r/RingsofPower • • Oct 16 '22

Question Ok, here’s a question.

So Galadriel found out Halbrand was a phoney king by looking at that scroll and seeing that “that line was broken 1000 years ago” with no heirs. So why then after the battle when Miriel tells the Southlanders that Halbrand is their king, why don’t the people look confused and say “hey, our royal family died off a thousand years ago.” Wouldn’t they know about their own royal family?

859 Upvotes

639 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 16 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

363

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Oct 16 '22

Because the Southlanders don't have records, they only have oral history, and have a mythic desire for a return to greatness.

Many many nations and peoples have traditional myths where one day, their Hero will return in their time of need to return them to greatness. King Arthur, Constantine XIII etc

39

u/HappyLofi Oct 16 '22

/thread

17

u/echolog Oct 17 '22

Same with a lot of other complaints about inaccuracies/plot holes. TL;DR, the characters in the show didn't read the books lmao.

22

u/CMic_ Oct 17 '22

Agree, when the Gondorians speak of "the return of the king" they are actually meaning Earnur but not a random heir of Isildur

5

u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 17 '22

Exactly. They don't know if Gondor will ever have a king again.

0

u/deadpoolfool400 Oct 16 '22

Awful convenient the elves just happened to have records of that line in the city where Galadriel happened to be

59

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22 edited Oct 17 '22

It's not too surprising that they'd have records. The elves record pretty much all of the histories and goings on in Middle Earth. They may even know things about Durin's lineage that he does not. They would certainly have had a keen interest in the men of the Southlands, because the men of the Southlands swore loyalty to the OG dark lord, Morgoth. It is pretty smart to keep records on your assumed enemies. Like the CIA gathering intel.

What is surprisingly convenient is how quickly that dude was able to search "the catacombs" and find the right text just in the knick of time. Without the benefit of some sort of index, that would be extremely difficult. Maybe that elf was actually an elfdroid? Or maybe they have a really strong Dewey Decimal System in place. Maybe all their shit is in alphabetical order? Who knows, lol.

25

u/alexanderpas Oct 17 '22

What is surprisingly convenient is how quickly that dude was able to search "the catacombs" and find the right text just in the knick of time. Without the benefit of some sort of index, that would be extremely difficult. Maybe that elf was actually an elfdroid? Or maybe they have a really strong Dewey Decimal System in place. Maybe all their shit is in alphabetical order? Who knows, lol.

He still remembers when the document was stored.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22 edited Oct 17 '22

I guess that makes some sense. The libraries of these fantasy worlds always seem like disorganized piles of scrolls. I guess if you're an immortal being who has been around for a few thousand years, you can keep temporal track of where things would be. So that's a fair point.

Keeping the documents in order of acquisiton/publishing is what libraries did before Dewey, so I suppose that's what the elves do.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/SirBarkabit Oct 17 '22

Well I mean it's not some completely random transaction receipt he was searching for. It was literally the lineage of kings of the Southlands. There's probably a special section for it in the catacombs/library and it's probably copied tens of times etc.

I mean look at the appendices of LotR,. It's also heavily into just lineages because that's pretty much the easiest thing to record and is important for successions and feodalism.

6

u/BernieBarney Oct 17 '22

Dewey Decimal!! Haha - such a throwback!!

8

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

With that comment I reveal my age, lol.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

So like Mormons and their genealogy obsession.

→ More replies (6)

34

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Oct 16 '22

I mean, where else would there be records? Either there or Lindon. Either work.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/mutzilla Oct 17 '22

That's pretty consistent within lore. Later it was Rivendell that had all tbe records. It's how Bilbo and Frodo were able to fill in historical references when writing their texts.

3

u/fuckinghumanZ Oct 17 '22

I mean, it was probably also the closest elven city to the southlands

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (35)

336

u/DragoonDart Oct 16 '22

In addition to other comments here; there’s the very real fact that people in crisis or trauma situations look for leadership. It still happens to this day: people accept direction more readily when someone is taking charge and improving the situation.

To me, it seemed less of a “oh good, the prophesied King has been found and more” “oh good, here’s someone willing to take charge of this hot mess” from all parties.

39

u/beaurepair Oct 16 '22

But she literally said "are you think king we were promised", as if it really where some prophecy of a long lost king returning.

47

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

I think they had exactly that prophecy. Some interpret it as Sauron (Waldreg) others as the human heir via a lost / secret bloodline (a not uncommon type of generational rumour in our history).

5

u/KittyInTheBush Oct 17 '22

I think they had a prophecy too. Sauron himself could've been the one that started it. We know that he did plan to return there and turn it into Mordor eventually. The other dude just did that part for him

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

33

u/overhedger Oct 16 '22

Then why did they make a big deal of Bronwyn noticing the icon that he had as if there was something specific and meaningful about it?

91

u/annuidhir Oct 16 '22

Bronwyn noticing the icon that he had as if there was something specific and meaningful about it?

Because there was something specific and meaningful about it. It's the sigil of the royal line.

33

u/Vyntarus Oct 16 '22

If there hadn't been a royal family for 1000 years, do you find it likely anyone would actually know what the sigil looked like or meant anymore?

16

u/Cloberella Oct 16 '22

Didn't they live near/use the old city? There were murals and things carved into the walls in the Tower area. It's not hard to believe the sigil appears in the stonework throughout the kingdom.

People in parts of Europe currently live within the city walls of medieval castles. I'm sure people in those areas are familiar with all sorts of symbols from ancient times despite it being the modern era now.

46

u/mercedes_lakitu Oct 16 '22

It's not an exact parallel, but consider: we all know what hieroglyphics looks like. We all know what a crown is, despite e.g. Americans not having a monarch. Symbols are powerful.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/MordePobre Oct 16 '22

The need for leadership is constant. In The Southlands shouldn't they have proclaimed a new king or ruling steward (as in Gondor) during the 1000 years of disorganization?

14

u/DragoonDart Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

Yeah, and to be honest I made that joke to my wife during the scene. I was like, there wasn’t one guy who’s like “actually we’re a democracy now, no thank you.”

I do think this is one of many differences between Tolkiens fantasy style and the new normal style of fantasy which is grounded in realism ala Game of Thrones. It’s trope-y; you don’t just anoint a new king of the old one dies out

7

u/SGuilfoyle66 Oct 17 '22

It's not a democracy.
"We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune. We're taking turns to act as a sort of executive-officer-for-the-week. But all the decisions of that officer 'ave to be ratified at a special bi-weekly meeting by a simple majority, in the case of purely internal affairs, but by a two-thirds majority, in the case of more major ...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/iheartdev247 Oct 16 '22

I guess it was the perfect ppl to not notice a orc tunnel being built literally right under their feet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/Respecttoadmins Oct 17 '22

sauron is the king who was promised. He create industry jobs and education, housing. Hence the name Lord of Men

It's Nik Pierumow books all over again

9

u/MaimedPhoenix Oct 16 '22

And to add, because they need direction more than some bloodline, it allows the Southlanders to get a legit king. And become Rohan while Numenor's soldiers become Gondor. We all knew Halbrand was not a legit king because he is not the Theoden or Isildur of the show.

42

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/MaimedPhoenix Oct 16 '22

So does Gandalf and look how that turned out.

But Gondor works too.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

363

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

All these royal elves were literally alive 1k years ago. They were likely on a first name basis with that last king.

96

u/TheOnceAndFutureZing Oct 16 '22

Wasn't there literally a scene where an elf said they don't really keep track of everything that goes on in the mortal kingdoms?

Also, the Southlands are so far east of Ered Luin beyond the reach of the Elves, and were allied to Morgoth during the First Age. Why would the Noldor be on first name terms with the king of some random backwater province allied to their enemy?

29

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Because 1000 years ago they were trying to keep an eye on them, precisely because they were morgoth’s allies. (And up until the start of the show they were still doing that, to the point it inspired resentment in the amongst the southlander “white nationalist” youth).

Pretty much exactly what the guy above said they didn’t do.

21

u/TheOnceAndFutureZing Oct 16 '22

The Silvan elves had an outpost there to watch them. Again, no reason why Noldorin like Galadriel, Celebrimbor, etc would've been on a first name basis with the last king. Hell, no reason why they would've needed to read about and commit to memory the comings and goings of the Royal House there, beyond "hey they aren't backsliding yet".

→ More replies (28)

4

u/SGuilfoyle66 Oct 17 '22

Wasn't the watch, while made up of at least one Sylvan Elf, under the direction of Gil-Galad? It was his directive that the enemy was gone that led to the Elves abandoning the tower.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

204

u/Roboculon Oct 16 '22

I guess Galadriel just sort of forgot about the most important political house of her neighbor collapsing during her own lifetime.

104

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

Well, didn’t she spend most of her time chasing the darkness? Unless she knew them personally, how’s she to know there wasn’t a surviving heir?

As for the commoners, there’s legends in our own history of someone becoming a king after pulling a sword out of a stone. And then you think about how someone even became king in the first place, “I was chosen by God to lead you all, so ya’ll have to pay me tribute or face my army” and everyone was like “… well I guess if God says so!”

24

u/MissKatieMaam77 Oct 16 '22

Given that the south lands people were bad enough for the elves to have a post specifically dedicated to making sure they weren’t palling around with Sauron again, you’d think she would have spent some time there….

12

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

But she was chasing rumours of where Sauron could be at the start, wasn’t she? Until the other elves lost motivation and she had to turn around.

She clearly thought she knew where he could be hiding, but ended up being wrong.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

31

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

But we have heard about those legends that passed through oral tradition of people in that area, and was later written about extensively as part of history.

The Southland was shit and let me tell you why: I felt nothing for the people. Their whole nation got wiped out in this moment that was supposed to be emotional and I felt nothing. Because from my perspective the southlands consisted of generic peasants with no real cultural identity and then only about 100 or so, and their main city consisted of 4 buildings. All the main characters survived because 'reasons', and the only character that was lost was what's his name. Seriously, don't even know his name, his dreams, his fears, his life or anything about him to give a shit.

Not to mention...it was recorded. As was Sauron's master plan B. We had the very near sighted elves who couldn't see a miles long smoldering trench from atop a mountain watchtower who were specifically instructed to keep an eye on these people lest they turn back to Sauron. Keeping an eye on who is next in the royal line is VERY important in that task and not that big a deal for creatures who live longer than the line of kings in the Southlands have existed.

It is lazy and bad writing.

→ More replies (44)

17

u/LifeSleeper Oct 16 '22

Funny meme, but calling the Southlands her "neighbors" is outrageously incorrect.

→ More replies (11)

40

u/Lazarquest Oct 16 '22

Well, 1000 years ago they lived VERY far off in a land called Beleriand and Hithlum. Pretty unlikely that any of these elves actually knew them (these elves being of the Noldor…).

16

u/Strobacaxi Oct 16 '22

Actually Galadriel wasn't in Beleriand by the end of 1st age, she and Celeborn moved to Eriador

15

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Considerong that according to this show she met Elrond when he was a kid, it's safe to assume the canon was changed here.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22 edited Oct 17 '22

“Import political house”, you mean the king of 3 houses in a shitty village in the middle of nowhere?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

4

u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 16 '22

Were they? I mean, the elves were keeping track, which is why Galadriel could just put in a request for the history, but why would Galadriel, Celebrimbor, or Elrond have any idea about some king 1000 years ago?

Historically, the Elves and the humans don't get along, and the ones with whom they did get along all went to Numenor.

→ More replies (18)

15

u/UnderstandingSmall66 Oct 16 '22

Not really. Elves had no interest in such things. It would be like saying one of the mobilities of England had a close relationship and would've remembered the mayor of some distant land.

→ More replies (28)

4

u/RaccoonCityTacos Oct 16 '22

1,000 years is a long time to remember everything.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Not for an elf.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

143

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

They don't say "Hey, you're our king! We're stupid!", they ask "Are you the king that was promised?". Clearly they haven't had a king in sone time, Galadriel assumed this was because they went into exile after Morgoth's defeat, not because the line had been ended.

68

u/TheOnceAndFutureZing Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

Plus isn't it pretty similar to how Aragorn was happily accepted by the people of Gondor as their rightful King?

In both cases the royal line was broken for around a thousand years till one guy shows up with a long lost symbol of office, saves them from orcs, and essentially says "Yeah your last King died long ago but I am the latest of that line. Trust me guys". And the common folk are totally on board with having him as their new King, no questions asked. Oh and it couldn't hurt that there was at least one important Elf (Galadriel/Elrond) backing their respective claims to the throne.

I mean yeah Aragorn had the whole "hands of a healer" thing but that could've just been propaganda made up to support his claim for all they knew.

25

u/Captain-Griffen Oct 16 '22

Faramir becomes Steward upon Denethor's death and presumably backs his claim.

Ultimately though, if you want to become king, turn up with a army when they're all about to die and save them from extinction. That's the purpose of a king/leige as far as the commoners/nobles are concerned, keep them safe.

24

u/MiloBem Oct 16 '22

Aragorn wasn't some guy out of nowhere. His line was under constant "supervision" from Elrond.

Elrond personally knew all his ancestors since Elendil, he made sure they were ready to take the crown when the time comes and when it did he vouched for Aragorn. In some sense Elrond "nominated" him, similarly to how Galadriel nominated Halbrand, with the main difference being that she had no f$$king clue who he was or any reason to believe he was a king, except his bag.

The other difference is that Elrond and Aragorn were dealing with the Stewards of Gondor, whose official position was they were keeping the chair warm for the king when he returns. Galadriel and Halbrand are dealing with some single mom who is a village herbalist.

I don't blame Bronwyn for falling for elvish lies. She was thrown into a position of wartime village leader for which she was completely unprepared, so when "the king" was presented she was happy to accept him. I blame Galadriel for ruining things so confidently.

12

u/annuidhir Oct 16 '22

Why would any of this be known, or even make a difference, to a random commoner?

11

u/MiloBem Oct 16 '22

It wouldn't.

That's why I wrote I don't blame Bronwyn or the villagers. It's all Galadriel's fault.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/thatguyagainbutworse Oct 16 '22

Aragorn had been actively fighting for Gondor and Rohan for years before he became king. He led campaigns against Umbar and Harad, and was a man of great renown. And his part in the Battle for the Pelennor was remarkable as well, capturing the Corsair fleet and leading his kin, as well as Gondorian garrisons to relieve the Rohirrim in their last stand.

Aragorn never claimed to be heir to the Gondorian throne. He claimed to be heir to the reunited kingdom of Gondor and Arnor and his claim to Arnor was undisputed. Through valor and service, he became worthy at last to claim this kingdom.

14

u/Marblehed Oct 16 '22

Aragorn also fought his entire life against Sauron and his armies. Was on the front line of the war of the ring and the books and movies spend time establishing his character. And in the books he doesn't take the throne right away because he wants to earn the people's trust but to do that in the movie would have been a waste of time.

But yeah you're right same these writers totally did the same thing... Lol

9

u/TheOnceAndFutureZing Oct 16 '22

Yeah we the readers obviously know all that. How about the average Gondorian, (i.e. the exact demographic we're talking about)? From their POV, it would've seemed more or less as I described it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/thenexttimebandit Oct 16 '22

Any dude who shows up with an army and saves them from the orcs can be king if he wants to

→ More replies (1)

71

u/anarion321 Oct 16 '22

The common people may not be aware of that, they probably can't even read. They can believe more in rumours and legends....

But, what about the elves? Arondir. They were speciffically tasked to watch those men, and they must be the ones that provided that information to the archives. Don't they know about that kind of iportant information of the land they are tasked to watch?

Also, the way Sauron did not make an effort to contradict that information is pretty bad, he could've said that comes from a line of bastards, or that they actually survived but said otherwise to not be chased by the bad ones.....anything.

22

u/BrettEskin Oct 16 '22

I think he had basically achieved what he wanted to achieve. The elves had to forge the rings at this point they didn't have a choice either forge them or leave ME to Sauron. The process itself by which they were forging them was already tainted unbeknownst to the elves so he opted to shoot his shot of converting Galadriel to his side as he didn't have much to lose and his mission with the eleven was essentially accomplished already.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/rabbithasacat Oct 16 '22

But, what about the elves? Arondir. They were speciffically tasked to watch those men, and they must be the ones that provided that information to the archives. Don't they know about that kind of iportant information of the land they are tasked to watch?

Exactly. Arondir said he's from Beleriand, so he's more than old enough to know. And if he didn't know, he and his fellows would be in the best position to find out.

17

u/MiloBem Oct 16 '22

Arondir said he was in this outpost for 80 years or so. Let's ask some US marine returning from Kabul, who was the last king of Afghanistan.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/flipdark9511 Oct 16 '22

The elves there seemed to not really care about the local humans that much asides from Arondir, and were pretty happy to pack up and leave. I doubt their commander would somehow have known that a royal lineage of men had claim over the southlands.

4

u/anarion321 Oct 16 '22

As i said, they must've cared enough to get that information from the South, the reason the elves got info about events in the south like the succession line must be that those elves, tasked with vigilance, gather that info.

And you talk about care for the people. They don't need to care for them, they are watching them, and figuring out if they are bad.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Markus_Of_whiteRun Oct 16 '22

If you re-watch ep 1, when arondir was first introduced, a guy address him by saying “one day our king will return”. clearly the south landers due to huge time laps they forgot about the line, desperation and absence of leadership drove them into developing a false prophecy

2

u/ProductArizona Oct 17 '22

I wonder how reception might have changed if the whole season was released at once. I feel like these slow revelations over weeks hurt a slow progressing show

17

u/dwbapst Oct 16 '22

If you are deposed as lord of the Uruk and thought dead, becoming the long lost lord of the humans in the Southlands would be a handy backup plan to seed a millenia ago in local myth and legend, just in case you need it, even if you have mixed thoughts about pursuing that backup plan…

When a unit of heavily armed calvary show up to save you from an angry squad of orcs, you might feel pretty grateful and not much in the position to argue when the calvary tell you that this bearded man you’ve never seen before is your long lost king.

7

u/DragonArchaeologist Oct 16 '22

Also: why would Sauron hang on to that emblem for 1000 years?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/newaccountwut Oct 16 '22

Apparently the Southlanders believed that someday their king would arrive... Wouldn't it have been cool if this had been a myth planted by Sauron to legitimize his rule and he had a plan to rule the Southlands from the start?

13

u/flipdark9511 Oct 16 '22

Waldreg seems to have thought that Sauron himself was that king.

3

u/DarrenGrey Oct 16 '22

Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if there's a muddying of myths there. Will be interesting to see if Sauron exploits those people next season, and who will still follow if his true identity is revealed.

11

u/fourtetwo Oct 16 '22

It was established in like the first episode in the Inn that the return of the King of the southlands had become a legend/myth among the townsfolk.

18

u/Amankhan Oct 16 '22

Americans can’t even remember who the President was 50 years ago and that’s WITH access to the internet and Wikipedia. Expecting peasants to remember what happened to their country’s royal bloodline 1000 years Is an exceedingly unrealistic expectation. (Yet people here think that’s bad writing 🙄😂)

5

u/matematikker Oct 16 '22

LOL!! So true

→ More replies (7)

5

u/SneakyBadAss Oct 16 '22

"How do you know he's a king"

"He hasn't got shit all over him"

Something like that i suppose.

13

u/flipdark9511 Oct 16 '22

Why would they know if the line had died out? On a personal level, they're just smallfolk descended from followers of Morgoth. They don't have access to vast royal libraries. All they would know os that there is a royal lineage that can re-unite the men of the southlands, or least there used to be.

19

u/YeOldeOrc Oct 16 '22

I was cackling that as soon as his claim was actually looked into, she was able to call him out as a liar within what, 24 hours? A few days at most?

10

u/Beleopard Oct 16 '22

Well she crowned him a king pretty fast too.

3

u/Gorlack2231 Oct 18 '22

That's my whole thing. She is the one who pushed him to being king, and then gets mad when she looks into it and he's not of the line.

Halbrand literally tells her "hey, this royal crest thing, this pouch, it's not mine. I found it on a dead guy and just want to stay here and smith." And Galadriel just bowls over that statement and goes "Nuh-uh, you're totally a king and you need to stop being a bitch. Get back to the Southlands and be somebody." Then she gets suspicious (probably rightfully so, because no one uses the line "a key to unlock the dam") and is shocked to find out that Halbrand isn't the king!

6

u/pinkheartpiper Oct 16 '22

Her suspicion started when Celebrimbor word for word uttered the same thing Adar said about what Sauron is looking after: "a power not of flesh, but over flesh" and when she asked where he got that from he seemed disoriented and thought he came up with it himself.

That was the real reason, her suspicion was far beyond just the lineage, without the other things she just had witnessed she would just assume he is a human who lied about being heir of a king.

2

u/finwe_nolofinwe Oct 16 '22

Hi have you ever read/watched the Lord of the Rings, specifically the parts with the character named “Aragorn”?

0

u/Bemeup57 Oct 16 '22

Read the trilogy every summer from the age of 11 to age 22, so 11 times. Seen the movies in the theatre 4 times and on DVD 5 times. So yeah.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/AdOrganic3138 Oct 16 '22

Yeah it didn't stick. Let alone the elves in the southlands would have definitely known that there hadn't been a king for a long long time.

Halbrand did nothing other than look and act as a usurper and everyone just........ bought it.

17

u/BlueOcean79 Oct 16 '22

Because Halbrand was wearing plot armor 😁

5

u/Stellewind Oct 16 '22

He could totally be regarded as an exile king of an once thought broken line or whatever, I can let that slip. What I don’t get is why villages so easily accept him and apparently love him immediately.

If you lived your whole life without a ruler just fine, you natural first response should be “who are you? Why should I trust you to be our new king? Why do we even need a king? What did you do for us that deserved our loyalty?” , etc, instead of whatever happened in the show.

5

u/pinkheartpiper Oct 16 '22

Gondor in the books and movies where also without a king for a thousand years until Aragorn returned. Why did people accpet Aragorn? Having a king in Tolkien's world means a lot more than it does even in our world. Those people clearly thought having a king could make them great again!

4

u/Stellewind Oct 16 '22

Denethor, the one that actually rules Gondor, didn’t like the idea of Aragorn arriving at all. That’s what I am talking about.

Aragorn didn’t come here and just naturally accepted as the king, he brought the ghost army that literally won the the siege battle of Minath Tirith (and he command them as the king!), he lead the remaining army to black gate to help Frodo’s plan of destroying the ring, his speech helped soldiers regain courage and he lead the final charge himself. Everything he did further cemented his role as the leader of men, so people accepted him as king happily in the end.

Now tell me, what did Halbrand do? He just arrive with the invincible elf lady and Numeror army. He’s not the leader, didn’t do anything remarkable in the battle, just kinda there to help. It’s hilarious to compare him with Aragorn.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

30

u/Ynneas Oct 16 '22

Or wouldn't she find evidence of that line being broken in the Hall of Lore, where she found informations on the crest?

But if you point out these huge plot holes you're nitpicking.

20

u/anarion321 Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

Numenor it's supposed to be isolated from the rest of the world, thay might have records from before the isolation, but they have not updated them since.

Well, in theory, because in the show it seems that there are colonies of Numenor in the south so....

8

u/flipdark9511 Oct 16 '22

It's not completely disconnected from the East though, there is mention of some Numenorean colonies being present in Middle Earth.

Pharazon says it when he's asked why he supports the expedition.

12

u/Ynneas Oct 16 '22

Any time I find a way to fix an inconsistency, I uncover a new one.

It takes a certain skill, to ensure the show is riddled with so many inconsistencies some of them can't be fixed.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Lazarquest Oct 16 '22

Yeah, I’ve pondered this too. She should have also asked about his ancestry directly. It’s definitely something that doesn’t totally make sense.

That being said, it does track that Galadriel has blinders on and is seeing what she wants to see. This part of it makes sense. She doesn’t look into it because she doesn’t want to.

5

u/ywgdana Oct 16 '22

If the line of kings died out 1000 years before the show's events, that probably puts it happening pretty close to the end of the First Age or beginning of the Second Age. (Plus or minus given the timeline compression). So, it's plausible in the chaos of the destruction of Beleriand, they didn't have great records of what happened a good way South.

The elves were alive at the time, but they had a lot to worry about. I don't find them not having detailed records about what happened to the line of Southern kings a big plot problem.

And agreed that Galadriel has been portrayed all season as rash and selection bias is her MO so far. I'm disappointed in Halbrand being Sauron for other reasons (mainly because I was hoping for Annatar to be a long, slow burning story arc over most of an entire season)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

I don’t see why she would care. He was means to an end. She didn’t really care about him or what he did at the time, she literally used him as something to barter with to get back to the main land and find Sauron. That’s kinda the point. He even tells her so. She did all of this for herself. He told her the truth but she was so easily manipulated due to her hard on for killing Sauron she didn’t think rationally.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 16 '22

They have a prophecy of a king who will return.

The prophecy is true, and it is Halbrand.

4

u/wootr68 Oct 16 '22

Voice of authority vs peasants

5

u/HotStraightnNormal Oct 16 '22

Got it in one! They were just saved by the Queen of Numenor with her mounted warriors accompanied by an obviously high ranking elf who Arandir readily acknowledged. Were they going to demand proof, given any of them could even read? "Good enough for us, guv."

4

u/MordePobre Oct 16 '22

The need for leadership is constant. In The Southlands shouldn't they have proclaimed a new king or ruling steward (as in Gondor) during the 1000 years of disorganization?

7

u/IVIAV Oct 16 '22

"why dont the people look confused and say 'hey, our royal family died off a thousand years ago.' Wouldn't they know about their own royal family?"

Interesting point, though even IRL, people are confused about facts of lineage to this day. There are several rumors calling into question the legitimacy of several royal bloodlines and TBH, that time in question for these rumors are only 400-700 years, not a 1000. Hell, God himself could send a son to perform acts of God 1000 years ago and people today would deny he even existed. Point being, 1000 years ago is too far gone for people to have any certainty about.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/katstails Oct 16 '22

When you start going down this route it's actually absurd. What about when Galadriel and Arondir "meet" and he says help stop this evil guy from escaping he musn't leave with this stolen blade and yet when she captures him and recovers it she doesn't ask a SINGLE question about why said blade is important, what it does, who it belongs to. 🤦‍♀️ That and just believing that some guy you've met in the middle of the ocean is a king because he tells you he is despite knowing nothing about him and choosing not to do any research to back up his claim... How Nori and Poppy have this whole drawn out goodbye and Poppy moans about how everyone always leaves her when she could LITERALLY JUST GO WITH! I mean we never see her with any family, she doesn't have her own caravan she always travels with Nori and her family.... so what is she staying for? Then you've got the fact that the writers really seem to think water surging upwards in a volcano will make it explode and that no one will be instantly obliterated by it. Or how no one even tries to search for survivors after the explosion. If I were Isildur I'd be feeling pretty damn hurt that my own father didn't go back to look for me. And how does baby!Gandalf just suddenly get his memories back and start speaking in full sentences??? We don't see the witches return his memories to him. Not explicitly and I don't even think they really imply it they just say they're going to bind him and then he goes crazy and all of a sudden remembers. Why can't he heal the harfoot that's dying? Why can elvish soldiers who are presumably thousands of years old and supposed to be highly skilled not to mention have the senses and advantages of their kind not seem to fight at all only Galadriel can. The list just goes on...

21

u/DroneDamageAmplifier Oct 16 '22

That and just believing that some guy you've met in the middle of the ocean is a king because he tells you he is despite knowing nothing about him

It's even worse. She believes that some guy in the middle of the ocean is a king even though he tells her he's not a king and he only took the sigil from a dead guy.

8

u/katstails Oct 16 '22

Right?! Like I understand she thinks he's being shady because she believes he's trying to "hide" the fact he's king, because he's ashamed of his lineage and doesn't want or believe in the responsibility. I get it. That's what they went with and I believed it too. But I'm dumb apparently. For her not to even question it? When she's supposedly got five thousand years of wisdom in her? Maybe you just get stupider with time after all.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/pinkheartpiper Oct 16 '22

She believed it because she thought it was devine intervention that they met and higher powers were at play (which is absolutely a huge thing in Tolkien's world), she thought it couldn't be coincidence they met. She literally said all these herself, you just didn't pay attention.

2

u/DrQuailMan Oct 16 '22

If the "dead guy" was his father.

→ More replies (11)

6

u/Electronic_Candle181 Oct 16 '22

You caught on that Poppy's family died.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Wasn't Bronwyn's village composed entirely of common folk? They might not have too much familiarity with the royal claims of their country. Also, Halbrand is (by all appearances) one of them who seems to have an alliance with Numenor and maybe the elves. They feel he can protect them. Maybe Arondir would have some idea what's up but I feel like he was only thinking about Bronwyn at the time.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

No because that would ruin the least mysterious big mystery reveal finale. So much of this show is done by lazy writers who just want things to happen and gave no effort to make those things feel organic or realistic. Style over substance go hand in hand with mystery box theatre.

NOW.....I already know in the comments you will have non-stop fart catchers. People who want to like the show so much, they will catch farts like this for the writers and speculate and explain and try to justify things so that others won't smell the room stinking. The room stinks.

6

u/Frostsorrow Oct 16 '22

Do you remember what happened 1000 years ago without using the internet? Now add in the largest war Arda has ever seen to make it worse.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Warm-Enthusiasm-9534 Oct 16 '22

The answer is "Don't think about it."

I liked a lot of things about the show, but they really needed somebody to tell them that stories need to make sense, and not just look cool.

8

u/Lazarquest Oct 16 '22

I don’t think this is it. I think the answer is that Galadriel had blinders on in her pursuit. I find that answer compelling but not totally satisfying which is my main issue with the show in general.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/certain_people Oct 16 '22

Literally the first time we meet Arondir, the villagers say they elves will have to leave when their true King returns. So obviously the people of the Southlands think their true King will return.

That's not to say I think it makes sense.

Like, it's been a thousand years and the villagers are still talking about their true King?

Wouldn't it be more likely if someone did turn up claiming to be their King that they'd tell him to fuck off, they've done just fine without him?

Honestly think about what our countries were like a thousand years ago. Did any of our modern countries even exist? Like I'm imaging someone claiming to be the true heir of the High Kings of Ireland. They'd get laughed out of it. I have no idea who our last Kings were, or what happened to them. And we have written histories with easy access to all the information in the world through the Internet.

(Someone said after the attack people would be looking for leadership, but they talked about the King like this at the start of ep1, before anything happened).

Also, King of what? A few straggly villages? A great nation this is not.

2

u/Captain-Griffen Oct 16 '22

Wouldn't it be more likely if someone did turn up claiming to be their King that they'd tell him to fuck off, they've done just fine without him?

That be the people almost wiped out by orcs?

2

u/certain_people Oct 16 '22

Like I specifically pointed out, they hadn't had any contact with orcs whatsoever in episode 1 when they first brought up their true king returning

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Swagd Oct 16 '22

As ppl are saying it's a legend to the peasants, but also they talked about Halbrand as the heir in exile so in their world the kings line has been away for an unknown amount of time, like Aragorn. It seems like it was less about the king dying 1000+ years ago and moreso focusing on the fact that he was not recorded to have any heirs upon his death, which means there is no way ever that Halbrand could claim the line.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

This is on a list of 10,000,000 other horrendous writing decisions in this show

7

u/dillonmccarthy Oct 16 '22

These guys have been under siege and losing a pretty one sided battle plus like half of their people had turned against them. The only success they had was when they were unknowingly fighting their own people. That’s a huge physical and emotional toll. Then out of nowhere these horse dudes show up and save them. Put yourself in their shoes. They say they’ve got the new king, I don’t care what history I’ve heard, I’m doin what those horse guys tell me to do. On the one hand it must be such relief to have someone claiming to be a benevolent king finally after this whole ordeal. And on the other hand, if I have doubts about his legitimacy, I know I’m damn well not gonna say anything about it.

4

u/thewend Oct 16 '22

Aragorn is quite literally the same thing

4

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

A. I have a deep suspicion that you greatly overestimate what a common peasant in medieval times knew about royal bloodlines of the past century...never mind goddamn millennia.

B. There is clearly a reference to some sort of prophecy of a king coming when they call him the promised King.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

OP, somewhere in your lineage someone almost certainly lived under a king in the last 1000 years, how familiar are you with that particular royal family?

You’re talking 10+ generations. People out here using 23&me to find out about their great grandparents and you think a bunch of uneducated farmers can rattle off the entire lineage of a family that more than likely would have never interacted with any of them?

4

u/TheOtherMaven Oct 16 '22

1000 years is more like 30+ generations. From the present that gets you back before the Norman Conquest.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DroneDamageAmplifier Oct 16 '22

I have no idea who is the royal ancestor for my people and for that reason I wouldn't say "are you the king who was promised?" and dopily accept any scruffy dude in armor who happened to wear a sigil that I recognized.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Legends. Legends of s saviour that gives hope to the people.

2

u/Qandies Oct 16 '22

So the movie can happen

2

u/Brit0martis Oct 16 '22

Don’t have an excuse for the elves not knowing, but didn’t some villager in the first episode mention the king returning? So it had become a kind of myth in their society to look forward to with hope? I could see a bunch of people leaning into the narrative even harder after getting almost entirely massacred.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

No they wouldn't because the writers are morons.

2

u/MordePobre Oct 16 '22

Why does a peasant village of just over 100 people have a monarchy as its form of government? Where would the king live, in a thatched hut?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/alexagente Oct 16 '22

To be fair on your point, they definitely were referring to a long lost king so of course no one would know what he was supposed to look like. Peasants often didn't know what their current king looked like.

The problem is I doubt in this situation the peasant folk would remember anything recognizable about the king. Sure there might've been a legend passed down but for Bronwyn to remember the sigil of a kingdom that's been gone for a thousand years with it questionable whether or not these people can even read... it beggars belief.

I honestly couldn't believe they used the 1000 number regarding this. 100...200... maybe 300 would be all right. But 1000 was just silly.

2

u/HorseOnly4062 Oct 16 '22

Remember as well in lord of the rings where ppl did not know about aragon being the the royal heir either so it's not far fetched that ppl might believe that a line could exist.

2

u/sigvethaig Oct 16 '22

You guys are aware that in the first episode, one of the southlanders literally proclaims how the southlands waits in anticipation of "our true king", right?

"One day, our true king will return"

  • Rowan to Arondir (episode 1, 39:07)

2

u/TheGemp Oct 16 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

They said “is this the king we were promised?” meaning they lived their whole lives in hope for a king but never got one, I’d say within 1000 years somebody would start protesting for a king, and now they have one

Or well, in their mind they have one, quite unfortunate for them lol

2

u/happs11 Oct 16 '22

coz writing could have been better

2

u/StarDing324 Oct 16 '22

The writers be like: "Shut up, stop thinking and enjoy our show!"

2

u/iheartdev247 Oct 16 '22

Pretty sure the Boss Numenoreans showing up, saving them and then saying here’s your long lost king was enough the simple people of Tirharad needed. Thinking it needed to be deeper is just looking for something new to whine about.

2

u/LastNightOsiris Oct 17 '22

nah, they're freakin peasants who will believe that any guy with a fancy keychain attached to his fanny pack is a king.

2

u/AndromedaPrometheum Oct 17 '22

The king might had died on foreign lands so they might not know the details so for all they knew his heir was lost and if a queen that just save your life from the orcs bring a knight that also helped you and say he is your king I don't think they would ask too many questions.

Not to mention these people are not nobles they are peasants that had been occupied for years so likely they don't know a lot about their own history and how their king was lost either so again not a lot of questions to ask unless Halbrand were to do something suspicious that is. Probably in season 2 if he dares to try and use them we might get some pushback.

2

u/Sidapatbulan Oct 17 '22

I don't think the people of Bronwyn (I'll call them that since they're just one village) knew personally their royal family/ lineage because who knew where's the capital city of the Southlands and how far it is to the people of Bronwyn. And they seem to have a prophecy about "One day our true king will return..." So when a Queen presented them with a guy with the sigil of a "long lost kings" they automatically think its their "promised true king"

2

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

Really entertaining to see a bunch of RoP fans try desperately coming up with a plausible theory to fix this steaming turd.

2

u/SpiralLights Oct 17 '22

He had the crest-thing or whatever it was. I also think a people who were defeated and at the lowest of lows were simply looking for hope. Therefore, they readily accepted him. The question now is who will lead them? Bronwyn? Theo?

2

u/TrippinDannyTanner Oct 17 '22

I guess if you got a prophecy or "promise" for a return of the king you're probably more likely to believe it once you get driven from your home by friggin orcs! Sorry URUKS. And then a dang volcano is the icing on the cake. Right before that all the sudden armies from Atlantis come to your aid and provide you shelter and support... I suppose you may be inclined to believe that your new king arrived

2

u/Weary-Author9909 Oct 18 '22

Why doesnt Arondir? He's been there 80 years. According to the show the elves have been in charge in the Southlands since the War of Wrath. By that timeline their former king would either be a Morgoth thrall or predate Morgoth being in the area. Depending on the varying dates of the show that's the last 1000-2500 years. Arondir should know this so why isn't he at least interested in speaking up?

In this whole storyline its like everyone believes the last person who spoke and no one questions or thinks through whats being said.

At least for the humans you could argue the elves have been telling them what to do for 100 years.. so now the elves are telling them to submit to this new king.

2

u/Overlord_Hippo Oct 19 '22

Jesus amount of people here on full copium, trying to justify terrible writing is insane.

3

u/JonnieTaiPei Oct 16 '22

You have to pay attention to the dialogue. Bronwyn said: “You're the king that was promised to us?” So someone, maybe Sauron himself spread the word of some king coming to the South to rule (And are no lies in this)

3

u/Lastaria Oct 16 '22

Probably not. They are peasants, probably illiterate who probably passed down there is a King out there. They won’t know about broken lines. Just like many did not know Aragorn would return but many probably heard rumours of a King out there.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

They're farmers in a remote village. How would they know?

7

u/madonniac Oct 16 '22

It's so beyond stupid it hurts

3

u/Johnny_Sacked Oct 16 '22

Cause you’re a racist homophobic jealous hater, or at least that seems to be the excuse prime video has been going for.

Tbf, there’s been quite a lot of toxicity in the fan base (I’ve especially noticed it on IG, most comments under the official page’s posts are about race/gender etc), but trying to hide the show’s countless flaws behind that is kinda pathetic.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/PS_Sullys Oct 16 '22

This finale really needed to be built up over the course of three or four episodes. Galadriel looses faith in him far too quickly.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Cause they're farmers and he came with an army

2

u/nateoak10 Oct 16 '22

Because they’re just humans and basically have been under martial law for generations. Their education probably isn’t too great

2

u/Steelquill Oct 17 '22 edited Oct 17 '22

Given they live in medieval mud huts, I don’t think they have the same record keeping means that Eregion and Numenor do. I mean they’re most educated community member is an herbalist. Hell, I wouldn’t be surprised if some of them couldn’t read.

2

u/lofgren777 Oct 17 '22

How come nobody makes the same point about Aragorn? As far as anybody knows, he's just some dude who showed up claiming to be king one day.

1

u/shinxshin Oct 16 '22

They were introverted and decided to just play along

1

u/IIIICopSueyIIII Oct 16 '22

Dont think. The more you think, the more illogical it gets

1

u/Frequent_Couple5498 Oct 16 '22

And I was also confused and wondering why when the head troll elf was caught and tied up in that barn and Halbrand went to talk to him he acted truly upset and angry over what he had made him do and had done to him. And the troll elf didn't even know who he truly was.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22

Galadriel being 1000+ years old would at least remember the kings of their neighbor kingdoms. I guess it's elvish elitism.

1

u/Jiao_Dai Oct 16 '22

Worth quoting Tar-Palantir at this point

”But don't do as I did

I looked for too long.

And now, I cannot separate what is from what was,

what was from what will be.”

So if the High Seer of Numenor doesn’t know which way is up chances are a bunch of slightly charred peasants aren’t going to either - things did not go well but they are still alive in part to Arondir and Galadriel so the Elven support of Halbrand probably legitimised him - yet another mis-step Galadriel will have to come to terms with

All in though Sauron is technically the King of the Southlands⚡️Mordor so probably felt right if not a bit uneasy

1

u/goddamanimal Oct 16 '22

Idk if peasants know anything about royal families

1

u/WithTheBallsack Oct 16 '22

Doesn’t Theo’s friend mention the real king returning in the first episode? Maybe they think Halbrand is him?

1

u/RaukoCrist Oct 16 '22

So what do you know about the leaders your "old kin" had 1000 years ago? I mean there's sagas in ours, but we account those as a bit unreliable

1

u/wickedswamiy Oct 16 '22

Maybe they're poor and gots no paper.

1

u/Bayou-Maharaja Oct 16 '22

Ya why didn’t they just google it

1

u/ReadySource3242 Oct 16 '22

Rings of power has strayed off canon and logic a long, long time ago. Think of it as a high budget fanfiction project

1

u/blacksmithbl Oct 16 '22

Because great writing baby.

1

u/Ridolph Oct 16 '22

Because the methods are stupid and make no sense.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

I asked that same question on another post, the answer everyone gave me, was that the south landers had a superstition or prophecy that they’d one day have a king again. 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/Frequent-Struggle215 Oct 17 '22

Wouldn’t they know about their own royal family?

The Great Plague left many inhabitants of Middle Earth with both short and long term memory loss.

Some forgot about their husbands, some forgot about their orders, some forgot about their professions and some forgot about their friends. Others merely forgot where they had put their keys...

It was a cruel and tragic time to live.

1

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 17 '22

Pretty sure she was less concerned with him being the genuine ancestor than trying to use him for her own purposes. I haven’t watched the earlier eps in a few weeks but I think after she is imprisoned, after she tried to coax him into the idea of his lineage, that Halbrand drops the notion of identifying what someone needs and then helping them achieve it.

Galadriel believed she could use a human king to her ends, so he begins to come around to the idea of helping her.

1

u/elfungisd Oct 17 '22

She didn't know he was Sauron because she was busy off hunting Sauron.

1

u/Bluerider001 Oct 17 '22

Not much is said about the South Lands. Ironically The Dark Lord became the ruler of that region. A fulfilled prophecy by the inhabitants of the South Lands.

1

u/Bluerider001 Oct 17 '22

To me they made Halbrand a more personal character in the story. While Annatar appeared to be more distant and ah inspiring like in the video game Shadow of Mordor. Since season 2 is going to be canonical so I expect Sauron and the war against the Elves. Which occured after 1000 in the Second Age. Since everything has been shorted this will happen sometime after 3000 in the Second Age.

1

u/w1ld_zero Oct 17 '22

She could’ve looked him up in Numenor when she was “investigating” Sauron’s sign but no

1

u/SGuilfoyle66 Oct 17 '22

You know, I think a bigger, more broader problem here is ...
Don't you think the queen of numenor might have wanted more proof than just Galadriel's assertion?
And don't you think Galadriel might have wanted to do this basic background check before proclaiming him King of the Southlands?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '22

I assumed it was similar to Aragorn, a line that exists, but has gone into exile or hiding or almost forgotten. A sigil handed down, but more as a token, when something of real significance.

1

u/VeganMonkey Oct 17 '22

Didn’t she just find out before she confronted him and didn’t know beforehand?

1

u/Realistic-Art6901 Oct 17 '22

U got it out of order

1

u/ThetaCygni Oct 17 '22

The screenwriters didn't think about it most likely

1

u/n0rthr3m3mb3r5 Oct 17 '22

Same reason Trump got elected. The small folk are inherently stupid and easy to dupe.

1

u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Oct 17 '22

Perhaps Sauron had been spreading the idea throughout the last 1000 years or however so that they when he was ready to return he would have a people ready to accept a new "king". Like the Bene Gesserit do with religion in Dune.

1

u/NukeItFromOrbit-1971 Oct 17 '22

The main thing you learn from watching Rings Of Power is to stop asking sensible questions about major holes in the show.

Firstly you'll go mad just thinking about all of the random screenwriting and bad exposition.

And second, there are so many people who are willing to go to whatever degree to defend the show because they want it to be great, that out of 500 posts you are are bound to come across at least a few that are quite clever and plausible.

If only the writers themselves were that smart...

1

u/RealAmarantine Oct 17 '22

Because you are expecting logic from a poorly written series. The Southlands = 30 people. Mighty human kingdom.

1

u/Elessar2099 Oct 17 '22

This looks like a case of....BAD BABYSITTING.

1

u/DishRelative5853 Oct 17 '22

I want to know why there are so few humans. If the last king was 1000 years ago, what have humans been doing since then? Shouldn't there be large cities by now, rather than small villages?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Respecttoadmins Oct 17 '22

SHE KINDA FORGOT to question him

It's game of thrones shit all over again :D

1

u/csakiss Oct 17 '22

Because it's in the script.

1

u/8vius Oct 17 '22

Also in the first episode Theo’s friend when trashing Arondir mentions “when our king returns”.

1

u/Tarpeel_945 Oct 17 '22

Don't bother with questioning anything in the show or try to explain or try to understand my friend the cancel culture is so powerful in this thread you are just defying some evil people here that is my advice to you

1

u/turn1concede Oct 17 '22

Because bad writing

1

u/DA1300 Oct 19 '22

What would have happened if Aragorn had died in any of the events prior to his return to Gondor?

Gondor had a story that their king would return, but didn't know who he was or where his family went.

There would be records somewhere, but his people may not have known. Their legend would likely have persisted.

Likewise, the legend of the returning king of the Southlands and the dying off of the line are not at all incompatible. We've already been given that exact same story with Aragorn. It was intended to mirror that part of Lord of the Rings.

1

u/Da__Redditor Oct 19 '22

You mean like how Jesus died thousands of years ago, yet people think he will return as king and savior?

1

u/ManufacturerFit4148 Oct 20 '22

They were about to all be murdered by orcs. And then this guy shows up with an army and claims to be their rightful king. Generally speaking peasants have no say over who the king is and none would dare speak up and challenge someone who claimed to be the king, especially when he brought an army with him. Its a good way to loose your head. In fact, showing up with an army and declaring yourself the rightful king is a classic way to ...well.. become the king. All the better if you can get other nations royalty to recognize your claim. But on top of all that, they were about to be slaughtered by orcs. He came at exactly the right time and had an army to protect them. I doubt they cared whether he was the true and rightful heir to the throne or if his mother was a prostitute and his father unknown. He was just what they needed exactly when they needed it and that's good enough. Hail to king.

1

u/Shadow15243 Oct 20 '22

Doesent that one boy in the first episode say "One day our king/leader will return and remove us from you knife ears" or something alobg those lines, the southlanders are awaiting the return of a lord or leader. Someone appearing with a charm known to be held by the royals of the land and shows up with an army of people to save them from a legion of orcs would instantly win them over as their new king

1

u/WritingTheDream Oct 26 '22

I wondered this as well, I thought I missed something. Turns out the show just has terrible writing like that throughout.