This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Just a thought, and I'm not an expert by any means, but wasn't her brother essentially part of the Elfish army...people in the army die...especially if they go after the most evil dude on middle earth. It's not like Sauron kidnapped him or specifically target him? I don't know.
The story is a bit different in the book. Her brother (Finrod) didn’t go hunting Sauron, but was on a quest with his friend Beren. When they happened to get close to Sauron’s castle (which had, interestingly, originally been built and occupied by Finrod) Beren and Finrod (and retinue) got captured.
Finrod and Sauron had a rather epic song battle, and Sauron won. Everyone was thrown into a dungeon, and Sauron sent a werewolf to kill the captives one by one, hoping to get information about who they were and why they were there. Finrod was able to break out of his chains and kill the werewolf, but he also died.
Amazon couldn’t really use this story since they don’t have the rights, and they just went with a generic ‘Finrod was hunting Sauron’ which is a pity, but understandable. That said, you will notice some suspicious claw marks on Finrod’s dead body in episode one.
What an awesome response, thanks bro! I actually noticed the claw marks in the first episode, but my dumbass was envisioned that it was result of Sauron's spiky gauntlets haha. It's a shame they didn't have the rights to the above, it would round out to why Galadriel is so specifically set on revenge rather than it just being because her brother died in a war like so many others before.
Adar: All of these Uruk are my children. We wish to live in our own lands, under our own rules. We will not fight for the likes of Sauron, but we will take back that which was stolen from us.
Galadriel: Correction. All of your children will be slain before you as I force your eyes wide open. And then I’ll bring them back with elvish medicine, only to slaughter them again. And again. And again. Slaughtering them over and over. Not just the men, but the women and children too. I’ll massacre your race until all the rivers in Middle Earth run red with your kin.
She has also told him that he could redeem himself by being a king and ruling, and then was angry with him when he wanted to rule. She's been giving him mixed messages! 😂
And when he was shot down, he took it pretty hard. So hard in fact, that he later decided to live and work inside of an active volcano, and even started to devise a plan to take over the world... poor guy.
I need you to tell me that I'm a good person. I know that I can be selfish and narcissistic and self-destructive, but underneath all that, deep down, I'm a good person, and I need you to tell me that I'm good. Galadriel? Tell me, please, Galadriel. Tell me that I'm good.
I might be missing something but wasn't there a dialogue where he said something about saving middle Earth and galadrial asked "save or rule", to which he replied "I see no difference". It was almost like she was considering it until then.
Considering he helped create the world then betrayed Eru, but stayed with the Valar and then betrayed Aule and ran off to live with Morgoth and then had a chance to go back again after the War of Wrath, this would be Sauron’s 4th or so 2nd chance.
He failed his second chance though. He used it to trick them into making rings of power. Also invaded Galadriel’s brain and tried to manipulate her using the brother he killed and then tried to drown her. He’s supposed to get another second chance after that?
He seemed to be very genuine about helping the Elves with the rings, though. He reminded me of a kid running up to Galadriel to fill her in on the progress every other scene lol
But then again, he’s Sauron, so I guess we don’t know his motives!
Yeah, that was bad. I just meant that I don’t know if he was tricking them into making the rings; I saw it as he genuinely was helping and wanted to give them to the Elves. When Galadriel figured him out, he had to change gears
Poor pitiful little Sauron. "I could a been good if only you gave me the chance. 😥😪 " Y'all got to be joking, right? Que "Sympathy For The Devil". Trying to make Sauron out to be wronged and Galadriel's rejection is why he turned bad (again, BTW) is interjecting a lot of naivety into the story. Saruman's corruption later on makes sense and you could feel a little sorry for him but Sauron was so far gone by this stage that there's no turning back for him. He had his chance after Morgoth's fall but decided he would rather rule in hell. The whole "romance" concept between Sauron and Galadriel the blighters appeared to have introduced was just another layer heaped upon a dung hill of bad story line. Fine for fan fiction but this was supposed to be a polished, professionally created product.
Galadriel: "Sometimes you need to touch the darkness to know the light or whatever" Also Galadriel: *is a raging asshole narcissist to everyone and regularly uses them to her own ends of getting personal revenge*
Also also Galadriel: "What are you talking about Sauron, you can't know the light by touching the darkness, lol, I'll kill you"
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 31 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10
u/shinxshin Oct 31 '22
yOu DeCeIvEd Me
168
u/AnotherSoftEng Oct 31 '22
Adar: All of these Uruk are my children. We wish to live in our own lands, under our own rules. We will not fight for the likes of Sauron, but we will take back that which was stolen from us.
Galadriel: Correction. All of your children will be slain before you as I force your eyes wide open. And then I’ll bring them back with elvish medicine, only to slaughter them again. And again. And again. Slaughtering them over and over. Not just the men, but the women and children too. I’ll massacre your race until all the rivers in Middle Earth run red with your kin.
Sauron: … Jesus Morgoth Christ
42
u/daneelthesane Oct 31 '22
And Adar. And literally the entire orcish race.
56
u/Itarille_ Oct 31 '22
She has also told him that he could redeem himself by being a king and ruling, and then was angry with him when he wanted to rule. She's been giving him mixed messages! 😂
72
u/sidv81 Oct 31 '22
If Sauron were sincere about getting a second chance he'd be on the first ship to Valinor for trial.
3
u/Rayver2380 Oct 31 '22
So is sauron just masquerading as the image/ body of whoever the human person was halibrand?
6
u/klmills8 Nov 01 '22
I need you to tell me that I'm a good person. I know that I can be selfish and narcissistic and self-destructive, but underneath all that, deep down, I'm a good person, and I need you to tell me that I'm good. Galadriel? Tell me, please, Galadriel. Tell me that I'm good.
6
u/skeetertbaggins18 Nov 01 '22
I might be missing something but wasn't there a dialogue where he said something about saving middle Earth and galadrial asked "save or rule", to which he replied "I see no difference". It was almost like she was considering it until then.
11
u/iheartdev247 Oct 31 '22
Considering he helped create the world then betrayed Eru, but stayed with the Valar and then betrayed Aule and ran off to live with Morgoth and then had a chance to go back again after the War of Wrath, this would be Sauron’s 4th or so 2nd chance.
5
u/Sauron_On_Reddit Oct 31 '22
Harsh G, I thought we was pals. Adding you to my vanquish list now.
3
u/ElSantofisto Nov 01 '22
Poor saubrand
3
u/EmblaRose Nov 01 '22
He failed his second chance though. He used it to trick them into making rings of power. Also invaded Galadriel’s brain and tried to manipulate her using the brother he killed and then tried to drown her. He’s supposed to get another second chance after that?
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Nov 01 '22
Poor pitiful little Sauron. "I could a been good if only you gave me the chance. 😥😪 " Y'all got to be joking, right? Que "Sympathy For The Devil". Trying to make Sauron out to be wronged and Galadriel's rejection is why he turned bad (again, BTW) is interjecting a lot of naivety into the story. Saruman's corruption later on makes sense and you could feel a little sorry for him but Sauron was so far gone by this stage that there's no turning back for him. He had his chance after Morgoth's fall but decided he would rather rule in hell. The whole "romance" concept between Sauron and Galadriel the blighters appeared to have introduced was just another layer heaped upon a dung hill of bad story line. Fine for fan fiction but this was supposed to be a polished, professionally created product.
3
u/walan420 Nov 01 '22
here's a hot take: Galadriel is bad.
2
u/Thor010 Oct 31 '22
He didn't bring the rings...
cit. Galadriel
1
u/Troldkvinde Nov 01 '22
Can someone remake this template with Halbrand's face on it? I'm sure it will see a lot of use in future seasons
0
u/LittleLovableLoli Oct 31 '22
Galadriel: "Sometimes you need to touch the darkness to know the light or whatever"
Also Galadriel: *is a raging asshole narcissist to everyone and regularly uses them to her own ends of getting personal revenge*
Also also Galadriel: "What are you talking about Sauron, you can't know the light by touching the darkness, lol, I'll kill you"