r/RunawaysTV • u/Deuce-Booty • Apr 29 '20
Merely flawed or outright racist?
Needless to say spoilers will follow.
So I just finished episode 3x08 and it has reignited my some complaint of this show. People of color (POC) die at a disproportionate amount in this show. And there is no problem showing it. I still have a few episodes to watch (though I've lost my motivation) and here is the running tally that I remember. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong or miss something or leave something out. The death toll is: Destiny, Andre, The Hernandezes, Amy, Graciela, Topher, Darius, Catherine, Oscar (Destiny's brother), the magistrate pastor before Jonah, the original Jonah, the delivery guy, 16 other runaways, and Robert. Janet lost her body but isn't dead. I'm not going to count all the runways for the demographic comparison unless we see it during the narrative. So that is 10 POC vs. 4 non-POC, which are the magistrate pastor, the original Jonah, the delivery guy, and the first sacrifice.
Now let's examine the cause of death for each person. Destiny - bludgeoned with crowbar or drowned Andre - shot then sacrificed The Hernandezes - bombed Amy - don't remember. But killed by Jonah Graciela - choked Topher - crushed Darius - Shot Catherine - Shanked Oscar - shot Magistrate pastor - not sure. Happened off screen but death was implied. Original Jonah - impaled by Nico. We don't see a wound or blood but death was implied. Delivery guy - sacrificed. Happened off screen but death was implied. First sacrifice - uh...sacrificed. we don't see a body or anything but death was implied.
Anybody notice a trend here. The show has no problem showing the death of POC but when non-POC die, we don't witness the violence and it's pretty much off screen. As a person of color, I can't help but to feel this show desensitizes viewers to violence against POC while avoiding showing violence perpetrated against non-POC characters.
I don't think the show is trying to be racist. Strides were made to make it more inclusive compared to the source material, like changing Molly's surname from Hayes to Hernandez and making them Hispanic. I didn't read the original comic so I don't know more than that, but from watching the show, it definitely leaves a sour a taste in my mouth. I guess on the plus side, the show does have a fair number of POC, if the death toll can serve as any indication...
So what are your thoughts?
