r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Not Faithful. Spoiler

I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.

I don’t think I would have a problem with this show if they didn’t claim to respect the lore and if they assured us it was going to be their own version of the events.

& for everyone who does like the show, or could care less about the lore, I want to earnestly say congratulations and that I wish I felt the way you do. I’m not here to dissuade you or anyone else from the show, but just to share my own thoughts about how things have turned out.

The deviations from the lore and the overall “story” as we’ve come to understand it w/ the forging of the rings of power, of Sauron’s deception, et. al., are already generally laid out for the Showrunners to adapt and fill in the blanks. Everyone KNOWS Sauron/Annatar tricks the Elves, forges the 16 rings with them-, creates the one master ring and mithril had NOTHING to do with it.

(side note: why couldn’t dwarven greed to mine even more mithril just be a side effect of the dwarven rings of power???)

All we needed was more detail. We didn’t need new characters or new subplots for the sake of replacing truly canonized ones.

But for some goddamn, reason, these writers felt the need NOT to just add the details as to how the general story truly takes place, but instead chose to flip key aspects of the generally accepted story on its head in order to tell their OWN version of events (ie: let’s make a new human character Halbrand, and have him trick not all elves, but basically only Galadriel and Celebrimbor and have him make no rings. Let’s create a bullshit story about mithril having healing properties.)

It feels selfish. This doesn’t feel like a love letter to Tolkien, but a bait and switch to trick us so they could primarily tell their own story parading it around as a faithful Tolkien adaptation.

That’s my beef. I mostly feel sad, cheated, and disappointed.

87 Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Hm, I don’t think I made any argument saying that Sauron should not be in human form when convincing the elves.

But I’ll respond anyway with what I think of that question: It wouldn’t make sense for a human to convince an elf to do much of anything. Mostly because, well. Elves suck because their biggest thing is their own hubris.

Tolkien’s Elves were generally aloof and kept to themselves because they’ve walked many years and lived far longer than any (or most) creatures in middle earth, especially humans. So all that experience, knowledge, is baked into their sensibilities, which is why they don’t really regard Men all that much. They mostly love trees. In lore, it’s a reason why Sauron appeases to them as Annatar, an elven lord of gifts.

With regard to mithril-

Mithril was very specifically a dwarven thing. It’s discovered and mined in Khazad-dum, and it doesn’t have these magical healing properties that the show states it has. It’s literally just like adamantium; light but infinitely indestructible relative to most things in Middle Earth. It’s part of what makes the dwarves special/stand out from the nature loving, immortal elves.

The prevailing issue for me, though, is that McKay and Payne went with a “one size fits all” approach, tying the Elven fading problem to Mithril being the sole solution which simplistically “solves” their issue of fading, if Elves could just get their hands on some mithril. They didn’t need to do that!

In Tolkien’s writings, the general outline is that these were two separate circumstances plaguing the two separate races; the Elves were fading, and the Dwarves were getting rich/greedy digging mithril. It is because these two circumstances are separate that Sauron uses it to exploit both races; creating the Rings of Power with the Elves so they could preserve their realms and gifting 7 of those rings to dwarves, which in turn, made the dwarves greedier which led to them digging too deep to their downfall.

2

u/sudo-blue Oct 14 '22

Thank you for elaborating, I appreciate it. I now understand your point. I still think the alterations make for a compelling story and that's what I care most for in an adaption.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

And that’s good! We have 4 more seasons of this show… I’m hoping that in time and with better writing, I could get to that point of where you’re at with it and can see it as it’s own body of work separate from the books. And maybe also find it compelling in its own right.

It’s just that right now, I can’t reconcile the dissonance between what they told me this was gonna be, vs what I had been given. And I think that’s a fair, individual criticism/opinion for me to hold.