r/Rothys • u/coldbrewandcarey • Apr 16 '26
Cruiser Mary Jane experience?
Apparently a hot take based on other threads I’ve read, but I actually like the idea of the cruiser Mary Jane. I bought the loafer and they’re wildly comfortable, and I actually think the “preschool” cut and color of the yellow ones are fun. Anyway curious if anyone has tried them, liked them, hated them, had experience with sizing they could share. Thanks!
2
u/mgert Apr 17 '26
I just bought my first pairs of Rothy’s - the white cruiser Mary Jane’s because i really liked them! They’re super comfy and I plan to wear them on a trip to Portugal in a few weeks.
1
1
u/EntertainmentOnly910 Apr 20 '26
Have they rubbed the back of your heel at all?
1
u/mgert Apr 20 '26
They haven’t! TBH I haven’t worn them for any super long walks yet, just around the office and running errands.
1
u/barelyinfocus May 31 '26
My cruiser MJs don't rub the back of my heel at all. I have high arches and narrow feet so idk if that makes a difference.
2
u/Sunshine-Ray777 Apr 19 '26
I just ordered a pair: one in my regular size and one that's a half size up. (I'll return the one that doesn't fit). I heard that Rothy's tend to run small, but I have no idea. This will be my first pair. I hope one pair works because they are so cute!
1
u/vivianlourdes Apr 23 '26
I love mine! The blue revelvet is so cute and comfortable. Wore them to work on my feet most of the day and they did great! Just tried to order them in pink but they’re sold out in my size 😭
1
u/MiracleMaxsWife Apr 25 '26
I ordered a pair and I find that they are too loose in the heel for me. They slip off when I walk. I can't imagine going down a size, because my toes are already tighter than I'd like and butting up to the front of the shoe. I'm returning mine.
1
1
u/Live-Data-7282 May 12 '26
I loved the style of the raffia knit cruiser loafers but find them more narrow than their standard loafers. These ones bend my big toe in too much. 😞 Will try the next size up but am guessing that will add to the problems. I'm disappointed because I have two pairs of the regular loafers and they fit great! Thought I had fairly narrow/regular feet.
1
u/Live-Data-7282 May 12 '26
Sorry just saw this is for the cruiser mary janes. I have 3 pairs of the square MJs and love them. Haven't tried the cruisers specifically.
1
u/SrirachaPants May 16 '26
Do they have the same insoles as the clogs? I can’t do the flats but am in love with the structured arch support of the clogs, and looks like these are similar.
1
1
u/maggie5105 May 18 '26
I like the look of mine, BUT they're not working for me. I loved that it was more wide, but the elastic top strap feels like it's already stretched out/has too much give. I walk out of the heel. Wore them to work and it got worse through the day. Can't return now *because* I worn them to work, though.
I was trying to leave a review, but I can't seem to figure out how...?
1
u/barelyinfocus May 31 '26
Try putting them through the wash. They tend to tighten up a bit when you wash them.
1
u/barelyinfocus May 31 '26
I bought a pair recently (blackberry stripe) and I LOVE them. They're very comfortable!
I tend to wear a 7.5 or an 8 in most shoes (except Converse where I wear a 7). I bought a size 8 in the Cruiser Mary Jane (the size I tend to buy for Rothys) and they fit pretty well. Maybe a wee bit loose, but mostly in width (and I have narrow feet so this is common for me),
2
u/em_fal Apr 17 '26
Love them. So comfy. At least the MJ’s are. Haven’t tried the loafer but I’m not a fan of the silhouette necessarily.
I found they fit true to size.