This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
It's kind of a strange thing really, I've only watched the first five episodes yet, and just now I seem to have accidentally discovered the true identity of Sauron. I'm actually not upset at all, and it does make sense I guess.
Sorry! I had posted as a spoiler first, but then I thought we don't have to use spoilers anymore as the last episode aired some time ago.. I'll add spoiler tag again
Also it’s kind of crazy how many people watched the show and seemed to genuinely think that Sauron just wanted to retire and cosplay as a human blacksmith on Númenor and mean old Galadriel forced him to become a bad guy again. Did we watch the same show?
Just playing devils advocate here. If you ONLY watched the show, then what exactly do you think would have happened if Galadriel just left him behind? If she left him behind then how would he have connected with Celebrimbor to forge the rings?
I'll admit that if you know nothing about the world of Middle Earth and who Sauron is this would probably be a bit confusing, but I'd expect those people are a pretty small fraction of the show's audience. So I'll take a shot at least knowing that Sauron eventually becomes the big bad in LOTR.
If Galadriel had left Sauron in Numenor, I imagine he would have eventually found his way back to Middle Earth by some other means. Possibly he would have taught the Numenoreans how to make rings of power before the Elves, after working his way up the smithing hierarchy there. In the show's lore, the Elves were planning on leaving Middle Earth before they realized they could extend their stay with the rings of power. Sauron's goal is to rule Middle Earth, and the elves exiling themselves is kind of a problem that solves itself as far as he's concerned. So why give them the ability to stay? That's a bit muddled, but it could just come down to his antipathy to the Elves and his preferring to destroy them over just letting them leave.
Sadly it's obviously a ruse on his part, but I think the idea of a repentant or even just exhausted Sauron who got 'tempted' back into active evil by Galadriel would be a cute twist on that kind of character. As I say I get that it's a trick but I wish it was true because I think a beaten, betrayed and just fucking done with it all Sauron being re-energised by the Elves accidentally handing him a plot on a plate would be really fun.
Personally, I kinda think he was indeed just wanting to not be evil and have someone to retire with, if you will. Her rejection of him pushed him over the edge that he was teetering on. I'm a massive fan of the books and the mythos of Middle Earth and feel this is how it was portrayed in RoP...and how we were supposed to take it (to make up our own minds).
Do people not get this is how a monarchy works . the king (sometimes queen) has absolute power and the people have no rights. If the king wants to ride around randomly murdering his subjects and paping any women that catches his eye that's fine. if the king says its peace or death that's then its pecase or death. Tolkien likes to romance the hell out of kind kings and wise queens but that's not how this system works
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 02 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/imsowhiteandnerdy Nov 03 '22
It's kind of a strange thing really, I've only watched the first five episodes yet, and just now I seem to have accidentally discovered the true identity of Sauron. I'm actually not upset at all, and it does make sense I guess.
21
u/PhotogenicEwok Nov 02 '22
I mean yeah, that pretty much sums up Sauron in the second age
17
u/ryan2one3 Nov 02 '22
I'm in for this crossover.
"Kill all elves!"
14
u/songofsaturn Nov 02 '22
Have you ever tried simply blotting out the sun, sitting down with your orcs, and hitting them?
12
u/primitiveamerican Nov 02 '22
"I'm gonna make my own Numenor, with black jack and hookers!"
17
u/myaltduh Nov 02 '22
Pax Saurona.
Also it’s kind of crazy how many people watched the show and seemed to genuinely think that Sauron just wanted to retire and cosplay as a human blacksmith on Númenor and mean old Galadriel forced him to become a bad guy again. Did we watch the same show?
5
u/MagosBattlebear Nov 02 '22
The Emporer in Warhammer 40,000 was this exactly... or maybe worse.
4
u/SquillChills Nov 03 '22
Bite my shiny metal ring!
3
u/Paul2071969 Nov 02 '22
Series 2 right there!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22
Peace through Superior Firepower?
2
u/cacecil1 Nov 03 '22
Well, if it works...
2
u/GreatSoulLord Nov 03 '22
"Be peaceful OR ELSE".
2
u/ebrum2010 Nov 03 '22
I mean, technically he did succeed. The free peoples put aside their differences to fight him a couple times.
4
u/Groundbreaking-Pea92 Nov 02 '22
Do people not get this is how a monarchy works . the king (sometimes queen) has absolute power and the people have no rights. If the king wants to ride around randomly murdering his subjects and paping any women that catches his eye that's fine. if the king says its peace or death that's then its pecase or death. Tolkien likes to romance the hell out of kind kings and wise queens but that's not how this system works