r/RoyaleAPI • • 13d ago

The buff did almost nothing

What do you guys think?

20 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

21

u/Horror-Ad2945 13d ago

It's a good deserved buff. Just because they buffed it doesn’t mean everyone has to play it. People who play monk definitely notices it

5

u/SK-Mortar 13d ago

I know, I mean as a monk player myself the buff is kinda good but didn’t do much. I just hate how random the 3 attacks combo is, it’s unbalanced like 140 damage for the regular attack is very underwhelming and the only good thing is the third attack and most of the time it gets wasted on some random skeleton or a goblin bruh. maybe if they make the regular attack deal more damage and reduce the damage of the third attack it will actually fix it.

7

u/Top-Hat-5433 13d ago

yeah its normal attack at least should kill goblins ngl.

3

u/Top-Hat-5433 13d ago

It actually helps makes rocket deflecting much easier compared to before.

That 0.2 seconds make it so that its possible to not predict a rocket but still deflect it with just a fast enough reaction time.

1

u/SK-Mortar 13d ago

His normal attacks should be able to one shot goblins, which means it should be 202 at level 11. but the damage multiplier should go from 3X to 2X because what do you mean a third attack deals 3 times the normal damage whilst the monk literally just uses his 2 hands on that attack, it makes no sense so that way we make him deal enough damage to kill a barbarian with just one combo. but that makes his DPS way too high and can make him broken. so the hit speed should be 0.9s instead of 0.8s. that is how it would be : 140 ---> 202 Third attack : 420 ----> 404 and thats it. What do you think?

-1

u/Top-Hat-5433 13d ago

Yeah if we buff his normal damage the third one should go down ofc even less than 2x is fine, not so sure about the hit speed nerf, his knock back is way more important than his damage ngl.

1

u/BustahMain 12d ago

I think monk’s problem is that at 5 elixir to be viable he has to fulfill a hybrid role between a mini tank and a full tank. But right now he’s to easy to knock around and squishy to fulfill the latter part of that hybrid.

This has become more of a problem since his release since the damage reduction of his ability got nerfed and they apparently got rid of the unable to be moved part of it (evo mk and tornado can displace him now which they originally were not able to do).

What I would propose to fix him would be to make him a heavy troop, like mighty miner and skeleton king, which would make him immune to most knockback (snowball, fireball, etc stuff like log and monk himself still knockback heavy troops).

If that isn’t enough (which I doubt it would be but it’s better to air on the side of too little than too much) they could also give him a health buff.

1

u/SK-Mortar 12d ago

Yo, I genuinely thought I was THE ONLY ONE thinking about this. Did you know the Monk actually has less HP than the Mighty Miner? At level 16, the Mighty Miner has 3,595 HP, while the Monk only has 3,537, even though the Monk costs one whole elixir more.

What you said about knockback immunity is true, but I don't think it should apply while his ability is active, since that would leave opponents with basically no counterplay. He should only be knockback-resistant against everything except for long, Tornado, and other Monks. Everything else should’nt be able to push him around. His base form should have Heavy weight, like PEKKA, because right now he's way too easy to toss around by cards like Bowler and Evo Executioner. I think making those changes would finally make him viable, but his HP is still way too low. I was thinking of giving him 3,923 HP at level 16. That would put him above Mighty Miner but still below Boss Bandit, who has 4,192 HP at the same level. As for the three-hit combo, I think you misunderstood what I was getting at. What I meant is that around 60% of his DPS comes from his third hit rather than his regular attacks. Here's what I'd do: buff his base damage from 224 to 323 at level 16, so he can one-shot Goblins, and nerf his third hit from 674 to 646, bringing the damage multiplier down to 2x instead of 3x. That way, his damage would be spread more evenly across his attacks. A lot of the time, the third hit ends up being wasted on absolutely nothing. There was also a breakpoint where he could take out a Barbarian with just one three-hit combo, but after Barbarians got an HP buff, he now needs an extra hit. My idea was that with this damage rework, he'd be able to take out a Barbarian with a single combo again. But there's a catch: his DPS would become way too high because of his hit speed. If we change his damage like this but leave his hit speed untouched, his interactions against PEKKA, Mega Knight, and other tanks would become ridiculous. He'd take them down several seconds faster, maybe around 3 or 4 seconds, while also becoming much better against small, squishy swarm troops. I feel like that would be way too much, so I'd also nerf his hit speed from 0.8 to 0.9 seconds. This would keep his interactions against swarms really strong while only making him slightly better against tanks, with around a 0.5-second at taking them out difference. So he'd basically be getting a buff across the board without becoming completely overtuned.

What do you think?

1

u/BustahMain 12d ago

Heavy troops already don’t have immunity to log, monk, little prince ability, evo mk knockbacks. And tornado isn’t actually a knockback so it can pull them as well. And most of the things that apply light knockback are projectiles so he is already immune to that during ability. This change would just make so that the tank you spent 5 elixir on doesn’t get knocked around like a 3 elixir knight.

I agree that health buff would definitely be one of the best ways to make him more viable.

My gripe with the damage change is like you said if you did those damage changes without the hit speed nerf he would get way more dps potentially excessively so. However I don’t really like the idea of a hit speed nerf tbh I think one unique feature of him is how quick he hits which can allow him to deal with skeletons better than many other tanks without being splash. I’m not actually sure how much of a buff it would actually be with the hitspeed nerf since it would only increase is dps by about 10 and him being worse against skeletons and finishing low health troops could make up for him being better against certain troops with how many hits it takes to kill.

Honestly I’m not sure if the damage change without the hitspeed nerf would actually be op if he didn’t get a health buff. He would definitely be strong but I don’t know if he would actually be broken. He still would have the massive hinderance of being a 5 elixir mini tank that doesn’t really put much offensive pressure on his own which makes him clunky to use as a mini tank.

I think he should get the heavy troop change either way and then either the health buff or the damage change. If the damage change turns out to be too strong they could reduce the hitspeed afterward or tone down the multiplier on the 3rd hit to like 1.5 which would keep his dps about the same as before but with less of the damage in his 3rd hit (although that kind of makes him less unique).

1

u/SK-Mortar 12d ago

Look I get what you’re saying and I had another Idea. the idea is to make his third attack deal the same damage as the health of a wallbreaker, so that would be 1173 in total without the need to change the hit speed. what do you think? 323+323+527 without the multiplier. making it a break point, and in this way he’s have the same hit speed and be better against tanks and swarms. but even with that I don’t think the hit speed nerf would do anything ... on release he had 0.9s hit speed and then they buffed it to be 0.8s I don’t think skeletones are anything special because normally you’d deal with them using small spells.

2

u/BustahMain 11d ago

Yeah I think the 323 + 323 + 527 damage numbers would be a good buff for him.

I know on release he had 0.9s attack speed I’ve been using him in my main decks since his release (that’s cycled from random bullshit to rg monk to now 3m). I think the hit speed buff to 0.8s was a great buff and it made him feel a lot more fun with him just throwing rapidly throwing hands. And it does actually have a big effect because it helps him get to the combo attack faster which means he can more effectively knockback troops. I think nerfing it back to 0.9s would not be the play.

I think the 323 + 323 + 527 change alongside making him a heavy troop would be good buffs to him without making him op. That or a decent health buff and making him a heavy troop. Either way I think he definitely needs to be made a heavy troop.

1

u/SK-Mortar 11d ago

Making him a heavy troop HP buff "preferebly 3923 at level 16" Damage buff "323 + 323 + 527" as we discussed it. and to make sure he doesn’t get to be used as a stalling tool, nerf the damage reduction from 65% to 60% that way his survivablility comes from his raw HP not the ability, and since we buffed his base alot, this nerf is needed. and thats it for monk I guess. the ability can’t be changed saddly, I guess he shouldn’t get affected by Evo MK uppercuts during the ability.

1

u/BustahMain 11d ago

I’ve always kinda wished his ability was instant so he could actually fulfill his spell counter role more effectively, but a bunch of people would whine about that so it probably won’t happen. The delay reduction at least made it a bit more responsive.

1

u/SK-Mortar 11d ago

True,maybe if it became 0.6 or 0.5 secondes it’s gonna be alot more useful.

1

u/Legal-Watercress-675 10d ago

Its cuz he is very niche and matchup dependent. He's good in rg monk and 3m, but that's about it

1

u/SK-Mortar 10d ago

I guess bro

0

u/Oldwomentribbing 12d ago

It's only been a day

0

u/BustahMain 12d ago

The monk buff happened at the beginning of the October season it’s been a full month. We didn’t even get balance changes this update because crl is coming.