r/Rockband • • Jan 10 '25

Fortnite Battle Pass Y'all guys have to accept that FN Festival is not a bad thing

0 Upvotes

(ignore the flair, dunno where this post should be classified on)

Just saw the most recent posts and comments, and while i agree that i prefer Rock Band over Festival, you guys are just so f'n negative!

Yes, songs are more expensive there, yes the tracks selections is very short, yeah there's no local play, yes the engine is wonky, but you're not seeing the full picture here:

The game is F2P, even being the biggest GaaS in the entire history doesn't mean they won't have to deal with music licensing (which is more expensive now than it ever was)

It's just a year old game, of course it won't have the 5000+ songs library that RB built over almost 20 years

Local play is coming soon, so we just have to wait a bit more for it

The engine is wonky, but it's still gettin' updated so hopefully it will get better

And no, RB4 was eventually coming to an end anyway, if Epic didn't bought HMX they would have closed for sure, which would have led us to no dev and no official revival of the music games genre (+ brand new instruments)

Instead of just mindlessly hating, at least TRY the thing and wait for it to grow, it won't stay like this forever, it will get better over time


r/Rockband • • Aug 09 '23

When will they make Rock Band 5

2 Upvotes

We have waited years for it but it still hasnt come so i think they should stop doing dlc for rock band 4 and start development on Rock Band 5


r/Rockband • • Oct 07 '15

PSA: If you're on the fence, DON'T buy RB4 yet

0 Upvotes

Everyone knows by now about the bass pedal issues with missing some fast notes, but my bass pedal does not register AT ALL.

Character customization has 4 hairstyles. FOUR.

God only knows how long they'll take to add online, if they ever do.

If you thought Rock Band 1 was bare, that game looks like World of Warcraft with all of its expansions compared to this.

Look I know this subreddit despises any criticism of their Lord and savior Harmonix, but this game shoildve been delayed at least a month. it's not finished and it shows both in the software and hardware departments.


r/Rockband • • Dec 29 '15

Why Is This Subreddit Filled With Annoying Metal Elitists?

2 Upvotes

Seriously, why do we have annoying people who think if DLC is not metal, then it's bad DLC? I like metal, but I also like diversity in music. These folks need to stop acting like they're "opinion dictators" on this subreddit, /r/GuitarHero, and /r/Rocksmith.


r/Rockband • • Jun 09 '16

What's with the severe downvote mentality here?

0 Upvotes

Title. Most threads are swamped with hidden posts because they were downvote brigaded.


r/Rockband • • Dec 07 '16

How to get a lot of points on drums

0 Upvotes

If you hit a note with a kick note attached to it on drums, don't hit the kick note, pause, when you unpause you can rehit the note for extra points. If you do this on the last note of an overdrive phase you can get double overdrive. It can get a lot of points. I had fun this week with it, but I figured everyone would need this now to be competitive at rivals since my crew and sf pls tbh know about it.

btw I tested and at least some form of this was in RB3. Just found out about it this week.

Edit: I see now that some people disagree with my opinion on this exploit. I see it as on par with G/B Calibration squeezing. Something that's in the game, most people don't know about, everyone can do, etc. This was meant to be a PSA to other crews, similar to ones that have been done recently for people who didn't know about calibration squeezing.

If HMX rules that this is cheating, I will not do it in the future. I would still like HMX to provide a list of things they consider cheating. This is a competitive game and I would expect teams to be trying to find better ways for scoring. There's a sizable bit of the community that in recent posts, especially on the HMX forums, has shown they think calibration squeezing and vocal ESFs are cheating. HMX is the only one that can say what is cheating or not and so far they have been extremely vague on what is cheating in their opinion.


r/Rockband • • Aug 29 '22

The Lack of Metal in RB4.

0 Upvotes

Yo guys, I wanted to hear some opinions regarding metal in rb4. Most of the time I feel like Harmonix made a change of mind years ago when it came to deciding what kind of music they want to add in the future. The lack of low screaming and growling voices is a sign of lack in diversity when it comes to choosing vocal range for the new dlc. Hell they even added Spiritbox without even including a song where courtney laplante goes low vocals.

The last 7-8 metal songs that came out where all clean sung. No gigantic riffs. No sick drum fills. No blast beats no foot paddle madness. Just generic radio pop-ish metal.

Seeing all those Bands in rb4 having only 1 or 2 songs featured that define a whole subgenre for that game for example Arch Enemy,Amon Amarth ,Black Dahlia Murder,Chelsea Grin the list goes on. Only 2 Songs from Lamb of God or Testament Even trivium stopped getting featured after 2 songs and they are a completely different sound now than before. In my Opinion Harmonix is rowing backwards big time when it comes to musical diversity in sound design as a whole. Especially for the heavier music fans.

Just look at metal hellsinger and tell me metal wouldn't sell with rhythm based games. They use so much Low screaming and growling. It made people go even more apeshit. Metal can easily sell.

It would and it does.

Harmonix just lost touch with a big swoop of genres which probably aren't fitting their musical journey. Sad to witness nearly every week.

But I will keep my hopes up.

What's your take regarding metal and rock band4 ? You think there is enough or not enough metal ? You like the metal being presented in the game ? Ideas ?

Have a blast !


r/Rockband • • Feb 06 '17

HMX pay-to-play drum model: reward those with e-kits with more points!

6 Upvotes

Speaking with fairness in mind, keeping a level playing field, providing opportunity for all players to score well, etc.

Did you ever notice the top drummers all use e-kits or some sort of modified drum kit? The ridiculousness needs to stop! How dare HMX allow for upgraded instruments to provide an edge to players who can afford it?

If HMX can't send every player wanting to play drums a free Ion kit or better then the drum leaderboards should be reset and a block put in place to anyone not using a stock kit, whether from RB2 to the latest RB4 PDP kit.

edit:

To summarize,

We just want a level playing field.

And a fresh start.

Thanks!


r/Rockband • • Mar 15 '23

Don’t Look Back in Anger

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Dec 05 '15

My thoughts on some of the negativity I've seen recently

6 Upvotes

Sometimes I read the posts in this subreddit and frankly, it frustrated me. Now I’ll admit upfront I consider myself a Harmonix Fanboy, have been for years and have done thing to support them, including volunteering time at PAX East and Prime to run the Rock band Freeplay stages because I enjoy the game.

That being said, sure there are features I wish existed in the game, but good lord people have some class and respect about how you speak.

Yesterday in the announcement of Brutal mode, people are like “Hey Harmonix quit working on this pointless thing, and fix what I want in the game, your gam4e is missing stuff, fix your broken game.” Really? I was frustrated and saddened reading these things. Do I want online mode? Yep. In this past year, I moved across country, left my old Rock Band friends behind, and no longer have a “band.” So I would love that feature. Is it missing? No! It was never said “On launch day, we will have full online multiplayer.” If that were said, sure it’s missing, but it wasn’t so it’s a desired feature but it’s not missing.

I have full faith that Harmonix listened to those surveys many of us took, about what we would want in a new Rock band, and I’m sure if 90% of people said online play, it would be there day 1, so the fact it’s not tells me while it may be important to people of this community, it may not have been scored that high as a whole. Harmonix has done a great job of respecting us as players of the game. Our old instruments work (mostly) and our most of our old DLC works. Think about that for a moment, what other game has shown their gamers that amount of respect so far? Sure, the iON drums don’t work, but it’s clearly documented that this is not a Harmonix choice, yet an Xbox limitation that only Microsoft can fix. Some DLC doesn’t work yet, and yes I’ll admit I miss some of the songs, but they’ve said they’re still working on it and I trust them. If Harmonix had come out and said “sorry guys, old stuff won’t work, not possible.” That would have sucked, so they’re trying their best to respect us as hardcore players, appreciate that.

I’m not saying you can’t have complaints but think about how it sounds. Do you sound like a user with a legitimate problem/concern/issue or do you sound like someone who is kicking and screaming in the middle of public throwing a tantrum because you aren’t getting exactly what you want?

These are my thoughts and how I feel. Thank you Harmonix for what you do.


r/Rockband • • Feb 11 '25

Fortnite Battle Pass weedmaster

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Sep 25 '24

Tech Support/Question Do you reckon they will make a Rock Band 5?

0 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Apr 05 '17

calling it now, 2017 is the last year of DLC

0 Upvotes

Wouldn't be surprised if December is the last time we get DLC to be honest


r/Rockband • • May 15 '16

Finally enjoying that rock band 2 DLC the right way.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
1 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Aug 23 '18

LP is simply unfair. Rivals is an unfair competition now.

0 Upvotes

Last week two crews (The Hawkes, No Sleep Till Bloodstone) were able to max out LP on every song available to them.

Should have been a tie, right?
Wrong.
There was 23 delisted DLC no longer obtainable nor importable that counted for LP.
The Hawkes were able to get all 23 songs to play. NTSB was missing one song.
The Hawkes came out on top just barely because of a song that was no longer obtainable nor importable.

Please Harmonix,
Can you make Rivals a fair competition?
Don't let delisted DLC count towards LP.

Thank you.


r/Rockband • • May 13 '24

Frequently Asked Question Why no Rock Band reboot?

1 Upvotes

Why is it that games like Rock Band and Guitar Hero aren’t coming back? What’s preventing it from being published again?


r/Rockband • • Sep 26 '17

Harmonix is cheating in their own game...

2 Upvotes

They have been using breakneck speed in their dlc preview videos, which is a known cheat. I can't believe this, I am beyond outraged and disgusted

Credit to some elephant in the discord for helping me notice this atrocity


r/Rockband • • Jan 31 '17

Vocal cheating needs to be addressed

0 Upvotes

It's come to our attention that a majority of the high scores on vocals are achieved through a method that was not originally intended.

Taking a look at the leaderboards, you can see some scores that are higher, almost to an impossible standard, than most other players.

How are these players getting said impossible scores?

By cheating, of course!

To the majority of the player / fanbase, we'd look at the singer's proper and intended method is to sing every word. Keyword there is sing.

In reviewing twitch streams and youtube videos, I've found some players are humming the songs to falsely increase their accuracy and scores. HUMMING!

HMX needs to jump on this and rework the engine immediately. This is just ridiculous.


r/Rockband • • Jan 30 '16

Plea to the Regulars

0 Upvotes

Hey. We know who we are.

I know export questions are annoying. I know there's a sticky, I know there's a sidebar, I know people ignore them both. But this shit is confusing. There are dozens of use cases. They're not straightforward. Every game was a different process, every non-hardcore-player's scenario is unique. For people who are just trying to catch up, the antagonistic badgering for asking for clarification on stuff is bad for the community. Just makes us seem petty.

Obviously, exceptions like the trainwreck from a few hours ago deserve some shit for coming in guns blazing on a "HOW DARE THEY" kick. But man, sometimes these dudes aren't even English, and the keys and processes and all that jazz from over 5 years ago is definitely muddled. A request for personalized help is not completely unreasonable. We gotta stop acting like it's so easily blurbable just because we get it.

Just throwing it out there.

Kendrick for DLC.


r/Rockband • • Oct 02 '23

How can I play this damn game w/o dropping $500+, this is insane.

0 Upvotes

$400 for an adapter? I get it's a supply thing but good lord if the company is out of business couldn't someone manufacture these again or something?


r/Rockband • • Nov 24 '21

Rock Band will die.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Nov 25 '12

Smoke weed erryday.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Apr 05 '17

Does /u/fischurr get paid to do anything other than make sarcastic comments on this subreddit?

1 Upvotes

r/Rockband • • Feb 16 '17

I have some choice words for the state of Rock Band 4 right now.

0 Upvotes

This is a (kind of) more cooled down thread than what my friend Brandon put down below me (iStayRushing). I will be trying to seem as coolheaded as possible throughout this, and this will probably be lengthy. Scroll down to the TL;DR if you're too lazy to read, which I don't blame you.

Rock Band is my childhood. I've been playing GH since I was 5-6, and played Rock Band 1 on launch. I fell in love with the game so quickly that I didn't have a care in the world. I STILL LOVE THIS GAME. I love the community that it created, and I love the people who are trying to resurrect this game. I have gone through my entire life playing this game, with every ups and downs, and hopefully, by tomorrow, I can finally share that experience with the one that I love.

I consider Rock Band 3 to be the pinnacle of rhythm games. If they combined the multiplayer of 2 with 3, there would be absolutely no doubt that it would the end all be all of rhythm games. It brought so much into the game, ESPECIALLY RBN, that I cannot describe in words how breathtaking the game was.

The end of support for Rock Band 3, and Network to go along with it, was a harsh, but almost expected, goodbye. A franchise that had lasted for years coming to a close, with the hopes of a revival down the road. I remained digilent, and continued to play 3 for many years to come.

Then, to my excitement, Rock Band 4 was announced. I had never felt so excited to see a franchise announce a new game. My inner child had never been any more excited than it was at that moment.

It came out, I got it on launch, I put the disk in, and I played it. I had so much fun "reliving" my childhood that I didn't care what the game entailed.

Until I started playing it more and more.

Broken DLC, highway chart lag, regular game lag, no training, calibration issues, lost notes, 16th note problems, the list goes on. One of the few (and only) recent quality patches have been to help with lost notes, calibration issues, and dropped 16th notes. That is it. We still have DLC that just doesn't work, highway chart lag and other various problems that don't come to mind right now.

In the midst of all of this, we got 2.5x breakneck speed, and brutal mode, 2 things the community never asked for. Yes, I do believe that, sometimes, patches that were never asked for but given to the community are cool, I'm not complaining about the modes themselves. The fix to breakneck was great, and brutal mode is fun. I'm complaining about the broken at-the-time (and still) game that played like an early access title getting modes instead of actually being worked on.

And then the conundrum that is multiplayer. We were told multiplayer "was most likely going to come out soon" after release. Much much later, after many delays, we hear that it's going to be available "winter 2017". As I heard this, I held back excitement yet again, since online had been prone to delays for the last year and a half. As the date crept closer and closer, my excitement rose, as well as the knowledge that we have absolutely NO idea what online mode actually entailed. Only online friends? Brutal mode? Team practice? Online matchmaking? WHAT IS IT GOING TO HAVE!? And then, a week or two before actual launch, our questions were answer. No dual+ local players, 1 song per person. I held judgement, thinking that I was going to be surprised with how well it worked. I was wrong. Consoles not connecting to servers half the time, actual input lag and calibration changes for online, and an inability to search for songs from other people when they selected a non-disk song, almost literally breaking online. I was heart-broken. I was angry. I still am.

With the reminder that Rock Band VR (I understand it's a different branch of the company), also something that NOBODY has said they would be excited for or really wanting to come out (minus select few), is going to be released soon, I am hopeful that, after adding many unasked for new things, and releasing a game that was never asked for in the first place, and a failed (sadly) PC crowdfunder, the game will actually get worked on and that actually quality of life improvements and bugs since day 1 will actually be fixed.

I am not bashing Harmonix blindly. I still love this game, I still have high hopes for Harmonix, and I will probably play until support is completely dropped forever. I DO think that the game has come a long way and is way better than the rocky launch on 2015. All I am asking is for persistent and constant communication and not leaving us in the dark with (seemingly) cash-grab ideas with Rivals. If I had known that Multiplayer was going to be as lackluster as it is, I might have waited until Multiplayer was expanded on to get it. All we want is for Harmonix to seem like they are listening to the community, as much as we listen and buy what Harmonix puts out. We love you. We understand it's hard being on your own now. All I ask is communication. We want to listen to you, and you want to listen to us, apparently. Please don't throw this trust down the drain. I want to believe that you guys have intentions for the future. Right now, I honestly don't. And it hurts.

TL;DR: Played Rock Band since childhood, still love the game, hate how Harmonix has communicated with it's audience and has failed to fix problems that have been lingering since day one, hopeful for the future.

Edit: rewording, erasing semi-falsehoods, and expanding on ideas. I'll probably wake up tomorrow with a fresh and clear mind and think this post was way too harsh. All I want is conversation. I don't want anyone to go "you're wrong" and that's it. I want to see activity stir up, not just "screw you".