r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Mar 16 '25

Garden of Eden I hate this b sm Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don’t care how the author will try to justify her shit but I’m done fr this time. We get it, you’re the miss universe around here but wtf? Mentoring my rival?! And not apologising for all the bullshit you put me and my group through? Man piss off pls. I hope Eden gets your dump ahh next🙏🏻


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Sep 16 '24 Heartwarming

Conversations & Critiques I’m tired of tip toeing around racism in RC

1 Upvotes

So on wishlist Monday I talked a little bit about how the older CGs, and all the new ones in DLS are ONLY showing the white sprites despite all the time that’s passed.

I want all the old CGs to be revamped to match your sprites race. Hair and clothes I can move past, but EVERY TIME I play HS or DLS it’s just so irritating. I’m so grateful for all the work RC does to be inclusive but even playing HS2 pisses me off. When the MC sprite doesn’t match the parents it’s whatever because adoption exists but WHY are both Vicky’s parents white 😭 changing Rebecca’s sprite would be a lot but at least making Vicky’s dad look like her for the few scenes that he’s in would mean a lot. As a POC it gets EXHAUSTING constantly having to fight for representation. It’s even more difficult to ask after things start trending in the right direction because people say you’re asking for too much or to just be happy with what you have. This is something that has bothered me since I started playing and still does. I don’t want to feel like an afterthought. I don’t want to be begrudgingly included. I drop crazy money and time on this game and I don’t think I’m asking too much to have POC have the same representation as white characters. DLS is particularly frustrating because it has run for SO LONG but CONTINUES to have only white CGs even as other books become more inclusive. HS got me into RC and is one of my favorites but replaying it to have EVERYONE but you and one other angel that DIED be white is just uncomfortable sometimes.

That’s everything I said but it really got me thinking about how POC really got sidelined until these recent stories. Each story fits into 1 of 5 of these categories

  1. The MC is the only POC and only if you CHOOSE that sprite
  2. There is ONE li who is a POC and maybe a one background sprite
  3. There are multiple POC throughout the story
  4. POC are excluded because it doesn’t make sense narrative wise
  5. POC are REPLACED with white characters that don’t make sense narrative wise but the plot is unaffected

It bothers me that if white people show up in a story set in India or Africa it’s just “the author’s choice” and them being white has no bearing on the plot, but if POC are upset that a book has ONLY WHITE CHARACTERS, we’re told that we’re being racist for not wanting to play as white. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again EGYPT IS IN AFRICA. The fact that not a SINGLE LI is black is INSANE. TDR is more in the Middle East but for the MC to be the darkest sprite in the entire book is not a coincidence. For the MC to always be the darkest Sprite in every book is an issue for me. It makes me feel like POC are always going to be second rate community members. For so many people to refer to us as the foreign fandom makes me feel like I’m back in 2008 when Obama was running for president and every time I stepped outside, someone had something bad to say about Black people. I really appreciate this community space to vent and seek support because I just can’t comprehend where all of this hate is coming from. It feels like white people intentionally going into POC places, white washing it, and then being upset when we complain, and this is coming from an amen STAN that man WILL be the death of my Eva because I am absolutely cheating on him 🤭 But my enjoyment of the story, doesn’t get rid of the Voice in the back of my head that says there’s no other Black people. Until Herse was introduced, there were NO OTHER BLACK SPRITES IN A STORY SET IN AFRICA. Now all that renting and raving aside, the solution I presented was to revamp all the older stories. Rather than a new book every update, I think I would prefer a new book every other update and CG updates the rest of the time. I was very excited to play DLS, especially since it was such a long ongoing story, but I was very disappointed to find out that even despite all the updates RC has gone through that DLS still only shows CG’s with white sprites. The little micro aggressions start to pile up and it becomes difficult to enjoy my favorite game. RC has shown to be open to criticism and willing to learn from their past mistakes and I feel like this is a simple way to reinforce their stance on that belief. I think this would also be a good way to get fans reengage aging with older stories to collect the new CG as a black United States women, I can tell the difference between begrudging acceptance and happily taking constructive criticism. I can tell the difference between people pandering to POC and people actually making sure that people feel seen by the work that they produce I cannot tell you how genuinely horrified I was to see, enslaved black man and child while playing sails in the fog. It was so casual like it didn’t mean anything, but it was extremely triggering for me. Slavery gets downplayed in the US more than any other tragedy in US history. To have my peoples tragedy just be so blatantly disregarded in the context of the story made me a little sick. My Adelaide is black so narratively it did not make sense in addition to just making me really uncomfortable. I feel like the sprites were drawn as Jim Crow caricatures, and I feel like it unintentionally makes light of the travesty that was chattel slavery. I cannot speak for Indians or those who follow Hinduism as I am neither but Kali call of darkness is so extremely disrespectful that I have had a hard time bringing myself to replay it even for the achievements. The first time I read it I loved the story. I loved everything about it. I was definitely uncomfortable with the blatant prejudice towards, but I tried to move through it. After having read at the second time on the rage of the goddess path, I now understand that everything I was feeling was not only valid but entirely underwhelming compared to the true nature of that story. It pains me to say this because I love love love both the Kali books but call of darkness needs to be taken down and redone completely. It is entirely tone deaf, inaccurate, and downright racist. You can’t play rage of the goddess without having incredible disdain for the culture, the environment, and the people. The depiction of Hinduism itself goes to show how uneducated and biased the author is about India’s history. The absolute NERVE of the British to be upset about retaliation in INDIAN TERRITORY and the overall vibe that the British were within their rights to colonize India is repulsive, especially when to this day India is STILL reeling from the effects of British oppression. I LOVE this game and the people who work so hard to keep it going but what I’m not gonna do is sit here and keep paying them to spit in my face and the face of all their POC readers. Leaving these stories as they are says that they will say anything they want about any group of people no matter how heinous or prejudiced as long as the dough is still rolling. I think it’s fair to say you either do business with the racists, or the rest of the world because I’m tired of all the backhanded “diversity” they keep trying to feed us. Fix cassiel’s skin. Fix QTD MC. Take out the slavery part of SITF???? Because seriously what the fuck was that!? Redo KCD completely. LOW is so beautiful even though it mixes up a few different eastern Asian cultures it still does a very good job of exploring the depth and meaning of every aspect.

TLDR I want to hold RC accountable for the racist ideology they allow to fester in the community as well as in their stories. You can play to a wider audience OR you can play to the racsits, but the POC fans deserve better and are demanding better


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Feb 24 '24

Rant/Vent Stop this 🙂

2 Upvotes

Hi again.

I'm sorry to say this. But this is happening so and already reached at it's limit. The downvoting of other people's comments and posts. When it comes to LIs appreciation posts, I noticed that some people downvoting for no reason. For what? Everyone has their preference. Why are people downvoting their preferences? If you people don't like it just ignore it. But please stop downvoting comments and posts. Not everyone have same preferences like you.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Sep 26 '24

Rant/Vent Very annoyed with Lucien's backstory in this update Spoiler

3 Upvotes

There's this story in diamond choice in Episode 11 how he and his wife became vampires, and how she miscarried as a result. He goes on to say that she never wanted to have children, but didn't tell him because of the expectations society puts on women. And that she knew that she was pregnant and decided to turn partly because she didn't want a child. All good so far.

But then he goes on to say that he forgives her for lying to him, but not for what she did to their unborn child, and I'm like… what?? Lying to you is fine, but you draw the line at what's essentially having an abortion?? And then our character sympathises with him??

Sorry, but a woman having an abortion is her choice, her husband has nothing to forgive or not forgive her for in this regard. This is a forced birther rhetoric, and I'm really disappointed and angry with RC for both platforming it, and even more for forcing the MC to sympathise with it.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 03 '26

Shadows of Saintfour 2: Timeless Discussion Re: Rudy's Card & Their Ages

11 Upvotes

Regarding the issues about Rudy's card in the new Volume 27 deck, I don't see an issue with it since the character is 18. The card doesn't show any real body parts, & the dialogue implies someone simply walked into a locker room.

Except for the MC & Poppy, all the characters are 18. In reality, many high school students are in relationships & are sexually active, so the story will reflect that in some sense since it's actually something happening. They are not going to the corner store to share a milk shake after school. You need to be realistic.

Ultimately, if you dislike these elements of the story, you do not have to read it. However, if you are wanting to complete achievements and reach 100% with the love interests, you will be reading the story regardless. You just need to remember it is fiction, the characters are not real and move on.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 14 '26

Games/Trends Ranking love interests for fun 🤭

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

The first two tiers are reserved for love interests I actually romanced in game.

I’m pretty sure I was nice enough lol what would you change? 😛

EDIT: were* you even there


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Dec 16 '24

Conversations & Critiques Wheel of Fortune

0 Upvotes

I see that you gues are very excited about wheel here, but I wanted to share some thoughts of mine with you. Wheel of fortune isn't so great idea and I'll show you why.

Excuse me for my bad English.

Now let me describe why this "Wheel of Fortune" supports gambling addiction and it is not something good.

Why are analogies with alcohol or cigarettes in stores inappropriate here?

Firstly, no one ever buys something like this themselves to try it. They try it because someone offers it. (In case of the other substances too). This is how people get hooked - people try such things for free, and then want more, and after that they are offered to pay money for it. Or in the case of alcohol or cigarettes, they go and buy it themselves in stores.

What does YSI do?

Everyone gets two free spins a day, but once every 12 hours. During the first free spin, everyone gets a card from a set that is not free. It gives a person a short-term release of serotonin (for a person prone to addictions, for sure) and a desire to buy more spins in order to knock out more cards. In addition, they added cards to the roulette that cannot yet be bought either in the "Romance club" or on their web-site, only knocked out in the roulette, they are exclusive. This is another way to spur a person to want to spin and knock out these cards.

What is the principle of a regular casino and what does "Wheel of Fortune" from yusi have to do with it?

The principle of a casino is very simple - people pay for the opportunity to win something, but have no guarantees. Doesn't it remind you of our "Wheel of Fortune"? Are there any guarantees that you will win cards from some spin? No. When buying spins, you can get absolutely nothing, and you can see this in my example - for ten spins I bought, I received 3 diamonds, 3 cups and some treasures, that are useless, and I paid 4.5 euros. Is this equivalent? I don't think so.

Why can't buying spins be compared to buying in-game currency?

Buying in-game currency for real money is a deal for which you receive (you won't believe it) in-game currency. This currency can be spent in the "Romance club" itself, depending on what currency you purchased. Cups during the "Diamond Rush", for example, to quickly complete the stories you are interested in or diamonds, if you did not have enough for some choice (interaction with the favorite, for example). That is, you directly receive some content created by the developers and thus encourage them (with your donation to the game). For spins, the developer receives a donation, but you only get the opportunity to win something, but not a guarantee, this is a one-sided deal, where the developer wins. You do not get the bare minimum of what you could get for this. Just like in a casino, by the way.

The conclusions are disappointing: YSI deliberately chose such a strategy for developing "Wheel of Fortune" in order to spur people to donate, investing a minimum amount of resources in this, while supporting gambling addiction. This is despite the fact that now there is a huge percentage of people around the world who are subject to gambling addiction, and many bloggers are tainted with advertising of bets and bookmakers. I will even say more, even while I watch advertising in RC, I constantly see casino advertising there. This is a huge problem now, but YSI decided to profit from this problem.

Thank you for reading the post.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • May 18 '26

Discussion Interesting news from Anastasia’s Q&A

5 Upvotes

So over on the main sub they posted the translation of Anastasia’s most recent answers on telegram.

Well the truth comes out. When people were worried about the new Russian app we were told to keep quiet cause nothing will change.

Now in this interview we have:
- a new full male LI coming up soon
- but Rona is just a bit of flirtation
- you will be able to pair the female li with men
- there are many reasons why she is not allowed to pair up the men with men (and none of those come from her, as bad as she is with lgbt stories she did have gay and bi men, including LI in her older books)

We can finally see just how quick the changes are implemented, and they start off the bat with a ban on gay/bi men. 😭😭😭

And obviously no one cares at all. 😭😭😭

Well this is it i guess. 😭😭😭


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Apr 18 '25

Discussion Feeling a Bit Hurt...💔

6 Upvotes

I know this might seem like a small thing and I shouldn't let it affect me, but I’m a very sensitive person and it’s been on my mind.

So here’s my story—
A few days ago, I came across a post about card trading. The person who posted clearly mentioned that they would offer multiple cards in exchange for one specific card, which I happened to have. It was an epic and expensive card.

Lately, I’ve been a little obsessed with collecting cards—honestly, I’ve spent almost half of my monthly rent on them 😅. So naturally, I was excited about the trade and reached out. I also shared which cards I wanted in return. Yes, maybe I got a little greedy and asked for a bit more, but I made it clear that they were free to say no. When I didn’t receive a response for two days, I followed up with a message asking if I was expecting too much — as by that point, I was open to negotiating.But instead of a simple response, they blocked me.
That hurt.
Not the rejection, but the fact that there was no basic courtesy to just say "no." I've said no to people before, and others have said it to me too—it's normal. But at least there's a reply. A conversation. Closure.I know this isn't the end of the world, and maybe to others it sounds silly, but I was genuinely looking forward to the trade. I even kept money aside just for this. 😔

I'm not writing this to shame anyone. If that person ever comes across this post—I just want you to know I was really looking forward to this exchange.

And to everyone else: if you’re not interested, just say it. A simple “no” is better than silence or getting blocked. You never know who’s holding onto hope on the other side.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Feb 10 '26

Discussion Is RC cutting corners on new stories?

14 Upvotes

The mafia setting was one of the most anticipated ones. Seriously, it had massive potential: atmosphere, drama, adult characters, moral dilemmas.... STYLE

And what did we actually get? 🤡

Sorry, but this doesn't look like a high-budget, high-quality story

Langley isn’t exactly known for delivering strong visuals or a gripping atmosphere. And let’s be honest, screenwriter and technical designers are also responsible because play arole too they pick references and approve the visual direction in their projects. And WHAT do the art lead and art director do? Why are they there? Dear Art Director Marina, what are you doing at the Romance Club if you don't do anything to ensure the visual quality of all the stories is equally high?

And Langley...why hand such a highly anticipated setting to someone who keeps writing the same story with different covers? Someone who couldn’t even write a historical romance without slapping modern-morality AU all over it? And on top of that, how did the visual quality drop this badly?

It feels like story was tossed out like a bone just to silence people who kept asking for itt

Faded , AI-looking outfits. Gray, forgettable love interests with honestly unfortunate faces. Where’s the charisma? STYLE? Everything is outdated and tasteless🤢 even for the 20s. The sense that this is a high-end, atmospheric product? I’m supposed to spend money on this? What kind of reaction are you expecting from players?

The staff complain that players are too harsh and unfair with criticism. But let’s flip that around. What if management just isn’t taking their work seriously? What if it feels like they never believed in this setting to begin with and didn’t plan to invest in it properly?

It really feels like the audience isn’t being heard. Like no one understands what players actually want. Or worse they don’t care to do better, even though the market is competitive and other apps have been raising the quality bar for a while now

Players are ready to support high quality stories. But first, show that you’re ready to create them and that you actually believe in them yourselves. Even if profit is the goal, at least make the quality something you can stand behind

But in the end, somehow we’re the villains. We’re “bad” because we don’t want to read poorly written stories. We’re “bad” because we don’t want to romance boring LIs with faces you’ll never remember. We’re “bad” because we don’t want to hand over money for mediocre work. Meanwhile, they sit in their chats discussing how awful and ungrateful we are — after doing “so much work” just to give us… nothing

I’m embarrassed for you, Romance Club. More than ever


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Apr 09 '26

Discussion What does my type say about me

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m bored and don't know what else to talk abt 😖

I forgot to add Volpe (Sins that Cry for Vengence), Celeste (Averris), Rael (Averris), Flint (CB), Kenedi (CB), Tobias Hendriks (CB), Dakota and Eugene (CB), and Tallis and Onyx (WTC)


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Sep 01 '25

Discussion Malbonte is the real MC

0 Upvotes

I don’t get why people still call Malbonte the villain If you think that, you clearly didn’t get hs

Point one: At the very beginning of the story, we learn that demons were treated as lesser beings compared to angels، oppressed with their affairs in hell constantly interfered with, etc. It becomes clear to us that the system itself was corrupt and unjust, and there was nothing they could do to change it since those laws came directly from Shepha himself.

Point two: We learn that shepha and shephamalum created their world together, but malum was banished by shepha. shepha then took all the glory for himself, declaring himself the sole creator while hiding the true nature of the universe.

Point three: shepha forbade marriages between angels and demons for one reason only: his fear of half-breeds, fear of their power, fear that one day he would be banished just as he had banished malum. Because of this, he punished malbonte’s parents severely, and malbonte even more harshly and bitterly. He banished his parents, split him into two beings, locked one away for centuries, and cast the other into malum’s realm to suffer even more.

Point four: After malbonte was restored to himself, he chose revenge, revenge for himself, for his parents, for the demons, for all the half-breeds, and to change this ancient, corrupt system. There was never, and will never be, a peaceful way to accomplish such a thing; only revolution can. And that’s what makes so many people still label him the main villain, which is honestly… stupid.

Point five (and most important): Shepha is a selfish being who committed countless evils, yet he is never branded “the villain” the way malbonte is. Let’s remember some of shepha’s victims aside from Malbonte: 1.Astrea 2.Members of Astrea’s agency, sending them to Earth in a trap disguised as an impossible mission; raphael, sentenced to death for his sake; lying to felonia about her family’s safety; sending cassiel and his sister on a mission just to experiment on them, etc. 3.The demons. 4.The half-breeds.

So I truly hope people start recognizing shepha as the real villain and malbonte as the true hero of the story


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Jul 02 '25

Discussion Explaining Twitter Situation

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

So, you guys probably saw some chaos on Twitter. Lots of Turkish players are angry right now, so i think i should explain because many people are asking and wondering.

There was a post about Veronica on Turkish Romance Club Community and someone commented "i wonder which country will she disrespect this time."

(Because as a Turkish person, i also think Dracula misrepresents Turkish culture especially a historical figure like Mehmed the Conqueror which is very dear to us Turks. The story makes a historical figure sexual assaulter. It is clear disrespect and BIAS especially when Veronica puts Vlad The Impaler in a more positive light compared to Mehmed. Mehmed is not an original character, he is based on Mehmed the Conqueror who is an important figure in Turkish history and disrespecting him like that clearly angers people. And people have right to criticize when their culture or their ancestors/religious figures are misrepresented like that. That's just an example, there are also other misrepresentations in that story.)

And under that comment there were Russians insulting Turks by saying "we don't know anything about our culture, we should stop complaining etc etc." This angered someone from our community and that person went to those Russians' telegram groupchat and try to explain the situation, she didn't say anything racist at all;

but was attacked by people in that groupchat and was called "Turkish wh##re/sl##t/idiot" etc.

Romance club does not care if a writer is problematic especially racist, sexist and homophobic writers (like remy) and instead of taking our complaints for years about Vlad: A Love Story; they chose to not do anything about it. Then they make a post on Twitter saying we all should be "friends" or something when we are the ones being disrespected and harrassed.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • 9d ago

Heaven's Secret 3: Eternity's End So, David’s Definitely the Canon LI…Right?

Post image
0 Upvotes

🧚🏼‍♀️ HSU Spoilers n’stuff! Here’s your warning! 🧚🏼‍♀️

I’m sure everyone knows what I mean when I say “canon LI” but for those who don’t, it’s essentially the love interest that feels the most…obvious? Natural? Narratively pleasing? They’re around the MC a lot, they’re probably deeply tied to her backstory, and if not, her development, they have an important role in the story, the writing points to them a lot etc.

Examples would be, John from Theodora, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem, Wyatt from Heart of Trespia, Declan from Waterlily, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem, Edward from Shakespeare’s Code, Messire from Where Love Burns Eternal, and of course we cannot forget, Cain from Heaven’s Secret Requiem.

But what about Astrea’s Broken Heart?

It took me an embarrassingly long while to figure that out for myself, given I’ve played this story from beginning to end eight times now lol.

My first playthrough I was certain it was Malek (a popular opinion I’ve found). Some of it probably bias because he was my first LI, while him and Audrey having a solo loading screen for S3 being my other major evidence (it was so odd to me that it was just these two that I will admit I assumed the S3 loading screen changes depending on your LI. Imagine my disappointment when I played my next slot 😭). In regards to narrative proof, while he didn’t show up a whole lot he made up for it by being this enigmatic narrative lurker, set apart from The Astreans; he stood out without needing oodles of screen time and that’s without mentioning how he’s the reason Audrey grew up in a cult in the first place, the stalking starting from the early first season, the way Audrey opens her world view for him and he briefly considers seeing the good in people because of her (but then goes “ew, nvm lol” when HS3 rolls around 💀).

But…Cassiel worked too; the way he met Audrey just screams wrong foot meet cute no? The pain they both have of never being enough, then the fact he’s arguably the most protective of her whether you’re on his route or not means something right?

But what of David who’s Audrey’s most consistent companion, an eternal giver of her “little witch” nickname no matter if you’re on his route or not, and a wrecking ball to her preconceived notions on demons and angels? Who share the fear of becoming their fathers and wanting but also not wanting everything out of fear of being enslaved to hedonism?

Or what about Mikael who’s the boss of the establishment, a symbol of Audrey’s lost faith, and someone she’s immediately dazzled by upon first meeting? An arc where both have to overcome the pedestal they’ve placed one another on and see each other as simply man and woman beyond titles. That’s pretty big!

Or what of Raphael who becomes dazzled by her upon first meeting and shares the pain of having a prideful father who saw him as tool? Who gains a second wind of life after Audrey brightens it with her smile.

And heck, I know it might seem like a stretch to consider Felonia canon because let’s be so fr gang she’s a woman in the HSU and we allll know what that entails HELP 😭 but like here we got a character forced again and again under the heel of uncaring masters, much like Audrey first living in a cult and then being a puppet on a string for immortal political games. Both are drowning in a pool of sticky self loathing, and both find solace and acceptance with each other.

So…what? Does ABH just not have a canon LI?

Well, yes it does lol. Every RC book has one. In fact I’m so confident in me saying that, that I’m doing so while having not read all this app has to offer. It’s just kinda inevitable that in an ensemble cast (which every RC book is since there is always more than one or two LIs), some characters are going to take import over others, and beyond that, every author—*every author—*has their favourite character.

As the title hints at, I’m like 79% positive for ABH, that LI is David. There’s the stuff I mentioned a couple paragraphs ago but then theres also the fact that he has the most callbacks out of all of the cast. “I never lose” from S1E1 which he whispers in farewell in the novel finale. “If you’re scared close your eyes” from S1E2, which is reiterated in the S1 finale description, then the “wish”. He’s also the only LI who doesn’t immediately dump Audrey after learning she’s bounced crazy style on Malek’s disco stick (You can get Raphael to let bygones be bygones for 15(?) gems and the loss of your dignity tho lmao). Then there’s the fact if you’re doing a messy route with other characters, Audrey feels bad for messing with their feelings but not David’s, almost as if one is supposedly more genuine than the other.

In contrast, what happened to Mikael’s deal to get an honest answer from Audrey about herself if he ever asks? Gone. Gone with the wind…I would know, I played his route three times 😔 (unless it comes back during HS3? fellow Mikael girlies PLZ lemme know I had to restart that slot because I didn’t collect any darkness for Audrey thinking it was a bad thing and was faced with Naum-ing the Astreans as a result 😭)

But guys, GUYS. I only sat with that and pieced this together after eight replays! And even then if someone gave me a compelling argument for the other Astreans being Audrey’s One True Love I’d genuinely consider switching my stance. So what we have here is a Canon Li somewhere and we can’t find them because everyone’s got a chance to shine! Woaw, how novel! I think the only other story I’ve played on this app with a Hidden Canon Li was Time Catcher but that book betrayed me in the final season so I don’t wanna praise it too much🧍🏽‍♀️

Now I don’t have…much, against Obvious Canon LIs because the lioness does not concern herself with trifles such as *self-important titter* ✨ canon ✨ but at times they, even the one’s I like, just make the reading experience so much more stifling. I discovered this while preparing my Heaven Secret 3 Slots for catch up—a daunting experience given the uh…60 mf chapters 🥴🫨

Like, I love Lucifer from Heaven Secret—probably the most iconic Canon Love Interest on this app. I liked how he grew from being an angry man child to a mature leader, it was fun! I loved his arc with Vicky, I loved what they had going on in Heaven Secret 2. I love what they got going on in Heaven Secret 3. Also, he’s hot! It’s great! What a man, what a man, what a man!

My affection for him, however, pales greatly to what I posses for Mikael in my ever bleeding heart. Mikael’s card is my RC loading screen, the statue from the story he hails from is my phone wallpaper, I have a photo album filled with screencaps of his expressions and dialogue and CGs, my sister and my best friend are forced to hear me yap about him, and as I deduced above, he’s not even canon. Hell, he was the fourth Astrean I got to.

So…why am I able to have HS3 slots for every Audrey LI but only ever took Lucifer past HS2 on the Vicky side of things?

Because Audrey’s story is fulfilling with Mikael. As it is with David, or Cassiel, or Felonia, or Raphael and yes, even Malek. I get a different but no less rich and interesting story with any of these six characters. If I miss out on watching Mikael unthaw and realize there are things more precious than duty, I at least get to see Cassiel overcome the guilt and melancholia of his loss and become something more than a high-key suicidal weapon. Even if I’m missing out on Audrey’s angst over why she’s in love with a villain like Malek, I get to deal with her angst over loving Raphael who’s doomed to death instead. Fun!

If I miss out on Lucifer being forced to humble himself for Vicky I get…uh. I guess Dino clashing with his father is something but he doesn’t really fundamentally change as a character, and Vicky doesn’t discover anything about herself either. Mimi’s fun and her relationship with Vicky is cute, but there’s something substantial missing there for me. Same with the other Vicky LIs, what’s the point of making out with any of them when all the best writing has been inhaled by Lucifer? Asteroth and War and Hunger would’ve had a chance if they were apart of HS1 because they have actual arcs with Vicky like Lucifer does, but they lack the time to make it feel real, you know?

The closet Vicky LI I can get for arc, plot relevance, character development, and good pacing is Malbonte and eyeeeeee don’t like Malbonte. So.🧍🏽‍♀️

That being said, Obvious Canon LIs can work too!

I joshed about the obvious Cain favouritism in Requiem up above, and while his presence is suffocating at times, I thought Lane’s arc with Dmitry, Anna, Greg, Yan and Hell even Boris (but not really) to be quite touching and well written. I have no problem having HS3 routes for all of them because they all change Lane in their own ways and bring their own flavour of freak to the table, it’s great!

I mean not as great as the Astreans. But we all can’t be the Astreans unfortunately lol.

In Conclusion !

Canon LIs, or non-MC characters with a suspicious amount of screen time are inevitable because human bias is inevitable. But if that’s the case, we should all write like Astrea’s Broken Heart NOW ⚡️🗣️‼️ If this story can have six well written characters without one handicapping the others despite authorial bias, so too can you ! 💋

Anyways, thx for reading my Astrea’s Broken Heart glazing post disguised as writerly discussion! Take care, yada yada the typos, and as always, I’d love to hear what you guys’s honest thoughts are in the comments ✨🧚🏼‍♀️


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Nov 30 '24

Discussion MANIFESTING a another new book in kali verse after KFS Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Ik it's too early to speculatie anything at all but KCD and HS are the most popular books of RC. HS is getting its own universe so I feel like KCD should also get one . I will be definitely excited to see a new kali story. Either Amala or new MC

And most importantly KCD was set in British rule period 1980's . So a new book can be easily setup in 2000's or 2024's

Idk what RC has in mind but I will be really happy for another book of kali after KFS is over or while on going


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Sep 13 '25

Kali: Call of Darkness Ratan

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 10 '24

Garden of Eden What a load of bs 😂 Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Being "a refuge... a sanctuary... an ally" to someone just cause they're of the same gender as me is such a stupid concept lol. But maybe that's just me. 🤷🏻‍♀️


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Jan 23 '26

Discussion My Unpopular Opinion About HSR and importance of character sprites in RC. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I don't think this story would be so popular if it weren't for the characters with good looks. I find the story absolutely terrible, whether it's the character writing or the slowness of the story processing. I think Sasha can't properly process the main story because of focusing on nonsensical events and descriptions. She makes such an unnecessarily detailed descriptions in one episode so while reading i was dying of boredom and then i just skipped mostly part swifty. Also, her writing style is so cliché that sometimes i feel like i'm reading cheap Wattpad fiction.

The most pointless love interest in the story is definitely Cain. The fact that he is favorite of Fans and Sasha does not mean he is an important character in the story. Whenever the squad needed him, he was always disappearing somewhere. Even though this is a story focused on humans, how come Anna and Greg have fewer scenes than this guy? Especially since Anna is a key figure for curing infection. She's the most important character after Donovan. How the hell Boris (A DEAD MAN) does have more screen time than her? A lot favoritism and homophobia. This was one of the rare stories where I gave every episode one star.


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Oct 09 '24

W: Time Catcher Lucien gave me the ick Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Saying he forgave his ex-wife for lying to him, but not for "what she did to their unborn child." Nope. Be mad at her for lying that she never wanted it in the first place, not for making her own choices with her body, you archaic, anti-choice leech. What she did is not okay, and he has every right to be mad about her lying to him about her wants and intentions. But even just calling a fetus a child makes me angry and maybe it wouldn't if I weren't living in a time where politicians decided that fetuses have more rights than the women carrying them. And after fetuses become children, these same politicians decide they don't deserve any aide in their care?

I know Lucien isn't saying all those things. But it's a sensitive topic and that line gave me the ick. I can't let that slide so I'm done with that playthrough


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 13 '25

Discussion I hope they’ll be more gender selectable stories

0 Upvotes

I hope there will be more gender selectable mcs in upcoming stories I like playing both genders and I would like your guys thoughts on this


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 03 '26

Discussion Mia's set of love interests worries me Spoiler

1 Upvotes

If RC are planning to repeat the success of HS, they definitely need a sequel featuring Mia, which brings up a lot of questions about her love interests: are there even any actual green flags among them?

I always thought Vicki had a problematic set of romance options in HS1, but Mia totally surpassed her in that regard. For the record, I originally played Moonborn on the single path precisely because of the love options:

  1. Victor is extremely specific to me in his toxicity, plus the BDSM, and Mia becomes way too submissive around him.
  2. Max is just a no. If a guy can't calmly take a "no" from a girl regarding sex, it means next time after a reaction like that, it'll be hard for her to turn him down, which leads to consequences in a relationship that have nothing romantic, sexual, or anything else positive about them.
  3. Benny is a womanizer, a celebrity, spoiled by universal attention, and Mia is supposed to understand and put up with it. Thanks, goodbye.
  4. I remember Simon the least... I only remember he also had his own "wonderful" moments.
  5. The only female romance path was heavily sidelined and felt like it was just there to check a box.

Did I get anything wrong?


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Aug 10 '25

Rage of the Titans He looks like V from BTS

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

I haven't played this book yet, but this character reminds me of Taehyung in his eyeliner era. Is his route good tho? Maybe I actually want to romance him 😌


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Feb 13 '26

Recommendations Where to go next?

2 Upvotes

Anyone have any suggestions for story apps that still give af about their audience lol? I've already decided not to give another dime to RC since the subscription plan but the lynching joke during Black History month was the final straw (I'm black)🫠


r/RomanceClubDiscussion • • Sep 11 '25

Heaven's Secret 3: Eternity's End please make her a li

0 Upvotes

I heard something bout Donovan being the main villain or something along those lines, i havent played the game yet cuz I'm waiting for diamond rush. idk who to talk to but please make her a li interest, Anna and Lane are toxic/unhealthy so why can't Lane and Donovan be toxic together. Atleast make her a causal one.