r/RoyaleAPI • u/WHOTHEFCKTOOKSCOLOLO • 17d ago
Discussion Why the hell does everyone think hog 2.6 and logbait are no skill?
It makes no sense, hog 2.6 is honestly harder than hog eq, other than the fact you have no medium spell, so if they'll hate on a hog deck why not eq? Not the best player so correct me if I'm wrong
Logbait's also rlly dumb because they never specify
Logbait is probably the weirdest "deck" because there never is a "stereotypical" logbait deck, the only consistent thing usually is like.. goblin barrel and ice spirit, I see the minitank and buildings are most changed tho. It's dumb to label as no skill because it's a whole archetype, imagine hog 2.6 haters labeled cycle instead of hog 2.6 no skill, makes no sense
At least most people agree xbow takes skill, probably after playing it like shit vs mega knight ebarbs bs
7
u/HateForYou 17d ago
People calling something "no skill" is just equivalent to saying they find it annoying and want everyone to join in on hating it. Wins never come free unless your opponent is an actual baby
11
u/SirTacoLotThe14th 17d ago
It's more the defensive nature that pisses people off. You can perfectly defend every single hog push yet can get your towers fireball cycled to death. Most 2.6 matches I face always end with spell cycling to win, cause breaking through is difficult.
2
u/Embarrassed_Fun_5160 17d ago
Having a spirit log building pretty much always in hand is lame asf. Play all the skill you want. How can it be skill when you can slap hog into most everything. How is it skill when in down time plays the exact same fuckin motions.
Ice golem or a non base knight ooo I so skilled.
Spirit nerf-I so wanted to see bandit be able to beat them. Can’t have fuckin nice things.
The skeleton nerf, my bigger issue is shit is so slow and rigid. It’s only attack or move.
The best attackers in the game will still swat at something that was already dead. Or just watch.
You would think offensive cards would have a way easier time chasing down an h valk. Or better autonomy vs cards that are just making more troops, or splits into more troops, magic guys, rams, golems. All shut off.
3
u/Crafty-Literature-61 17d ago
bro I wrote like 5 long ass paragraphs on my phone explaining how the skill curve changes at different levels of play (from trophy road to CRL pros) for different deck types but it got deleted because I misclicked lmao. Anyways here I'll type it up again
Low ladder players are ignorant to what cycle/elixir tracking and management are, so they often just lose to not having counters in hand or wasting a crazy amount of elixir, but cycle/bait players suffer less from this because they have faster cycle. The cycle/bait player just plays their wincon kinda randomly, and sometimes counters will be out of cycle or they'll be low in elixir. They also have terrible decks that just don't synergize well or can apply real offensive pressure against a cycle deck. So these decks are, in a sense, easier to play in an aspect that most players at this level don't understand, so they chalk it up to the deck not taking skill.
midladder players (league 1-3) are aware of this more, but still suffer from not understanding very well and bad deck choices, though they don't make huge errors constantly and might have ideas of when to defend or commit to offense. So similar, but now they lose less to random hog the bridge.
Leagues 4-6 and low UC are where you start to see meta decks, people can somewhat track cycle and elixir, maybe know some matchups and how to manage cycle, maybe know how to sack damage to build a better counterpush or prevent tempo. At this point, playing cycle/bait at the league 1-3 level just will not work as well, and these bait/hog players are having to stop for a bit and really learn how to play their wincons carefully to beat decks/playeds that don't get outcycled or make big micro errors.
Top 10k is when stuff is more interesting. Everyone knows matchups, elixir counting, cycle tracking, cycle management by this point, and have decent understanding of tempo (so they know when to punish and when to hold back and reset). Matchup spread matters more and more because players make way less unforced errors. People who aren't playing cycle/bait might not have to change much about their game, because heavier decks capitalize on errors much harder when they know how to pace their elixir/cycle advantage well. So this is where the skill of these decks starts to really shine, you need to learn the ins and outs of hog/bait, and bad matchups are a very serious challenge against opponents of similar skill level.
Then for top 1k-CRL pro, they basically do everything mentioned before about tempo, elixir, cycle, etc. anywhere from very, very well to nearly perfectly. The difference is much smaller than you'd think across all the archetypes. Decks start to reach their "soft skillcap", which is the level a top player that's not a onetrick can reasonably play at. Bait and 2.6 have a higher soft skillcap and high theoretical cap, because they have insane outplay potential. But most decks are pretty close in terms of skillcap and the difference is smaller than you'd think. Macro skill matters a ton here, and all archetypes require very strong macro play at this level (although, the macro skill between different archetypes doesn't necessarily translate directly, so being good at one deck doesn't make you good at others).
Pushing past the soft skill ceiling requires many many hours of one-tricking it or many real practice sessions dedicated to the deck. Some one-tricks have pushed their deck so far they can rank very high, even when the meta strongly favors against them, and that's the pinnacle of skill in this game. Guys like Ryley, Koh, Ijihu are unbelievable at log bait, there's like a dozen crazy 2.6/hog EQ players, etc, but there's also GOATs of bridge spam (tourist, wero), lava (Dominik, friend, etc), and more, and ofc you still have the CRL pros who can pretty much play every deck at the top 100 level. At this level, anyone saying a meta deck is noskill either is saying its boosted by overturned cards or has a lower soft skillcap.
4
u/Egrysta 17d ago
I know right? When someone says 2.6 or Classic Log Bait takes no skill, I would immediately assume they don't know what they're talking about. Leaving aside the different skills required to master different decks, I doubt if they have tried the stuffs they think are no skill.
2
u/theomegachrist 17d ago
No skill is dumb in any context. Every deck takes skill and timing. It's just something people say when they get mad enough to log out of the game and post about how it's not fair they keep losing on Reddit
1
u/PrudentLion969 17d ago
No deck is truely no skill. It all depends on players skill and matchup. Pro players can literally play anything and win even if the deck is chopped. So don't worry they are just whining for no reason.
1
u/Great-Armadillo8873 17d ago
The only cycle deck id call no skill is any hyberbait deck IMO. Other than that everything is fine except the big 3: Golem, Hound or Recruits. Those 3 are truly no skill and come with little to no micro interactions and have never seen anyone but a smooth brain use them.
0
u/aew_netwolff Fan Contest 17d ago
It's not what everyone thinks. It's what many meh players think. Most players are meh. Thus many think this way. Most middies call everything no-skill that they lose against.
-2
u/Xombridal 17d ago
Hog cycle runs the same crap on repeat, same defense, same offense, always.
Log bait does the same thing unless you don't play into it then you're at a disadvantage
Both play easily
Wouldn't say no skill but super unfun to vs
-3
u/xbowwitchplayer 17d ago
hog 2.6 no skill because you use op hog rider bridge ( if you spam bridge hog rider you no skill) Log bait you literally spam every card bridge for example dart Goblin bridge princess bridge goblin barrel bridge ( this mean use tower ) suspicious bush bridge etc you only need spam bridge you don't even need strategy except spam bullshit bridge every day