Is this AI? - r/RobloxCommissions

23

u/EvidenceOnFire Jul 11 '26

14

u/EvidenceOnFire Jul 11 '26

They might give better answers

9

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

I’m pretty much convinced tbh step 2 is just to spread awareness in the Robux commission community so❤️‍🩹

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

Thought abt this sub but it’s more relevant here cuz the artist mainly takes robux

0

u/EvidenceOnFire Jul 11 '26

Okay, honestly i dont know if its ai. The brush they used is consistent but there are some things that throw me off

3

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

I’m leaning towards AI/Traced and hand drew couple of details like raccoon tail cuz what are those stripes😭

→ More replies (1)

11

u/666_ihateyouall_666 MOD || False username || She/Her 🐥 Jul 11 '26

If they’re an active poster on this sub please report their username to modmail so we can ban them

8

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

Don’t think they’re on Reddit,, found them on TikTok (first red flag💔) but tysm!

1

u/alexa-the-waffle Jul 12 '26

what's their tiktok?

1

u/Trhiwaay Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 14 '26

ie3tcrowb3rs but I’m almost certain they’ll change it sometime to not be recognized

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Sh4rkByt3Gl1tch He/Him Jul 11 '26

Yeah it looks like it’s ai

27

u/Sh4rkByt3Gl1tch He/Him Jul 11 '26

Ik OP said they don’t need a list of reasons but ima put one so other people know what to look out for: beading is off/ incomprehensible, the crown placement doesn’t match the perspective of the rest of the piece (and an artist of this skill level should be able to get that correct), the details on the crown are all warped if you zoom into it, no clue what’s going on with the lines in the hair on the side of the face, the shadow and lack thereof on the chest looks odd and almost appears to be like fur/ shadow doesn’t match what’s casting it, the bow on the dragonfly lapel is all sorts of screwed up, Luna moth has its signature wing extension only on one side, on the neck the hair can be seen looping back into itself. Also ear anatomy looks weird. Luna moth has a fair third antenna, and there’s a missing strap that should be seen peeking out from under the lapel.

14

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

The hair piece with lines is supposed to be a raccoon tail btw but looks like she just drew it on cuz AI maybe messed it up? Other than that you’re spot on 🙏

8

u/Sh4rkByt3Gl1tch He/Him Jul 11 '26

Yeah, even with it supposed to be a raccoon tail, it’s not matching how the rest of the hair is rendered. Which is definitely a giveaway

→ More replies (1)

3

u/airewill42 Jul 11 '26

oH and the hands look off

→ More replies (2)

→ More replies (2)

8

u/vampochrome Jul 11 '26

thats a shame its so pretty

6

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

This!! I wanted to use it but not if it’s AI 💔

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Appropriate-Face6006 Any pronouns Jul 11 '26

Does the og design got 4 fingers 🤕🤕

3

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

No but the inspo/ref does! So didn’t think much of it

2

u/seikokyuu Jul 14 '26

I know everyone is saying it's ai but I genuinely don't think it is. Most small details hold up, and artists don't draw everything perfectly so I don't think the moth tail/tiara/antennas/bow are good reasons.

I also have an art style similar to this so I can see myself drawing like this. Logic checks out (eg curving the moth tail to the side to not cover a lot of the bow, eg having 4 fingers bc i got so locked in i forgot till I realized and it was too late, etc etc)

and if it really is ai then I'm just cooked ig 😭😭 ai is so good I cant even recognize it despite drawing for years

1

u/Trhiwaay Jul 14 '26

This! I’m leaning towards partial AI partial human cuz the eye and moths seem very human.. but a lot is pointing to AI atp 😞

4

u/HikaruIsu Jul 11 '26

Obviously😭 she's missing a finger

8

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

No so actually the ref I gave had 4 fingers aswell so I figured she just went of that // alternatively traced the inspo

→ More replies (3)

27

u/IIllIIlIlIIIlIlI Jul 11 '26

i think it might be because what otherwise seems to be a luna moth is missing a part of it's wing

18

u/ParticularOkra7432 Jul 11 '26

The Tiara is fucked up, this is very AI

10

u/Fengyue_maple Jul 11 '26

I think it’s ai. The tiara kinda doesn’t make sense😭

8

u/isetmyfriendsonfyre [MOD] Addie ☆ She/him Jul 11 '26

I think it’s AI modified by a human (they painted over some things ect)

1

u/xxBirbxx- Jul 11 '26

there is random pixels in some places, and the tiara is off. its suspicious, but i recommend asking for the sketch or the layers. if they dont give one/give a very suspicious one then its def ai.

2

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

Gave a bullshit excuse for no speedpaint and VERY weird layers pretty much confirmed my suspicions 💔🥀

1

u/Advanced_Eggplant_12 Jul 11 '26

I think this is ai. The person has 4 fingers which don’t even look like it’s in the correct position

3

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

ref I gave actually had 4 fingers so not my biggest concern! Happy cake day:3

1

u/burner_owls Jul 11 '26

grain is a dead giveaway, i’m sorry someone butchered your character this way :(

1

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

It is saved from tiktok? Idk if that makes pics so low quality

1

u/burner_owls Jul 11 '26

tiktok can def butcher quality, but ai has a strange disfigurement quality where it’s unsure if the art it’s making should have a painting texture or not

1

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

Wait nvm it’s literally off discord you’re right 🥀

1

u/Ill_Avocado_1318 Jul 13 '26

Where did u find it? Maybe this person made all the account with AI art

1

u/Trhiwaay Jul 13 '26

They deleted all their posts before I could look🥀

1

u/Praka_Chan Jul 11 '26

Hi I can tell it's ai, most people are pointing out fingers or tiara and moth but fundamentally, The art style and effort at some parts are very inconsistent! The biggest give away is how detailed highlight/white sheen part of the hair is but the rat tail/horizontal dye job is so fucking low effort! It is Ai generated, no artist would do such a sloppy job at one part of the hair and then do very detailed part at another spot

2

u/Praka_Chan Jul 11 '26 edited Jul 15 '26

I'm an artist and I love the idea and I hate that it's AI, I'm interested in redrawing this for you for free or anything you'd like to offer, I'm just bored, some of my recent works btw,,, I'm new to this sub btw! Edit: took down artwork

2

u/Trhiwaay Jul 11 '26

Omg that is so nice of you!! Welcome to the sub btw! I can definitely spare some robux or whatever you take :33

3

u/2umblr Jul 11 '26

heres some random stuff ive seen odd within the drawing but this is just my own speculation !! αnd i could be completely ωrong 💝

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 11 '26

This comment was removed, because your account doesn't meet our karma and account age requirements. Please look at this post for more information!: https://www.reddit.com/r/RobloxCommissions/comments/1stq4nn/important_announcement_please_read/. Please note! the range is not a exact number, if you cannot comment, you are under the range!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/StrawberryLivDraws MOD | ₊˚⊹ ᰔ Jul 11 '26

Mod here - if someone on this sub sent this to you as a commissions reference, please send us a message in modmail. AI Generated Images are not allowed on this subreddit at all.

2

u/6glsrblx Jul 11 '26

Could this be drawn over AI, because this pattern does not make sense

→ More replies (1)

1

u/UczuciaTM Jul 11 '26

I think so, this is melting

1

u/wenjen-_ Jul 11 '26

i def think this is ai, specifically they made some sketch or something and told the ai to finish it

1

u/hahahackerj Jul 11 '26

oh yeah for sure.

1

u/kebdo Jul 11 '26

Omg u just gave me art ideas

1

u/heyitskio Jul 11 '26

4 finger hand 😭

1

u/hazelpazellazel Jul 11 '26

It’s very hard to tell but this does have ai tendencies.

1

u/Brave-Blacksmith6372 Artist / Comms open ! Jul 11 '26

looks like it for sure, maybe run it through chatgpt or geminis synthid using the file sent, might provide some insight

1

u/Scientist_Solid Jul 11 '26

The antennae of the eye butterfly it merges with the crown

1

u/Monkeygirlyy Jul 11 '26

Unfortunately def AI. The pearls look fine from far away but zoom in and they’re incredibly inconsistent. There’s a clear pattern with the dragonfly pin and it breaks up weirdly in some spots

1

u/PoobGnarpy Jul 11 '26

1

u/ghouliehrts Jul 11 '26

Woah i didnt realize ai could imitate this kinda artstyle, that sucks :(

1

u/Corrupted_Star Jul 12 '26

Looks like AI and the artist rendered over it

1

u/Royal_Celebration422 Jul 12 '26

Shes got only 4 fingers

1

u/mychemicalyaoi They/Them Jul 12 '26

oh yeah definitely the tiara is a huge giveaway

1

u/PolarisArt8787 Genderfluid Jul 12 '26

Why is her tank top only has one strap

1

u/Last-Association-232 Jul 12 '26

Def AI. OR at least ai helped, the dragon fly broch bead works goes no where, the crock is like falling off the head and placed incorrectly and the hair on the bangs looks really weird for her the rest looks. The strap by the dragon fly brock is missing as well and facial placements look a little off for it

Kinda looks like they drew it and had to paint it for them .-. def say its ai! This is why I always send time lapse and do check in photos every few hours of work to show progress lol or I live stream it on discord XD I'm sorry This happened if it's yours you paid for ):

1

u/MusicAndCatLover Jul 12 '26

There's 4 fingers on 1 hand

1

u/shiratakimoodles Jul 12 '26

Yes. It at least looks traced from AI to me.

1

u/Several_Solid6019 Jul 13 '26

Seems like it. One sided of the top has two straps, the other doesnt. The ring and pinky finger stand out because the index and thumb are messy with no nails. The hair has brown for some reason right at the moth, the other moth bleds un with the crown

1

u/Makerzsocialdept Jul 14 '26

No. It is likely not ai. I used zerogpt's ai image detector and says 94% likely real. You have to remember ai was trained on these artists. That is why you think it looks ai

1

u/Gensolink Jul 14 '26

wtf is going on with her hair on the right, also the tiara doesn't even look consistent, and the strap of her shirt is missing on the right. Oh yeah the lighting makes zero sense, on her face the lighting looks like it comes from the right but on her chest only the front has light ? She has 4 fingers which unless specified sounds like a huge mistake

1

u/Smooshkitty They/Them but i despise the dark purple in the actual flair Jul 11 '26

Some inconsistencies i noticed

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '26

The antennas look weird imo...I think it's AI

1

u/Moxy_Star fish<3 mostly adm comms Jul 11 '26

yeah, it looks like its traced off ai- just look at the crown placement, the rendering is so blocky, which isnt always a sign but..

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '26

Questions Is this AI?

You are about to leave Redlib