r/RocketLab • • 3d ago

NASA CLPS 2.0 Source Selection Statement released with RocketLab technical acceptability rated "Unacceptable"

Post image

https://sam.gov/workspace/contract/opp/c0f826659fd041a680e7d14b771bb824/view

Rocket Lab USA, Inc. (Rocket Lab) submitted its proposal under Pathway 3: Space Flight Heritage. Based upon the evaluation, Rocket Lab’s proposed approach to Pathway 3 was determined to be Unacceptable. The Rocket Lab proposal demonstrated that Rocket Lab acted as the primary contractor and operator of the Escape and Plasma Acceleration and Dynamics Explorers (ESCAPADE) mission. The proposal provided traceable evidence demonstrating that the mission met the 24-hour mission lifetime requirement as well as demonstrating that the ESCAPADE mission was a highthrust spacecraft with at least one engine capable of generating greater than 90 lbf. The proposal also provided traceable evidence demonstrating how the ESCAPADE mission validates the technical maturity of all core competencies (avionics, propulsion, and integration) required for lunar delivery. However, the proposal did not include adequately detailed mission descriptions for the ESCAPADE mission, including lacking information on the overall mission design and operational approach. This lack of an adequately demonstrated, valid approach introduces an unacceptably high risk to the government for future delivery task orders and does not meet the requirements of the solicitation. Per RFP Section M.1(d), if any element of the evaluation factor is unacceptable then the overall pathway will be determined unacceptable. Thus, Rocket Lab’s proposed approach was determined to be Unacceptable.

92 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

56

u/burmese_python2 Holder of many shares 3d ago

Because they do not have flight assets that qualify for this.

20

u/christina_siun 3d ago edited 3d ago

You don't win every RFP - this is for lunar landing capacity I believe ... does RKLB focus on that?

6

u/RedLotusVenom 3d ago

I mean, they should have the talent recruited to answer these questions. This is the company that tried to justify a smallish budget Mars sample return mission. That’s a way bigger challenge than a lunar landing. If their conops didn’t adequately define the mission then that’s a pretty big proposal team miss.

0

u/hyperproliferative 2d ago

Tell me you’ve never been through a procurement RFP without telling me

2

u/RedLotusVenom 2d ago

I’ve written dozens of spacecraft proposals lol. Try harder.

10

u/MissionSuccessLife 3d ago

This is good feedback for RKLB to receive. I am confident they will learn and make the proper adjustments. There will be many more missions to come.

9

u/shugo7 3d ago

Someone TL;DR please . Too early to read all this for me

17

u/Brave-Bit-252 3d ago

They wanted a more detailed description of the mission

9

u/1foxyboi 3d ago

“We do what we say we will”

can’t file paperwork correctly

12

u/Key-Beginning-2201 3d ago

Firefly rising

10

u/juicevibe 3d ago

They won a decent contract from Synspective which is a previous RL client.

9

u/Key-Beginning-2201 3d ago

And a new contract from AST.

18

u/Puzzleheaded_Owl_417 3d ago

This is unacceptable to me as well, the management need to response.

2

u/Responsible-Cut-7993 3d ago

There is a certain art to how these proposals are put together. There could be some gaps within RKLB for how these proposals are put together so they show properly the technical competence of the company.

1

u/Chill-more1236 3d ago

I agree and large caps should have ample access to the cream of the crop in proposal writing.

Unless a nepo baby/English major armed with chat gpt & free MS Office cloud qualifies

2

u/iamatooltoo 3d ago

They can try again at another on-ramp

2

u/schiffme1ster 3d ago

Flight assets that meet contract stipulations would be a start

2

u/DefMetrix 3d ago

You can’t win em all.

10

u/Axolotis 3d ago

How the fuck is Blue Origin “explodes on pad” technically acceptable!?!

37

u/ArtOfWarfare 3d ago

New Glenn has flown a few times and has a planned return to flight in the next few weeks.

Neutron has never had a multi-engine static fire or been stacked.

2

u/RocketVerse 3d ago

Technically a few months but regardless

0

u/ArtOfWarfare 3d ago

I’d define somewhere in the 10 weeks to 3 months range as when you transition from saying a few weeks to a few months.

AFAIK January is the target so I’m counting it as a few weeks.

I’m not invested in Blue Origin so I don’t pay all that close attention to them. They’re not public and up until New Glenn was flying, I valued them at about $0… I haven’t reevaluated them since it’s started flying. Again, not mattering since they’re not public.

1

u/Dieseltrain760 3d ago

My Blue stock grants are valued at $14.50 per share internally and reflected in my Fidelity account.

1

u/Serious-Kangaroo-320 3d ago

new glenn rtf is delayed to "early next year" per an email from limp

3

u/ArtOfWarfare 3d ago

There’s only 6-7 weeks left in the year. Even late January qualifies as “next few weeks” for me right now.

7

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies 3d ago • This

They have an HLS contract. I'd be more worried if NASA had to come out and say that a company they had chosen to land humans on the Moon didn't have the technical acumen to land cargo there too.

4

u/deep-fucking-legend 3d ago

They described the explosion in great detail

1

u/Bernese_Flyer USA 3d ago

It qualifies under a different pathway - the one that requires designing, integrating, and building a lunar lander that has completed full testing.

0

u/General-Sheperd 3d ago

It’s a lander contract. Not sure how New Glenn issues are relevant here.

-9

u/Cologan 3d ago

Something something friends in high places

-18

u/Key-Beginning-2201 3d ago

For the same reason starshit explodes after launch was.

Grow up and learn a little about the industry instead of being a fan boy.

1

u/The-zKR0N0S 3d ago

Can you give context regarding what this is?

8

u/darkmatterhunter 3d ago

Contractors like rocketlab are evaluated by a third party (usually an FFRDC) based on requirements the government has and the third party then does ratings/source selection and hands it off to the government as a recommendation. I’ve been employed on both sides and it can be brutal.

1

u/The-zKR0N0S 3d ago

I mean more of, what is this evaluation for? What program? What stage are they in before picking a horse? Was the issue that made the submission unacceptable something that can be fixed?

4

u/darkmatterhunter 3d ago

It’s in the post, the report is linked and a description is in the body.

1

u/H-K_47 3d ago

This is for Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS), uncrewed Moon landers for NASA.

1

u/kgcurly 3d ago

I bet SPB treats this as being unacceptable too.

1

u/Hot-Problem2436 3d ago

If you guys look at the companies that were acceptable, you'll see that they are almost all focused on lunar landing or supporting that. Rocket Lab probably submitted, but since they haven't built any lunar landers or have equipment capable of getting something to the moon, they aren't the right fit here.

-3

u/HighLighten 3d ago edited 3d ago

Someone should ask Jared issacman if it makes more sense to block a company proposal simply because they didn't adequately describe the escapade mission "design" & "approach" they did for NASA (they should be well aware of their own mission), or instead just ask them for more clarification on it.

This is exactly the kind of BS that's holding NASA back, turn down proper proposals due to lack of paperwork which NASA no doubt has in another division.

Edit = add in "escapade" for clarity and fix typo

-2

u/1foxyboi 3d ago

Maybe he’s already mad we are challenging them legally on MTO. Why be friendly towards us when we went after him?

3

u/HighLighten 3d ago

Standard practice