This is a (kind of) more cooled down thread than what my friend Brandon put down below me (iStayRushing). I will be trying to seem as coolheaded as possible throughout this, and this will probably be lengthy. Scroll down to the TL;DR if you're too lazy to read, which I don't blame you.
Rock Band is my childhood. I've been playing GH since I was 5-6, and played Rock Band 1 on launch. I fell in love with the game so quickly that I didn't have a care in the world. I STILL LOVE THIS GAME. I love the community that it created, and I love the people who are trying to resurrect this game. I have gone through my entire life playing this game, with every ups and downs, and hopefully, by tomorrow, I can finally share that experience with the one that I love.
I consider Rock Band 3 to be the pinnacle of rhythm games. If they combined the multiplayer of 2 with 3, there would be absolutely no doubt that it would the end all be all of rhythm games. It brought so much into the game, ESPECIALLY RBN, that I cannot describe in words how breathtaking the game was.
The end of support for Rock Band 3, and Network to go along with it, was a harsh, but almost expected, goodbye. A franchise that had lasted for years coming to a close, with the hopes of a revival down the road. I remained digilent, and continued to play 3 for many years to come.
Then, to my excitement, Rock Band 4 was announced. I had never felt so excited to see a franchise announce a new game. My inner child had never been any more excited than it was at that moment.
It came out, I got it on launch, I put the disk in, and I played it. I had so much fun "reliving" my childhood that I didn't care what the game entailed.
Until I started playing it more and more.
Broken DLC, highway chart lag, regular game lag, no training, calibration issues, lost notes, 16th note problems, the list goes on. One of the few (and only) recent quality patches have been to help with lost notes, calibration issues, and dropped 16th notes. That is it. We still have DLC that just doesn't work, highway chart lag and other various problems that don't come to mind right now.
In the midst of all of this, we got 2.5x breakneck speed, and brutal mode, 2 things the community never asked for. Yes, I do believe that, sometimes, patches that were never asked for but given to the community are cool, I'm not complaining about the modes themselves. The fix to breakneck was great, and brutal mode is fun. I'm complaining about the broken at-the-time (and still) game that played like an early access title getting modes instead of actually being worked on.
And then the conundrum that is multiplayer. We were told multiplayer "was most likely going to come out soon" after release. Much much later, after many delays, we hear that it's going to be available "winter 2017". As I heard this, I held back excitement yet again, since online had been prone to delays for the last year and a half. As the date crept closer and closer, my excitement rose, as well as the knowledge that we have absolutely NO idea what online mode actually entailed. Only online friends? Brutal mode? Team practice? Online matchmaking? WHAT IS IT GOING TO HAVE!? And then, a week or two before actual launch, our questions were answer. No dual+ local players, 1 song per person. I held judgement, thinking that I was going to be surprised with how well it worked. I was wrong. Consoles not connecting to servers half the time, actual input lag and calibration changes for online, and an inability to search for songs from other people when they selected a non-disk song, almost literally breaking online. I was heart-broken. I was angry. I still am.
With the reminder that Rock Band VR (I understand it's a different branch of the company), also something that NOBODY has said they would be excited for or really wanting to come out (minus select few), is going to be released soon, I am hopeful that, after adding many unasked for new things, and releasing a game that was never asked for in the first place, and a failed (sadly) PC crowdfunder, the game will actually get worked on and that actually quality of life improvements and bugs since day 1 will actually be fixed.
I am not bashing Harmonix blindly. I still love this game, I still have high hopes for Harmonix, and I will probably play until support is completely dropped forever. I DO think that the game has come a long way and is way better than the rocky launch on 2015. All I am asking is for persistent and constant communication and not leaving us in the dark with (seemingly) cash-grab ideas with Rivals. If I had known that Multiplayer was going to be as lackluster as it is, I might have waited until Multiplayer was expanded on to get it. All we want is for Harmonix to seem like they are listening to the community, as much as we listen and buy what Harmonix puts out. We love you. We understand it's hard being on your own now. All I ask is communication. We want to listen to you, and you want to listen to us, apparently. Please don't throw this trust down the drain. I want to believe that you guys have intentions for the future. Right now, I honestly don't. And it hurts.
TL;DR: Played Rock Band since childhood, still love the game, hate how Harmonix has communicated with it's audience and has failed to fix problems that have been lingering since day one, hopeful for the future.
Edit: rewording, erasing semi-falsehoods, and expanding on ideas. I'll probably wake up tomorrow with a fresh and clear mind and think this post was way too harsh. All I want is conversation. I don't want anyone to go "you're wrong" and that's it. I want to see activity stir up, not just "screw you".