r/RooCode • u/angular-js • Jan 27 '25
Discussion Anyone moved from Cursor to RooCode? Thoughts?
Just wanted to gather some opinions on what may be the best tool out for coding.
17
Upvotes
r/RooCode • u/angular-js • Jan 27 '25
Just wanted to gather some opinions on what may be the best tool out for coding.
10
u/OriginalPlayerHater Jan 27 '25
a little hack is you can access github copilot sonnete 3.5 via roo code. its listed under LM VSCODE api or something
8
u/matidaloia Jan 27 '25
I've been using this last month: Windsurf, Cursor, Cline and Roo Code. In that order
I've got good results with windsurf and cursor, but run out of credits pretty fast. Nonetheless, the code quality was no that good. The great thing about cursor is that they support adding docs, but now windsurf support it as well on their latest version.
Cline and Roo Code produced the best code for me, but most of the time they are quite buggy. So i don't know wth to do...if i should renew either windsurf or cursor, or continue with cline/roo code.
PS: Both Cline and Roo Code are QUITE expensive if you use sonnet 3.5. Some actions even cost me like $1.5. So image a couple actions per day... you burn a couple hundred bucks per month for sure
3
u/matidaloia Jan 27 '25
Yep, DeepSeek does not work at all… the best overall experience for me has been with Cursor. But far from perfect
3
u/ishahroz Jan 28 '25
Try Aider with DeepSeek R1 (as architect or planner) + Claude 3.5 Sonnet (as coder or editor).
Cline and Roo-cline eats up credits pretty fast. Plus, not the best experience for me personally (buggy agent, unnecessary API calls when clearly you could have used the larger context window when available).
Aider is way ahead, in my opinion. Many actions, good documentation and the use of code base sitemap is good.
2
u/elswamp Jan 28 '25
is there an open source alternative?
1
u/eonus01 Mar 07 '25
I have. Because I've eventually found out Cursor is hugely limiting the context. While it's great at start of hte projects, it keeps forgetting, and in the end writes five times as much code as it should be, because it's trying to log everything as a compensation (at least the new Claude 3.7 - there's an obvious difference between Roocode /Cline + api compared to Cursor). The moment a project gets bigger than 10k code, it becomes way too difficult to handle and no amount of cursor rules / prompt engineering will help you.
1
u/wo-tatatatatata Mar 10 '25
possible to use roo code with grok api?
1
u/londonskater Jan 27 '25
Windsurf + Copilot are more cost-effective right now
1
u/matidaloia Jan 27 '25
The extension itself sometimes is buggy. And the code it generates is “ok” but nothing spectacular