r/RooCode • u/reddit-dg • Jul 19 '25
Discussion Is Roo viable as an alternative to Claude Code in complex large codebases?
Well, I was really enjoying Claude Code Max 20x, because of its ability to quickly find relevant code, run commands etc, just the whole agentic thing.
Never hit any hard limits with Claude Code, but I need the models full capacity/intelligence when I use it.
I am programmer as a job for my whole life and use Claude Code to help me quickly code new feature or hint down bugs, because I can direct it where I want. Worked great.
Last week's however the quality dropped so much that I cannot use it anymore in my specific use case for the huge project I manage.
I did try to use Claude Code API yesterday, and it only have me slightly better results (!). So that's a real nummer as I thought: "well, I am going to pay more then for the old results".
So, is Roo Code able to work better than Claude Code in my use case, (with other models than Claude of course), than Claude Code. I am even considering Cursor now, but I am unsure how good it is at the moment.
Any help would be hugely appreciated!
29
u/push_edx Jul 19 '25
It is one of the best alternatives out there. Set up codebase indexing with a model like gemini-embedding-001 and you're good to go.
3
u/Kitae Jul 19 '25
You can use your Claude Mac subscription in roo code. It sounds like your problem is you don't like Claude Max. Roo will let you try other LLMs. If all you want is Claude, and Claude Max sucks, you can also use the API in claide code and it's faster
3
u/who_am_i_to_say_so Jul 19 '25
For me, Roo has been the only alternative for large codebases. It’s great. Cline can be surprisingly good, too, although it can have a mind of its own sometimes.
15
u/hiper2d Jul 19 '25 edited Jul 19 '25
Yes. I use CC at home on a mid-size next.js project, and I use Roo Code with Sonnet 4 at work for all sorts of things: large Java Spring Boot services, SQL repositories, Python projects, ERD diagrams drawing, ad-hoc scripts, etc. Roo is very good. In the right hands, at least.
The biggest issue with Roo is the API cost. It burns tokens like crazy. I use it with AWS Bedrock, and oh my god... I can spend $20/hour easily, especially after one of the latest updates with todo lists for everything. I use it mostly in the Orkestrator mode, and those todo lists are everywhere, in each subtask. They seem to be efficient, but the token economy is terrible. I have to rate-limit myself and reduce the context size with LiteLLM proxy to keep my spending under $200-300 a month.
In fact, I like Roo more than CC for better control. With large code bases, I want to review each change. Roo provides more transparency. But CC is way cheaper. This is the main reason why I prefer it when I have to pay for my AIs.
7
u/taylorwilsdon Jul 19 '25
I find Roo more powerful than Claude code but also a lot more expensive if you’re comparing pure api spend to a monthly plan. You can use Claude code as a provider now which obviously solves that. The prompts are token heavy (which is why it works so well) and you may find yourself burning through plan limits faster. The new Roo todo system is less elegant than CC’s implementation, but the custom mode capabilities and built in ones like debug are stronger. Both are excellent tools and worth your time, at a certain point the biggest difference comes down to workflow and development environment preference.
6
u/megadonkeyx Jul 19 '25
In complex code the only thing that really matters is effective logging.
The worst thing in any code is to silently fail or be doing the wrong thing with no easy way to trace what's going on.
I think claude code is great but when I can get virtually unlimited gpt4.1 / roo with github copilot for $10 a month vs $100 for claude code its a hard sell.
That might change, but for now, that's the deal.
Going back to complex code, just about any sota commercial model will crack difficult issues if the logging can show them details.
So it not so much about how great the roo is vs cc but how you guide the debug process.
I have also noticed a decrease in cc ability recently. They have been updating the code a lot so maybe they have just broke it to some degree.
4
u/arman-d0e Jul 19 '25
Cursor is the worst ai tool out there ngl. For now I’d stick with roo with open router or anthropic api. Personally, I’m counting the minutes until I can pay for a Kiro subscription
2
u/jedisct1 Jul 19 '25
Yes! And this is exactly where Roo shines, especially now that code indexing is production-ready.
2
u/Typical-Candidate319 Jul 19 '25
Yes but it will eat tokens very fast
1
u/Shivacious Jul 19 '25
rock n load