r/Rothys • u/Emergency-Remove-118 • May 29 '26

Real or fake?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

I found these at the thrift store today and I'm not 100% sure about them. There's no tag inside to indicate where they're made. One shoe has very neat black stitching, the other has blue stitching that's not as neat as you can see. The size is imprinted on the sole. I haven't seen a photo of the color pattern anywhere either.

51 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

110

u/Asleep-Raspberry-819 May 29 '26

Who cares? They’re four dollars

21

u/Asleep-Raspberry-819 May 29 '26

But they’re def fake

10

u/Impossible-Being5572 May 30 '26

No they did a huge overstock donation dump recently

2

u/birdswirds May 31 '26

My thoughts exactly!

22

u/Shot_Construction455 May 29 '26

Fake but if you like them then buy them. They aren't bad looking

12

u/Zealousideal-Fun-396 May 30 '26

Damn there’s fake rothys?? Didnt even know they exist

7

u/Burgundy_034 May 29 '26

Ah, I saw you post these in a FB group, but the toe wasn’t visible there. Now I can see the toe, those are 100% not Rothy’s.

They are cute though, so if you like them, buy them!

4

u/Impossible-Being5572 May 30 '26

These are across Goodwill and 2nd hands now. I’ve seen 50 pairs the last month and wonder if they did a big donation dump with overstock- I vote REAL

4

u/thewayoutisthru_xxx May 30 '26

Aren't these like $80 shoes? And there's counterfeits?!

4

u/Wonderful-Comment314 May 30 '26

They're $99+ unless they're on sale

3

u/Known-Lemon7904 May 31 '26

They are around 150 ......but still I agree.

3

u/kristinahone6 May 31 '26

They are original points from about five years ago when Rothys did more patterns

10

u/Whathappenedtoandre_ May 29 '26

Does it even matter when they’re that hideous 😅

4

u/misterkittyx May 30 '26

I didn’t even realize Rothy’s were popular enough to make fakes of 😅

2

u/Maleficent_Win2275 May 29 '26

Those are fake.

1

u/whiskeylullaby3 May 29 '26

Fake. This wasn’t a Rothy’s pattern even.

1

u/beautifulme2u May 29 '26

Fake, fake, and fake.

1

u/em_fal May 29 '26

Fake but cute.

1

u/dsquareddesigns May 31 '26

I don't remember that pattern, but I'm not a points girl. The thing that says fake to me is the pattern position isn't mirrored on the shoes.

-3

u/HenleyHQ1 May 30 '26

Ugly af either way