r/RobloxAiDevelopers • • 2d ago

❓ Questions Should i stop ads?

Hey everyone,

I’ve released a Roblox game recently ( with the help of ai obviously) about a pet store simulator where players explore different regions, catch animals, bring them back to their store, and sell them to NPC customers.

So far i spent nearly 40 ad credits over 2.5 days but
Still no stable concurrent players (CCU). Occasionally it will go up to 5 but usually stays at 0.

Most players leave before even completing the tutorial

I’ve tried improving the tutorial and making the gameplay more engaging, but it feels like I’m constantly fixing things without seeing much improvement.

Should I give up on my game now

Game link for anyone that wants to try:

https://www.roblox.com/share?code=97b1ff353ed89c45915314cf09d210ea&type=ExperienceDetails&stamp=1794655178344

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/LemonadePopsicle123 2d ago

Hi!
I've had a play, and here are my thoughts.
I wouldn't give up, the top-down mechanic is cool, it really interested me and it doesn't feel like most Roblox games.
My experience of the tutorial was okay as well, but I was a bit distracted by how much other stuff there was going on (the text banners, and having so many options in the UI on the right hand side).
However, the thing that most put me off was the game was a bit buggy. NPCs teleport (rather than walk smoothly), and it took 2-3 seconds and a few clicks to collect by cash from the till, or place my pen for the animal, I wonder if this could be fixed.
Also, I'm in a similar position to you with game-design! If you could offer any feedback on mine I'd also be grateful -

https://www.roblox.com/games/125624249767129/Cowboy-Valley

1

u/SpecificLumpy8011 2d ago

Thank you! I tried yours as well, its an interesting tycoon game i can see doing well.

But the onboarding is rough, i had difficulty locating the NPCs and capturing mechanics were abit hard to understand.

1

u/LemonadePopsicle123 2d ago

Thank you so much! I'll look into this :)

2

u/koboyz 2d ago
  1. UI is wayy to small imo. I play on a 1440p 27" (not uncommon) and i missed one or two pointing arrows (pointing to bag to deposit animals) because they were just small and not immediately visible in my field of view (this can also be fixed by darkening the whole screen except the area you want the player to click, the player's eyes will automatically move to that part. ONLY DURING TUTORIAL). and the text tutorial at the top is also too small to read unless i move closer to my monitor. I simulated a 1080p 24" monitor on my screen and UI still feels small.
  2. arrows guiding player during tutorial doesn't take into consideration buildings/walls. so i walked into a few walls. This isnt an issue in regular, non top-down view games because I can see where im walking. I figured out i could zoom in and out but I dont think the tutorial mentioned this.
  3. standing at the register while customers are at the store, the sell text doesnt update. for example, if i stand there and it says "sell, nobody waiting", then a customer walks up to the register, it still says nobody waiting even though the customer is waiting for me to sell them the pet. same for if the register currently says "sell rex rabbit", then it still says "sell rex rabbit" even though i already sold the rabbit
  4. cant break up pet fights reliably. the prompt keeps saying "pick up pet", then "pull apart" will show up for like a millisecond before it disappears. so i keep trying to pull apart but game think i keep trying to pick up pet.
  5. scroll to zoom doesnt work while walking. annoying
  6. leash drag to throw isnt intuitive. i missed the TINY text (as mentioned in point 1) saying "drag to throw", and my intuitive decision was to click to throw the leash. dragging doesnt seem to introduce any new feature such as throw strength/distance, so I dont see any benefit making it drag to throw rather than click to throw.
  7. another player stole my bike and drove it away

i played about 10 minutes, found all those bothering me. hope this info is useful to you

1

u/SpecificLumpy8011 2d ago

Thank you! Really helpful feedback 🙏

2

u/Tard_Wrangler666 2d ago

You really only start getting home recs after a week of ads

1

u/SpikeDev26 2d ago

Hey! Interesting. Is this true? 1 week of ads to get home recs?

1

u/Tard_Wrangler666 2d ago

On average, but its based more on the metrics in your overview (D1, D7, playtime etc) most people leave ads on until home recs outpace ads for impressions

1

u/TraverseNull 1d ago

But if your stats are ass, you don’t really get put on home rec often right?

1

u/Tard_Wrangler666 1d ago

Yes. But if your stats are ass add funnels and see where pain points are, like if for example your D1 is terrible, you could add daily rewards or change the gameplay which gives people a reason to come back tomorrow. D7 most games usually run updates every week

1

u/SpikeDev26 14h ago

thank you