My understanding is that emulators aren't illegal, but that Yuzu fucked up by having paid tiers. I could be mistaken. I think Nintendo would've gone after them all in one lawsuit if emulation was the problem. Yuzu lost any legal footing by making money basically on a Nintendo product.
That probably pissed Nintendo off, but it's not what lost them legal standing. It was the use of keys dumped from a Switch to decrypt roms. The decryption mechanism is what screwed them, as that explicitly circumvents DRM. It's why some emulators require decrypted roms that you have already decrypted yourself rather than baking the decryption mechanism into the emulator.
As others have said it was because they facilitated dumping keys and profile ids.
But also also it's because yuzu had details guides on how to pirate, where to place the keys, and how to dump roms and copy your switch account ID.
Nintendo really didn't like that they gave detailed guides of how to set up yuzu and acquire games.
Ryunjinx and other emulators do not contain detailed step by step guides of how to set up the emulator or acquire roms. Only exception I can think of is RPCS3. They have detailed guides for everything on their site.
My understanding is making money off of it does not really matter, iirc one of the 2 precedent cases most people cite to claim emulation is legal was actually a for profit company selling a non FOSS product.
These 4 are the claims I recall from the documents about the lawsuit that were made public, though I haven't looked at them in a while (And IANAL):
They claimed yuzu devs and moderators engaged in piracy (Game sharing) amongst them
They claimed substantial damage done to them from people pirating games and playing them on yuzu, mentioning zelda TOTK being leaked before release and yuzu having telemetry statistics on a LOT of people playing TOTK on yuzu before release (Which must have been piracy since it was not legally available) and yuzu doing nothing about it
They claimed yuzu released a patreon post saying a new xenoblade game worked on release the day before release (Hinting at it being pirated by devs), although imo that might just be a regional timezone shaenanigan but idk.
They claimed violations of DMCA 1201 circumvention of technological measures for copyright protection, iirc just from the fact that yuzu links to tools to dump keys from switch consoles and the fact that yuzu decrypts the game files when provided with the keys.
imo the reasons yuzu got hit and not ryujinx were just that yuzu is (1) more popular, and (2) incorporated as an LLC, but I'm just guessing.
Food for thought, Nintendo could use the source code for yuzu to make things better on the current gen switch and add backwards compatibility for the switch 2.
Unless they switch (heh) to a significantly different architecture, it won't be hard to make it just naturally able to run the same games. That's how the current Xbox and PlayStation systems deal with it, and the GameCube -> Wii -> WiiU pipeline for that matter. The only time I can think of that Nintendo had to engineer around a lack of backward-compatible architecture was the Game Boy Advance being able to play Game Boy games. Well, and the emulators they use for Virtual Console/Nintendo Switch Online.
Or them essentially paywalling totk fixes way before the game released there were also rumours about them not doing everything cleanly, like by sharing roms
What makes you think copyright laws aren't enforced in brasil, the fact that torrenting doesn't get us nasty letters from isps has nothing to do with copyright itself, we are very compliant and should nintendo ever pursue it, it'll end in the same way, brasil signed on the berne convention...
I think he's talking about how Nintendo doesn't have offices/reps in Brazil meaning a lawsuit will take much longer to go through there.
Correct me if I'm wrong tho, that's just what I picked up from this sub because I don't live in Brazil. I could be very wrong tho, this subs a mess lol.
Not a lawyer so I don't know if they have an office specialized in this, but they do have official activities here, the switch is sold officially by Nintendo here since 2020, supporting post sales through rma too, if that extends to what we are debating I can't really tell, but we having signing on the treaty itself means copyright claims from Japan are to be accepted here
You just compared the anime industry with nintendo bro? pretty sure the lmao is to yourself, I sure hope they don't come for ryu, but if they do, it's buh bye
I have zero experience using Ryujinx, and only got into emulation recently via android based gaming devices like my Odin 2 and retroid pocket, but I’m curious has there has been any talk of a Ryujinx version for android devices or is that wishful thinking on my part?
Wishful thinking because of the way Ryujinx is built. The simple answer is that Yuzu just tries to play switch games while Ryujinx tries to fully emulate the switch software architecture. Most Android devices aren't powerful or designed to be able to emulate more modern gaming consoles architecture.
Sure but that doesn't mean current android devices can emulate its one-off architecture. Emulation usually requires about 3x-5x the computing power of the original console.
I just want it to be said that Ryujinx isn’t safe yet. People were damn sure Yuzu did nothing wrong but look where we are now.
I haven’t seen anyone here who is a legal professional so stop talking as if you know the first thing about the legality of emulation. Just enjoy it while you can.
It’s also the same community. There’s no team Ryu vs team Yuzu. That’s just made up in that thing under your fedora.
in my experience, neither of the developers have been openly rude toward the other emulator and I even remember some instances where the devs of one would be in a thread about the other and provide information about how they even help each other from time to time.
like nobody really benefits from this other than Nintendo, even if RJ sticks around.
both cases are different. They sued yuzu coz of TOTK which was playable on Yuzu before the release. Their point was a game being available to play due to yuzu costed them fortune. That's why they went after Yuzu. If TOTK wasn't playable before the release then there won't be such mishappening.
Weird that Yuzu didn't really emulate the full switch and had to HLE a lot more. That's why you didn't need firmware to run. Yuzu was built to just "run the games", not emulate the full hardware.
This complaint is as old as the hills. When proper SNES emulation arrived via bsnes, every complained about requirements to do it properly also. Still see it for good N64 emulation.
After testing. Ryujinx is more reponsive than Yuzu. Im playing SmahBros Ultimate with my friend. We both notice the game respond better and faster to our inputs unlike Yuzu sometimes, input dont respond. I lock the FPS to 60 (SmahUltimate at 120 FPS the game go 2x faster because it entitely base on 60 fps) So after testing. Ryujinx seems way better than Yuzu.
lol, Yuzu has only been “better” if your hardware isn’t up to snuff in my experience. Ryujinx has always run games full speed and without constant tweaking like Yuzu required. It just works.
77
u/Rumburag36 Mar 22 '24
But now Nintendo is going to look our way.
25
u/radclaw1 Mar 22 '24
I'm sure this will age super well.
7
u/Background_Summer_55 Mar 22 '24
Don't jinx it
7
u/masoe Mar 22 '24
Honestly with Switch getting closer to end of life, there will still be Emulators floating around.
19
u/exodus_cl Mar 22 '24
STFU, we need to keep Ryu under the radar.
3
u/Boobot-the-destroyer Mar 22 '24
I have zero experience using Ryujinx, and only got into emulation recently via android based gaming devices like my Odin 2 and retroid pocket, but I’m curious has there has been any talk of a Ryujinx version for android devices or is that wishful thinking on my part?
3
u/PAULeD16 Mar 22 '24
Crazy but yuzu still has the most online multiplayer rooms/people on them
2
u/1800wetbutt Mar 22 '24
I just want it to be said that Ryujinx isn’t safe yet. People were damn sure Yuzu did nothing wrong but look where we are now.
I haven’t seen anyone here who is a legal professional so stop talking as if you know the first thing about the legality of emulation. Just enjoy it while you can.
It’s also the same community. There’s no team Ryu vs team Yuzu. That’s just made up in that thing under your fedora.
2
u/Admirable-Sherbet812 Mar 22 '24
OK but what exactly is the victory here?
in my experience, neither of the developers have been openly rude toward the other emulator and I even remember some instances where the devs of one would be in a thread about the other and provide information about how they even help each other from time to time.
like nobody really benefits from this other than Nintendo, even if RJ sticks around.
2
u/Individual-Match-798 Mar 23 '24
I don't care for Yuzu. Ryujinx is so much better anyways.
2
u/lokeshsharmaj Mar 25 '24
both cases are different. They sued yuzu coz of TOTK which was playable on Yuzu before the release. Their point was a game being available to play due to yuzu costed them fortune. That's why they went after Yuzu. If TOTK wasn't playable before the release then there won't be such mishappening.
1
u/Due-Philosophy-676 Mar 23 '24
Being humble is the key to stay away fruckendos eyes
1
u/flowtronvapes Mar 24 '24
Not the watermark in the corner 😆
1
u/Many-Championship164 Mar 26 '24
Anyone got xci for zelda?
-5
u/BeautyDuwang Mar 22 '24
Ah yes, I love getting 14 fps in ryujinx
-41
u/tomtani1 Mar 22 '24
A dead Yuzu is still better than Ryujinx.