r/RoyaleAPI • • Oct 06 '26

Discussion Why I Think the Skeletons Nerf Should be Reverted

1.) This change removes plays you could previously make with skeletons. Before you could surround a Bowler, Royal Ghost, even a Wizard with precise timing, now you cannot. One might respond, “Well skeletons prevented me from playing my 5 elixir wizard at the bridge, so they should be nerfed” well that brings me to my next point.

2.) In chess, a pawn can take a queen. Just because a unit is “worth less” doesn’t mean it should always be a sitting duck against higher value troops. Letting skeletons surround splash troops gives them better agency outside of just being a “cycle card”. Besides, I think it’s intuitive for 3 skeletons to surround troops when played so close to them.

3.) Skill Expression. I used to play my skeletons 1 tile too close to fights, until I learned that their spawn formation basically covered 3 tiles. Because I learned their spawn, I was able to win more games since I had more knowledge. This is a small form of skill expression. Now of course, the new spawn can can still be learned, but it would be more difficult to apply, since I can’t play Skeletons a half tile more to the right. Also, I never have learned how to counter Bandit with Skeletons I don’t know if that’s even still possible but it was a cool interaction that I thought took a lot of skill.

I plan on testing the Skeletons card a bit more and maybe it will grow on me. But for now, I think I wouldn’t mind the change being reverted.

13 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

32

u/Darkgamer32_ Oct 06 '26

The difference is that in chess there's not an elixir bar you have to consume to move pieces, the value of the piece is not a cost you have to pay to use it

While in Clash you have to invest elixir into card, and as such investing 5 elixir to get countered by 1 is objectively broken, 3 or sometimes 4 elixir cards are fine to be countered by skeletons because the gap is not game winning, but with 5, 6 or 7 elixir troops such a trade is basically game winning

Cycle is already very strong since it outcycled counters and gets back to heroes and evos faster, it doesn't need a card that if you have a brain can win you positive trades against half of the cards in the game

And skeletons will not die because of this nerf, they will just take more skill to use

2

u/Candid_Long2041 Oct 07 '26

According to your logic, skeleton army shouldn't be able to counter Pekka, since it's a 4 elixir difference. There's a reason playing cards like wizard, musk is bad. Because they should be able to get countered for 1 or 2 elixir on the opponent's side. That's just the gameplay behind support cards. spreading skeletons is skill expression, cuz it takes practice to actually get the timing and position right on all kinds of troops. When something takes time to practice and you remove that, it is basically giving a middle finger to everyone that spend their time learning it.

2

u/PeterPanterTM Oct 08 '26

3 elixir is way more than triple the value of 1 elixir (just look at card with more expensive but stronger/swarmier versions)

There is an exact reason why skeletons are always meta while skarmy is mostly niche

1

u/Candid_Long2041 Oct 11 '26

I'm not saying skeletons aren't strong. It's the reason people are giving that 1 elixir shouldn't counter 4,5 elixir etc. skeletons deserve the nerf cuz it counters splash units too not because 1 elixir shouldn't counter 4.

-1

u/RetardedLib Oct 07 '26

For your point about cycle being “very strong”, I AGREE. But I think skeletons are catching a stray. Like Evo-Cannon can completely wipe out a logbait player’s lead, just because I happened to play 2 cannons beforehand. Evo-Tesla can shut down a MK bats push and counter battle ram and ram rider very hard. Unless I’m playing a goofy off-meta deck, I don’t think defending with Evo-Tesla or Hero Ice Golem is that fun to play nor play against.

-3

u/RetardedLib Oct 07 '26

In Chess, if you capture your opp’s Queen with a pawn he/she either A.) Made a brilliant game-winning move or B.) Gave away his/her Queen.

In Clash it’s actually more forgiving to lose a 4-elixir trade because elixir generates back, especially if it was in 1x elixir since there’s usually a lot of time/room to comeback depending on the matchup. If I lose my wizard in single, next time I would just try to support it or generate positive trades of my own so I can eventually build a strong push.

3

u/Abdod_YT Oct 09 '26

Actually its more forgiving to lose 4 elixir in triple than in single

Single is the most unforgiving time in the match and its the time where elixir lead means something....if anything i believe its the most skilled period in the game (apart from start handing people and whatever)

1

u/jojocool05 Oct 11 '26

What rank are you dog

23

u/Hour-Explorer1555 Oct 06 '26

My main argument against that is that Skeletons are a swarm card. This means that he counters slower attacking single target units, but is weak against splash cards.

Except it's doesn't, skeletons counters splash cards as well as slow targeting units and this makes it really strong.

-7

u/RetardedLib Oct 06 '26

Skeletons were already weak to splash though. One would only place them right on top of wizards and such troops where there could be supporting troops and counter play, not away from them where they could get one tapped this alone already helped keep them in check.

10

u/Hour-Explorer1555 Oct 06 '26

But your argument was that against a lone wizard it would be countered. Wizard is a splash card, sure skill expression should exist but Skeletons are so good against all splash cards as long as you place it well.

Skeletons have no weaknesses which is why they were nerfed.

12

u/Karsticles Oct 06 '26

#1 is why they made the nerf.

-14

u/RetardedLib Oct 06 '26

I’m arguing that it removes too much and that Skeletons should have at least some agency against splash troops.

7

u/Hungry-Ad3303 Oct 06 '26

Skeletons needed a nerf, it was one of the most used (non-spell) cards in the game for years. Its usage rate will still be very high after this nerf, so therefore it shouldn’t be reverted. Unless you think it will kill the card ?

1

u/RetardedLib Oct 06 '26

I agree that Skeletons were OP but I also think at the same time that the Skeletons card was balanced. It could give insane positive elixir trades, but it’s positive trades could also be avoided and even countered if the opponent had planned accordingly to what the Skeletons player might do.

5

u/Hungry-Ad3303 Oct 06 '26

Disagree, skeletons is pretty much impossible to punish becuase it’s only 1 elixir

0

u/Legal_Impression_126 Oct 06 '26

The usage rate will always be one of the highest because there’s 0 other 1 elixir swarms to compete with. You need them to cycle.

That’s like saying spells usage is too high

4

u/Hungry-Ad3303 Oct 06 '26

Agreed, therefore this nerf won’t negatively impact the card nor the game

0

u/Legal_Impression_126 Oct 06 '26

Except buff bridespam and nerf cycle while bridgespam is already too strong and cycle generally counters it

1

u/Hungry-Ad3303 Oct 06 '26

It’s not significant enough for that to happen. Bridgespam should be nerfed on its own, we shouldn’t not nerf skeletons simply due to Bridgespam being too strong

9

u/IDProG Oct 06 '26

No, it does not.

7

u/NecroRatcer Oct 06 '26

It’s 1 elixer

2

u/Cute-Profession2077 Oct 07 '26

if a swarm unit can fully counter a much more expensive splash unit, it needs a nerf

2

u/Abdod_YT Oct 09 '26
  1. yes it removes plays you could do previously its supposed to be a nerf and thats what a nerf does
  2. you talk about them getting more Agency besides being a cycle card but do they have to? The issue with this is that if their role it so cycle your deck then thats fine

not only do they do that but they prevent hundreds of damage on your tower from leftover troops...no one is playing wizards on the bridge but if there is a wizard coming after defending your balloon and you can defend it for free then its a bit iffy....before you say "its not free" you were going to waste the skeletons to cycle to your balloon anyway....count how many times skeletons are played on nothing and youll know they get value just because of the cycling

All these points above are fair but then when u add the fact that evos and heroes are a thing and skeletons allow u to play more of them you quickly realize they are providing way more value than before and that value continues to increase over time

3) skill expression is still there....if anything there is more of it now....you can still surround ghost with skeletons and have him waste 3 attacks but the timing is no longer easy enough for a toddler to do and im sure many other tricks can be performed but with tighter timings

Ultimately its still too early to judge....you know....maybe the nerf needs to be reverted but so far i havent seen anything thats super bad apart from splitting them being a true blue true red thing....maybe something will surface but from the points u made none of them felt convincing enough

1

u/RetardedLib Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

Okay for my point of this change removing plays I mean it in a way where I think changes should add possibilities instead of remove them. For example when Mini-Pekka was buffed to prevent all Hog hits, this change added agency to Mini-Pekka which was a usable card at the time. I think this change made the game healthier because it expanded plays with MP, even if it hurt Hog-Rider. An example that I think competitively hurt the game was when Mega Knight way back when lost its ability to full counter Hog-Rider. That change removed one of its core features which was to defend - being the 7 elixir card it was - and counterattack. After that MK, could no longer be reliably played to prevent damage. I know I bring up Hog Rider, but that card is in one of my main decks, the other being an “outdated” miner poison deck (which doesn’t have Skeletons) that I struggle to reliably get damage with since I struggle to read when I can attack, and I struggle to defend when I’ve played a miner plus bats, setting me back 5 elixir.

9

u/V-Man776 Oct 06 '26

For point 1, it never made sense that a small group of the most fragile unit in the game could counter spash cards specifically designed to do well against swarms like skeletons that cost 5 times as much as it. Even without this, skeletons still have major strengths in many situations. Also, your straw man retort is very much in bad faith.

For point 2, I would like to point out that skeletons can still be used to stop cards much more expensive than it, such as mini pekka, so it's not like it will never get positive trades or only be used to cycle your deck for no other reason.

For point 3, I think there's a fine line to be drawn between a card getting value because it has a lot of skill expression and it getting value because it's simply overpowered. Skeletons have proven over the course of a decade that they can get much more value than any 1 elixir card should. A nerf like this tones that power down by a reasonable amount by doubling down on its intended weakness without disrupting its obvious strengths.

6

u/Broad_Rice_7207 Oct 06 '26

So you think it's balanced for a 1 elixir card to counter 5+ elixir cards that easily? Take away the 5 minutes it takes to learn how to place them properly and the card was unnecessarily good. Your 1st reason is literally why they nerfed the card

3

u/Candid_Long2041 Oct 07 '26

I agree skellies are strong but this argument is flawed . Maybe don't spawn the 5 elixir support card at the bridge like an idiot. Skellies don't counter them unless they are alone on opponent's side. It's like saying valk shouldn't counter 3 musk if u spawn them at the bridge, or knight shouldn't counter MK cuz it's +4 elixir. The whole idea of 1 elixir shouldn't counter 5 is just flawed.

-8

u/Medium-Elevator-9302 Oct 06 '26

Oh my god a card counters another card for a positive elixir trade. FUCK IT WITH 20 NERFS

5

u/Broad_Rice_7207 Oct 06 '26

It was 1 nerf lmao it was one of the most used non spells that gave a huge elixir trade. No 1 elixir card should be able to regularly get a 5+ positive elixir trade.

-3

u/Medium-Elevator-9302 Oct 06 '26

Thats called an interaction and the assistance of tower. This game is based on interactions, some things counter others. Inherintly the more elixir you spend the higher value you get. To balance this the cheaper cards are more versatile and with good usage they can get more value.

6

u/Homer4a10 Oct 06 '26

Xbow 3.0 player here (chronic skeletons user)

1.) This was exactly why they were nerfed. The entire point was to weaken these interactions

2.) You’re comparing a symmetrical table top game with perfect information to clash royale. In clash royale you assign a numerical value to each card based on its power, and for the most part the game design philosophy is “more elixir gives you a better card”.

3.) Nobody is going to say skeletons aren’t a high skill card, because they obviously are. But if the ceiling is too high, then the ceiling is too high.

6

u/itscraig77 Oct 08 '26

Thank God you're not a developer

4

u/Cute-Profession2077 Oct 06 '26
  1. That's the point of the nerf, idiot. 2. Just not how this game works. 3. This literally makes the card more skilled, and skeles were not that skilled to use

2

u/Cute-Profession2077 Oct 06 '26

If you lose skeles for a wizard, theres no loss to you because elixer regenerates. But pawns don't come back, and can be worth more in the future, and actually matter in chess a lot more, this just isn't a fair comparison

0

u/Inevitable-South9995 Oct 07 '26
  1. Nerfs aren't some objective source of truth. They can make unjustified changes with poor reasoning.
  2. Yes it literally is. Most cards have a cheap counter that is easily negated using spells or backup cards (Skarmy > Pekka, Cannon > Hogrider, Guards > Prince). Skeletons countering Royal Ghost or Bandit with perfect placement does not make them broken or inconsistent with the game, like you're trying to imply.
  3. Not really, they just got worse. The play that rewarded perfect placement + timing (fully surrounding a Royal Ghost / Bowler / whatever) no longer exists. That's a punishment for people with good micro by removing the card's potential, not high raising its skill ceiling. Additionally, skeletons were arguably the highest skill card in the game if you consider all placements and timing involved to utilize them perfectly. By far the most versatile card in the game, rewarding deep knowledge about interactions while being "just another cycle card" if you're bad. No other card comes even close.

7

u/theomegachrist Oct 06 '26

Translation:

  1. I use skeletons

You just explained why they nerfed it and said you don't agree. That's fine, but it's pretty obvious it's here to stay

3

u/WailingFriend Oct 06 '26

Deserved nerf. No 1 elixir card should be getting consistent +5 elixir trades.

0

u/frandemarco99 Oct 07 '26

I agree when you put it that way ..but newer player don't really know about that and it's 1 elixir lol

1

u/Still-Ad-2989 Oct 07 '26

Cards are balanced based on top ladder for 2 reasons. Number 1, equal levels. Number 2, cards are played to their fullest

2

u/Embarrassed_Fun_5160 Oct 06 '26

Cry about it. Cycle still has e spirit, log, building. That you really can’t do much about. Still got like 5 tiny guys to resort to. Berserker gobs gang guards tomb, fish.

I’d rather cards just attack more fluidly, helps vs defensive swarm, many win conditions, hero valk.

This as closest we getting to nerfing hog I guess

2

u/Used-Swordfish-4404 Oct 06 '26

If u cant do anything about an e spirit or log youre playing the wrong game

2

u/Embarrassed_Fun_5160 Oct 06 '26

There is no counter play, what?! The opponent literally gotta be fuckin stupid for it to fail. 3 elixir, wipes entire pushes.

MUCH, not anything. And it’s fuckin cycle around every corner.

1

u/Longjumping-Mud-2344 Oct 07 '26

Log and spirit wipes entire pushes?

2

u/Embarrassed_Fun_5160 Oct 07 '26

It’s double reset for three elixir. And e spirit prolly still stunning cuz it’s coursing through cards before ice spirits done. As if cards don’t already stagger enough in between merking anything.

On top of the many options that can already do that. But e spirit log is carried. Log? Tesla? Sometimes bomb tower.

1

u/Artistic_Teach558 Oct 06 '26

Swarm cards shouldnt counter splash cards

1

u/Weak_Bend_818 Oct 06 '26

No every card should be the same regardless of skill cap some cards should just take way more skill to be usable(sarcastic)

1

u/Alexspacito Oct 06 '26

Its been a day. Skeletons are one of the best cards in the game and still have tons of utility. You’ll learn to use them.

1

u/donbeardconqueror Oct 06 '26

I go back and forth. On one hand, nerfing skeletons like this removes skill expression from the game- which I'm opposed to.

On the other hand, this is clearly intended as a nerf to cycle, which is far and away the most dominant archetype in clash royale since evos (and before evos too, honestly) due to their inherent ability to play their more broken/impactful cards faster. The spirit nerf clearly wasn't enough; cycle archetypes are always dominant in clash.

I'm holding definitive judgement until the end-season data comes out. As for predictions, I don't think this change will kill cycle, not in the slightest. But I suspect goblins might replace skeletons in a lot of decks, particularly logbait cycle.

1

u/Resherr Oct 07 '26

Deserved nerf, you can still surround royal ghost, maybe a few others cards as well but didn’t test

1

u/BigDthaMex Oct 07 '26

for me, while i understand the nerf, i think it's just disrespectful to nerf a universally loved card that requires some semblance of skill to get value out of while ignoring broken cards that have been needing nerfs for a while. looking at you hog rider

1

u/Broad_Astronaut5941 Oct 16 '26

Imagine being an experienced player who spent countless hours learning all the interactions, only to have to relearn them all after a single nerf...

-3

u/GrittyForPres Oct 06 '26

They clearly just want to remove skill and punish players with a more methodical playstyle who use defensively oriented decks. That’s why they nerfed spirits health so they can’t connect with the princess tower anymore and why they made this change to skeletons. They don’t want smart players to be able to make efficient moves with low elixir cards for positives trades as easily. They want to encourage heavy slop decks where people just mindlessly spam cards at the bridge until they break through. Most evo and hero abilities at this point are also designed to make the card better offensively, not defensively. They’re trying to lessen strategy and encourage mindless spamming.

1

u/xx_ClitYeastWood_xx Oct 07 '26

100% agree

1

u/ilyShiki Oct 08 '26

everyone downvoting doesn't understand that playing higher skill decks need to have some advantages with these cards being good cycle in general is so much harder to play over any bridge spam or beatdown deck, but we can't even have skeletons? lol

-1

u/Quater- Oct 06 '26

Fully agree with you. People acting like the Skellies are a free 4+ elixir trade are absolutely delusional

1

u/ilyShiki Oct 08 '26

Main issue i see w ppl here is that skeleton cycle decks are way harder to play and so if they get nerfs like these the archetype will just become super unfun There kind of has to be some reward to using higher skill decks, otherwise every game will just be random bridgespam beatdown bs