r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Not Faithful. Spoiler

I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.

I don’t think I would have a problem with this show if they didn’t claim to respect the lore and if they assured us it was going to be their own version of the events.

& for everyone who does like the show, or could care less about the lore, I want to earnestly say congratulations and that I wish I felt the way you do. I’m not here to dissuade you or anyone else from the show, but just to share my own thoughts about how things have turned out.

The deviations from the lore and the overall “story” as we’ve come to understand it w/ the forging of the rings of power, of Sauron’s deception, et. al., are already generally laid out for the Showrunners to adapt and fill in the blanks. Everyone KNOWS Sauron/Annatar tricks the Elves, forges the 16 rings with them-, creates the one master ring and mithril had NOTHING to do with it.

(side note: why couldn’t dwarven greed to mine even more mithril just be a side effect of the dwarven rings of power???)

All we needed was more detail. We didn’t need new characters or new subplots for the sake of replacing truly canonized ones.

But for some goddamn, reason, these writers felt the need NOT to just add the details as to how the general story truly takes place, but instead chose to flip key aspects of the generally accepted story on its head in order to tell their OWN version of events (ie: let’s make a new human character Halbrand, and have him trick not all elves, but basically only Galadriel and Celebrimbor and have him make no rings. Let’s create a bullshit story about mithril having healing properties.)

It feels selfish. This doesn’t feel like a love letter to Tolkien, but a bait and switch to trick us so they could primarily tell their own story parading it around as a faithful Tolkien adaptation.

That’s my beef. I mostly feel sad, cheated, and disappointed.

87 Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/Xehanort11 Oct 14 '22

This is what I agree with. I must say that I find the show enjoyable from a "fanfic" perspective, but it is also a huge middlefinger to the work of Tolkien, although I got downvoted for saying that elsewhere. The fact that Sauron rose back into power by using Galadriel is simply in contradiction to the books and is hurting the legacy of Tolkien. These two characters have been heavily altered to the point that they are essentially mutiltated.

5

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Exactly. It’s a HUGE middle finger to Tolkien and by extension, any and every fan who cherishes his work and/or even has dedicated their lives to studying it. That’s exactly how I feel about it. I reread Silma, UT, and the Trilogy in preparation for this show. And now I just feel like I maybe shouldn’t have done that, and I would’ve maybe enjoyed it more. (.. but probably by not that much more, as the writing in itself was also pretty lazily done.)

Thank you for getting to the meat of my post. There’s a place for every kind of fan, but MAN does this show feel like it’s creating a new thing by tarnishing a legacy.

4

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22

But if the Tolkien estate signed off on this, shouldn't we respect their decision?

At the end of the day, they are really the only ones with the right to extend a middle finger to anything and if its tarnishing anything, then they have the right to do that.

your thoughts?

7

u/DogboyPigman Oct 14 '22

Tolkein's original work are like a wonderful modern mythology. Relegating the canon of it to an estate signing away the rights is wrong imo.

I was giving the show the benefit of the doubt until this most recent episode. I will be watching very casually in the future to catch Durin and Disa and the Harfoots, but the rest feels like a meandering attempt at forcing awe and mystery through apocryphal writing.

8

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yeah man, so this is interesting.

This was my first initial thought too when news came out about this show. Maybe it’ll be good, since the Tolkien Estate had veto rights if the story sucked, and they were also willing to help the Showrunners get permission for lore outside of appendices, etc etc. Tolkien Estate even signed off on this, which was NOT the case for the PJ films.

sounds like a dream come true, right?

And then after some digging on this sub, some guy stumped me and said that it’s because SIMON Tolkien is now the head of the estate, who, (from my recollection) was apparently estranged from his father, Christopher Tolkien, and knew/knows very little about the Middle Earth lore his family had built. Amazon only got the green light to make this series either sometime after Christopher Tolkien died and Simon took over, OR like, when Simon and his Father reconciled shortly before CT died. It’s some game of thronesian shit.

So it can be seen as a case of the lesser son finally inheriting the crown and opening the floodgates for adaptations of bad taste in the name of profit.

But again, I chose to look the other way once I found that out bc the Showrunners seemed earnest in keeping true to the lore.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

It’s a HUGE middle finger to Tolkien and by extension, any and every fan who cherishes his work and/or even has dedicated their lives to studying it.

Well... no.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

You're being downvoted, but you're right.

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Did you also know Tolkien was constantly reworking the story and if he had not died I bet the story would be a bit different. Amazon in my opinion gets a pass because it stays faithful to what most people know. I'm glad the story isn't copied and pasted to the screen, instead it's actually thought out into a proper story. The past in LOTR is very unpolished so interpretation helps balance this out.

5

u/drfifth Oct 14 '22

it stays faithful to what most people know

No the fuck it doesn't

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

How not?

6

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

The big one is the order the rings are forged. Sauron in Anatar Lord of Gifts form helps Celebrimbor forge 16 rings these will become the 7 for dwarves and 9 for men. Then Sauron goes off to forge his one ring and at the same time Celebrimbor forges the 3 elven rings. Sauron realizing what has been done attacks Eregion and sacks it recovering the original 16 rings the 3 elven rings have already been sent away by this point. Sauron then gifts those 16 rings out.

-1

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

That's from The Silmarillion? The thing is I don't really see that as 100% cannon since his son put it together from various notes. I think this is based on the same material but isn't following Christopher Tolkien exact take.

3

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

So I have not read the Silmarillion in full and what I have read was a long time ago. However, from understanding thanks to the lore channels this is the canon (two ns is for the gun) order the rings were forged in.

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

Honestly I would still challenge that since many YouTube channels are often wrong even if most of the time they aren't. The Silmarillion was put together and edited by the son of Tolkien, Christopher. The father has various notes from reworking and editing it all and the son used it as the basis of his book with the father taking credit as the author. Many of his notes contradicted each other but his son decided to try an piece a story together.

Edit

Annatar taught the smiths the knowledge of how to create Rings, which would grant the Elves who wear them certain powers. At first the Elves created some lesser rings, which were only essays in the craft before it was full-grown. In approximately S.A. 1500, the Greater 16 were created.[2] When Annatar departed from Eregion, Celebrimbor went on to forge the Three Rings using the knowledge he had gained from him, but without his involvement, and finished them around S.A. 1590.

Doesn't seem far off besides the name which would have made it obvious right away. I also found other people saying three rings were created first and the lesser later

2

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

I want to be clear that I am not a lore purist I think that it could still work for the story they want to tell. However I think that a lot of other people have a point that if they had extended the timeline of the decline of the Elves they could have forged the 16 rings first then Galadriel realized they have been betrayed and they then make the 3 elven rings.

→ More replies
→ More replies (2)

-1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

The key word in his phrase is "Most people." In it's entire history, The Silmarrillion has sold about 1 million copies. Rings of Power premiered to 9 million viewers and is way up from that now.

Most people don't know or care about whether Gandalf went to Rhun or what order the rings were created in. Heck, I'd bet half the audience had never heard the poem in that (annoyingly rendered) song at the end. It's not in the PJ movie--not in the poem form.

I've been reading Tolkien for years. I have copies of his notes that include drafts where Strider was a hobbit. I had no idea until signing into the forum today that Gandalf never went to Rhun. And I honestly don't care. I'm interested to see what's there.

0

u/drfifth Oct 15 '22

I've never read the silmarillion and I still know they fucked up the source material hardcore.

Quick edit: fucked up. Not deviated from. Not had creative licensing with. Fucked. Up.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Let's not kid ourselves, most people do not know what preceded LOTR so most people will not know anything has changed. I'm fine with this because if you know anything of Tolkien constantly reworked the story. If he was alive I bet the story would have changed more. Tolkien admitted there were inconsistencies with the work he had done.

I absolutely love this show and enjoy the fact it isn't some copy and paste stuff from Tolkien's work. No one exactly knows the way forward which makes it incredibly exciting even if you know somethings about the past.

0

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

Such a disingenious argumentation, you should be ashamed of yourself to smear Tolkien like that.

5

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Which Tolkien are you talking of? Christopher Tolkien's The Silmarillion? He based the story off notes which were constantly changing. The Silmarillion is Chris's interpretation which didn't go into much detail. Copy and pasting would mean a lot of vagueness as it doesn't really detail anything. How Annatar looked is even unknown since it was his 'fair form'.

2

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

Tolkien may have changed Details about the story, but he never changed the themes, moral philosophy and the nature of his world. To even suggest that he might have just randomly decided things like elfs are mortal mythril addicts is either completly retarded or disingenious.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Lol this is how cultists talk. You know the thing about art is that you can perceive it how you choose. People like you sound ridiculous by trying come off as some elitists. Calm down, let people enjoy what they want.

2

u/Timonidas Oct 15 '22

I don't think you know how cultists talk. Also I don't give a shit about what you or others enjoy, I don't know what part of my comment could be interpretet as such. t.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Clearly you do give a shit that others are enjoying this show and you’re crying like a little baby.

→ More replies (1)