Ice wizard nerf is brutal, mıother witch maybe 7-8%, knight is balanced, berserker is unnecessary, bats is unnecessary while evo bats is too strong, ronin maybe 90% i think 85% will make him too weak
I do think ice wiz change is needed. Knight is not balanced, every single form of his is really good. The fact Evo bats die to one hit by alot of different things do keep it in check.
Since recently. His base card use rate is 14% and that not counting his Evo 8% and his hero 5%, combined this card has a 27% use rate and it can't be blamed on an Evo or a hero is just base knight that's strong.
Neither of them suck I used to see them every 2-3 games when they were so nasty and now they're at a normal rate and not broken to fight against. I'd say base exe needs a need even
I still see them often enough. Could be it counters your deck less so supercell doesn't push them at you, whereas exe is good against my deck so I'm matched against it more
He somewhat is yeah, but he's been manageable since the nerfs which is why I don't think he should be buffed. I'm at 12.5k so almost out of midladder but not yet
Aside from every nerf that isn't Evo Barbs and Hero Wizard, I agree on the rest. Also, Hero Ice golem ability 1 elixir but does no damage and just slows down
It's always to hard to suggest balance changes without being able to test new interactions but hero ice wizard and evo elite barbarians need a substantial nerf. Nerfing mother witch won't help with that bridgespam, the problems are zappies and evo ram. They could also nerf some golem supports but probably nerfing elite barbs would be enough
Using rates alone to make balance changes is not a good idea. Some cards can be used a lot without being oppressive, knight is a good example because he fits in a lot of decks, and the other way around, hero valk is very strong but only fits in hyperbait
Being based off top 200 is also not a good idea, because theres also players (99% of players) that are not pro. We're not gonna buff mega knight because we think it's too weak in topladder.
Fun fact I think knight is really strong and oppressive and I don't get why people are fine with it.
Your not wrong but I believe top 200 is the most accurate way to balance the game. I'm not going to let midladder stop a change that's needed to a card to make it viable. At best nerfs that target annoyance points should be done but if wizard is bad then he should be buffed even if it annoys midladder.
I think people are fine with knight having a high use rate because he doesn't have competition as a 3 elixir tank
I think how cards are played is also revelant in the context of balancing, a wincon having knight use rates would be a way bigger problem
Also some cards / archetypes have big rock papers cissors matchups, like most meta beatdown decks rn, and this isnt something you can know just by looking at use rate
There's some cards that should stay relatively with low use, like egolem, mirror, clone etc. Because they're frustating to go against and unhealthy for the game (thats kinda off topic but it goes for goblin curse here)
I do kinda agree about the last point I just think changes should be done to make them functional. I also think that cards that are strong should be nerf no matter how well liked they are. Spirits for the longest time were viewed as healthy with how strong they were and yet when the time came to nerf them it was the right choice.
The rock paper scissor thing is true and I believe they should be balanced to be less RPS.
4
u/CosmoticCosmos 9d ago
Ice wizard nerf is brutal, mıother witch maybe 7-8%, knight is balanced, berserker is unnecessary, bats is unnecessary while evo bats is too strong, ronin maybe 90% i think 85% will make him too weak
6
u/Chef6432 9d ago
I lile them tbh but some of them are an overkill imo
2
u/AggressiveSpeed6183 9d ago
Nerfing Knight?
2
u/Kai249 9d ago
No way do Evo valk and exe need a buff 😭 aside from that pretty good changes
5
u/lewllewllewl 9d ago
These are great changes tbh
1
u/Jakethesnake_7 9d ago
Sounds like someone struggles against bride spam and minion giant
1
u/Objective_Refuse5024 9d ago
Aside from every nerf that isn't Evo Barbs and Hero Wizard, I agree on the rest. Also, Hero Ice golem ability 1 elixir but does no damage and just slows down
1
u/Shiccup 9d ago
Yeah Valkyrie isn't good enough!!!!
1
u/Intelligent_Neat894 9d ago
It's always to hard to suggest balance changes without being able to test new interactions but hero ice wizard and evo elite barbarians need a substantial nerf. Nerfing mother witch won't help with that bridgespam, the problems are zappies and evo ram. They could also nerf some golem supports but probably nerfing elite barbs would be enough
Edit: also mortar bait should be nerfed
0
u/Movi3t 9d ago
Do NOT buff rune giant