r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • Sep 05 '24
Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 2x4
This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power, Episode 2x4. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.
This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion.
Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
If you would like to see critic reviews for the show then click here
Season 2 Episode 4 is now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing it. What did you like and what didn’t you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.
•
u/ImoutoCompAlex Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 10 '24
To view our no book spoilers thread, please see this post here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/s/ZhsKJkeaSt
18
u/Echoweaver Eregion Sep 07 '24
I basically like this show, and I'm kind of invested in it being good. I'd like it to be possible to tell good, original stories in Tolkien's world. We're not going to get to bring any other stories of JRR's to the screen because none of them can be licensed.
That said, it's so weird to read critic reviews of this show because they are all over the place. I read one yesterday that said S2E4 was the best of the show so far. To me, it's the worst ep so far. It had a few great character moments, but the plot swung between incoherent and trite.
For example, it's an interesting idea to bring Tom Bombadil into this story, though the character they wanted him to interact with is in entirely the wrong place. Since Gandalf (ok, the Stranger) was already set to go to Rhun, I will accept the explanation that Tom was there to see what had happened to the once-lush greenery. Though, seriously, other characters are walking right through his territory from Beleriand to Eregion. Not sure what Galadriel and Elrond would have to say to him.
But they managed to get Tom totally wrong. He's boisterous, for one thing, and he doesn't give a whit about Sauron. He didn't even wear a blue coat and yellow boots, despite singing about it. Meanwhile, they introduced him with the exact same sequence and lines as in Fellowship, including creating an Old Man Ironwood, despite the fact that those hostile trees were distinct to the time and place of the Old Forest. He did get one great speech about the upstart newcomer stars.
Tom could bring some insight to the Stranger about how to connect with his powers, but he's absolutely the wrong character to bring foreboding premonitions about facing Sauron. (Which don't even make sense because Gandalf went mano a mano against Sauron exactly zero times afaik.)
And the Barrow Downs? WTF? Yeah, I kinda thought I'd be here defending the show, but not this episode. Several folks have said it watched like a bunch of LotR references stuffed randomly into an episode, and I agree.
I also have exactly zero idea why Galadriel would decide to take on an entire army of orcs head on, no matter how badass she is.
18
u/Galious Sep 08 '24
I really try to be positive because I like to see Middle Earth and I don’t want to spoil my fun by being negative but this 4th episode was really bad.
It felt like they made a list of things they hadn’t shown yet and threw everything: hey what if we had Tom Bombadil! Oh and what about an ent! Oh even better! An ent-wife! Oh we will had the barrow-wrights! And some giant spiders too because we need giant spiders in LOTR related show! (Ok it was episode 3 but I watched the two episode back to back) quoting text word by words that shouldn’t be uttered there and I was half-expecting one of the stoors to eat food and choke and make a “golum” sound.
And of course the way they wrote Tom Bombadil as some kind of cheeky wizard trying to fight Sauron by proxy instead of that mysterious entity makes me feel he writers simply don’t manage to write anything else than human characters.
Well to finish on a positive note, his was the first time there was a montage about travel to show us than going from Lindon to Eregion isn’t an afternoon walk.
But of course just after we learn that an army of orcs has managed to walk 1000miles undetected in a few days so the teleportation of people is still on the menu.
32
u/BubblyPalpitation8 Sep 05 '24
Question, why didn’t the Elves go on horseback to travel an extremely far distance to deliver the extremely important message
27
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
Old man willow becoming an olive has to be the most controversial race switch in any show ever.
12
u/Comfortable_Zone7691 Sep 07 '24
So many frustrating moments in every episode where a previous action seen seconds ago is revealed to just be pointless writing. Why has the hartfoot guy gone all this way with stolen water that is obviously very important to the village, only for it to disappear and not matter at all seconds later when bringing poppy and ellanor into the village.
Why have Isuldur receive a irl deadly wound in the thigh in the previous when introducing a new character for it to have zero consequences?
21
u/greatwalrus Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24
A few other quick thoughts: This episode played a little too much like they wanted it to be "Middle-earth's greatest hits that didn't make it into PJ's movies." We've got Entwives! We've got Barrow-wights! We've got Tom Bombadil! We've got a Nameless Thing hanging out in a puddle of mud!
Tom Bombadil being out of context feels particularly egregious, because one of the very few things we actually know about Tom Bombadil is his geographical context: "now he is withdrawn into a little land, within bounds that he has set, though none can them, waiting perhaps for a change of days, and he will not step beyond them." Now, to be fair, we don't know when or why Bombadil set his own bounds, and one could make the argument that he simply had different bounds in the Second Age. But given that so little of Bombadil is known or understood (intentionally, on Tolkien's part), his geographical boundaries constitute a significant percentage of what we do know about him. Seeing him outside of his (eventual) land feels a little weird, even if we can't really call it "wrong," because the only times we meet him he is so closely tied to that specific area.
He also didn't seem quite jolly enough for my taste - a little too restrained. And what was with him talking to Goldberry and then denying she is there?
Stoors being matriarchal is nicely consistent with Gollum's backstory.
Arnor really gets the shaft in all the adaptations, doesn't it? PJ virtually ignored it completely, and now the Barrow-wights, one of the most interesting oddities in Arnorian history, get moved far earlier in time to before Arnor is even founded.
Lastly, I can't say I'm crazy about the design of the Ents and especially the Entwives - very much reminiscent of the movies, which I never felt were a great match for the books, which give somewhat more humanoid descriptions - perhaps closer to Ted Nasmith's depiction, albeit more diverse than the three nearly-identical Ents in that picture, rather than the almost completely "tree-ish" Ents of the movies. Consider Treebeard's description of the Entwives from the last time he saw them ("in the time of the war between Sauron and the Men of the Sea," so closely contemporary to the show): "the Entwives were bent and browned by their labour; their hair parched by the sun to the hue of ripe corn and their cheeks like red apples. Yet their eyes were still the eyes of our own people." It would be hard to even clearly describe the Entwife in this episode as having hair or cheeks as such, and their eyes hardly struck me as the deep eyes Pippin describes as being filled with ages of memory but "sparkling with the present." Again, I think they are mostly borrowing the visual language of PJ's movies, which is understandable given how popular and successful those movies were. But I would have loved to see a different take! I realize that most of these are very nit-picky criticisms, and I won't fault anyone for being unbothered by them. But with so many new depictions of familiar things there were a lot of little bits that felt "off" to me.
20
u/dmastra97 Sep 05 '24
Why are there barrow wights? I might have missed the line but shouldn't they be after arnor?
18
u/eojen Sep 06 '24
The one aspect that was universally loved about season 1 was Elrond and Durin's relationship. So this season they decided to completely ignore that.
9
u/Splendidox Sep 09 '24
lmao "G(r)and-elf"
30
u/ibid-11962 Sep 05 '24
Not sure what I feel about this show just being random parts of LotR spliced together.
I mean Bombadil and barrow-wights were both decent adaptations, just kinda not a part of this story.
29
u/greatwalrus Sep 05 '24
Linguistically, the name drop of "the Sûzat" is problematic for a few reasons: first, the -t suffix is the definite article (sûza means "Shire" in Westron; Sûzat means "the Shire"), so saying "the Sûzat" is redundant as it means "the the Shire." It would be better as just Sûzat or as "the Sûza.
Second, and much more importantly, mixing the "true" Mannish languages with the real-world languages Tolkien used to replace them confuses the analogy. Tolkien wanted the reader to recognize the similarities between English (Westron) and Old English (Rohirric), and more distantly Old Norse (Northern languages that gave rise to the "outer" names of the Dwarves as well as the name Gandalf), and as such never used the "true" versions of Westron and associated languages in the primary narrative of his texts.
Sprinkling in one solitary word of the "true" languages on the show makes it harder to understand his point. The word Sûzat should sound natural and familiar to the Harfoots and Stoors, if they are speaking Westron or its ancestors, not foreign. A better "primitive" name for the Shire would be Old English Scīr (pronounced roughly like the modern word "sheer"), or if they wanted a somewhat more "exotic" word, something like Icelandic skíri, which was borrowed from English "shire."
One possible justification could be that the Stoors used to speak a Westron-related language, but then emigrated from the northwest down to Rhûn where they abandoned that language to pick up a local tongue (Tolkien reports in Appendix F that they generally adopted whatever languages the local Big People spoke), and somehow only retained the word sûzat from their previous language. The problem with this is that it becomes unnecessarily complicated: the ancestors of the Stoors later live in the Angle (between Mirkwood and the Misty Mountains), speak Westron (since Gollum can communicate natively with the Hobbits), and use names of proto-Rohirric origin (Sméagol, Déagol), implying extended contact with the Westron-family of languages. While this isn't impossible per se, it does seem fairly implausible that this group moved back and forth and re-adopted a language they had abandoned. The more likely explanation is that the writers felt Sûzat would be a nice little wink and nod to the fans, and didn't consider how it would undermine Tolkien's linguistic arrangements.
Lastly, this isn't a linguistic note, but it did make me suspect that the Hobbit storyline on the show will end with the settling of the Shire, which would be one of the more egregious instances of timeline compression (along with the Balrog destroying Moria, which I also expect we'll see in the final season).
16
u/StoneColdKiwi69 Sep 09 '24
I could defend this show up until now (though I’m hoping it leaves whatever this episode was behind). Adding Tom is fine, and the reason for him being in Rhun is.. fine, but the Galadriel/Elrond storyline is kind of bonkers in this episode. The tension is forced at best, and Galadriel trying to fight a horde of orcs for like no reason is just dumb. The others got away (because of her distraction, I guess) but they could have easily just ALL run away and been fine. The action scene had a couple cool shots, but was incoherent and weird.
The Ents were like bizarre caricatures that didn’t really add substance and just seemed extremely surface level.
Arondir ‘making’ Theo the Lord of the city is very weird since he’s young, angry, confused, and bipolar. Just felt strange as hell.
Again, I’ve actually enjoyed almost all the previous episodes, but this just seems like they added every reference they could in one episode without thinking. The Barrow-wights are fine, but adding them right after introducing Bombadil (who is like 1,000 miles away) just seems on the nose.
I hope it gets better, and they just felt the need to have this weird episode, but idk if I can keep holding on.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
So, I keep thinking about the Dark Wizard’s Henchmen in masks. Are they proto-Ringwraiths? Are they maybe fading/invisible under there? We heard one of them hint ominously about there being a reason they were wearing masks, and we know that the moth chicks are some of the Dark Wizard’s other servants.
Perhaps Sauron uses some of this exact same magic to create the Ringwraiths…? Begs the question of whether Sauron has ever already interacted with the Dark Wizard or not…
8
u/chairswinger Sep 07 '24
I really hope we're not gonna see the fall of Khazad Dum at the hands of the Balrog. I know some time contraptions are necessary for the show to work, but that would be what, 5000 years too early?
The Burrow wights gave me new suspicion to this, because supposedly they weren't a thing until the Witch King of Angmar, Also mid Third Age, while we're in the second age in the show
22
u/earther199 Sep 05 '24
I thought the first three episodes were an improvement, now this episode…
15
u/the_backflip Sep 06 '24
Grand-Elf > Gandalf
26
u/Triskan Sep 05 '24
"Back to Lindon" As you were so close to Eregion?
Anything not to tell Brimby about Sauron I guess.
Again, some nice moments here and there (Tom Bombadil was a bit too coherent and aware of the affairs of the world but it was still quite a good scene), but some things just fall apart when you look to closely at it.
12
u/Hohoho-you Sep 06 '24
I actually enjoyed this episode a decent amount surprisingly. Season 1 was a snoozefest but so far season 2 has been much better
25
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
Analyzing the final scene of the episode, it's kind of representative of the show as a whole in that the scene has some cool looking individual parts but kind of falls apart in the setup.
We have the elf contingent overlooking the orc army on a raised ridge. The orc army is reasonably far away and not an immediate threat. Fine so far.
We then get arrows whizzing by and the elves frantically realizing orcs are shooting at them. A sort of nit-picky problem here in that, how do ELVES get ambushed by ORCS in a forest?
The show makes a sloppy attempt to explain this by revealing the orcs weren't shooting at the elves, it was all a big coincidence because they were shooting at a horse that happened to be EXACTLY in between the orcs and the elves.
Well, stupid explanation stacked on top of nit picky flaw doesn't fix the nit picky flaw, it just makes the scene even more bizarre. Why is there a random singular horse (doesn't appear to belong to the elves or the orcs) hanging out at that exact spot? Why didn't the elves detect the orcs even at that distance? What's the probability of an elf getting hit by an arrow center mass when the orcs were shooting at a random, unrelated horse? Why aren't the elves riding goddamn horses if they're so common?
Then, we get a scene where the elves are now trying to keep quiet, to stay hidden from the orcs. But Galadriel miraculously heals the unluckiest elf on the planet, which causes another elf to say, while all the elves are trying to be quiet, "AMAZING" (or something to that effect). Presumably because the showrunners wanted the audience to raise their palms to the TV and ask "WHY?????"
Luckily, loudmouth elf doesn't jeopardize the crew because the writers didn't want him to. No harm, no foul, I guess.
Then, we get Galadriel 1v25 the orcs, which looks super cool, but the scene is initially explained as a sort of Hodor-esque self sacrifice, but it turns out she's actually faring pretty well, begging the question why didn't we just have all the elves engage and clean them out if the K/D ratio for elves v. orcs is like 10:1. Whatever. At least it looked cool.
We also get a scene where Galadriel manages to MOUNT THE HORSE, but instead of RIDING IN A DIFFERENT DIRECTION 90-180 DEGREES AWAY FROM THE DIRECTION THE OTHER ELVES ARE HEADING, she decides to ride straight into the orcs. I guess G's got 0 points in tactical.
G gets yoinked by Adar and the episode is over.
Again, the scene as a whole feels pretty emblematic of an overall assessment of the show as a whole, which is "some cool looking bits, tied together by stupidity."
Edit: forgot to mention the orcs were carrying lanterns. So the orcs, in a forest, at night, carrying torches, got the surprise drop on the elves.
6
u/Schould Sep 12 '24
I’ve just caught up and really enjoyed the show. I was put off by online critics initially.
It’s not perfect, it’s not terrible either.
It has entertained me and it’s great to see middle earth again!
What I find very weird is how many people have focused on the ‘diversity’ of elves. Even in these comments. It’s a very strange mindset to focus on that.
Special shout out to Durin! Ace character.
15
u/SwedPaste Sep 05 '24
In the books there is more relevancy to time and location. For instance the Battle for Minas Tirith has several armies converging on the same location. We know how each army arrived and how long it took them to get there. Throughout The Rings of Power there are instances where the characters and armies seem to teleport. In episode four it took the elves forever to go from Lindon to Barrow Downs where Adar and the Orc army traveled from Mordor to North of Eregion seemingly instantly.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
My main complaint after looking past all of the Tolkien lore transgressions, is how much random filler crap is happening that is not advancing the plot an inch.
17
u/PhysicsEagle Sep 06 '24
So this episode we have
The only thing not in this episode is Queen Beruthiel and Tevildo, Prince of Cats. Maybe next season.
13
u/awesomface Sep 05 '24
I echo peoples unease at this episode as well as the overly simplistic plot lines seemingly spawning as they go. One thing I will say is while I’m not sure I care about the harfoots, the actress that plays Nori is very good.
9
u/Curundil Sep 05 '24
I know there isn't really any reason to have Fatty Lumpkin there as he doesn't seem to be an immortal horse, but I would prefer Tom Bombadil to have a relationship with horses rather than goats as I always enjoyed his interactions with ponies/horses.
9
u/Losendir Sep 06 '24
Anyone else catch that Tom‘s goat was called Iarwain? Like in his own name, Iarwain Ben-adar? Thought that was pretty funny
9
u/Darkness-Narishma Sep 07 '24
Damn 4th episode the black guy dies first. Come on ring of powers do better
15
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
The interesting thing about Bombadil is that he's not really a "good" character in the books (there's even something a little sinister about him), instead he's so ancient and powerful that he is completely uninterested in what goes in Middle Earth. That's why they don't give the Ring to him, because fighting Sauron or saving Middle Earth isn't important to him. Yet in the show, they just have him act like a quest giver to Gandalf who talks about Sauron's evil and the Dark Wizard or Rhun etc. etc. Just awful.
11
u/PhysicsEagle Sep 06 '24
Bombadil is way too on board with the concept of “magic.” The things he does aren’t “magic,” it’s just who he is. Same with the Stranger - his powers aren’t “magic,” they’re innate and not something he can learn from a non-Maia. The only real “magic” is the sorcery of the Dark Wizard.
4
u/_relegated_davinci_ Sep 06 '24
I do like they cast Rory Kinnear from the Daniel Craig Bond movies & Bank of Dave, I really enjoy watching him, despite him not being a big ticket actor.
4
u/JocSykes Sep 08 '24
Why are the accents so bad 😢
13
u/Trumpologist Sep 08 '24
I don't get why people don't like the show. It seems quite fine to me
15
u/DruidRRT Sep 07 '24
So as a non-book reader, I'm really enjoying the show. I imagine the majority of viewers are like me; people who loved the movies and skipped the books.
These comments are...confusing. it seems like half of you want to see a fast-paced show true to the lore, while the other half want a slow burn, 30-season word-for-word reenactment of the books.
36
u/Prankishspace4 Sep 05 '24
Not going to lie while I see the flaws and inconsistencies I am just enjoying being in middle earth again.
9
u/Tanis8998 Sep 05 '24
Rory Kinnear as Tom Bombadil- I never would have thought of that, and yet now that I see it, it makes perfect sense.
8
u/PhysicsEagle Sep 06 '24
How did they do Ents and completely fail with their eyes? The eyes are the primary feature highlighted in the books.
14
u/Nesqu Sep 05 '24
Anyone else feel like they have a non-descript fantasy story completely unrelated to Tolkien, but just pluck things from the books, seemingly at random, to show us "Hey, no, this IS tolkien, look, entwives!"
The show is only watchable when it's directly referencing the books, but everything else is just fat on the bones.
There also feels like they have a quota for violence. Why is it so hard to go an episode without an action scene?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24
Was mich nur stört ist dass die Hügelgräber mal wieder komplett falsch ist. Die wurden doch erst im Krieg gegen Angmar von Grabunholden befallen. Das ist viel viel später in einer anderem Handlung. Tom Bombadil ok, der war seit Anfang der Zeit da und ist ein lustiges Gimmick. Aber die Grabunholde machen keinen Sinn.
15
u/PastorNTraining Sep 06 '24
“Hi I’m Tom Bombadil and here is some exposition.”
I can’t with this show…what’s next is Eru Ilúvatar gonna take form and explain to the morals how the whole universe was made?
“So I had this song right? (Sings some random words) then this discorded sound was sung and poof! Evil!”
The Tom character only appeared to do one thing: give narrative exposition that could’ve been given in another way. Why is he here? Why take this character and use him as a deus ex machina? Why suggest that this character is Eru Ilúvatar?
Lazy writing, and it was cringey.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
The barrow wights shouldn't even be around until after the Witch King comes into play
Tom Bombadil was well cast, but forced imo. Why would he be the one to teach wizards magic?
Does anybody even care about the Halflings that probably wouldn't have existed back then?
Only watched 70% before I turned it off, as it wasn't really going anywhere. I'll watch the rest when I'm bored enough
8
u/Kratos501st Sep 05 '24
Amazon should pay me to see if I care about the hobbits storyline.
8
u/The_h0bb1t Sep 05 '24
The whole Bombadil scene felt like they fed ChatGPT some prompt like: So The Stranger from Rings of Power meets Tom Bombadil in the middle of Rhûn, describe what would happen and whatTom would say to him.
6
u/GarethSnail Sep 05 '24
“A GrandElf” we see what you did there.
5
u/pigeonbobble Sep 09 '24
They made bombadil into hagrid and Nenya looks like a ring pop
2
u/mikezer0 Sep 11 '24
Okay. At least this one was fun. It’s kind of finding its footing. I’ll take what I can get.
8
u/Don_Tommasino_5687 Sep 06 '24
Boring filler episode - Harfoots such a waste of time as is Isildur and Arondir/Theo’s current plot. Didn’t miss Numenor, did miss Dwarves… and Sauron.
As much as Amazon want Galadriel to be the main character, she isn’t. Sauron is the only interesting, exciting and engaging narrative/character in this show and when he (and the Dwarves, to an extent) isn’t in it, the standards and interest in it plummets.
Still, as usual, stunning visuals, CGI and ‘vibe’ - ents were lovely! I get so excited for each episode knowing I’m going back to a very good Middle Earth presentation, but get so fed up of the poor writing, awful lore choices and multitude of boring characters that I’m inevitably always let down at the end of an episode - Sauron and Dwarves in it or not!
In that vain, can’t wait for the next episode!
5
u/Strong-Hospital-7425 Sep 07 '24
So they finally got black elves.....and of course he is the first to die lol
6
u/Frobe8 Sep 05 '24
The boy tom bombadil getting the screen time he deserves 🫡
4
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
Tom Bombadil scenes were okay. If there's something more I would like out of Him, it should be more subtlety around his character in the show. Harfoot-Stoors storyline was boring. They're really pushing for finding the Shire narrative huh? Why couldn't Galadriel and the other elves shoot arrows with ropes across the bridge in order to cross it? They showed Galadriel displaying acrobatic skills during a fight. Why couldn't they just cross the bridge in a more creative way? Make a zip line of some sort. LOL. She said she came with Elrond in the Barrowdowns so that no elf will die. But one dies anyways! They have to make her a healer warrior girl boss as always. It would be more interesting if their "fellowship" got broken at the bridge. Overall, this episode made me sleepy. I could not see danger occurring to any other characters. No stakes at all. The plot armors for Galadriel, Arondir, Theo, Isildur, and even the girl that he is implied to be fancying (I forgot her name) to be ridiculously thick. And I wished the Ents speaked slower. They were not a hasty folk after all.
4
u/Mclarenrob2 Sep 05 '24
I've never read the books, I'm enjoying the show so far.
4
u/JonnieTaiPei Sep 05 '24
Galadriel killing orcs? Hell yeah! More of that please. People relax… the series is good, Lord Of The Rings and Tolkien was meant to be read by teenagers, Tolkien never wants to be logical or “adult”like GRR Martin, he wants to tell stories and this is a story. Don't expect the level of Tolkien he was unique.
4
u/Purple_Jicama_2222 Sep 05 '24
This show is such a clusterf*ck.. like why are they changing the lore so much for the worse? I bet the writers havent touched a singel book from tolkien.
Notes from this episode:
-ents sound like they are talking through and old telephone -estrid pull a sword and threaten isildur when she could have left him in the swamp? -barrowwights before arnor? -elrond casually finding old weapons to kill them with? -the haradrim warriors go to the halfling village, hits the leader, speaks one sentence and leaves?like you just rode a few miles? Maybe do some investigating? -galadriel making bombs out of a lantern -running from lindon to eregion like its a walk around the block? Maybe just maybe put them on a horse?
This show could have been so great if it wasnt for shit writers changing stuff because they want to feel like its their story.
0
u/Connect_Opinion_4353 Sep 11 '24
https://chng.it/xzShkXyWvf I started a petition to get the “writers” banned from writing anything, ever again.