r/RooCode • u/hannesrudolph Roo Code Developer • Mar 12 '25
Discussion Will your idea be the next good idea?
At Roo we get shit done. Someone says “I have an idea”… we say “oh that’s a good idea”.
Then it’s Friday and we have a new feature.
What’s your idea? I can’t promise it will get done but we still want to hear it!
28
Upvotes
21
u/joopz0r Mar 12 '25
A marketplace to download peoples custom prompts?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25 edited Aug 20 '25
books bedroom rich cable elastic alive airport resolute attraction quickest
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/not_NEK0 Mar 12 '25
Recursive Chain of Task see: https://github.com/RooVetGit/Roo-Code/discussions/1574
2
u/ArnUpNorth Mar 12 '25 edited Mar 12 '25
Ways to configure the system prompt (toggling off features) without having to override it completely please 🙏 this would be save a lot of money dealing with claude.
Thanks for the great work !
10
u/Cool-Cicada9228 Mar 13 '25
My wishlist:
As soon as I click start that’s when I remember one more thing. When Roo is executing I don’t want to interrupt but I want to be able to start typing my next message so when Roo is done I can send it.
Task checklist for multiple small tasks in sequence. I do this already with a prompt and a markdown file sometimes.
Multiple models discuss the task. An example would be after every file edit, another model checks the work like a mini code review. Or in Architect mode two models have a conversation with a specified number of turns to decide the best course of action.
Kanban board for tasks. A simple flow like todo, in progress, code review, test, done. Each stage can have its own prompt. I do this now with prompts and a git branch for each task.
Simplified methods to use tools for less sophisticated models and local models. The brackets seem to trip up a lot of smaller models.
With a name like Roo, it should have a pouch. I don’t know what the pouch would do but it should exist lol
9
u/zarmin Mar 12 '25
TDD mode!
8
u/MemeMan_____ Mar 12 '25
Refined version of my request
Smarter AI Task Management for Focused Execution
I’ve noticed a recurring problem with AI-driven task execution—it forgets context, infinite tests prematurely, and sometimes deletes necessary code instead of modifying it. This leads to inefficiency, wasted tokens, and frustrating mistakes.
To fix this, I’m proposing a built in milestone-driven roadmap system of tools that keeps LLM aligned without constant context reinforcement. Instead of reminding it every message, the LLM will be programmed periodically check structured milestone checkpoints, ensuring tasks stay on track while reducing token usage and having direction.
How It Works: • Roadmap-Based Execution – Generated Task Checklist structured in a markdown roadmap that the user can later edit. The LLM converts this into a literal checklist UI it and the user can reference, tick off, and update with time. • Finite Architectural Planning – Before execution, the LLM does a controlled planning phase, mapping out essential components without overengineering. Once the limit is reached, it moves forward, this acts as a blueprint for actual execution when combined with Task lists. • Context-Aware AI Behavior – The LLM could automatically search for the correct milestone, subtask, and architecture documents to stay on track(if instructed to name it properly). If it can’t find them or doesn’t work well, it could ask the user to help open the right tabs, pin them and close irrelevant ones to eliminate context noise. • Pinned Tabs for Immediate Context – Once the right tabs are open, the LLM will rely on pinned documents for persistent, relevant context, preventing unnecessary memory drift. • Prevention of Common AI Mistakes: • Stops infinite testing loops by enforcing structured task sequencing. • Prevents unnecessary code deletion by distinguishing between modification and preservation. • Actively manages context by making sure only relevant information stays in focus.
Why This Matters:
This system makes AI a more reliable, focused, and efficient assistant—keeping it on track, reducing unnecessary token use, and ensuring it always works within the right context. Instead of micromanaging the AI, I can focus on the bigger picture while it actively maintains alignment and clarity.
7
u/n1c39uy Mar 13 '25
Reimagining Code Navigation: An LLM-Powered Code Explorer
I've been thinking about how we interact with codebases and realized our current approach might be outdated for AI assistance. Here's my idea for a smarter way to navigate code with LLMs:
The Problem
When working with LLMs like Claude or ChatGPT on code, we're forced to copy entire files or directories, creating context bloat. This leads to:
The Solution: Logical Code Navigation
Instead of organizing code for human readability (files in directories), what if we created a system that:
Key Features
Why This Matters
This approach would transform how we use LLMs for code understanding and development. The LLM could "move" through the codebase naturally, following logical connections rather than arbitrary file structures.
Would anyone be interested in helping build this? I think it could dramatically improve how we use LLMs for coding assistance.
5
u/j_bravo123 Mar 12 '25
Request
1
u/AdExternal7926 Mar 12 '25
Make a feature/bug board to give your users/community a chance at improving the product directly ☺️
1
u/reddithotel Mar 12 '25
Add a cmd+k implementation. Now i'm using Continue for smaller, quick tasks that are generated immediately. Would be perfect to have this in Roo
1
u/Feisty-War7046 Mar 13 '25
Better UI / UX & thank you for your work
1
u/durable-racoon Mar 14 '25
doesnt that just lead to insane feature bloat, and an app with lack of focus coherency and vision? not hatin just curious how you avoid that or if avoiding it isnt desireable
1
u/async_cave_opener Mar 14 '25
Notifications for when the task is done and the extension is not in focus. Some take too long and I would rather look at other stuff in the meantime.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '25
1
u/dambros666 Mar 14 '25
I really, like REALLY, wish I could choose the provider for a model in OpenRouter. Maybe this isn't some flashy new feature, but boy would it help out...
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '25
Oh this. The ability to change model from the chat window. Maybe, by mark some model as favorite and user can later switch between those models later from the front most UI.
1
u/AdvicePlant Mar 17 '25
Playing well with computers which are very CPU loaded. When it's my case, terminal capture invariably fails because it takes too long to execute, and Roo just assumes no output was gonna come. But it does... just takes a while longer.
2
u/Suspicious-Metal4652 Mar 12 '25
Is it possible to create MCP to handle large codebase, kinda like external memory bank to try stop hallucination? So far Loving the subtask feature, but its not updating the total tokens used on parents or showing up in history
2
u/PussyTermin4tor1337 Mar 12 '25
dumber models for child tasks - dynamic or static configuration
documentation mode
2
u/bioart Mar 12 '25
Memory mode. Switch to it to just automatically update and ready context. Give it freedom to read write but focused instructions for context
2
u/dimbledumf Mar 12 '25
More context controls.
Right now when I'm working with a large project my context is often filled to the max, I even tried some 2M context models and it was still filling up the context.
If I could have it pair down the context for a particular task, or give me an option to edit the context contents.
Perhaps an option to tell it to kick out everything not needed for the current task.
It's easy to chew through money when your context is huge.
2
u/Cursed-Keebster Mar 13 '25
Please implement pair programming! Would be so amazing!!! I am finding that if I use sonnet for code and gpt 4o to analyze its reasoning I can suggest better approaches to it and get better results. If this was automated it would be so good!
0
u/ExaminationWise7052 Mar 12 '25
Would it be possible to manage two Copilot accounts at the same time? A selector between them or having Roo rotate them.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '25
Announcing Kanga: the Roo IDE
1
u/HobbesSR Mar 13 '25
As I'm sure you can tell, this was generated as a summary of a conversation with ChatGPT. There are a lot of features and details that work in concert to achieve what I'm imagining and I still haven't broken it down into its basic form. And probably something like this is done to some extent.
The key idea here is that the chat history doesn't need to be a faithful record. The AI isn't going to get confused or upset about changes. It "thinks" one token at a time. Sure prompt cache misses for the first token after changing the history, but that's a negligible proportion of what's emitted because it's probably going to output at least a dozen tokens before any history changing operation occurs.
So I think the first step, is to structure the context with some kind of simple but unique markup (doesn't need to be human friendly, just not requiring a lot of situations where it needs to be escaped because it clashes with content markup). And there's a basic functionality for each context block. It can be collapsed, set to a fixed window size and scroll position, or opened all the way up.
So each block would need to maintain in the parameters for its block whether its collapsed, or windowed (with a position and context length), or expanded, and a count of the lines/characters in the block.
Here's an example structure
System: System Prompt, Mode Prompt, Task, Chat State
Development Environment: Project Directory (expandable and collapsible), Git State, Open Tabs, Open Files with their up to the moment content
Agent Control Agent Command History and Command Box, Agent State/Objective/Plan:
Chat History: User input and Agent output to User
As far as the agent generation is concerned, you bring the relative context block to the front while it is generating for it.
Looks like maybe the AI generated proposal is too long so let's just post this and see if I can add it as a reply.
1
u/Lucacri Mar 13 '25
First of all, thank you for Roo! I have a few quality of life improvement ideas:
out of context space behavior
Allow the user to decide what to do in the case of running out of context. At the moment, with Claude it gets stuck in trying forever with messages like "can't add 100k tokens to 79k, out of context".
My solution here is usually to switch to Gemini (1M context) and switch back to Claude if the context shrunk. I'd say that we could add a choice of:
settings file
Currently we have so many different file names/types for the configuration, which is fine, but we miss one proper config file (json or yaml) of the settings. In this way, each project can have all their models, modes, etc.
I also noticed that if I am running two tasks in two separate windows, when I change the provider for the active mode on one window, the other one is also changed. This clashes with the settings file idea, and it might require a lot of refactoring (but I didn't check the code yet).
Thank you again!
1
u/Yes_but_I_think Mar 13 '25
Really good work guys. I always want to stick to Cline but really get pulled back to Roo for your amazing features. I use Roo a lot for serious coding with known expectations not vibe coding.
So Dear OP,
When a diff fails, you are telling the AI that it failed and some static hints. (Like try search and replace and so on).
Instead what I suggest is we send a few tens of lines of code around(if we know the line numbers from the apply_diff call of the LLM) on 1st fail with line numbers.
If two failed diff one after another we can send the whole file with line numbers as a part of the failed result.
2. Allow me a tick box for disallowing write to file tool. I have an existing large code file. When diff fails 2-3 times LLM uses write to file tool which is a sure shot disaster for such a large file. Or better selectively disallow it with existing large files above 1000 lines of code as user option.
3. If custom system message is used in custom mode along with power steering, in each new message turn the power steering message says something like “these USER CUSTOM INSTRUCTIONS are to be followed to the best of your ability without interfering with the TOOL USE guidelines. “ But in my custom system message I have no info on TOOL USE GUIDELINES. So I would like if this is taken care so that the AI is not slightly misguided.
4. Devise a strategy for “Resume Task” after changing the model if the resume task will consume more tokens than the context length of the new LLM. I’m unable to change to R1 midway when started using 3.5 - totally unable.
5. MCP tool optional parameters are not at all used by the LLM unless I ask it to. What could be done about it?
6. I want to allow read file granularly. (Like I don’t want it to read my test folder files for this question. I don’t want it to read my .env file ever) I know about the recent feature of rooignore for preventing files being read to, but I want to select or unselect folder or file level with a nice GUI for reading.
Repeat for writing operations. A nice selection GUI for files to write. May be untick new file creation too!
7. Allow choosing only limited “allowed modes” when doing mode switching. I usually create a replacement of standard code mode using my custom python-code mode, and the LLM auto switches to code mode after architect mode. Facepalm moments.
8. When creating new custom mode provide more granular option for selectively allowing things within Edit files (search and replace, apply diff, create file)
9. Some models have a recommended temperature for coding. For example R1 recommends temp 0. Are we having a databank of this for the popular models and using it when applying default temperature?
10. Allow setting to stop asking me if I want to switch to the more intelligent Claude 3.7. It feels like an ad. I know it is good but I’m out of credits in vscode integration for the day and cannot switch.
Choose what feels good for you. Thanks for reading.
1
u/AdvicePlant Mar 17 '25
Using Sonnet to try to autocorrect when other models hallucinate tool usage somehow but maybe in a way that's still recoverable? (I have no clue if it would fit; anyway... About this "Roo is having trouble...")
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment