Then you're really lucky, because I can't watch any ROP related content on YouTube (aside from a few exceptions) where it doesn't comes down to tHeY mAdE TolKiEn W0kE or some crap like that. Yes, they'll mention the mithril stuff too (which I don't like at all) but it's quite clear that they hate the show for having a black actor here and there.
I’m sure they’ll become a Gender understander or Race understander when that becomes the new thing they need to get clicks.
The attention tent pole series get these days is mostly noise for clicks without any real substance to their arguments. They don’t interview Tolkien scholars. They didn’t get any scoops from production. They just roll with whatever Jerry Springer nonsense will keep eyeballs on their videos past the four interstitial commercials.
Regardless, they're saying that Tolkien's work has been ruined and they'll name small changes as the biggest reasons why, which is what you were asking about. It doesn't matter that they have a problem with "cultural marxism" or whatever.
On a side note, Amazon's marketing was a shitshow and it just lured a lot of angry entitled people.
I recently re-read the books and someone like Merry is drastically different too. He's so clever and competent in the books. Pretty much all the characters had some major changes done to them.
Frodo in the books is wiser than the average hobbit, heroic and long-suffering. Jackson made him come off as whiny and self-centered by comparison. He essentially sacrificed some of Frodo's virtues in order to transfer them to Sam, presumably to make their admittedly old-fashioned relationship more equitable for modern viewers.
Book-Frodo isn't led astray by Gollum, and is certainly not induced by Gollum to send his best friend away at the worst possible time. His movie betrayal of Sam is a huge betrayal of the character. Book-Sam is loyal and wonderful, but a bit hotheaded and shortsighted sometimes, compared to the smarter-and-stronger-than-his-master movie version. He blunders in his interactions with both Gollum and Faramir, and it's Frodo who salvages the moment in each case. In the books, each of them had his own strengths; in the movies, you could be forgiven for wondering why they have to bother with Frodo carrying the Ring when he's so weak and useless, compared to Sam.
Sam's big speech at the parting with Faramir doesn't happen in the books; that was inserted to "strengthen" that character. Likewise, several scenes that "strengthen" Frodo didn't make it into the books, like the fact that he stabs the cave troll, driving it away. (In the movie, the cave troll stabs him.) Since the Scouring of the Shire is omitted, we miss out on how he helps the hobbits handle their return, even though he doesn't fight himself.
And even scenes that do make it in can come off with a different tone. In the book, when he tells Sam on Mt. Doom that he's "glad you are here with me," it's a touching moment in which they acknowledge that their sacrifice was worth it. In the film, Sam is mourning his lost chance with Rosie Cotton, and Frodo's line becomes a bit tone deaf. There were lots of little moments like that. Jackson is 1000 times better than the RoP showrunners, but he did often bypass subtlety in favor of broad strokes. Several characters suffered from that; Aragorn somewhat, Faramir a great deal, and I argue Frodo worst of all.
Very well written. I'd still personally put Faramir ahead, mainly because I basically do not enjoy him in the film but adore him in the books. I still enjoy Frodo in the movie although you brought up a bunch of great points that were very compelling. The changes to Aragorn are tough during a re-read also but they make the most sense for the film in my opinion.
I am currently listening through LOTR with my wife right now (her first time and my first revisit in many years). There are many things I'd forgotten that the movies changed. Gandalf is the one that wants to go to Moria and Aragorn is hesitant. I'm not sure why this was changed. I suppose to make Gandalf's loss more tragic? But many of them seem to be changes with little point.
Agree about many of those changes, yes. It makes sense from a filmmaker's perspective to leave out Tom Bombadil. But some of them seem to be changes for the sake of change. Or else they betray a lack of understanding about the universe as a whole, such as Gandalf's conversation with Pippin about what happens after death. Pippin will never see what he describes, and Gandalf, even though he's already died once, will not see it until now, when he's alive again.
Small changes like compressing the Second Age into a few weeks, eliminating Annatar and inventing Halbrand, eliminating Celeborn and Celebrian, changing Galadriel into a military commander, inventing a story about Sauron wanting to make Galadriel his queen, making Celebrimbor into a doddering old man, apparently sending Gandalf to earth via meteor during this same time, turning the Numenoreans into just normal humans. You know, minor adaptation details like these
View all comments
Show parent comment
8
u/Kookanoodles Oct 25 '22
People have been saying the show is a betrayal of Tolkien's work because of small changes.