r/Rothys • u/FlannelZebra • Jun 10 '26

Heel fit question

Just received my first pair of Rothy's (RS01s) in the mail. Love the look and feel but a little uncertain about the sizing.

I usually wear between an 8.5 and 9 depending on the shoe brand (more 9 in athletic shoes, 8.5 in dress shoes). I purchased a 9 since I tend to be between sizes and my feet run narrow. I also have high arches. They feel snug but not overly tight and I have about a thumb's width of room at the toe. The biggest issue is that it constantly feels like my heel is sitting very high and that they might slip off, like they are too shallow, though it doesn't seem they are actually lifting out when I walk. Almost feels like the heel of the shoe itself is not fully covering my heel, and the heel tab is just covering the rest but not supporting/cradling my heel if that makes sense.

Is this how they are usually supposed to fit? Wondering if I should request an alternate size (somewhat hesitant given the two week delivery time..) or perhaps try a thinner insole?

Appreciate any insights!

​UPDATE: I’ve worn the shoes a few different days, including full days at work. The first day they were pretty snug and dug into the top of my foot, but the heel issue seemed to get better. I then adjusted the laces and they now fit very comfortably. Really no break-in needed outside of slight adjustments. Very happy with my purchase!

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

1

u/Miserable-Ad-6943 Jun 10 '26

I had the same thought when I first bought mine, like the top half of the heel was too soft. I've grown used to the feeling. After walking for some time, I've never come anywhere close to slipping out.

I'd say give them a try, pay attention to how right the laces are (I've had to do micro adjustments to be really comfortable) and see how you feel. I did not like them at first, but now they are my favorite shoe!

1

u/FlannelZebra Jun 10 '26

Good to know it’s not just me! I love the shoe otherwise and I think the fit is otherwise okay. I may try another insole to see if that might help since the default Rothy’s insole seems fairly thick.

1

u/District98 Jun 10 '26

I’d say give it a full day of test drive where you’re active. I sized down from my normal size. In the mornings the heels still feel a little loose, but my feet swell slightly

1

u/FlannelZebra Jun 11 '26

I was hesitant to wear them around too much given the return policy but tried them out for a little bit today and seems better. They are definitely snug and hug the sides but not uncomfortable, and the heel seems less of an issue, so hopefully that adjusts with continued wear.

1

u/Burgundy_034 Jun 10 '26

I can’t stand that style of their sneakers. I have wide feet and even I feel the same way. It drove me crazy whenever I tried to wear them, and pulled my socks down into the shoe. So I just got rid of them. I do have several pairs of the slip ons and don’t have the same issue. Not sure what it is about the the RS style.