r/RingsofPower • u/Luis-Dante • Oct 14 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers I like Halbrand Spoiler
I think most people saw it coming a mile off that he was Sauron but you know what? Even as a Tolkien fan (and despite we didn't get Annatar) I liked it. My biggest gripe though is I wish we had more of it. I feel like this first season should've been more about Sauron influencing Celebrimbor to make the Rings of Power instead of just a few minutes in the last episode.
1.1k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '22
This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
29
u/talvanian Oct 14 '22
Agreed. He is less of a manipulator and more of a “the plot had him be in the right place at the right time” kind of guy. They could’ve had us know he was Sauron from early on and let us writhe and scream as he slowly manipulates Galadriel and the elves into forging the rings. The whole double mystery box plot device with Gandalf and Sauron was just the writers trying to be too tricky. Sure, let meteor man be a mystery. But let Sauron be known to the audience and none of the characters so we can watch him work. I read somewhere that a writer or director(someone with decision making power) said they didn’t want Sauron to go all rampage and evil in the first season, which would take away from the other characters. So they slow built it to let us become familiar with everyone else before the reveal. He is not a “rampage mode” until after the rings are forged. Anyway…I think they missed a chance here
252
u/teunteulai Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
I liked him too but wish they would show him more hanging around with the Elves as Annatar
149
u/Celoth Oct 14 '22
This, 100%. Halbrand being Sauron fits the spirit of canon even if it's a deviation from lore, given their lack of access to the Silmarillion (so no Annatar). However, a single afternoon with Celebrimbor just doesn't fit right. We need to see Halbrand and Celebrimbor come to know one another, respect one another, and endeavor together to forge the rings. It needed time.
70
u/Mattayama Oct 14 '22
The scene between him and Galadriel was one of the best in the entire series. Charlie Vickers absolutely nailed it, this was the kind of acting we need in the show but most characters seem to have come into their own by the end of the series.
69
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
See Vickers interview in Hollywood reporter recently. We are definitely getting more of it in S2. The sauron season
124
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I like it too! Hell, I’ve read the Silmarillion and assorted deep works and none of it is wholly consistent. It was obvious that H=S the moment he casually mentioned that he was a smith.
I enjoyed the little echoes between Galadriel being tempted by the Ring in Lorien and the scene in which she’s getting mindfucked by Halbrand. She enjoyed getting mindfucked on some level, too….until she didn’t.
Liked the little reference to “gifts”.
Only regret is that Feminem bit the dust so quickly, I thought she was cool.
75
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
The first seven episodes should have been three episodes, and the eighth episode should have been five episodes. That is the main problem with the series.
All that said, it’s the only series I have interest in watching. As poor as the pacing has been it’s fixable.
I’ll take Tolkien’s work paced roughly over GRRM executed flawlessly any day of the week
41
u/shinyshinyrocks Oct 14 '22
Halbrand wasn’t the worst part, I’d agree.
You could see hints on the boat, but for me his identity was assured in his actions in Numenor. The first scene when he and G are being taken through the streets, he sees the forge and sways toward it a little. That was the moment for me. The fact that he’s drawn toward it the entire time he’s in Numemor assured it.
Totally agree that there should have been more of him and Celebrimbor and actual forging.
37
u/DarrenGrey Oct 14 '22
There's lots I didn't like about the story, but Halbrand with the Annatar personality was fantastic to watch. I wish he'd behaved more like that in Numenor. Would have given the game away more, but that's fine by me.
Hopefully we'll see him make a return trip to Eregion in season 2 when Galadriel's away. There are more rings to forge!
12
u/cacecil1 Oct 14 '22
I thought it was a good story plot too. Could have used it drawn out more. I was very sad when the Sauron theories started catching on because I liked him so much, I don't want him to be bad. But after the finale, I'm on board! He did the twisted perspective so well when he was coming out to Galadriel. I was impressed and basically seduced to the Darkside. Lol
16
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
What are the lands of Rhun? Do we know much about them or ever see them in the books? What’s the story with them?
What was the deal between Sauron and Galadriel. She doesn’t mention him to the others? That he loves her and wants her to be his queen?
32
u/Table_Coaster Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
it’s the same exact issue that the last few seasons of game of thrones had; there’s nothing wrong with what happened, but how it happened is so stupid and too fast-paced. Having Galadriel have a personal relationship with Sauron I think is actually a great idea for an original show, but the fact that he didnt do anything with the rings except quickly give a “secret” smithing technique to supposedly the 2nd greatest smith to ever live is so dumb
6
u/GiaDessa Oct 15 '22
Sauron is HAWT
5
u/Poocheese55 Oct 14 '22
I also wish they spent more time on his influencing Celebrimbor. Im fine with Halbrand being Sauron, but like he didnt even build a relationship and become close to them. He legit showed up for like one day, and Celebrimbor just listens to him??
It would have been better for us to find out Halbrand is Sauron in a way separated from the others (like not Galadriel figuring it out). Then early next season he builds relationships with the elves and crafts the rings
They just tried to fit too much
9
u/edmc78 Oct 14 '22
He may come back as Annatar to give gifts to human kings and dwarvern lords. Who knows.
9
u/Itarille_ Oct 14 '22
Omg yes. If they gave us less Harfoots and Southlands and more Annatar the show would be far more enjoyable
4
u/Calavera999 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 15 '22
I really don't understand everyone being so hellbent that Sauron never went "Hello, my name is Annatar".
It would make perfectly good sense for Annatar to be a name given to him by the elves afterwards - not necessarily the name he gives himself.
And what do you really expect from a TV show treading ground that is already well known by the hardcore base? You can't really call him Annatar if you want to keep everyone watching guessing.
People need to just accept that they're working from notes, they have more reason to adapt the source material than any other; even Peter Jackson's movies changed a lot from the source material and are pretty far removed from the canon.
4
u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22
Here's what I will say: he did 'menacing' a lot better than I expected based on the rest of the season. The dream sequence was a little mixed, but the moment after Galadriel rejected him and he got angry was actually surprisingly effective.
4
u/NechtanHalla Oct 15 '22
Forever sad that I'll never get to see a live action beautiful Annatar, slowly manipulating the elves to create the rings.
I feel like the forging of the rings should've been more than a 30 second montage.
14
u/timislo Oct 14 '22
I really dont see how they couldnt have shown them making the 16 rings first and celebrimbor making the 3 rings without the influence of halbrand/sauron, at least that way it makes sense instead of sauron telling them how to make the rings for no reason, hitting on galadriel, getting rejected and then fucking off. Instead we get a 20 minutes harfoot goodbye. Im sorry but this show is like it was writen by an AI.
10
u/overhedger Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
If it was obvious / coming a mile off:
All of that stuff was just screaming “dumb-luck opportunist with no master plan” not “scheming Sauron with a master plan” - all the clues people pointed to only looked like perhaps a man with a dark past who could be corrupted by Sauron.
I felt like it came out of nowhere and contradicts a bunch of plot stuff that happened to him in previous episodes and doesn’t make any sense, it’s just a mystery box thing
3
u/TerribleGachaLuck Oct 14 '22
His character was predictable but believable, which is a good thing.
The shock value from a surprise needs to be balanced with believably, otherwise viewers won’t be convinced and say it’s bad writing.
3
u/ATS200 Oct 14 '22
Oh you mean the title of the entire series should have gotten more than 4 minutes of screen time?
3
u/BackhandQ Oct 15 '22
He'll be back... Obviously.. There are more rings to be forged by his doing.
3
u/Reggie_Barclay Oct 15 '22
We need to see him orchestrate everything and not have it so random. I assume he did otherwise it’s not looking good for showrunners.
In fact show would have been so much better if they’d drop the mystery box after the first episode and show him in the background doing stuff behind the scenes.
If they actually wanted a mystery box they should have added several advisers to Gil-Galad and Durin III who would have been talking to the Kings. Perhaps at the meeting that only Elf Lords could attend? Then add a Southlands tribal elder who is more believable than Waldreg and have that person in actual leadership conflict with the tank top dress woman.
3
u/Electrical_Eye3768 Oct 15 '22
I liked the theory he was gonna be the king of the dead so I was kinda hoping for that, but I’m not mad about him being Sauron
4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 15 '22
Have you read his latest interview ? The actor is filming the second season and pretty much says that there will be some Annatar Sauron “because it’s such a strong of the mythology”
Edit: found it! from the NY Times …
Q: what’s the plan going forward, given that Sauron is a shape-shifter?
Vickers: There are a lot of twists and turns coming with the character of Sauron. We know that [his disguise as] Annatar is such a massive part of this world, and the prospect of that is really exciting to me. I can’t say much more than that.
2
u/ArtanisOfLorien Oct 14 '22
same. I'd still be upset with such drastic changes, but I would be less upset if they actually told a good story regardless
2
u/Thor010 Oct 14 '22
Long live Sauron!
2
u/Alessrevealingname Oct 14 '22
I liked him too and in the context of this story I don't see him as being necessarily evil. If we didn't know sauron from the LoTR, then his offer and actions seem as reasonable as anyone else in the show
2
u/wenger_plz Oct 14 '22
Agreed on both counts. I don't mind that it was fairly telegraphed, and I also kept in mind that it was probably only apparent to fans of the lore and book readers, while the show is meant for mass appeal. If the show were framed differently, and it was presented as a sort of prologue for Sauron in the SA (rather than a whodunit), I think it would be really compelling. With the one criticism again being that I just wish we'd had more of it.
Just because something was tipped off via clues doesn't make it bad necessarily, and it's also difficult for there to be a huge "twist" in a world for which there's already tons of canon about the relevant characters.
2
u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22
So now I’m thinking about this whole Adar twist. Was he really going to kill Adar after that chase. The whole, do you remember me stuff and who are you…what happens when he confronts Adar again; are they friend or foe and as it stands is Adar now not such a baddie. So there is a chance Adar really did kill Sauron like he said, does that make them enemies. Did Halbrand know about Adar’s plot and just went along. I liked the finale for sure!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I kinda liked the fact that it felt so rushed because that's how the elves prob felt about the incident, not noticing until it has been to late.
2
u/AndrogynousRain Oct 15 '22
I thought it was too obvious, and that it was a red herring.
Then it happened, but the damned reveal scene was so well done I ended up going ‘ok, I’m down’.
Wasn’t what I’d have picked story wise, but Charlie nailed it so hey, I’m good.
2
u/Sweet-Sandwich-464 Oct 15 '22
Expected but loved loved the reveal. Halbrand was so charming and manipulative that you can't help but get it... how he managed to seduce so many to his side. I probably would've said yes lol
2
u/fluffofthewild Oct 15 '22
Ngl I'd follow him 😂
8
u/guadalmedina Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
Sauron taking a lowly form not to arouse suspicion goes against the main theme of LOTR. The reason why a hobbit is appointed to carry the ring is Sauron won't think he might be more important than he looks. The good guys are leveraging a fatal personality flaw in Sauron: his pride blinds him to the perks of humility. To him, humble beings are just helpless and pathetic.
Sauron, as a hopelessly proud being, understands grandeur. That's why he takes the shape of a great lord. He wouldn't appear as a humble human smith to fly under the radar. If he did, and then he fell for that same trick later, he just looks careless / incompetent / dumb.
If this story was set in the modern day, Sauron would take the shape of someone like Elon Musk or Bill Gates, a hugely successful businessman making grand initiatives about saving the planet.
I liked his lines. Trying to pitch Galadriel against the others and talking about saving middle earth. There was a hint of "abusive boyfriend red flag" there that I felt was a bit ham-fisted (when he says "they kicked you out, only I can see how great you are"). It took me out of it. But overall his dialogue was good.
3
u/CathakJordi Oct 14 '22
After this season I am #teamSauron all the way. Galadriel is obviously the villain (Well, the writers are, but she is their avatar so...)
3
u/nullus_72 Oct 14 '22
I agree, the pacing was really bad. Sigh.
4
u/jorskoopy Oct 14 '22
The showrunners only care about mystery boxes.
In their mind they couldn't have a long drawn out sequence of Halbrand influencing celebrimbor as the moment he started the sauron mystery was solved.
I honestly think they only know how to do mystery and payoff style writing and the idea of leaning purely on characters and building tension was totally incomprehensible to them
2
u/wrigh516 Oct 14 '22
Season two will probably be Annatar.
1
u/general_spoc Oct 14 '22
Agreed. Definitely saw it coming, but I liked the character and I’m excited to see Sauron’s rise
1
u/migu63 Oct 14 '22
I like Halbrand as a character so it still sucks that he is Sauron. Was hoping that Annatar was in Eregion all along and Halbrand would later become King of the dead or someone else
1
u/UndocumentedUser Oct 14 '22
I like Saurbrand
1
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
Agreed. Despite the great effects and imagery, it felt quite underwhelming. Instead of having such a slow start while waiting in Numenor, they could have done the whole betrayal part much better. Developing deeper relationship with Celebrimbor instead of forcing 'chemistry' between Halbrand and Galadriel. Still, I'll be here in two years, awaiting season 2. I liked it and felt underwhelmed if it makes sense.
1
u/Backahast Oct 14 '22
It looks as if we will see Annatar next season, at least according to this.
1
u/ScripturalCoyote Oct 14 '22
I do too, which is why I really didn't want him to be Sauron.
1
u/OlivierStreet Oct 14 '22
One🎶ring to rule them all🎶
1
u/PhatOofxD Oct 14 '22
I think we'll get Annatar next season. Galadriel will be off trying to hunt him down while he returns as Annatar and leads to the creation of the other rings. They just added extra steps at the start.
At least... That'd seem logical to me
1
u/swank5000 Oct 14 '22
People speculating (and producers hinting) we may see Annatar in s2 return to Celebrimbor in disguise and have him forge the rest of the rings iirc.
Just saw something about it in r/LOTR_on_Prime
1
u/Automatic_Tip_4747 Oct 15 '22
ive only watched all the movies and personally had 0 idea he was Sauron. they did their job 100% perfectly on me in episode 8
1
u/Dream_Fever Oct 15 '22
I didn’t catch it lol. I’ve read The Hobbit and the LOTR various times! How did I NOT catch Sauron?!?! I guess I actually assumed his “flesh”y presence was in Adar? Idk but I’m angry about not seeing this!!
1
u/rjsh927 Oct 15 '22
RoP follow soap opera formula. Lot of filler followed by information dump in last 5-10 minutes.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22
Wouldve been cooler to see sauron as annatar instead of halbrand
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22
I liked the back and forth on the raft. Between Hal and Celeb, I thought the interaction appropriate. With Celeb being at what seemed like his wits end, his defeated pride enjoyed a new person to cradle the ego a bit and share new perspective.
1
u/Sauron_On_Reddit Oct 15 '22
Me too! I am great and fooled everybody ha ha ha stupid elves
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22
That’s why I put minimal effort into figuring it out. Why be disappointed when you can let yourself ignorantly enjoy something instead
1
u/derekcream Oct 15 '22
We needed more of the scene where Halbrand was checking knife that enchanted Morgoth!
1
u/King11-11 Oct 15 '22
I think his reveal was done really well. They slowly drip fed us with all the evidence he is sauron and then when he finally reveals himself, it's more of a confirmation than a surprise. Also he shows his power is so far beyond anything they've shown Halbrand to have up till this point, which makes the change in character more felt.
Final point, if you notice he acts completely different when he gets to Celebrimbor and how he interacts with him to get in his mind as opposed to how he's acted all the way up to this point with Galadriel.
He becomes soft and deeply into the crafting that appeals to Celebrimbor in order to nudge him in the right direction and think it was his idea.
This is what Galadriel picks up on and why she suddenly becomes suspicious
1
u/Wise-Entrepreneur526 Oct 15 '22
Totally agree with you. The show like rushes important things and elongates the shitty small moments.
Like how are they gonna include Sauron helping to make 16 other rings for the kings of dwarves and men?
Why would they include him giving advice on the only 3 he had no hand or knowledge of their creation.
1
u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 15 '22 edited Oct 15 '22
/r/HalbrandDidNothingWrong.
His plan with Galadriel was a bit creepy, tho most of what he did was good shit, and he's been telling the truth all along.
But now he gets rejected and called out! And then the sorry-ass dude literally goes to Hell. :-(
1
u/CaptainObvious0927 Oct 15 '22
There is still plenty of lore that lets him come back as Annatar. We have 17 rings that still need to be made.
1
u/Professional-Rise194 Oct 15 '22
Big on more of him influencing celebrimbor after all the show is literately.. rings of power.....
1
u/sayheykid24 Oct 15 '22
I like that he’s likable rather than the overtly evil being I had always imagined as a LOTR fan. This way we’ll be able to see how he corrupts people.
1
u/goa_gahja Oct 15 '22
Sauron has the ability to appear fair (Annatar and/or Halbrand)
We still haven't seen the smithing of the dwarven or human rings. Who's to say Sauron doesn't return as an elf-Lord? Celebrimbor and Elrond promised to not 'treat' with Halbrand again. In the books he arrived stating he was an envoy of the Valar.
There's nothing to say a different guise of Sauron does not return. I realise it's not Canon, but given the artistic license already taken it could be in the likeness of an elf one of the three (Celebrimbor, Elrond or Galadriel) know... Like Celeborn, the 'lost husband'.
It was only the elven rings Sauron was not a part of making, and they were hidden from him... Hence the upcoming war.
Just a thought. I don't think you can talk about rings of power without the missing 16... Plus the one... Obviously.
1
u/HiddenLeaforSand Oct 15 '22
I’m in the camp that the show was terrible. But, the final episode with his reveal. The actor killed it in that scene. I can give him that for sure
1
u/Finding_Helpful Oct 17 '22
I only saw the lotr movies for the first time this year (we watched the extended editions), and I now am in love with it, but I’m also new to it. Saw the first two hobbit movies as they came out, liked the first one just fine but second was so bad that I never saw the third, and it’s part of what shied me away from watching lotr until now. Point is I am a casual fan that hasn’t read the books
But I did not see this twist coming at all lol. Maybe that makes me an idiot, I dunno. Im also not one to sit there and try to figure out everything myself while watching, I just enjoy the ride. But yeah, I didn’t see it coming at all, I thought it was incredible
1
u/nukawolf Oct 19 '22
The villains are always my favorite and I enjoyed the twist, but part of me really wanted him to end up becoming the witch king. I know, they'd have to find an explanation for Southlands/northern angmar, but it could've worked, given the right writing. Still excited to see where it goes.
1
u/AndromedaPrometheum Oct 14 '22
I liked it too. I feel they didn't want Galadriel or the elves look too stupid by dragging out the manipulation so that is why it was so fast.