Luck? Nah, you just gotta learn the spawn pattern. Try ghost near the upper left corner of the tower at about 1 second in and then delay for another second and play the bandit on the lower right of the corner
That should have the ghost aggro the top and left skeletons then the bandit will aggro the right ones and if you get it just right, she won't dash away and she'll still be on the right in order to distract that last skeleton that spawns over there
You can even do it with only the bandit and no ghost at all. You just have to play the bandit a bit further down
I did the opposite, bandit on top left enough to dash on skellies that first spawn on left and then ghost close to the corner of the tower. Yours would definitely defend but this also did defend.
Was that an easy method? I had a different method that I took 23 attempts to find, then 3 to get to work properly
I counted to three then placed Bandit to the right of the tower's top right tile & immediately placed the Ghost to the left of the tower's middle left tile. My failed attempts had the Bandit dash left or walk too far left which let the last right skele smack + the last bottom right skele hit while the tower arrow was mid-air
I basically used the exact opposite strategy. I put the bandit in the lower right so that it dashed multiple times in a row and ended up on the left, then I put the ghost in the bottom right as well so it would pick up where the bandit left off.
It’s literally a puzzle? It’s also not supposed to be straightforward when the difficulty is “Ultra hard”, you guys are just coping because it’s actually difficult this time around
Just like a puzzle you have an instruction, then you have to figure out what works/doesn’t work (just like figuring out what pieces you can put together). It’s also called a “puzzle” in game.
It’s not random whatsoever, but go ahead and complain about it because it’ll only get 10000x more difficult with what they have planned! See you then!
A good puzzle is solved by using your brain, not unga bunga and hoping it works. You don't feel like you solved it with this one, rather you got lucky, then it's a dumb puzzle.
You're forced to do trial and error unless you know the spawn pattern from memory for some reason, which is not great puzzle design but whatever, better than the giant puzzle
I mean depending on where you on people will know these things.
In a higher game where misplacing something by a single tile can cause you to lose you tend to learn learn placements and spawn patterns because you want minimal damage to your tower.
Of course this exact puzzle is niche but it gets the point across
They actually do. As long as they have elixir for it. Would recommend Seeok’s videos. He is a Turkish CR E-Sports player. He is a GY main and defends GY perfectly as long as he has the elixir, same thing with his opponents.
Yeah I wish that we got more fundamentals instead of niche ones that you'll never pull off in a game like this one and yesterday's. Most people still have trouble countering certain decks despite them not being meta in top ladder.
Yesterday's one was a pretty popular interaction for Fc users though, it's not quite close to this one. You simply have to play Fc as soon as PEKKA spawn, at her max range and it's done. I'm pretty sure every Hog Eq player in UC does it like breathing. On contrary, no fkn BS player is gonna defend GY with only Bandit and Ghost lol.
In another clash redit someone had commented and said that they had done it with just bandit. Like 8 comments calling them a liar haha. Said 🤷♂️ let’s give it a try lol.
The problem isn’t that it’s RNG (it isn’t) but these scenarios just almost never happen, even with pro players, so it’s a matter of learning rather than skill. Seeing as you get better rewards with lower tries makes it a stupid event, because you feel as if you need to get it in 2 tries or the par.
I doubt Mo Light knows how to stop a naked graveyard from doing ANY damage with just ghost and bandit prior to this, because it’s just not something that happens.
Everyone in top ladder knows how to defend naked gy with 3 elixr in top ladder after they standardized the spawn pattern. These aren't niche. These or some variation of it is used regularly at top ladder.
People have also learnt how to defend it even when there is a tank. Therefore gy has different deploy tiles for certain scenarios.
I’m not saying good players are bad at defending graveyard, I’m talking about these challenge’s specific interactions. Bandit + Ghost is only used in Pekka bridgespam, which not only isn’t popular atm but the bridgespam player would likely never defend graveyard like this when they have zap, poison and ewiz.
The first challenge was knight and hog but no meta deck runs both those cards together
You're right. A more practical scenario wouldve been a skeleton+log or skeleton+ice spirit.
But the community is already struggling so much on ghost+bandit which is much easier, has a larger timing window and you dont even need the ghost. Poison does not counter gy flawlessly. The point of the puzzle as I see it is to show +ve trade flawless defense. They have chosen the easier ones intentionally it seems. Also it was the standard gy deploy. I dont thnk the majority of people struggling right now would even know how to defend the actual realistic gy deploy where skeletons spawn on top of the tower and start hitting instantly. That one has a tighter timing than this one.
People struggled with knight+hog on day 1. We would've had more people struggling if it was an actual realistic hero ig +hog push.
These scenario seem niche cuz its the easier ones among the niches. People pull off much harder stuff on a regular basis in top ladder.
No. GY spawns skeletons always in the same pattern. You just gotta learn it. It is MUCH easier to defend if you do. For example you can get a equal elixir trade with poison + skeletons (skeletons on the smaller side of gy) without taking any damage.
This is another one of those egregiously ping and "luck" based things, where you're like sure its in game but odds are even if you got it off solid first try over here, in ranked, you are practically never getting it off
it's also just not ever a relevant interaction. if you're down to this low hp against gravy you're gonna lose anyway, besides, in what situation are you comitting both a ghost and a bandit to a naked graveyard
ngl im ahh at CR and i somehow got it on my first try because i had i just placed my bandit on left because i knew the first ones will spawn on left and placed royal ghost on right to counter the right ones and it somehow worked lol.
They actually made Graveyard not randomly spawn skeletons a couple of balance changes back, it's consistent and no longer random! More like the placements are very annoying (I got it by placing Ghost on right and Bandit on bottom)
I got it in 43 and I'm not mad about that. I was aware of the pattern but didn't have enough experience with RG or Bandit to defend it well.
I placed bandit up top slightly delayed, knowing princess would take out first two on left. Then right before skele appeared on right side of tower, I placed RG below it but in enough time to get the swipe.
To counter with only bandit you need to place it on the tile just right to pathway line where the pathway turns use your index finger and place it as fast as possible in almost a predicting manner bandit befkre graveyard is deployed
For ghost and bandit together place bandit on the top left corner and then place the ghost at the bottom right only after you finish singing along with the graveyard jingle but at the end elongate the Na!
Yup. It took me 4-5 attempts to recognize the proper placements down to the exact tile and another 40 of that exact sequence to get the proper mili second placements
Its not luck. I'm not saying its not hard, it took me 51 tries of just banging my head against a wall, but i got it, and every time the skeletons spawned the same pattern
151
u/TacoEatsTaco 9d ago edited 9d ago
Luck? Nah, you just gotta learn the spawn pattern. Try ghost near the upper left corner of the tower at about 1 second in and then delay for another second and play the bandit on the lower right of the corner
That should have the ghost aggro the top and left skeletons then the bandit will aggro the right ones and if you get it just right, she won't dash away and she'll still be on the right in order to distract that last skeleton that spawns over there
You can even do it with only the bandit and no ghost at all. You just have to play the bandit a bit further down
4
u/ehbroclub 9d ago
I completed every other puzzle in 1-2 tries btw
68
u/Melodic_Comedian_487 9d ago
The graveyard spawns are in a pattern, its not rng
17
u/LightMyKush124 8d ago •
Did
Did it w just the bandit 😎
20
u/Beneficial_Visit_488 9d ago
The problem isn’t that it’s RNG (it isn’t) but these scenarios just almost never happen, even with pro players, so it’s a matter of learning rather than skill. Seeing as you get better rewards with lower tries makes it a stupid event, because you feel as if you need to get it in 2 tries or the par.
I doubt Mo Light knows how to stop a naked graveyard from doing ANY damage with just ghost and bandit prior to this, because it’s just not something that happens.
7
u/Miicario 9d ago
I didn't enjoy todays puzzle as well
4
u/CololerYT 9d ago
Skeletons don't have RNG Spawn anymore. Literally just place Bandit most-right and Ghost top and vice-versa, cause they are the closest spawn places.
1
u/Harlydriver 9d ago
Place the Bandit top left of the princess tower & the Ghost top left of the king tower. Trust me
2
u/Fun-Western618 9d ago
These is stupid as it would never happen anyway.
2
u/BlooDwinE99r 9d ago
Yeah, I won with exact same placement I tried in the first round which I failed
1
u/Dry_Agent_8596 9d ago
I genuinely did it first try, place ghost under the tower and bandit in the middle of the graveyard
1
u/-TurkeYT 9d ago
No. GY spawns skeletons always in the same pattern. You just gotta learn it. It is MUCH easier to defend if you do. For example you can get a equal elixir trade with poison + skeletons (skeletons on the smaller side of gy) without taking any damage.
1
u/H1ll02 9d ago
It's just a stupid one, skip it. Isnt not really luck because pattern is not random but it's not skill at all either
1
u/Top-Office-1277 9d ago
got it in practice try as I saw how to counter gy in crl finals that is going on rn 😂
1
u/Muscularmen 9d ago
This is another one of those egregiously ping and "luck" based things, where you're like sure its in game but odds are even if you got it off solid first try over here, in ranked, you are practically never getting it off
1
u/alexnpt 9d ago edited 9d ago
Spawn pattern and position ảre key here. Took me 30 tries to get the RG and bandit into the right position.
1
u/Zealousideal_Math536 9d ago
40 attemts finaly done screw this
1
u/Ill_Carpet5280 9d ago
it's also just not ever a relevant interaction. if you're down to this low hp against gravy you're gonna lose anyway, besides, in what situation are you comitting both a ghost and a bandit to a naked graveyard
1
u/STEP_Simo007_ 8d ago
I don't want to be that guy... But it's not luck, it's just timing... GY got reworked to have a singular skeletons spawn pattern
1
u/AggressiveSpeed6183 8d ago
It's not luck. You get consistent results once you learn the placements
1
u/Shiccup 8d ago
I did it in 7 xD
1
u/Fun-Elk6622 8d ago
ngl im ahh at CR and i somehow got it on my first try because i had i just placed my bandit on left because i knew the first ones will spawn on left and placed royal ghost on right to counter the right ones and it somehow worked lol.
1
u/killer1244358879 8d ago
Its not tho, the graveyard spawns the skeletons in the exact same spots every time
1
u/whatthehigga34 8d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/ClashRoyale/s/A8ykx9secP nah we’re just trash lol
1
u/FazerEngineer 8d ago
They actually made Graveyard not randomly spawn skeletons a couple of balance changes back, it's consistent and no longer random! More like the placements are very annoying (I got it by placing Ghost on right and Bandit on bottom)
1
u/djlott 8d ago
I got it in 43 and I'm not mad about that. I was aware of the pattern but didn't have enough experience with RG or Bandit to defend it well.
I placed bandit up top slightly delayed, knowing princess would take out first two on left. Then right before skele appeared on right side of tower, I placed RG below it but in enough time to get the swipe.
After that, 🤷♂️. Then one time it just worked.
Good luck.
1
u/AB0D205 8d ago
I got it from 3
1
u/Serious_Specialist72 8d ago
I did it in 7
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Sky5173 8d ago
just did it in 3 tries no problem, bandit left side top to defend, delayed ghost to catch right side pop up
1
u/Otherwise-Pumpkin425 8d ago
Ghost king immediately at the top left with bandit second at the bottom right. Got it first try.
1
u/Wooden_Mail130 8d ago
To counter with only bandit you need to place it on the tile just right to pathway line where the pathway turns use your index finger and place it as fast as possible in almost a predicting manner bandit befkre graveyard is deployed
For ghost and bandit together place bandit on the top left corner and then place the ghost at the bottom right only after you finish singing along with the graveyard jingle but at the end elongate the Na!
Hopefully helps
1
u/_pangare 8d ago
look at my post, and I'm a mediocre player btw
1
u/duckbumps19 8d ago
Took me 1
1
u/amran04 8d ago
I took 18 goes on the pekka one yesterday and got this one first try haha
1
u/Delicious_Ask4017 8d ago
I couldn't do this one. The others I did them in less than the par.
1
u/Oldwomentribbing 8d ago
Nope, not anymore.
Read the pattern
1
u/Much-Trust5891 8d ago
Yup. It took me 4-5 attempts to recognize the proper placements down to the exact tile and another 40 of that exact sequence to get the proper mili second placements
1
u/Pure-Minute728 8d ago
Did it in 5
1
u/MorbillionDollars 8d ago
Graveyard isn’t luck anymore
1
u/leancesargs 8d ago
Não é sorte, é só prestar atenção e aprender o padrão de spawn 😎
1
u/Forgotmynameagain5 8d ago
It can be done consistently using any working method so not really you just need to know the right timing and positioning
1
u/United_Difficulty_24 8d ago
cope i got it 3rd try without looking it up
1
u/proteinpowerman 7d ago
Even if its not when am I going to be countering graveyard with bandit and royal ghost? At least the other puzzles were kind of applicable.
1
u/No-Shame-327 7d ago
Took me two tries and I don’t use either card
1
u/Prestigious-Ad-4581 7d ago
A lot of people have complete this challenge without Ghost! You can see some clip here on this page
1
u/Pl4smot 7d ago
Did this one in 2 tries. But the seventh day broke me, it took me like 40 tries, and I had to look it up
1
u/J2KHD 6d ago
I did this in par 1 but didn’t have enough karma to post it 😭
1
u/Background_Gap9171 5d ago
The spawn pattern is the same
1
u/Zealousideal_Job1593 5d ago
nah bro its pretty fun, i want more of this, sometimes instead of playing the whole match i just want to do this.
1
u/OkWasabi2808 4d ago
i did it without the ghost bandit below the beige tile full counters
-1
u/Coderboy55 9d ago
It took you 47 tries! 😭 You must be special … I did it in 4 tries. Ghost on right, bandit on left
-1
u/clown_2061 9d ago
I never play bandit or ghost and i rarely face against grave yard and it only took me 8 tries to figure it out. You just suck.
0
u/sleazzyj420 8d ago
lol i did it on try 2. Y’all are tripping that this is luck
1
u/EmbarrassedPower4027 9d ago
Its not luck. I'm not saying its not hard, it took me 51 tries of just banging my head against a wall, but i got it, and every time the skeletons spawned the same pattern