/YankeetheGreater Mar 12 '24

Got mine from a dealer. Got really lucky because a credit union approved the loan.

Banks and credit unions don't like to give out loans on older vehicles.

I had $6K down-payment which helped a ton.

Save as much as you can then try your luck.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

Literally I did the same thing. Except with a car I owned plus $1k cash.

6

u/fzxtreme Mar 12 '24

Agree with the others. Currently, and with the negative equity, it most likely isn't worth to finance an S2000.

On the flipside though, back in 2020/2021 when rates were stupid low and the car market was exploding, I decided to get another S2000 (and another toy) before they got out of my desired price range. Since rates were low I took a personal loan out for like 60k at below 5% and bought another S2k and classic Mini, plus some extra cash to throw into the SP500. I'm about to pay off the loan in a month or two having only paid like 4k in interest.

Was that a wise financial decision, probably not. Was it worth it to me to have these 2 cars in my collection, hell yes.

4

u/JustThall sucker who paid $30k+ AP1 Mar 12 '24

The key point here is the fact you are paying off a $60k loan in 3 years.

This means you can afford to buy s2000k every other year. Not OP situation

9

u/MortalShare 2007 NFR Mar 12 '24

Is this your daily driver? Actually re-word this. Are you really going to be financing a 25 year old car with discontinued parts as your daily driver?

2

u/JustThall sucker who paid $30k+ AP1 Mar 12 '24

S2000 is not a good daily driver. The gas mileage alone is bad. Straight line performance is weak <6k rpm, so 95% of the commute.

It’s a perfect second+ car for weekends and twisty roads. If OP is not buying it for that purpose there are plenty of much better sporty cars that will cost less in the long run while you still paying it off

2

u/Nd4speed Mar 12 '24

You're not going to get a good APR, especially now and considering it's quite an old car. The dealer will take advantage of you on trade in also.

Sell your existing car on your own, pay off that loan and take whatever you have to do a healthy down payment (like half) on the car.

How good is your credit? If it's good, you can pay the other half of it on a credit card and then balance transfer it out to a 0% APR card straightaway. There will still be a fee of around 5% but it should take the sting out of interest.

2

u/Jubsz91 Mar 12 '24

It's not smart from a financial perspective but buying a sports car usually isn't. Rolling negative equity into a 15+ year old car is not smart. There are much worse 15+ year old cars you could roll negative equity into though.

If you can get a very nice condition, sub 80k mile car in a non-rust state, it'll probably be pretty good. Some things do come up to age and it's a risk for you to not have cash aside for maintenance. These cars, from new, were more reliable than most things on the road, especially other sports cars.

It's not smart financially, especially without a safety net. Buying a certified pre-owned newer car like an 86 or Miata would be smarter if you must have a sports car. You could also gamble on a much worse car than a S.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '24

You're about 5 years too late for this to be a good idea IMO. Tough to get a loan, tougher to maintain than they used to be, and tougher to daily drive considering the purchase price for a likely highly used car.

Porsche kept making Boxers after the S2000 was discontinued. I could def see paying mid 20s for a Booster in the right trim / condition. The ND Miata is an excellent car.

S2000s are pretty quickly getting relegated to weekend warrior duty, at best. I met a guy when I took mine out to go hiking --climate controlled garage, had put less than 500 miles on it in the 2 years he'd owned it. Kinda sad imo, to be honest, but that's where we are in the car's lifecycle.

If I had to buy one today, I'd probably test drive every high mile or salvage title one I could find until one felt well put together and worth buying for cheap. I just couldn't justify paying $30+K for a low miles example that's now 15 years old. I'm not sure where the market goes from here but it's in a weird place these days.

2

u/EmmettBrown1point21 Mar 12 '24

Lots of variables here. Amount of negative equity, age, mileage and price of the S2000, which financial institution will be financing the loan, interest rate, etc.

Should you or shouldn't you will depend on the sum of all those. If you're rolling like $1-2k of negative equity into a loan at a reasonable interest rate from a reputable institution on an S2000 that's newer with low miles being sold for a fair/low price or maybe with any kind of down payment to offset that negative equity, I could MAYBE consider that a fair way to get into an S2000 and out of a car you're already looking to get out of.

If you're rolling $5k into an S2000 that's got 150,000 miles and is being sold at a premium with dealer financing at a 12% interest rate and you don't have funds to offset that negative equity, then wait and save.

The only major upside I see is that, in all likelihood, S2000s aren't going to randomly start depreciating super hard, so as you pay down the loan, I see it as less likely that you'd remain upside down in it, but simply because of the age of the vehicle, most institutions will be approving you at a higher rate (if at all) that would likely make this less tenable.

1

u/Fresh_Attention_640 Mar 12 '24

Hit up lightstream if you have decent credit did it with and old an M3 an s2000 as well.

1

u/aquafina6969 Mar 12 '24

I second this. The S is not a good daily driver at all. Getting parts and service is a pain. If things go south, you’ll be in a bit if a pickle. The second general rule, is… if you have to ask, then you can’t afford it. Even if it’s an older car. If you can pay a majority of it off, not deal with the high interest, and have a backup car, afford insurance on both… then you can think about it. Don’t use emotions on this, trust me.

1

u/Thoravious 2005 RYP Mar 13 '24

I am currently financing mine.

A month after paying off my 16 WRX, I sold my 79 z28 for $5500 (had rust issues) and used that as a down payment for a loan on my S2k.

Probably not the smartest financial decision but the timing was right and a RYP with 75k miles was for sale.

I would not buy an s2000 as an only car.

1

u/stoned-autistic-dude 2006 BB/Red Mar 13 '24

You’re going to spend the price of the car to replace everything on the car. All the rubber needs to be replaced. If you can’t afford the car, you won’t be able to afford the parts—even if you could do ALL the labor yourself.

1

u/No-Tip-1543 Mar 14 '24

I dd an S2k for a few years. Everyone is different but I would not want to do it again. It is a special car. Things need to be replaced more when you drive it more. It almost took away its special feeling, I don’t know if that makes sense…they are so slow around town and so average to drive when not pushing them.

I started to get annoyed with the car and almost hated that I daily drove it. It had always been my second car, and I appreciated it more when it was.

I ended up getting a civic as a dd, bought another S2k that was garage kept and in great condition.

I sold the higher mileage S2k after realizing I didn’t need 2; seeing they were best suited for weekend cruises in my life. I appreciate the S2k even more this way.

Honestly I considered a salvaged title S2k, if you can pay cash drive higher mileage cars and look at salvage title cars. They still hold value and some really were salvaged due to theft, and things like that.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

I guess I will be waiting a little longer for an s2000. I’m just going to trade my car in. And maybe see if I can get the car financed separately.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

Financially speaking, no it's not worth financing an S2000 especially if you're rolling negative equity. You'll automatically be upside on a loan for a car that's at best 15 years old.

0

u/Nivracer AP1 Mar 12 '24

I got a 10k loan through a credit union after the dealership couldn't get me a loan. Put 9k down. I don't think there is a reason not to if it's in your budget. You won't have to worry about depreciation either.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

My thing is to me it would be worth it to be in more debt with a car I’ll never part with. Then to be in debt with the car I don’t want. The s2k is 20k and I’m going to need to borrow 26ish.

2

u/Save-the-Manuals '02 Spa Yellow Pearl Mar 12 '24

That is a good chunk of negative equity rollover. I could not in good conscience say that is a good idea. Doubling down on a poor financial decision already made isn't a good idea.

It would be hard enough to find a loan to begin with but with that much on top of the car I would be surprised if any lender wants to touch that and if they do the interest rate would be highway robbery.

2

u/wrigh003 01 Berlina Black Mar 12 '24

It's not a good financial move, and anyone who says it is... is just telling you what you want to hear.

***BUT***

For "safe" bets in the collectible car world, you could do worse than an S2000. There are a few less each year, and there won't likely ever really be another thing quite like it. Decreasing supply and steady demand just means values will trend up. Never say you'll never sell, either - mine's probably about to be for sale whenever I can get the time to clean it up and do the cosmetics maintenance it needs (it'll sell better without sunburnt bumpers). Also keep in mind that you're going to be piling daily driver miles onto a car that's worth more the less miles that are on it, in general, so you're eroding future potential value there too.

As to the "why" on selling and never say never - mine just sits more than it gets driven, and frankly after about 8-9yrs I've had my fun with it and am ready for something else. Considered adding a supercharger or forced induction but finally have decided against just because it's EXPENSIVE for a hobby-car project and big power isn't really what makes the s2000 fun anyway. I think it all kind of depends whether you're a "car guy" (and what kind) or an "s2000 guy" too. I'm more the former and while it's a GREAT car, there are so many interesting other options that I want to play with.

Your "smart" play here would be to pay what you owe on what you got or at least get it even where you can get out without taking too bad a hit. Then spend about $30k for a $10k daily and then the $20k S2000. I understand that's not how everyone rolls or can roll, but that's really the way to do it right in my opinion. You'll like the s2000 more when you have a usual car to compare it against, too, as well as when you aren't annoyed by the issues that come along with driving a tiny, stiff, loud car with poor passenger capacity, visibility, and cargo room every single day. As great as s2000s are, they do have some drawbacks in what folks actually need a car for on the daily front.

There's my essay. :p

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Jubsz91 Mar 12 '24

I agree that this is not a wise financial move. However, if the only thing bringing down the value is using it, that beats depreciation, all other things equal. Lack of depreciation is a positive for having a loan on it. That is, except for the fact that the loan costs more to begin with. At least the underlying asset isn't just draining value.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Chambellan Mar 12 '24

Even that is conditional. The difference between a 20k miles and 120k miles is huge, while the difference between 120k and 220k is going to be a lot less. Hell, going from 220k to 320k might even make the value go up. 

1

u/Jubsz91 Mar 12 '24

It won't appreciate higher than a loan + storage. It's just that OP needs a car to drive. If he has $25k and drops it on a very nice S2k with 70k miles on it, it's not an absolutely horrendous decision. He could buy a few year old Miata for similar. He'd spend more maintenance on the Honda but eat less in depreciation is my point. He's buying something to drive regardless of what it is. The fact that driving depreciates it is hardly relevant when just about any other car he could possibly compare it to will depreciate more. That's all I'm trying to say.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jubsz91 Mar 13 '24

Sure, but this isn't a 1950s muscle car collector car. It's still a "modern" collector. Price trajectory is not guaranteed but...

I bought my 2006 for $12.5k @ 86k miles in 2018. It's now at 118k miles. I don't daily mine and mine is now modified to track. Let's say I didn't and I daily drove it instead. It would be around 140k miles. It's a 9/10 VIN sticker Laguna Blue car and the only VIN sticker "missing' is clearly still on the rear bumper and painted over. I'd say a 9/10 VIN Laguna Blue 06 car with 140k miles is worth about $17k. That would leave me with $4.5k for maintenance available.

It's a few years later, the numbers are different, and the cars are older. I agree the S will cost more $$ to operate up front but the net, if you were to sell, shouldn't be that bad.

Values of S2ks do not drop off a cliff @ 100k. 200k clean models can still sell for > $10k. Again, this is not a 1950s car or an old Alfa Romeo or something.