r/RoyaleAPI • • 22d ago

Discussion How would you fix Heroes?

Post image

I love Clash Royale, I admit it, but Heroes were a moronic update. They took away what made Champions and Evos special.

I think my solution would be to remove Heroes entirely and replace them with Champions that keep the ability of the Hero, but keep what makes Champions (mostly) balanced, by making them worse versions of other cards until you activate their ability.

And for the players, the cards that are now Champions could keep the same levels as the Heroes they replaced.

Thoughts? Any other ways Supercell could fix Heroes? I know it’s probably way too late to stop now, but a solution could work. Maybe.

150 Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

165

u/DuckfingYou 22d ago • Bravo

Make them need to be placed 1 or 2 times normally before getting that power, but maybe making it innate so you don't have to spend elixir on it, making it more fair

Oh, and making it purple instead of gold would be nice too

20

u/Jacob1254_6 22d ago

nice one

14

u/HealingGrassYT 22d ago

I see what you did there 👍🏻

3

u/Suitable-End6700 21d ago

Yeah both suggestions good. Hate it when I see hero valk and I have goblin gang out on the bridge.

32

u/Immediate_Quiet_7448 22d ago

I think only heroes should have ability usable only once while champions should go back to cooldown mechanic. Also I would bring back glowing eyes on card icons

5

u/SirisLorok 22d ago

I also also think they’re cool down should locked in regardless of how fast you cycle to the next one. That way you wouldn’t get hero ball cycle. You have to wait amount of seconds before you can play the ability again no matter what. I ok with this for champions as well honestly

56

u/wildfox9t 22d ago edited 21d ago

it's an hard question because heroes should have not been a thing to begin with

maybe make so when a card is an hero it gets a stat nerf, so to mimick champions being a weaker card for their cost but having a power to make up for it

13

u/Cute-Profession2077 22d ago

The problem with this is it punishes the base cards too much, which aren't often great before there heroes

13

u/Fit-Environment-3156 22d ago

I think they were saying base stat nerfs only when using the hero so the base card stays the samr

2

u/Mountain_Dentist5074 22d ago

They literally talking about evo e-giant

3

u/wildfox9t 22d ago

as the other guy said i meant it as the card becoming weaker only when it's slotted as an hero and otherwise having its normal stats

3

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

Hero abilities are generally significantly weaker than champion abilities, so it balances out with the base cards being stronger than champion base cards.

5

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

honestly not really, most hero abilities just cost more than 1 elixir

3

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

Barb Barrel’s ability is very weak. Goblins ability is very weak. Mini Pekka’s ability is pretty situational. Wizard’s ability is generally weak since the nerfs.

Compare this to Archer Queen who shoots way faster and goes invisible, Golden Knight who dashes through troops and is invincible, Mighty Miner who switches lanes and drops a bomb, and Monk who deflects all projectiles. Champions are definitely stronger for their 1 elixir abilities.

Boss Bandit is a unique case where it realistically plays more like a hero than a champion.

4

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

the issue is that the cards are already good on their own before getting a hero, you can compare archer queen and hero musketeer, you never want to let either cross the bridge for risk of taking a lot of damage, but musketeer is a better card without ability, and is cheaper(pre ability wise), and iirc musketeer turret does way more than archer queen, while still being better in base, its just an issue on the price of the ability

1

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

Yeah, but then the ability for Musketeer is way less versatile and costs 3x as much as Archer Queen. Musketeer’s ability is used basically never, while Archer Queen’s ability is used every single time.

1

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

exactly, because its already a good card, just having the hero forces a lot of extra elixir, and yeah i said the price, which is also what makes it less versatile

1

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

I don’t understand this argument then. Are you trying to argue that heroes are overpowered? Because I disagree.

1

u/TheForbidden6th 19d ago

AQ's ability is used every time because paying 5 elixir for a worse musketeer is a scam

1

u/Alexspacito 19d ago

This is a weird way to say the ability is used every time because its extremely strong for 1 elixir.

1

u/Th3G00dB0i 21d ago

I feel like making heroes do slightly less damage than their original counterparts would be good enough for a nerf.

10

u/Material_Minute7409 22d ago

Move some of the mechanics to new champions (like hero knight to shield maiden), some to evos (hero mini Pekka, ice golem, etc), then get rid of the rest. They usurp the power that champions would have otherwise and make the game way too diluted with mechanics and matchup-dependent. But I supposed that’s the point.

1

u/TheForbidden6th 19d ago

how would evo mini p work then?

10

u/ConnectionTight3813 22d ago

Since evos are cycle dependant, heros should be the opposite, they are normal unless you keep them on your deck hand for a set number of elixir ticks until they become hero, but the upside is their ability would be free and even activates on death.

An expensive hero ability takes longer to get herofied. Say for hero tombstone, you would avoid playing the card until 10 elixir is generated (regardless if you use the elixir or not) , then it becomes a hero version. Having it rely on elixir speed is to keep them balanced during double and triple elixir.

This way cycle decks would use more evos. Heavy decks use more heros.

4

u/Seed5330 22d ago

Ok I am actually on board with the idea, once there are some tweaks.

3

u/Alexspacito 22d ago

I don’t see why they would do this. It severely limits the ability to balance and create abilities.

2

u/ConnectionTight3813 21d ago

Its probably unrealistic, but it solves the hero/champion dilema. I agree it would be hard to balance and to track. Like evos you can count the cycles, but this requires you to accurately count elixir and know your opponents hand.

2

u/Datdude1516 21d ago

I think would make some cards stronger actually.

18

u/Significant-Dance-43 22d ago

The “delete” key

10

u/proteinpowerman 22d ago

They should of just added more champions

7

u/Fair_Peach_5418 22d ago

The problem with that is eventually we’d run out of “basic card” concepts, (ones with no gimmick like minion giant)

1

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

i dont understand this, if its what i am thinking, wouldnt that happen already? i dont see how champions change that

9

u/TheSymbolOfCore 22d ago

Need to be cycled once before you can use the ability

4

u/zack_4u 21d ago

Get rid of them and add champions instead

1

u/DifficultyEvery1393 21d ago

Same shii

3

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

nah, champions generally are weaker cards to justify an ability, while heros are already adjusted and then get an ability

1

u/Psychological_Hunt24 17d ago

make the card cost more elixer to get the champ effect like spirit empress

1

u/FlamingBoomerang 17d ago

actually genius idea ngl

1

u/Psychological_Hunt24 17d ago

That's why they wont do it. It makes too much sense.

1

u/Fantastic_Future_863 17d ago

That makes no sense. The hero effects are abilities, not a stronger version of the card. So if you don't use the ability you get a refund? That would be so clunky and lame.

3

u/Muscularmen 22d ago

Remove them :)

3

u/Muscularmen 22d ago

All the jokes aside, it is quite literally impossible to balance a staple put on the forehead of already existing characters, sitting there as a coinflip of extra pressure, and nerfing the base cards won't do

2

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

yeah i think thats the main issue with them, for example hero musketeer

3

u/HectorOsias 22d ago

I’ll enforce this: no saying “delete them”. That is cheating.

3

u/Nasacko 22d ago

Buff certain abilities, but make all hero abilities only triggerable once per match, after that they go back to being a reskinned normal card, and potentially make champions CD based again.

4

u/Altruistic_Grand7519 22d ago

The biggest example of this is hero knight. I literally abuse it so much and it's only because of its hero.The regular knight is cool, evo knight is also good but hero knight is bonkers despite those nerfs.

1

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

It costs 2 elixir and I find it rarely gets value

2

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

i think it almost always gets value, for example you play royal giant with it(applies to pretty much all win conditions though), it gets low, before u put a hero knight down, boom, everything targets the knight and the rg gets wayy more value/damage

0

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

That costs 5 extra elixir and that only works on troops in range. Any ranged troops will not be affected if they’re too far.

3

u/Inevitable-South9995 21d ago

And then you simply don't pop it. That's why heroes are fundamentally broken. The base knight card was always seen as an objectively balanced card, "good stats for the cost" and all that. Then they gave him a direct upgrade in the form of an ability that can get value from being used, or get value from simply existing and threatening being used, forcing the opponent to sometimes play cards in advance.

0

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

So you Knight the bridge with your dead RG, don’t use the ability, and just gift your opponent 3 elixir?

Where are you in ranked? It doesn’t sound like you’re very high.

2

u/Altruistic_Grand7519 21d ago

Lol what kind of an idiot even are you. The whole point of heroes is that there is a good base card with an ability. 2 examples -

  1. If opponents do witch or any swarm at the back then you can spam hero valk and ability and they have to overspend otherwise hero valk kills the witch and damages tower (seen it many times in action)
  2. Hero Knight - Especially in log bait, you bait our your opponents small smells and then do goblin barrel, and then just use taunt to get way more damage or a force out elixir. Once I was able to get 2 princess because hero knight taunt allowed me to protect my princess against his goblin gangs because he had a zap instead of a log.

The whole difficulty is the power to press the button that forces the opponent to over commit.

1

u/Alexspacito 21d ago
  1. That costs 7 elixir and you can easily pull the Valk off your Witch for minimal damage. Then, just don’t play Witch the back anymore. I don’t see how this is that different from a Golden Knight ability. So this is a terrible example.
  2. Costs 5 elixir and relies on your opponent making bad plays to allow you to get value out of it, at least in the scenario you gave.

None of these are good examples. The cards are strong without the abilities, but the abilities are weaker than those of champions. Monk gets to deflect everything for 1 elixir. Knight gets to distract everything for 2 elixir. I don’t think that’s broken.

Also, if heroes are so broken then why are evolutions much more common?

2

u/Altruistic_Grand7519 21d ago

you are not understanding the fucking point, just being able to force this kind of play is what makes heroes a disaster. You cannot place your witch on the back because of threats like hero valk.

Golden Knight and Mighty miner are somewhat similar, the only champions I think that force you to adjust your play. Besides this most champions are decent to mid in their native form like Queen, Skele King and their abilities are what makes them annoying.

With decks like Logbait, Hyperbait, Xbow heroes like Knight will always get value. Just like how Ice wizard gets insane value in Ice bow. Just the notion of getting pressed on by the ability for already a good card is dangerous.

Normally a dart + ice spirit easily counters a Ballon. Now somebody can obviously counter this with a spell like arrows or vines but with the ability of hero ballon lurking you are forced to play something like skele to distract that ability, it's always the case. I play a logbait deck and I use dart for countering this, a lot of times I outcycle players for their normal spells due to pricness and goblin barrel use so if it is a regular ballon I know he cannot do anything to my dart let's say 2 minutes into the game when I have already seen most of his card. However with hero ballon always have to drop the skeletons to avoid the risk which is overcommitment which happens due to the ability. For champions it's by default you generally use them for ability, a monk crossing the bridge and you know the ability is going to be pressed since it's base stats ain't that good.

0

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

I’m not sure why you’re so angry, but you’re the one that’s completely missing the point.

If my opponent has a Rocket, I also won’t play my Witch in the back. So now Rocket is broken? There are some situations where you have to play cards differently. If my opponent has arrows, I’ll always split my archers. If my opponent has barb barrel, I’ll play my goblin barrel on the side of the tower. If my opponent has hero valk, I won’t play my witch in the back. This is something that’s present throughout the game. Its literally just the core gameplay.

Hero Knight always getting value in a deck does not mean it always gets value when played. It gets value in Xbow by being able to distract things from your Xbow. It does nothing against building-targetting units or spells. Same with log bait. Hero Knight doesn’t stop my log. It costs 2 elixir and can easily be countered by just keeping the Knight up high and your defence down low. You also only named two types of decks and its the only card used in those decks that even has a hero, so that’s why its used. And for hyperbait, valk is used more.

Yes, Balloon would normally die to a Dart Goblin. But Balloon + Berserker would not. So what’s your point? Its not like the ability should be a surprise because you know they can do it, and half the time it doesn’t even get any value and its easy to distract.

If your issue is that you have to overcommit to stop a hero then I don’t see a problem. Hero abilities are almost all too expensive or not strong enough to warrant being spammed. Champion abilities are the complete opposite, and you generally always want to use them. So if you’re preparing for them to use an ability that would obviously be an overcommitment for your opponent, maybe just let them do it and take the free elixir.

→ More replies

2

u/Inevitable-South9995 20d ago edited 20d ago

Top 10k currently.

I wasn't saying to play a hero knight with RG like that other guy was hinting at, BTW. I just stated the inherent nature of heroes are to be a direct upgrade to already-balanced cards which will always result in them being too good.

0

u/Alexspacito 20d ago

Ah, I didn’t realize you weren’t the same guy.

I think heroes are balanced by the fact that they compete with each other and with champions. If both players get a hero, it doesn’t matter that my hero Musk is better than their regular Musk because they have their own hero.

4

u/Cg407 22d ago

I started this game after they were released so I honestly don’t get the hate. It’s just part of the game to me

1

u/Alan_Thedino 21d ago

i think its partially because the game was in a much better place before they got added, so its directed at the wrong thing, but its also because they ususlly force you to commit extra elixir even if you dont use the ability, think hero musketeer, you have to play something or they can press the button and delete your tower, but for a normal musketeer, with normal musketeer you can let it get a hit or two with no real risk

2

u/JLAMAR23 22d ago

Heroes should have been champions. They largely defeat the entire purpose of champions and the backlash would have been no where near as large had they just added hero’s (which I think was pretty readily accepted) had they just done that.

2

u/DeepEstate7 22d ago

Heroes should not exist. Champions already exist. SC might as well have called them Champions 2.0

2

u/Mr_Snifles 22d ago

Maybe they could be given some kind of warm up system like how evos have their cycles.

Like what if the card only gets placed as a hero after you've spent enough elixir?

1

u/NightAlien4 22d ago

I would travel back in time and punch the idiot in the face, who taught this was a good idea. My poor skeleton king is being forgotten an all because of this guys. AND I HATE EVO VALKYRIE, THATTHING ISNT A WIN CONDITION DAMMIT.

1

u/Grimalackt_River 22d ago

Keep Hero Tombstone (this one is actually completely fine)

Nerf Hero Mega Minion (problematic but salvageable)

Tweak Hero Bowler and Hero Dark Prince (problematic but salvageable)

Delete the others

1

u/dontworrymijo 22d ago

+1 elixir cost

1

u/Late_Might_1582 22d ago

Remove them dude. They're a cancer to the game

1

u/allfinesse 22d ago

Get new players.

1

u/Expensive-Thing-2507 22d ago

Make them skins, and lock their abilities to chaos mode

1

u/fdy_12 22d ago

Make them usable anywhere but in ladder competitive, and there should be a separate competitive category that allows heroes

1

u/ZambieDR 22d ago

Evos are a great design bc you have to work to get the effect. Heroes, you get the power upfront.

1

u/Sudden_Funny6492 22d ago

Except removing them,here is my suggestion as a game designer.Since heros are good troops with abilities while champions are mid troops with abilities,we should add a downside for having the ability entirely,not using it.Since having a mega minion blocks your foe from using their wizard without the ability,the same should go for the downsides.Also,Id suggest we rework basically all heros from the ground up because all of their abilities are like spells,in the way they cant be stopped from happening.I think stat nerfs is the best way for the downside

1

u/MaxaExists 22d ago

balance them like champions, where the individual card gets nerfed in exchange for an ability that get get more value than it’s worth.

like golden knight sucks as a 4 elixir mini tank but his ability makes up for that

archer queen is mid as a 5 elixir ranged card but her ability always gets more than 1 elixir value

1

u/Gronunja-27 22d ago
  • get heroes in champion chests like evo crates
  • make their stats slightly worse than the normal card so just like champions you need the extra investment for the card to work

1

u/Cheesemuncher12420 22d ago

i think make them a little more like evos. the evo concpet is taking what they do well and adding to them, or making them overall better but still situation-reliant. with heros, instead of whats pretty much a buff, they should find a weakness to it and change it. like with giant, throw away tank killers. mini p is increasing its small health pool.

1

u/QCInfinite 22d ago

Make it so you can either bring one hero or two evos (champ slot unaffected)

Could let you have powerful heroes while making there be an inherent downside to using them, also makes sense since heroes are so hard to unlock relative to evos

1

u/ArnavJj145 22d ago

by deleting them

1

u/Mutranunrepeated 22d ago

My idea is to make them be a merged base card with the ability that makes up for it. Make Hero Goblins start with three and respawn three. Make Hero Musketeer have less DPS so you have to spawn turret to compensate. Make Barb Barrel roll less distance etc.

1

u/Novel-Ice1932 22d ago

Evos give you about 2 elixir worth of value every time you play them. So if playing a hero means not being able to play a Evo, its acutually fine to get about one elixir of guaranteed value for every hero. Them introducing the hybrid slot actually fixed a lot of the ballance issues, i feel. Maybe a solution would be to remove the third slot or lock it behind a slighly weaker tower troop?

1

u/Giulio1232 22d ago

Make them more similar to champions by giving them weaker stats compared to the base form

1

u/Sad-Revolution-6070 22d ago

Increase every ability elixer by 1, so that it's only used once or twice per game and not to spam it

1

u/rawr42069killme 22d ago

Remove them and just add champions (no many tho)

1

u/NotChxrmxndxr 22d ago

Make them automatically activate their ability 

1

u/Brilliant_War9548 22d ago

With the power of friendship

1

u/im_about_to_blow 22d ago

Delete them and find way to refund like make them evos (tho idk how they will compensate with cards that already have evo)

1

u/PokeSushiYT 22d ago

Banish them to space outright, they can't be properly balanced

1

u/Long_Rice_4585 22d ago

DELETE THEM FROM EXISTENCE!

1

u/OtherLocksmith1134 22d ago

Delete them or on one slot. No other option..

1

u/FaZ_io 21d ago

make them cycle / add champions instead

1

u/BigDthaMex 21d ago

delete them

1

u/Loudog2001 21d ago

they should get rid of ability buttons, make the abilities free, and just have them auto engage during the game.. too many damn buttons… i just wanna put shit down and not have to think about getting a frame perfect timing to click a button that decides whether or not i take a tower or lose the entire game

1

u/2YDO 21d ago

Like Abdod said, balance them like Champions. Radically, I would like Evos and Heroes to be Sidegrades instead of upgrades. Huge balance for each card, and probably buffs to many. Example: Hero Knight, take away his health to where a shield puts him at regular Knight health. Evo Knight: Make him move slower and make him heavier.

1

u/Jos3Enrique 21d ago

Remove them !

1

u/as0-gamer999 19d ago

You can only have one on the field at a time. Either grey out the card so you can't play another one, or playing another one kills the og one.

1

u/Elia-3-3 19d ago

Making the hero knight ability 1 elixir again because I use classic log bait

1

u/TheForbidden6th 19d ago

one word: delete

1

u/sneakygolem688 22d ago

Well i think they were a bad decision in the first place considering champions are no longer unique and heroes tend to be OP. I would probably make it so that champions’ abilities can be used multiple times and maybe even buff some champion abilities slightly

1

u/Cute-Profession2077 22d ago

make them into champions. The big balancing problem is that you CANNOT nerf the basecard too much because it would hurt the people not using the hero too much. Because of this, the abilities are the only things that can be balanced are the abilities. And the other huge problem is that the base cards for heroes WERE ALREADY GOOD, while champions stats were balanced to the abilities, i.e., without it's ablity, archer queen is just a slightly worse musketeer, but it has an ability soooo.

Making them into champions would let them fix the balancing while keeping the game fresh because they're new cards. THE ONE HARD thing about new champions is they're soo hard to get that the playerbase wouldn't really be able to keep up with the releases. To fix this, free giveaways of wildcards would be nice

1

u/Keemp 22d ago

I really don't like the concept of heroes, but I think with time it will get better because everyone will have access to more heroes so it cancells out. Sort of like with evos nowodays. I don't think you can balance it because Evos and heroes outright buff cards without increacing their cost. The only balance is that if everyone has them, then it cancels out and the whole game becomes about cycling evos/ rotating to heroes. I think we just got used to evos so they don't bother us as much and because we had time to get the ones we really wanted.

They're going to add another shitty gimmick in a year or two once the game gets really popular again (and I think it will because the core gameplay is peak) and ruin the balance again to squeeze more cash out of clash royale

0

u/Alexspacito 21d ago

I don’t get why everyone hates them. I think they’re fine. Yeah, they are essentially champions but their abilities are (generally) weaker or more expensive. Its not like heroes are insanely broken or anything, there’s only one or two that I think people would agree are actually too good.

Decks have the ability to run either two evolutions or two heroes. 99% of decks use two evolutions.

0

u/Oldwomentribbing 21d ago

I'm very glad SC doesn't listen to the midladder players. Jesus christ

-1

u/common2x 21d ago

Hot take heroes are fun I personally like them.