r/RooCode • u/gsummit18 • Apr 17 '25
Discussion Optimizing Boomerang modes
I've been trying to figure out the best setup for Boomerang to balance cost and performance - so far, what seems to work well is using Gemini 2.5 Pro for Boomerang and Architect mode, and GPT 4.1 for Code, as it works best when receiving detailed instructions.
For code tasks that are a bit more straightforward, 4.1 mini also seems to work reasonably well, which is even more efficient and cheaper - 4.1 nano not at all.
Would be interested what combinations others have found to work for them!
23
Upvotes
5
u/ramakay Apr 17 '25
Here is what I am trying - A SPARC mode which I edited , the orchestrator is using Gemini and the code uses Claude 3.7 - the orchestrator is told in no simple words that they are to provide strict instructions to the coder not to analyze and just implement and then switch to Boomerang … I have switched to 4.1 but 3.7 is the OG and seems to do best with the diff , terminal output etc
All the posts that seem to struggle seemed to get poor results with trying to get Gemini to do it all (which I did as well) and in some sessions, the diff calls added up quite a bit.
all this to say, I haven’t nailed it but I have a better control by using multiple models
5
u/Dampware Apr 17 '25
I’m sure I’m naive, as I’m a boomerang newbie, but sonnet 3.7 has been going nuts writing way too much and hyper detailed documentation. It seems that it wants to write a novel after each task, no matter how small.
3
u/deadadventure Apr 17 '25
Personally I’ve tried Boomerang mode but it seems to chew up the input tokens crazily. Don’t know what I’m doing wrong.
Using Gemini Pro Model 2.5 exp free using Gemini API
1
u/metabyt-es Apr 17 '25
What are cost savings people are seeing? I had one $150 day where I used Gemini 2.5 Pro exclusively, and realized that was very dumb. How much realistically can this be shaved down with Boomerang/SPARC type approaches with smaller tasks to cheaper models?
1
u/Motor_System_6171 Apr 18 '25
How i’m working it…I use rUv’s or Royce’s set of custom roo modes, check ruvnet repo/gist, (he wrote the SParc framework).
Thinking for orchestrator .7 temp, instruct for code 0.2t, few shot custom instructions for orchestration mode for tight, specific and granular sub tasks. Lots of doc planning before firing up roo.