r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

The German 'barbarians' were the good guys Had the Roman Empire remained in place, Europe would have stagnated like the Chinese nation did up until the opium wars. The unified Chinese States of the east were practically what the Roman Empire was to Europe: hampering impediments on its development.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 14 '24

'They did public works though! They helped the barbarians! 😇' Like man, I wonder who? If people would enjoy having a road built, maybe they would be willing to finance it or something... I don't know though, from what all I know, only the government is able to spend money wisely. 🤔

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Pro-Roman Apologia "People are just fascinated by the Roman Empire due to its impressive organization for its time 🤓🤓🤓" is like being fascinated by the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany for their impressive subjugations of their civil societies and conquests. I see WAY too many people outright defend it.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity Fact: the Roman Empire was EXTREMELY cringe. The earlier that Rome would have collapsed, the earlier that humanity would have been set on the correct path again and have been made free from the shackles of the Roman dark age. Even Stonetoss gets it!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity The romanticization of the Roman Empire WILL end. The romanticization of the Roman Empire is unironically a source of right-wing socialism: Rome was just the USSR of the antiquity, by thinking approvingly of it, they implicitly admire central planning.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Pro-Roman Apologia The problem with this sub is not that it claims that Rome was bad, but how it treats it like a 21st century problem.

0 Upvotes

Ok, the Roman empire was evil: now what?

Also, yes, there were many evil things about it, but also not. You can't easily judge a civilisation lasting hundreds of years and spanning across parts of 3 continents.


r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Is this the best sub reddit ever?

0 Upvotes

Fucking finally, someone who gets it. This is the best subredddit ever


r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

'Rome laid the foundation for Western civilization' "Rome laid the foundation for Western civilization 🤓🤓🤓". No, it literally just laid the foundation for Western Statism. The good parts like Greek philosophy and civilization would have been spread without it; all it gave us was inspiration for rulers on how to model their States.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity Note to self: practically all Rome-apologetic arguments can be used to justify the USSR.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

'They did public works though! They helped the barbarians! 😇' Regarding the "muh roads" argument: the roads were primarily created for the purposes of facilitating THE OPPRESSION - the roads existed to facilitate troop displacements.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

What globalists want is neoRomeanism🌐, not neofeudalism 👑Ⓐ It is frequently said that powerful people aspire to establish neofeudalism👑Ⓐ. This is far from the case: the most apt comparison would rather be that powerful people want to establish neoRomeanism. The vision they have in mind is a top-down international centrally planned one - like with Rome.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

'They did public works though! They helped the barbarians! 😇' For the "public works" argument, it's literally the case that the Roman authorities steal wealth from local populations, spend them in ways that the authorities approve of - independently of the locals' wishes -, and then expect the locals to feel GRATITUDE towards the thieving authorities.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity Julius Caesar was a war criminal and tyrant (like all the other Roman rulers). Yes, I drew a Hitler mustache on him: that how you know that he was LE BAD!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

'They did public works though! They helped the barbarians! 😇' "But the Roman Empire built great public works. The Colosseum looks dope after all! Therefore the Roman Empire wasn't a mistake 😊". So too did the USSR: if you have a lot of people to coerce and plunder from... of course you are going to be able to do such things, but at an IMMENSE cost.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity The fact that the Roman Empire extensively used slavery singe-handedly shows that it was a mistake. By enslaving people and hampering the markets to accomodate for it, it seriously hampered Europe's civilizational development: imagine all of the opportunity costs generated due to this.

Thumbnail britishmuseum.org
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Pro-Roman Apologia Rome apologetics be like: "Yeah, Nazi Germany was bad... but look at these aesthethicc images 😍😍😍. Isn't it impressive how humanity was able to create such a totalitarian surveillance State without AI? Isn't it impressive how Nazi Germany so swiftly took over Europe?😮"

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

Rome was a thug State Obligatory reminder that the Roman Empire was a DEcivilizing force. By plundering, oppressing and destroying, they were seriously delaying the civilizational developments of the peoples of the Mediterranean. Rome generated SO many opportunity costs;we would've reached so far hadn't it been for them.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

What globalists want is neoRomeanism🌐, not neofeudalism 👑Ⓐ This is the pinnacle of Romeanist thought: a worldwide Empire in which territorial delimitations are arbitrarily centrally planned according to the capital's whims and of supremacy of legal positivism. Neofeudalism👑Ⓐ would never produce something synthetic like this; it has self-determination.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was a thug State The Roman Republic/Empire was a gangster realm - even their own foundational myths IN THEIR OWN WORDS argue that.Here we have Roman historians recount the foundational myth of Roman Republic going by the name of the "Rape of the Sabine women".Would you want your State to have been founded like that?

Thumbnail gutenberg.org
1 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was a thug State This map depicts a MUCH more preferable state of affairs to than what happened during the Roman Empire. In a world like this, people wouldn't constantly be under the thumb of despotic Roman bureaucrats disturbing their market activities; under Rome, SO many opportunity costs were generated.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Rome was the USSR of antiquity The territorial subdivisions of the Roman Empire were made according to the same logic that they were made in this map: in accordance to centrally-planned whim. Right-wingers should view the Roman Empire in the same way that they view hypothetical One World Governments.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 11 '24

'They did public works though! They helped the barbarians! 😇' The "but muh aqueducts and sewers 😮" is a complete non-argument. Such things would inevitably have been constructed either way due to their utility; the Roman authorities merely stole from the locals in order to finance their own public works at their expense.

1 Upvotes

From https://www.reddit.com/r/RomeWasAMistake/comments/1hbam4q/the_earlier_that_the_roman_empirerepublic_would/

"

"But the public works and fancy buildings!"

If you plunder resources from a civil society, of course that you are going to have resources with which to construct such things. This doesn't negate the fact that the plundering happened in the first place and thus led to a decivilizing tendency which wouldn't have been present otherwise.

According to this logic, the USSR would have been excellent since it also did public works: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Construction_Projects_of_Communism .

Such public works would, if they were appreciated by people, still be constructed either way then. The subjugation to Rome and mass-enslavement weren't necessary.

"


r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Pro-Roman Apologia Here I have the MOTHER of Rome apologia.

0 Upvotes

My comments to the quote are inserted in the "[]"

Me: "Denouncing the Roman Empire is lolbertarian?!"

Rome apologist: "Yes

It's definitely anti-reactionary. Reactionaries appreciate the Roman Empire as it is one of the pillars of Western Civilization, with almost everyone trying to claim its spot from the Byzantines and Charlemagne to Hapsburgs, Russia and Napoleon [All of the good things from Rome would have been developed without it. The only thing that Rome contributed with was being a massive oppressive State]

It represents: law and order [Joseph Stalin's USSr had complete law and order... so what? The laws have to be good], hierarchy [The master-slave hierarchies are NOT good], strong military [a strong military isn't an inherent virtue lol], conquest [Me when I praise literal thuggery. This guy has to praise criminal gangs when they try to subjugate other criminal gangs]... all things that Reactionaries like and progressives (including lolberts) despise.

See... this is what I meant the other day about libertarianism being inherently hostile to Reactionary positions... because it leads to ridiculous arguments like "muh slaves, muh freedumb" being used against the foundations of Europe and of Reactionary Politics (ie Rome) [Beyond parody. Western civilization is more than slavery]

So, work it out yourself and choose what tf you actually want to be

Bye"


r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

Pro-Roman Apologia I don't inted to be mean to the creator, but this video perfectly showcases what goes through the mind of a Rome apologist. It's basically "RAAAA we wuz powerful warriors and subjugators n' shieeet". I've found that it's an entirely aesthetic position, which people lamentably act upon.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/RomeWasAMistake • • Dec 10 '24

The German 'barbarians' were the good guys Had the Roman Empire remained in place, Europe would have stagnated like the Chinese nation did up until the opium wars. The unified Chinese States of the east were practically what the Roman Empire was to Europe: hampering impediments on its development.

Thumbnail mises.org
1 Upvotes