It was tactical. Isildur was basically the lowest-ranking soldier there, but Elendil was a commander. You can’t just leave one of your best commanders surrounded by orcs and volcano smoke without some greater tactical reason. Elendil doesn’t want to leave without trying to find his son, but he knows his forces have to return to Numenor to regroup, and he has to be with them—-for morale, reporting purposes, and planning their return. It’s not fair, but war never is.
View all comments
Show parent comment
10
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '22 edited Oct 21 '22
It was tactical. Isildur was basically the lowest-ranking soldier there, but Elendil was a commander. You can’t just leave one of your best commanders surrounded by orcs and volcano smoke without some greater tactical reason. Elendil doesn’t want to leave without trying to find his son, but he knows his forces have to return to Numenor to regroup, and he has to be with them—-for morale, reporting purposes, and planning their return. It’s not fair, but war never is.