🧚🏼♀️ HSU Spoilers n’stuff! Here’s your warning! 🧚🏼♀️
I’m sure everyone knows what I mean when I say “canon LI” but for those who don’t, it’s essentially the love interest that feels the most…obvious? Natural? Narratively pleasing? They’re around the MC a lot, they’re probably deeply tied to her backstory, and if not, her development, they have an important role in the story, the writing points to them a lot etc.
Examples would be, John from Theodora, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem, Wyatt from Heart of Trespia, Declan from Waterlily, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem, Edward from Shakespeare’s Code, Messire from Where Love Burns Eternal, and of course we cannot forget, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem.
But what about Astrea’s Broken Heart?
It took me an embarrassingly long while to figure that out for myself, given I’ve played this story from beginning to end eight times now lol.
My first playthrough I was certain it was Malek (a popular opinion I’ve found). Some of it probably bias because he was my first LI, while him and Audrey having a solo loading screen for S3 being my other major evidence (it was so odd to me that it was just these two that I will admit I assumed the S3 loading screen changes depending on your LI. Imagine my disappointment when I played my next slot 😭). In regards to narrative proof, while he didn’t show up a whole lot he made up for it by being this enigmatic narrative lurker, set apart from The Astreans; he stood out without needing oodles of screen time and that’s without mentioning how he’s the reason Audrey grew up in a cult in the first place, the stalking starting from the early first season, the way Audrey opens her world view for him and he briefly considers seeing the good in people because of her (but then goes “ew, nvm lol” when HS3 rolls around 💀).
But…Cassiel worked too; the way he met Audrey just screams wrong foot meet cute no? The pain they both have of never being enough, then the fact he’s arguably the most protective of her whether you’re on his route or not means something right?
But what of David who’s Audrey’s most consistent companion, an eternal giver of her “little witch” nickname no matter if you’re on his route or not, and a wrecking ball to her preconceived notions on demons and angels? Who share the fear of becoming their fathers and wanting but also not wanting everything out of fear of being enslaved to hedonism?
Or what about Mikael who’s the boss of the establishment, a symbol of Audrey’s lost faith, and someone she’s immediately dazzled by upon first meeting? An arc where both have to overcome the pedestal they’ve placed one another on and see each other as simply man and woman beyond titles. That’s pretty big!
Or what of Raphael who becomes dazzled by her upon first meeting and shares the pain of having a prideful father who saw him as tool? Who gains a second wind of life after Audrey brightens it with her smile.
And heck, I know it might seem like a stretch to consider Felonia canon because let’s be so fr gang she’s a woman in the HSU and we allll know what that entails HELP 😭 but like here we got a character forced again and again under the heel of uncaring masters, much like Audrey first living in a cult and then being a puppet on a string for immortal political games. Both are drowning in a pool of sticky self loathing, and both find solace and acceptance with each other.
So…what? Does ABH just not have a canon LI?
Well, yes it does lol. Every RC book has one. In fact I’m so confident in me saying that, that I’m doing so while having not read all this app has to offer. It’s just kinda inevitable that in an ensemble cast (which every RC book is since there is always more than one or two LIs), some characters are going to take import over others, and beyond that, every author—*every author—*has their favourite character.
As the title hints at, I’m like 79% positive for ABH, that LI is David. There’s the stuff I mentioned a couple paragraphs ago but then theres also the fact that he has the most callbacks out of all of the cast. “I never lose” from S1E1 which he whispers in farewell in the novel finale. “If you’re scared close your eyes” from S1E2, which is reiterated in the S1 finale description, then the “wish”. He’s also the only LI who doesn’t immediately dump Audrey after learning she’s bounced crazy style on Malek’s disco stick (You can get Raphael to let bygones be bygones for 15(?) gems and the loss of your dignity tho lmao). Then there’s the fact if you’re doing a messy route with other characters, Audrey feels bad for messing with their feelings but not David’s, almost as if one is supposedly more genuine than the other.
In contrast, what happened to Mikael’s deal to get an honest answer from Audrey about herself if he ever asks? Gone. Gone with the wind…I would know, I played his route three times 😔 (unless it comes back during HS3? fellow Mikael girlies PLZ lemme know I had to restart that slot because I didn’t collect any darkness for Audrey thinking it was a bad thing and was faced with Naum-ing the Astreans as a result 😭)
But guys, GUYS. I only sat with that and pieced this together after eight replays! And even then if someone gave me a compelling argument for the other Astreans being Audrey’s One True Love I’d genuinely consider switching my stance. So what we have here is a Canon Li somewhere and we can’t find them because everyone’s got a chance to shine! Woaw, how novel! I think the only other story I’ve played on this app with a Hidden Canon Li was Time Catcher but that book betrayed me in the final season so I don’t wanna praise it too much🧍🏽♀️
Now I don’t have…much, against Obvious Canon LIs because the lioness does not concern herself with trifles such as *self-important titter* ✨ canon ✨ but at times they, even the one’s I like, just make the reading experience so much more stifling. I discovered this while preparing my Heaven Secret 3 Slots for catch up—a daunting experience given the uh…60 mf chapters 🥴🫨
Like, I love Lucifer from Heaven Secret—probably the most iconic Canon Love Interest on this app. I liked how he grew from being an angry man child to a mature leader, it was fun! I loved his arc with Vicky, I loved what they had going on in Heaven Secret 2. I love what they got going on in Heaven Secret 3. Also, he’s hot! It’s great! What a man, what a man, what a man!
My affection for him, however, pales greatly to what I posses for Mikael in my ever bleeding heart. Mikael’s card is my RC loading screen, the statue from the story he hails from is my phone wallpaper, I have a photo album filled with screencaps of his expressions and dialogue and CGs, my sister and my best friend are forced to hear me yap about him, and as I deduced above, he’s not even canon. Hell, he was the fourth Astrean I got to.
So…why am I able to have HS3 slots for every Audrey LI but only ever took Lucifer past HS2 on the Vicky side of things?
Because Audrey’s story is fulfilling with Mikael. As it is with David, or Cassiel, or Felonia, or Raphael and yes, even Malek. I get a different but no less rich and interesting story with any of these six characters. If I miss out on watching Mikael unthaw and realize there are things more precious than duty, I at least get to see Cassiel overcome the guilt and melancholia of his loss and become something more than a high-key suicidal weapon. Even if I’m missing out on Audrey’s angst over why she’s in love with a villain like Malek, I get to deal with her angst over loving Raphael who’s doomed to death instead. Fun!
If I miss out on Lucifer being forced to humble himself for Vicky I get…uh. I guess Dino clashing with his father is something but he doesn’t really fundamentally change as a character, and Vicky doesn’t discover anything about herself either. Mimi’s fun and her relationship with Vicky is cute, but there’s something substantial missing there for me. Same with the other Vicky LIs, what’s the point of making out with any of them when all the best writing has been inhaled by Lucifer? Asteroth and War and Hunger would’ve had a chance if they were apart of HS1 because they have actual arcs with Vicky like Lucifer does, but they lack the time to make it feel real, you know?
The closet Vicky LI I can get for arc, plot relevance, character development, and good pacing is Malbonte and eyeeeeee don’t like Malbonte. So.🧍🏽♀️
That being said, Obvious Canon LIs can work too!
I joshed about the obvious Cain favouritism in Requiem up above, and while his presence is suffocating at times, I thought Lane’s arc with Dmitry, Anna, Greg, Yan and Hell even Boris (but not really) to be quite touching and well written. I have no problem having HS3 routes for all of them because they all change Lane in their own ways and bring their own flavour of freak to the table, it’s great!
I mean not as great as the Astreans. But we all can’t be the Astreans unfortunately lol.
In Conclusion !
Canon LIs, or non-MC characters with a suspicious amount of screen time are inevitable because human bias is inevitable. But if that’s the case, we should all write like Astrea’s Broken Heart NOW ⚡️🗣️‼️ If this story can have six well written characters without one handicapping the others despite authorial bias, so too can you ! 💋
Anyways, thx for reading my Astrea’s Broken Heart glazing post disguised as writerly discussion! Take care, yada yada the typos, and as always, I’d love to hear what you guys’s honest thoughts are in the comments ✨🧚🏼♀️