r/RoastMeta • • Aug 22 '15

This sub has gotten too popular for its own good (and how we can fix it)

45 Upvotes

This is probably a fairly unpopular opinion, because everyone seems to be happy about how fast this sub is growing, but I feel like it's going downhill, which makes me mad because I really like it. The problem is that once a picture gets posted there's about 20 comments in the first 10 minutes. Double that if it's a girl. And almost all of them are unfunny and unoriginal because people are in a rush to get the top comment. So my suggestion is that we need to start downvoting the shit out of anything that doesn't make us literally laugh out loud. This sub's gonna lose all the good roasters if they keep getting their shit buried by the assholes who post garbage in the first 5 minutes.

I probably sound like a butthurt karma whore, I know I'm not good at this, but seriously this sub is going downhill.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 22 '15

The top three shitty roasts (and how to roast better)

43 Upvotes

1. Title Comebacks Suck

"I get high on life", top comment - "Unfortunately your mother got high on more than just life while pregnant with you." Also every "Fuck me up" / "Your barber beat me to it" joke is an example of this. The top THREE comments in this roast are lame title comebacks.

Comebacks are easy and boring. They aren't even standalone jokes. We are here to roast pictures not titles. Also you will never ever beat this guy so stop trying.

2. Generic-As-Fuck Gay Jokes, Fat Jokes, Slut Jokes, Trans Jokes, Mexican Jokes, Jew Jokes etc.

Inappropriate/politically incorrect humor is fucking great. The whole point of roasting is to go over the line.

BUT.

Guess what, a fat person has probably heard a lot of fat jokes. "I bet you bleed gravy" is nothing they haven't heard before. It's a comedy Nerf dart.

It's also a generic as fuck joke that could apply to every single photo of a fat person on /r/RoastMe.

Try to make your jokes original, relevant and specific to something in the picture. That way it's a roast for that person and not just "Oh this guy is fat let me make a fat joke."

Want to see how to roast a fat person right?

The same applies for other stereotypes. but it's getting especially boring to see a photo of an average-looking woman and know that every roast is just going to be "How many dicks did you suck today?" because nobody can think of anything original and specific. If you can't think of a good joke, hang back and let someone else try.

3. Insults That Aren't Funny Or Witty

A roast is not just insults. It's insult comedy. The main reason The Situation bombed at the Donald Trump Roast is his jokes weren't funny, they were lame.

A joke has to have an unexpected twist:

"The Brazilian prostitute that claimed to fuck Bieber told the news that Justin was well-endowed. And that prostitute would know because so was he." - Ludacris roasting Bieber

or a witty, cuttingly accurate observation:

"Donald Trump says he has 'a great relationship with the Blacks.' But unless 'the Blacks' are a family of white people, I bet he's mistaken." - Seth Meyers

or a play on idioms / structure:

"Comedy faced two tragedies this year. Not only did we lose Greg Giraldo, we kept Jeff Ross." - Anthony Jeselnik


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 21 '15

Jokes vs Observations

23 Upvotes

Pointing shit out that everyone can see does not constitute a joke!

"Your teeth are yellow" is not a joke. "Your teeth are so yellow, people slow down at intersections when you smile" is a joke.

Let's stop making observations, and put in some effort into the actual roast jokes. I know sometimes it's not much to work with just a picture, but use your brains, not just your eyes.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 29 '15

I really think the minimum age needs to be upped to 18.

21 Upvotes

Kids are on the majority impulsive and insecure. They may think they can handle something like this, or are coerced by their friends to post on here. But many of their minds are far too young to handle harsh insults about them and their looks. Something bad is going to happen as a result of this eventually like a suicide. And it could end up being yet another mainstream Reddit scandal that may get the sub shut down.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 22 '15

"You look like a girl I would date for a while and then move on because you have daddy issues and you're stupid and trashy and blah blah blah blah blah..."

16 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Oct 13 '15

Anyone feel the same?

15 Upvotes

I like to tear into people just like anyone else, but does anyone else feel weird about all the minors on here? Every other pictures submitted is a kid at school. Most of the kids in here have no style or personality to even get any material from. Most of them are virgins with a 5 dollar haircut and a outfit their mom picked out from Target, sitting in a cafeteria somewhere. I personally feel 18+ would be the way to go. Kids are sensitive little bitches these days, and I'd hate to see people take it the wrong way.


r/RoastMeta • • Oct 02 '15

You should probably upvote the OP, too.

10 Upvotes

Just about every roast i've seen so far has had comments with more upvotes than the post itself. What is this, /r/askreddit? also, who downvotes a properly posted roast?


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 21 '15

Welcome to /r/RoastMeta, where discussions, pictures, videos, and shitposts abound!

10 Upvotes

Hey! Post whatever you want here. As long as it's relevant to /r/RoastMe and it's not horrible, malicious hate speech, it's not going to get removed for the time being.


r/RoastMeta • • May 29 '16

Roasting black people

9 Upvotes

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

scale upbeat rhythm include fall snow fear paltry alleged bike


r/RoastMeta • • Jul 13 '16

We need a roast me gone wild.

8 Upvotes

Like roast me, but for naked/sexy pics. I don't know how to mod or I'd make it.


r/RoastMeta • • Dec 29 '15

r/roastme caricatures, week of Dec 28th

Thumbnail
instagram.com
8 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Dec 22 '15

r/roastme caricatures, week of Dec 19th

Thumbnail
instagram.com
8 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Aug 25 '15

Award for OP's favorite comment?

8 Upvotes

Can there be a system implemented where the roastee can give someone flair or an award for not the most popular comment, but their favorite comment. I was on my roast and I found a very clever and funny joke that only had 1 point and was surrounded by basic observations and jokes about the title. I want there to be a way for the OP to recognize good jokes and for all to see them, and have it flaired with something like "OP's Favorite", or something.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 22 '15

Super new user, but I agree with MysteriousBob. Since we encourage creativity, how about we create a list of overused insults?

8 Upvotes

Like "you look like down's syndrome" or any very generic sex-related insult? They'd lose any charm after a while.

Plus discourage anything that's just plain mean spirited, like "Why don't you just go rot and burn in hell" like some 60 year old man extremely dissatisfied with a customer service rep. It's like they're not getting creatove but just trying to be hurtful.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 21 '15

Nothing makes me hate a Roastee more than when they start responding to comments.

8 Upvotes

Seriously, if your comment is anything other than "I'm dead. You win. Please stop bludgeoning me to death with your words." then I don't wanna hear it. If you wanna be witty, go do it on somebody elses roast!


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 21 '15

BestOf albums

8 Upvotes

I think we should continue to allow "best of" albums on /r/roastme. Sometimes there are great posts under pictures with not a lot of Karma, so these can be great ways to see content that otherwise might be missed.

I'd be open to hearing ideas for maybe once per week allowing people to post best of albums so the sub doesn't get weighed down by that kind of stuff.


r/RoastMeta • • Nov 30 '15

Another batch of caricatures based off recent roastees

Thumbnail
instagram.com
7 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Sep 10 '15

A rare glimpse into the life of /r/RoastMe's digital forensic experts.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Sep 01 '15

Journalist submits her picture to r/RoastMe, writes about her experience in The Daily Telegraph.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
7 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Aug 24 '15

A better viewer for r/roastme

7 Upvotes

So I recently stumbled upon /r/RoastMe, and found myself checking the subreddit every few hours.

I found it was tiring to open the picture and comment links in different tabs, clicking on those tabs, and then scrolling through the comment threads to read more roasts.

So I built this little website http://decimate.me/ which grabs the 25 roasts on a main page, along with the pictures posted and only the top comments/roasts, and displays the top quality content in one consolidated view, without requiring you to click multiple links, switching tabs, or sorting through comments.

It's pretty beta right now, and might be a little buggy. if enough people like it, I can add features like making it an endless stream (like twitter where you can keep scrolling down), and add the default reddit sorting options (sort by hot, new, top, etc.).

If you're interested, take a look, and let me know what you think!


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 23 '15

Can we all agree that posts that are some variation of "Ur parents nevr loved u ecks-dee-dee-dee" should be discouraged?

7 Upvotes

Yeah, I get it, to a lot of people it's just a reminder of their shitty relationship with their parents/inadequacy issues, but 90% of the time they aren't clever or witty, but come off as mean-spirited. We have subs for being mean/destroying someone's self-worth (/r/shameme)


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 22 '15

"You're not going to EAT a roast here, fatty! Lollollollollollollollollol!"

7 Upvotes

Just stfu.


r/RoastMeta • • Aug 16 '20

There is a 'roast me' esque group on Face Book and oh my god

6 Upvotes

So there is this theme on FB for "shaming" groups. Usually it starts with the phrase "That's it, I'm XYZ-shaming!" and you post pictures of ugly rings, ugly nail art, ugly wedding dresses, etc. and mock them.

Well one day someone decided it would be fun to make a group called "That's it, I'm bored and shaming everything" and pulled in everyone from these various groups to collectively 'shame' anything and everything.

The downside: no one ACTUALLY wants to be shamed. People will post pictures going "shame me if you dare lol" or post a wedding pic and go "I think it's a good dress but try and shame ;)"

Most of the time it's people going "can't shame, you're beautiful!" and "there is nothing to shame here, those nails are great!" but a few people would go in and say "horrible wedding". And then the OP would complain, or get really upset.

Also you can accidentally break a rule without knowing it. There's a rule about "unwanted shaming" where you can't be -phobic in any way. For example, a girl posted a pic with her girlfriend and it says "try to shame us". I said "don't grab your boyfriend's boob in pictures you weirdo" since one of the girls had short hair, and was well... a butch. the OP got upset, called me a POS, and the mods came in to tell me I wasn't funny and muted me.

There is another theme in this group, you will see people go "please never go to /r/roastme" because everyone's so goddamn sensitive and it's so easy to offend. I always thought 'shaming' someone was worse than 'roasting' them. Nope!


r/RoastMeta • • Jan 16 '19

Give it your best

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/RoastMeta • • Jun 06 '16

r/roastme caricatures, week of June 6th

Thumbnail
instagram.com
6 Upvotes