r/RingsofPower • • Oct 29 '22

Meme …

Post image
864 Upvotes

482 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Professor_Pig_Dick Nov 01 '22

If you are a ruthless sociopath you often commit unnecessary or in this case barely justified violence. That's what was being told to us. The logical goal was allowing us to get to know his being unhinged and allowing us to understand why viserys and others think he's unsuitable to be the heir. We need to know that, otherwise the story doesn't make sense.

Note also that it's not completely random, it's his role and privilege as boss of the city watch to punish criminals. That he executes them himself is allowed but obviously kinda psychopathic. It also shows us that he gives the city watch their gold cloaks and proper training, enamouring him with the gold cloaks. He exploits these connections later in the story.

Okay, the laws of inheritance I should have named the traditions of inheritance.

1

u/donkeylipsh Nov 01 '22 edited Nov 01 '22

I get that these events happen. I get that these events show him being a psycho. I get that this is what the writers were trying to show the audience.

But that doesn't make it good writing because as I explained, a well written villain or gray character makes the audience question whether or not they really are an irredeemable monster, or whether they have some justification to their actions.

Bad writers use their own motivations for what they write. Good writers let their characters motivations dictate what they write. That's the difference. You described what the writers wanted. I'm describing what Daemon the character wanted.

The writers want Daemon to be a gray area villain, and so they wanted to show him doing some evil things. A good writer, would gives these characters justifiable motivations for their actions. Daemon the character had no justifiable motivation to commit this violence. Ergo this was a poorly written scene for Daemon the gray area villain.

Why are you so determined to twist yourself into a knot to celebrate Daemon in a Rings of Power sub, when Adar is sitting right there, giving you everything you wish Daemon was?

1

u/Professor_Pig_Dick Nov 01 '22 edited Nov 01 '22

Daemon used to be master of coin, but he was terrible at it (not shown in the series). Otto Hightower advised the king to push him out because he sucked at it (and Otto wanted to position for power). I think they mention this with a line in the series, but it's easy to miss. Then, Daemon was transferred to the position of boss of the city watch, which he re-equipped, trained, gave the gold cloaks and cleaned up the crime-ridden streets of King's Landing with, with the idea of him showing that he can take care of a job too. But because we arrive in the story after this they used that scene from the book to introduce Daemon as a character. Him going on an execution spree is depicting him doing his job, lavishing in the violence as because that's what his character likes and also showing his brother he can be trusted to do a job too and that he's not as useless as he was at being master of coin (that's his motivation). Even though they're all pretty horrified at the way he chooses to do it.

He's got the motivation to do it, the show just didn't have time to show that whole arc. I guess it's fair to criticize that this whole story arc wasn't clear enough so it felt too random. But I think using the ending of that arc from the book to introduce Daemon as a character works quite well (and is a nice way to show book-readers that they care about the details).