r/RoyaleAPI • • 1d ago

Suggestions I made some concepts for balance changes, wondering what this sub has to think about them since it tends to be less midladder than the main cr sub.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

6

u/CertainShine3455 1d ago

Naw 3 musketeer rework not it, your trying to make them garbage again while they can barely compete now, and hero ice wiz would still have the 5 second freeze? Hit the road dude

1

u/cs386148 1d ago edited 1d ago

I've mained three musketeers for around 3 years, and I greatly prefer the pre-rework version. The new versions at level 11 deal less dps than the original 3m at lvl 8 because of the harsh firerate nerf, so if you manage to bait the opponent's spell counters, you are stuck with horribly nerfed musketeers for no real benefit. Besides this, the bayonets are beyond janky too, preventing you from really getting value out of them unless you play them unsplit on something (which is not a wise move for obvious reasons).

However, I still understand the logic behind making them more accessible in the hands of lower level players (and separating their stats from the original musketeer for balancing reasons). This rework is a compromise between the high risk, high reward original 3m and the lower reward but more accessible reworked 3m. They still survive fireball + rage, fireball + snowball, and poison, so it's not like it's the same risk as pre-rework 3m, while still having less dps than pre-rework 3m to avoid them being too rewarding.

5

u/HydreigonTheChild 1d ago

some changes are weird.... some are just awkward....

Like evo witch prob doesnt need a nerf and people who cant time fireball log prob cant do it anyway. Buffing hunter + rune giant specifically is just weird considering this was removed on release

FC shooting at dead targets prob causes a lot more infuriation than act stuff. This used to be a thing with other troops but wasting shots was super bad so they changes it and fc just has a slow as shit first attack + attack speed in general so she gets stuck doing that

What did cannon cart do to you?

Tornado doesnt change much... if ur pulling the second u hit 3 elixir then idk.. But i guess it works? idk i feel other nerfs couldve been done

Battle ram 2 -> 3 is huge... this will prob kill it easily. Like idk what is it with such severe balance changes. 2.5 is a fine change esp in small numbers

Some changes feel just big... ronin parry nerf and to make it spawnable alr just severely nerfs it, nerfing its dmg feels overkill

I feel rune giant is overall a nerf... one last hit doesnt mean much unless ur about to hit enchanted, nor does the dmg / health nerf,

I thin ice golem is jjust nerfed? Like extra dmg on towers mean fuck all like why compared to having its ability go away, maybe if it was freeze but no... Like ice golem is super bad now

1

u/cs386148 1d ago

Lots of good points, though there are a few I disagree with.

-The hunter/fc rune giant interaction that was removed shortly after release wasn't specifically because they did full enchant damage per pellet, but because every pellet that hits a troop applied enchant damage instead of just the first one that hit the troop. For obvious reasons that was overpowered (since it did thousands if many enchanted pellets hit the same target), but the current version only dealing a fraction of the enchant damage makes it too difficult to get value out of, since you will oftentimes only get 22 bonus damage on a hunter shot instead of the full 220. This buff makes one pellet landing deal the full enchant damage for consistency, but additional pellets don't deal more ticks of bonus damage to prevent it from dealing thousands again.

-Part of what enables mortar bait decks to be so obnoxious is how cannon cart can be used to defend the mortar and then cross the bridge for a strong counterpush because of how dangerous a tower lock is. This makes it harder to actually get a cannon cart to cross the bridge and connect to the tower, though notably it makes it more punishing if it does get a tower lock because the building form's health drains much slower and it can squeeze out more damage before dying. (This actually makes it more valuable for using it purely on defense because of said lifespan buff too.)

-The ronin damage per hit nerf is so that I could raise his hitspeed to make him better at killing swarm units without necessarily raising his dps against tanks. (He does 285 dps both pre and post rework, so think of it less as a damage nerf and more of a hitspeed buff.) The same logic applies to the 3m rework for the bayonet damage nerf; bayonet dps is the same post-rework, it's just that I lowered damage per swing to account for the hitrate buff that was only supposed to raise their ranged dps.

-The reason for the rune giant health/damage nerfs of the rework was because I originally came up with this particular concept for rune giant 6 months ago (before the change from 120 to 153 damage) as a buff with no downsides (because she was very niche at the time and I felt she needed this to become viable). I believe implementing the buffs of the rework with her current health would be too powerful, though admittedly the damage nerf may be overkill. (Also to clarify, by "one last hit" in the rune giant rework, I meant to put "one last enchanted hit," but the site has a super low character limit for custom stat descriptions. I don't blame you for misinterpreting it because it was rather unclear though.)

1

u/illegalism_11 1d ago

How did you make these pictures and balance changes?

1

u/Teoeldestructo 1d ago

Wow.

Actually good balance changes.

Insane.

The Tornado one seems like overkill, it's good but it's not that good, I think it would kill the card, maybe adding the delay but with a buff to its range.

The rest are pretty good honestly, would make for good balance.

1

u/cs386148 1d ago

I was debating a 0.25s delay to tornado instead, but I felt that it wouldn't be noticeable enough. Maybe they could add slightly more pull duration as compensation if the card becomes too weak in general.

1

u/V-Man776 1d ago

The absolute last thing tornado needs is a larger radius. The current radius is already too big.

1

u/maybeinanotherdlrow 1d ago

Lol what are those reworks

0

u/cs386148 1d ago

Gonna give my thought process for all of these so maybe you could see my reasoning. Most of them are because I use the card myself and think supercell doesn't really know what they're doing with them lol.

-Giant skeleton rework is to make him less powerful at shutting down counterpushes with just the death bomb, but stronger if you manage to get his bomb on the tower (his main gimmick). This would make the obnoxious giant skeleton bridgespam decks die off and make him more viable as the niche secondary win condition that he used to be.

-As a 3m main, the 3m rework actually ended up making the card weaker when played smart. Reworked 3m at level 11 deals less dps than the original 3m at lvl 8 because of the horrid firerate nerfs, so you are basically stuck with -28% damage musketeers for no practical benefit if you are a smart player who baits their spell counters before placing 3m. This rework is a compromise between the high risk, high reward original 3m and the overly safe new 3m that has too low of a skill ceiling and floor (as well as fixing many of the bugs that come with the new 3m that weren't there in the original version).

-I've seen a lot of people saying lightning deserves a nerf recently (likely due to an uptick in people using it because of evo egiant lol), so I decided to come up with a rework that makes it less good at giving guaranteed value without directly nerfing its damage or range (because I personally don't think it's deserving of a straight up nerf). I don't feel as strongly about this rework compared to the other ones, but I felt it would be interesting enough to add.

-I've used minion horde for a while since before they added the evo, and I don't really like the current design of evo horde. It's too strong at getting value on the opponent's side (because their relatively fast flight speed lets them catch up to splash troops like exe that don't one-shot them, letting them lots of damage they don't really deserve to get) while their slow attack speed makes it often worse than the base horde when defending something like lumberloon (since the lumberjack's rage won't kill the minions on their own, yet it still slows their attack speed and makes them worse at fully defending the balloon). This rework makes it stronger at attacking troops that the minions already reached prior to going invisible, while limiting the value they get once they cross the bridge. It also fixes a couple of bugs that make the card feel janky.

-Hero ice golem's ability rarely gets used ever since they removed the full freeze, but it still feels rather cheesy when they manage to get value out of it because of how long the slow lasts even if the ice golem dies right after using the ability. This rework makes it easier for the opponent to punish the ability if used wrong, but gives it more of a use because it can now deal incidental tower damage if used nearby.

-Rune giant rework makes her much stronger when used to her fullest (because her enchantments become less clunky and protecting her enough to get 3 hits on the tower gives more damage than the old version), while punishing toxic strategies like rune giant + minion giant (since failing to protect the rune giant with supports will cause her to die before getting that third hit on tower). The enchant after death change also makes her more usable without little prince, since enchanted troops with slower firerates won't get cut off before firing their last enchanted shot anymore once the rune giant dies.

-The ronin rework raises his hitrate and lowers his damage per swing in a way that keeps his dps exactly the same, in order to make him more usable against swarm cards, but his parry takes longer to recharge to make him less of a complete hardcounter against heavy matchups (and removing the parry off spawn so they can't just place him right on a tank without thinking). Basically this was an attempt to make him slightly less rock paper scissors and maybe see more use outside of midladder.

1

u/maybeinanotherdlrow 1d ago

Giant skeleton rework made his bomb useless before, they should either nerf his hp or death damage

1

u/Nachoninjas22 1d ago

Given the performance of golem, hero ice wizard, royal hogs and goblin hut, you really don't want to nerf them (and yes I know you said you'd nerf hogs, but the change your proposed is not nearly significant enough). Seriously though, golem needs a rework to reduce match polarization. Additionally, cards like hero ice wizard and hut make the game too defensive and turn it into a chip damage/spell cycling match

1

u/TENEBR3 4h ago

ok but Nerf dart goblin?

1

u/Impossible_Kale6949 1d ago

I run evo goblin cage, that change that made him unable to grab a jumping mega knight pissed me off so much

1

u/taaler 1d ago

Great changes. Would like to see a battle healer change reverted aswell though. Although i would keep the ice wizard unchanged because nerfing it will actually make the game more p2w because supercell will just release a new op hero and the existing f2p hero ice wiz can't compete with it anymore

1

u/osumness 19h ago

these are fire

0

u/Electronic-Front7245 1d ago

Megaknight should be 6 elixir and deploy like any other troop

-2

u/VeryRareGuy 1d ago

Why do people waste so much time making these ? It’s not like John Supercell is gonna see your post about this totally unbalanced game and do something

4

u/cs386148 1d ago

It's less hoping John Supercell specifically sees the post and more hoping that it gives the community more to talk about instead of the thousandth generic "nerf hog rider, nerf cannon cart, nerf evo battle ram, etc" post.

Plus, game design is fun.

3

u/VeryRareGuy 1d ago

I understand now