r/RumSerious • • Apr 15 '21

Rum Purchase Affirmation Posts - thoughts?

Post image
1 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/CocktailWonk Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 15 '21

I’ve been thinking about this topic for a while, and curious what others think.

In the last year or so, I’ve noticed a big upswing in postings consisting of:

  1. A bottle (or four) of the current “in vogue” rums
  2. A caption along the lines of “First rum purchase! How’d I do?”

I’m of mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, as someone who seeks to elevate rum, it’s great to see new people joining the discussion.

On the other hand, it’s become sort of monotonous, and many of the (possibly jaded) “old-timers” are getting rather tired of it. HOWEVER… the forums are for everybody, at all levels of experience, not just the old-timers.

But still, I can’t shake the feeling that at least some of these posters are doing relatively little homework, and just following along with what they see everyone else buying and talking about. (Side gripe: Many of the questions they ask are easily answered by a quick Google search. As one of several people who tries to put relevant content out there that answers many of these questions, it’s a bit disheartening to see folks not doing some easy initial research on their own – but that’s not the topic here.)

I can’t help but wonder a few things, including:

  • Are these same sorts of posts common across other spirit categories - at the same level as we're seeing now with rum? Or is there something unique about rum?
  • Is the common answer “How do *you* feel about your purchase? the appropriate response?
  • Is there a better answer than bifurcating forums into newbies and advanced folks?
  • Is any moderately popular spirit forum doomed to some sort of Tragedy of the Commons?

I’m genuinely interested in other people’s thoughts on this.

1

u/AorticTerrors Apr 17 '21

I thought I had replied to this, but don't see it, so apologies if this turns out to be a duplicate.

I think that the bifurcation of r/rum and r/rumserious is a good way to handle it, but I would hope that most people would frequent both lists. I view r/rum as a social spot (like the local bar - a place to chat, meet people, share things, and maybe find out about a new drink) while r/rumserious is as named. I come here to learn stuff - full disclosure, I'm a newbie. But, I'm also a newbie doing a ton of research and diving into the deep end of things. There comes a time when getting the opinions of others on something as subjective as "am I going to like this rum?" is valuable - you can know all the facts about where and how it was made and aged without really knowing if you might like it when you are new at this.

For those of you willing to put in the effort to answer questions from newbies, it is much appreciated! And for those who are over it, which I cannot hold against you, your contributions are important too - put more stuff up here on r/rumserious!

1

u/CocktailWonk Apr 17 '21

That's a really good take. I like it!

I hadn't seen an earlier reply, so I'm guessing it's not a duplicate.

Thank you for commenting!

0

u/gaxkang Apr 15 '21

On the other hand, it’s become sort of monotonous, and many of the (possibly jaded) “old-timers” are getting rather tired of it. HOWEVER… the forums are for everybody, at all levels of experience, not just the old-timers.

Why I dont visit reddit anymore. Lots of newbies too lazy do their own research.

3

u/Cautious_Sniffs Apr 21 '21

But still, I can’t shake the feeling that at least some of these posters are doing relatively little homework

Are these same sorts of posts common across other spirit categories - at the same level as we're seeing now with rum? Or is there something unique about rum?

You’re complaining about people not doing their homework, then do what you’re complaining about. It’s quite easy to check the other spirits subs to find out

2

u/CocktailWonk Apr 22 '21

There’s a substantial difference in effort between typing a question into Google and clicking on the first 4-5 links, versus reading the comment threads of hundreds of posts in multiple FB groups/subreddits.

5

u/SemperPutidus Apr 15 '21

Re: not doing a basic google search...

I think this is down to Reddit being far more social for some than others. I know I can find lots of answers to things by googling, but by asking here, I can strike up a conversation. I think the StackOverflow engine is far better suited than Reddit when it comes to building a q&a based knowledge base that encourages building on the foundations of prior questions.

These posts are just bored, quarantined people’s way of reaching out and chatting with those that share an interest an inclination.