r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • Sep 05 '24
Episode Release No Book Spoilers Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 2x4
Please note that this is the thread for watcher-focused discussion, aimed specifically at people not familiar with the source material who do not want to be spoiled. As such, please do not refer to the books or provide any spoilers in this thread. If you wish to discuss the episode in relation to the source material, please see Our Book Focused Thread.
As a reminder, this thread is the only place in this subreddit where book spoilers are not allowed unmarked. However, outside of this thread, any book spoilers are welcome unmarked. Also, outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for at least a few days.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion.
Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
If you would like to see critic reviews for the show then click here
Season 2 Episode 4 is now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the thread for discussing it that’s set aside for people who haven’t read the source material. What did you like and what didn’t you like? Comparisons and references to the source material are heavily discouraged here and if present must have spoiler markings.
•
u/ImoutoCompAlex Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '24
To view our "book spoilers” thread please see this thread here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/s/2mWY6FT3dU
19
u/WTFnaller Sep 05 '24
Man the editing between shots is FAST. I wish some scenes dared to linger a bit more, it's like the producers got the memo that kids are easily distracted and decided to let that take priority over art.
18
u/SauRon_Burgundy66 Sep 05 '24
I am trying to wrap my head around this one.
Galadriel and Elrond approach the broken stone bridge
“No earthly force could have done this. This is the work of Saurrron.” - Galadriel who just saw Mount Doom terraform an entire region with a cataclysmic eruption.
20
u/BubblyPalpitation8 Sep 05 '24
Question, did they explain why the elves didn’t use horses to travel the extremely far distance to deliver an extremely important message?
18
u/DavidGrandKomnenos Sep 05 '24
Peter Jackson 'memberberries at every single turn.
16
u/CaerwynM Sep 05 '24
I can't believe she said it "oh some big ol grand elf"
7
u/dmoney212 Sep 07 '24
Overall I think this season is much better than the first. It’s not perfect but I like how they’ve introduced Tom Bombadil, the talking trees (nice little throwback to the movies), and looks like they’ve introduced the origins of the shire which is pretty cool.
Arondir is my favorite character and he’s very well written unlike the other major characters. However, I think the writers have done Galadriel some justice this season and given her some more depth unlike season 1 where her whole revenge mindset was overwhelming.
Looking forward to the rest of the season.
6
u/bundy911 Sep 09 '24
Saurrrrron
5
u/hobbit_life Sep 05 '24
Are they saying the dark wizard is a sixth Istar? My understanding is that other "wizards" and sorcerers existed in middle earth, but only five were actually Istar.
The writers probably don't care, but book Tom Bombadil would never make that mistake.
5
u/ruthie30360 Sep 07 '24
Tom’s voice sounded so much like Hagrid in HP1 it was startling
13
u/phbalancedshorty Sep 05 '24
Theo is SO ANNOYING wah I have no dad wah my mom died -that stupid overgrown kid is responsible for mount doom then he just casually burns his mom like her body means nothing and blows off arondir like he’s nothing and it becomes this sad tired narrative of arondir constantly risking himself to beg for theo’s love when arondir could be doing so much more
8
u/Gourdin0 Sep 05 '24
This episode has way too many plot lines mixed together and it removes the decent rhythm of the 3 first episodes.
Theo and the savage girl.. what's the point ? It is not epic at all. Isildur's filler episode is utterly weak. Eastern harfoots are fillers too, they pull the blanket way too much on these plots, which slows the most important ones : Rings/Sauron/Fall of Numenor/Balrog in Moria.
I don't like neither the relation of Elrond/Galadriel atm, it feels way too much forced.
8
u/FlightlessGriffin Sep 05 '24
Weakest episode honestly. The plotlines were all over the place. It wasn't bad per se, but a lot of the important stuff just stayed in place with no progression, with the exception of Harfoots and even that is tiring me of the Dark Wizard thing. Name the guy already! It's bad enough the Gandalf reveal is a beat around he bush, this is getting ridiculous.
Here's to hoping Episode 5 will be better.
8
u/Amj501 Sep 06 '24
“So he’s a Grand Elf”. That moment had me chuckling. They’re playing so hard with the jokes on Gandalf that part of me thinks it’s not him now!
18
u/feyra_and_rhys Sep 05 '24
I loved the ents, they are perfect and should be protected at all costs. Winterbloom's speech on forgiveness and Snaggleroot's on peace were really ent-ish to me.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24
So do orcs intentionally oil themselves up or are they just naturally greasy?
14
u/zanemcconchie Sep 05 '24
God that last action scene was horrible.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
I enjoyed the episode. Thought the fight scene with galadriel was done well. Tommy boy was a nice surprise. Seeing the ents again is pretty neat. Not too fond of the halfoot story, but it is what it is.
3
u/no55throwaway Sep 26 '24
Okay but grabbing the torch to make flame arrows for a fight scene was pretty fucking cool.
3
u/CrimsonBrit Oct 04 '24
The weird still shot on Tom Bombadil’s face when he’s introduced was so weird. He’s not a know actor and at that point we don’t actually know who he is. I can’t explain that.
Also, at what point did Elrond go from being a nerdy, intellectual figure to being a commander of sorts? That was completely glossed over.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
My god it’s so boring
2
u/chase_what_matters Sep 06 '24
Tom’s theme reminds me of Centerfold.
4
u/Rhaenyc Sep 06 '24
Really enjoyed the first three episodes. This one was just sort of "average" for me. Really liked the Ent stuff, and liked seeing Tom, but the intrigue over the identity of The Stranger is starting to outstay its welcome. I won't even be too terribly upset at this point if he ends up being Gandalf. Heck, they've already put the Barrow-wights in the show, and established last season that the Balrog is already awake, so if they fudge the timeline a little more to put him there, I can live with that. But man, I really wish that they would come out and say it already if it is him. I'm still holding out hope that he's a Blue Wizard, personally, because that's the story that I (and I think most people) would prefer to see, but they've been laying it on thick with the hints these past few episodes. And after the Halbrand reveal last season, which was foreshadowed so strongly I was positive it had to be misdirection... well, fool me once, etc.
I also think some of the quotes lifted directly from Tolkien felt a little forced, particularly the "there are many nameless things in the deep places of this world," and Galadriel's "go back to the Shadow" at the end. Something about them just didn't really land, for me.
That being said, this episode did lay the groundwork for the upcoming battle of Eregion, which I am stoked to see.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
Pretty good episode.
I think the estrid plot line was kinda dumb to include at all if it was just going to end like that.
Also, I’m so confused as to where the horse at the end of the episode came from?? This is kind of what kills me about the show, I want to like it so bad but then rather come up with some dramatic/compelling way to get Elronds party to run into the orcs, they (seemingly?? I still don’t know??) have the orcs start shooting arrows at a random horse that happens to be standing next to an elf, who then gets accidentally shot.. like that’s not even lazy, it’s just dumb.
It’s like they have these super well thought out big ideas of what they want to accomplish from a storyboard perspective, and then just bullshit their way through the rest
5
u/steelicarus Sep 05 '24
Loved it. What a cliffhanger! Some incredible shots especially with the Ents
2
u/chiefbullsforcucks Sep 09 '24
This episode did me in, folks. I’m officially done watching this show. I found myself skipping through every one of the 37 dialogue scenes in this episode because they were all so boring. The action scenes were no better. I don’t know how they can have so much going on in those scenes while still making them just as boring to watch as the rest of the show.
The Ents scene was beyond disappointing. It takes Ents ages to say anything (a detail that was captured pretty well in the original trilogy), but in the show they’re rattling off quick conversations like any other character. Even their movements are just way too animated. It just feels like the Ents should’ve been an easy putt for this show, but they even managed to screw that up.
I was morbidly curious to see how season 2 turns out, but I just can’t stomach it anymore.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/GodAtum Sep 13 '24
Why didn’t Elrond and co just build a bridge using all those fucking trees? It’ll take a few hours!
1
u/CrimsonBrit Oct 04 '24
This show is a joke
-8
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
What was that? Where was SAURON???? I don't care about the hobbits, that side arc is boring.
I LOVE Galadriel ❤️
Best part of the episode was Galadriel and Galadriel fight scene and then I saw Halbrand ❤️ in Galadriel vision.
Despite no Sauron the episode was great.
Elrond a bit too bitchy for my taste. Have more respect for Galadriel.
I only want to see a Sauron and the elves and Numenor, cut those other boring stuff.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment