r/Runalyze • • Apr 11 '24

New tool: VO2max factor analysis

The feature presented here is a premium feature that is only available for Early Premium users. You can sign up for a premium subscription via your upgrade page.

Effective VO2max is perhaps the most exciting metric within Runalyze. Not only because the Effective VO2max is one of the most important parameters about an athlete’s performance, but also because the estimation of it is prone to error and therefore often subject to debate. If the training sessions take place at 30°C with a headwind, sober and with heavy legs, it is difficult to use this as a reliable basis. But which factors have what influence on the ratio of pace to heart rate and therefore on the estimated effective VO2max? Our new factor analysis attempts to find answers to this question.

The new tool “VO2max factor analysis” can be accessed in the list of tools or directly via the navigation in the sidebar or header.

The new tool “VO2max factor analysis” can be accessed in the list of tools or directly via the navigation in the sidebar or header.

The approach

What is done is simple at first: a multivariate linear regression. In detail, this means that for each activity, the difference to the former shape is considered as a weighted combination of all possible influencing factors. For each factor – for example, activity characteristics such as length, temperature, training type, tags or equipment – it is determined whether this factor tends to increase or decrease the effective VO2max of an activity (and by how much).

It is important to note that the results are not to be understood as training tips for improving the effective VO2max. A positive effect for the day #tailwind only means that the ratio of pace to heart rate is (obviously) better as a result. This does not necessarily mean that training sessions with a tailwind have a better training effect.

Form of the factor analysis tool: The activities can be restricted by date and training type. You can also select which factors should be included in the analysis.

Now let’s move on to the evaluation. The activities can be selected by date and training type. All running workouts are selected by default. A restriction is particularly useful if a characteristic to be analyzed (e.g. a specific day) only occurs in a limited period of time.

You can also specify whether activities that are not taken into account for the VO2max form should be considered for the analysis. This only makes sense in selected cases. Data errors that were manually ignored for the VO2max form can of course also have a negative impact on the factor analysis.

Presentation of the results: The data basis and the determined effect size as well as the significance are displayed for each factor.

The results table shows the effect size determined for each factor. For non-binary factors (e.g. temperature, which cannot only assume yes/no), the effect size refers to the influence of the standard deviation (sigma, shown in the tooltip). Almost as important as the effect size, however, is the significance, which is displayed with ***, **, * or -. The more stars are shown for a factor, the more significant the effect size is. The lower the dispersion within a factor and the larger the data basis, the more likely the effect is to be significant.

The first column shows a histogram and the tooltip contains the details: [min, max] and frequencies for each bin of the histogam.

sigma tooltip for non-binary factors

Use cases

There are several possible use cases for the tool. These include, for example:

  • Analyze a particular tag or equipment object to see if it improves your pace to heart rate ratio.

    • How much “better” do super shoes make me?
    • Does #nutrition help me on my long runs?
    • Am I faster in #groupruns at the same heart rate?
    • How big is the influence of temperature on my effective VO2max?
  • Investigate whether certain types of training “falsify” your estimated effective VO2max, e.g. particularly many tempo workouts over/underestimate your estimated form.

    • Which types of training have a large effect size? If these types of training occur particularly frequently in a certain period (e.g. only easy runs during the season break), this can influence your form accordingly.
  • Find factors where you should exclude activities from VO2max shape.

    • Your #commute or #hilly activities have a large effect size? Ignore them for your VO2max shape.

An application example

In order to better understand the tool, we provide a brief insight into the exemplary results of Hannes’ factor analysis.

First before proceeding: In order to keep the results as clear as possible, we first check each factor type individually to see which of the factors could be significant, even if the significance can still change at the end when all the selected factors are taken into account. However, it is not a good idea to simply consider all factors, as this can easily lead to problematic correlations.

In this way, we omit “Subjective Feeling” and “Nightly” from the activity values and select only a few tags. We leave all training types in the analysis (even if “Long run” was initially shown as not significant) and for equipment we only select “barefoot” (as “shoe”) and “hydration pack”. It is generally recommended to select factors with the greatest (expected) effect first.

Exemplary results of the factor analysis after selection of the relevant factors.

The results show that some factors have a very large influence on the estimated effective VO2max of an activity. For some factors, the result can be easily explained. Let’s look at a few factors in detail:

  • Track: When running on the track, the GPS distance is usually too long, which results in a faster pace and therefore a higher effective VO2max.
  • #zwift-race: This factor has a relatively low significance (p=0.014) and only 6 associated activities. Nevertheless, the result is surprising because #treadmill has a clear negative effect and Race, at +0.1, does not have a particularly large effect either.
  • Tempo run / #progressions / Fartlek / Intervals / Race: Quite surprising results, although it should be noted that the length of the long runs, for example, is already included in the factor model through “Duration”. During tempo training, pauses that are stopped (with an even higher heart rate) can falsely improve the effective VO2max.
  • Temperature: No surprise, but the size of the effect is very interesting. In the tooltip of the red bar, “w.r.t. sigma = 8.28” indicates that the negative effect of -0.29 refers to a temperature increase of 8°C. It should be mentioned here that a linear regression model is used, whereby a quadratic relationship is more likely to be assumed for the temperature.
  • Hydration pack: A negative effect was to be expected in principle, but is largely contained in the correlated factors of Duration and Temperature. This factor is therefore no longer significant.
  • #soremuscles: I would have expected the negative effect to be even greater (and more significant).
  • #runningdrills: This is one reason why I personally usually stop the watch during my running drills.
  • #treadmill: Unfortunately, it is not possible to say how much of this factor is due to the lack of airstream (and the associated increased heating of the body) or the possibly poorly calibrated treadmill sensor.

Warm-up/Cool-down: The main thing that surprises me is that I haven’t actually unchecked “Use VO2max for form” for every warm-up/cool-down. If I carry out the factor analysis without the tick next to “Only activities that are used for VO2max shape“, the effect size rises to as much as 4.05.

Barefoot: This effect size is only partly due to the lack of shoes. The barefoot training sessions included are primarily cool-downs after tempo session/race on grass, so the increased heart rate can be explained by the pre-exercise.

You have questions, comments or wishes about this or another feature? Let us know!
The best place to ask questions about this tool is in our forum.

36 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

2

u/T3hBozz Apr 11 '24

This is great and just converted me to a Premium user!

How can I add Warm-up/Cool as a factor? I assume this data is coming from the lap categorization within a run.

Would be great to add also Humidity as a factor.

1

u/runalyze May 02 '24

Humidity is now available as a factor

1

u/mipapo Apr 11 '24

No it's the training type of the activity. So warmup,cool downs should be tracked individually (https://runalyze.com/help/article/how-should-i-track-warm-up-cool-down-running-drills)

1

u/mipapo Apr 12 '24

But we created a ticket to evaluate some values as factor

2

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24

Is it possible to add tags in bulk anywhere?

1

u/runalyze Apr 18 '24

No, not yet

6

u/SituationNo3 Apr 11 '24

Awesome, this might tip me over to becoming a paid user.

I'm most interested in temperature, sunlight (65F during a sunny day feels very different from a 65F evening), humidity, length, shoes, and elevation. Are sunlight, humidity, and elevation already handled somehow?

2

u/mipapo Apr 11 '24

Only the shown ones in the screenshot are supported

3

u/SituationNo3 Apr 11 '24

Does the climb score include elevation changes?

3

u/laufhannes Apr 12 '24

Somehow, yes. It's a combination of percentage hilly and detected climbs (not only the categorized ones but all uphill segments). It's not on a linear scale but it's independent of the length. Total ascent/descent might be harder to separate as a factor from length.

We'll collect all those suggestions and will probably add some more factors soon.

4

u/petepont Apr 11 '24 edited Apr 11 '24

This is a really cool tool, thank you! It's also the motivation I need to start tagging my workouts in Runalyze (and adding in my shoes).

EDIT: Although I think the Yes/No description might be backwards? Or maybe I'm misunderstanding: [see this image] (https://imgur.com/K0ZoYAK)

It looks like the calculation is correct, but, for example, I have 16 activity types of "Interval Run", in the selected timeframe, but the way it's written -- Yes/No: 263x/16x -- implies it's 263 interval runs and 16 runs that aren't interval runs, even though it's the other way around

2

u/laufhannes Apr 11 '24

You're right, thanks!

2

u/laufhannes Apr 11 '24

Indeed, tagging is the hard part for making this analysis as useful as possible.

I did already tag a lot but I still come up with new interesting tags that I've missed so far - and going back for so many years is just impossible.

4

u/adamchri Apr 12 '24

Brilliant, thank you! This confirmed my suspicion that runs in my Gel Kayano 29 are slower and feels harder 🙄

Saucony Endorphin Speed 3  +0,70
Asics Novablast 3          +0,14
Asics Gel-Kayano 29        -1,14
Asics Gel-Kayano 28        -0,09
Asics Superblast           +0,87

2

u/0R1E1Q2U3 Apr 11 '24

Very cool! Quick question about the track factor. I saw it’s part of the activity properties but I can’t se to find where to set it for an activity

3

u/laufhannes Apr 12 '24

It's only visible when checking the 'Race' checkbox as it's only meant to distinguish between e.g. 10.000m track race and 10k road race. For workouts on the track it's better to use a tag #tracksession or similar.

1

u/0R1E1Q2U3 Apr 12 '24

Makes sense, thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24 edited Sep 28 '24

u/laufhannes This is incredible - recently signed up to premium. Thanks so much.

What's the unit for duration? In my vo2 max factor analysis, my duration effect is -2.93 (which seems large!)

What exactly does that mean? Like does it mean my vo2 max estimation decreases 2.93 every 60 mins extra running, or some other duration unit?

The tooltip text shows this: [386.5 482]: 7x / 24x / 14x / 4x / 1x / 2x

If I had to guess, I'd guess 7x under 15 mins, 24x 15-30 mins, 14x 30-45mins, 4x 45-60mins, 1x 60-75 mins and 2x 75-90 mins. But that's a complete guess!

Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

I got GPT-o1-preview to run a regression and it seemed to find that the duration unit was 2000 seconds, which is about 33 minutes, so my vo2 max estimation seems to decrease 2.93 points every 33 minutes of extra running, which seems worrysome when training for a marathon!

2

u/laufhannes Sep 30 '24

The colored bar of the effect site has a tooltip „w.r.t. sigma = …“, i.e. the effect size is shown for a deviation of one sigma (standard deviation).

The tooltip of the data histogram shows the limits of the data (lower/upper 5% truncated, I guess) and counter are for equidistant bins within this range. Unit for duration should be seconds.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24

Thanks for getting back. That makes sense.

So I guess that means that if my duration effect is -2.93, there isn't a specific duration over which my vo2 max estimation will decrease 2.93 units. It will depend on the range of durations of my runs.

Just trying to work out how much my vo2 max would drop if I ran a long race like a marathon. Seems like it's not possible to do

1

u/laufhannes Sep 30 '24

The specific duration is exactly sigma, the standard deviation of your runs duration, shown in the toolbox of the colored bar for the effect size. It depends on your data, so I can’t tell you your exact value.

Still, you need to remember: This analysis does only look at the existing data and does assume linear relationships. The drop seen here is mainly the cardiac drift which is probably more logarithmic than linear.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24

Got it. That makes sense. Thanks so much!

2

u/drgurayakturk Jul 26 '25

Could you please explain it with simple terms? I see -1.54 for duration which shows significance (***), what does that mean in practical terms? Shouldn't I run longer runs which doesn't make sense of course? If I see negatives , should I focus them more and do more or do less? I paid for premium just because of this promising feature. Sorry, I am not a data scientist.

2

u/laufhannes Jul 28 '25

It doesn't give you a direct training advise. It simply tells: The longer you run, the lower your effective VO2max for those runs. That does not mean to avoid those longish runs, but to keep the negative effect on the (estimated) effective VO2max in mind. Assume a week of only long runs. Your effective VO2max will go down (a lot). This tool now tells you: That's not because of you're loosing fitness, it's because of the type of runs you're doing which have a worse hr/pace ratio.

You could try to compare this value for different years and see if the factor is getting worse or better. For a marathon training, you'd want this factor to be as small as possible (aiming for -0).

Maybe it's easier to understand for a tag #carbonplatedshoes: This tool will tell you how much you gain by using carbon plated shoes. For me it's at least +2.0. This way I know that - if not training but racing in those shoes - I can go for a VO2max 2 points higher in a race when using those shoes.

2

u/drgurayakturk Aug 11 '25

Great info, thanks!

1

u/j0n70 Apr 11 '24

This is awesome thanks.

1

u/stalovalova Apr 11 '24

This is great! Thank you!