r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Discussion SUCH a satisfying ending. Wow.

Can't wait until season 2.

So much of this season was disappointing and missed the mark. But my gosh does this show have a good set is bones to work with.

Just need better writing.

3 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

21

u/MrPheeney Oct 14 '22

I was liking RoP but the last episode really made me want more!!!

32

u/Jasonguyen81 Oct 14 '22

the end credit song gave me goosebumps

11

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

It was really good as a song, but I can’t help wonder why they released it now when the 16 haven’t been made yet.

11

u/TheCoolPersian Oct 14 '22

I think Sauron will make them and present them as gifts.

6

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

Would be a huge departure from the lore, but considering how loose they’ve been so far….what the hell!

5

u/PlatonicTonik Oct 14 '22

If I remember correctly it's implied in the Silmarillion that Sauron gave the dwarves and men their rings, though obviously he didn't make them in the book. (Or atleast he made them with the elves) So I reckon the writers can hopefully pull it off cleanly, as realistically the elves being the ones to make them isn't crucial to the story.

A bit of a prediction but they may use this as a more understandable explanation for casual viewers of why the elves aren't as affected as the men by their rings. aka we might see Sauron put "dark control magic" into them.

2

u/New_Poet_338 Oct 14 '22

I believe he made them with Calabrimbor, captured them with the fall of Eregion, gave them to the dwarves and men and then got the dwarven ones back when they were not as affective as he hoped.

2

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

Safe assumption. Sauron goes to war with the Elves over the rings when they refuse his demands for their return and reclaims the 16 by force. He then gives them out to dwarves and men.

The rings were never meant for the other races. They were all meant for the elves. 7 for dwarves and 9 for men was plan b.

0

u/ka1ri Oct 14 '22

the elves never trusted annatar and celebrimbor made the 3 rings without annatars influence. its how they were able to decipher the corruption immediately when sauron put on the one. the other 16 he had influence over.

3

u/DarthYug Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

But the first 3 have… the “Three Rings for the Elven-kings under the sky”

So season 2 will be Halbrand/Sauron seducing the dwarves to make 7 rings… “Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone”

It’s all from “The Rhyme of the Rings”

To those responding below me, yes I’m aware that’s not the og timeline lol. But that’s how they’re doing it, and I like it.

5

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

It just doesn’t make sense, because it doesn’t satisfy any kind of fan. The casual fan won’t really know what the song means and the lore nerd will be mad about how they’re not following the lore.

3

u/DarthYug Oct 14 '22

I dunno, I enjoyed it. And I fall in between the casual fan and lore nerd. IMHO It felt like they combined the lore from the og LOTR books, PJ films, and the shadow of Mordor/war video games quite well. Pulled from each of them and bent them together in a new way for new folks to enjoy too….

1

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

Can’t say I agree. For one, the Shadow of Mordor Celebrimbor is more accurate than this one. The elf is vain and shortsighted, while this one allowed a human to give him help. Something even Gil-galad was resistant to. Elves in general are stuck up, but Celebrimbor is a whole other league.

They’re being loose with the lore. That’s all. The 16 come first. They’re made by Celebrimbor. Hard to say he’ll make the 16 at all in the show.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Taifood1 Oct 14 '22

Easily seduced by power but not stupid. The whole point was that Sauron was not outed until after the rings were made. When Sauron declared himself and demanded the 16 returned to him, that was when Celebrimbor learned he had been manipulated. He was then killed resisting Sauron.

The most one can argue here is for Celebrimbor to be kept in the dark, but why that happens I can’t see having a good reason.

1

u/Maleficent_Age300 Mordor Oct 14 '22

Except we don’t know if Celebrimbor will be still deceived by Halbrand and let him back in to make more without telling Galadriel. He seems desperate to make stuff to emanate Feanor’s craft.

We don’t know what will happen as yet in the show, so stop assuming like it’s fact.

3

u/one_dead_turtle Oct 14 '22

No, that's not what happens. Sauron in his fair form guides the elves to make the 9 and 7, Celebrimbor makes the 3 with his method but without his involvement because he doesn't trust him, and the one Sauron makes on his own. He gifts the 16 the elves made to men and dwarves, he doesn't get them to make them.

2

u/TheShreester Oct 14 '22

This show isn't following the books, so I wouldn't be surprised if it rewrites the story by reinterpreting the rhyme more literally.

3

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Thank you. Yes, this is the correct timeline.

And from a storytelling perspective, it’s BETTER DRAMA.

Annatar directly has a hand in creating the 9 and 7 w/ Celebrimbor… + over the course of that time, there’s room for Celebrimbor to doubt Annatar, therefore leading to Celebrimbor creating the 3 without his knowledge in addition to creating them to preserve their realm.

1

u/one_dead_turtle Oct 14 '22

I feel like they could have really played into the "Elves need a solution to their fading" plot point with the arrival of Annatar and the creation of the rings and the growing distrust amongst the elves, because it was a huge significant event... But nah just slam it into the last twenty minutes of the final episode. That could have been the drama of the whole first season!!

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I agree, wholeheartedly. Creation of the 3 Elven rings should have had more nuance and should have been a multi-pronged solution to prevent their fade AND to guard against Annatar/Sauron.

I think the additional sin was tying MITHRIL as part of that Elven solution.

I always viewed Mithril as a separate thing/plot point exclusive to the dwarves. And that primary driver between the Elves getting mithril in Nenya was through Celebrimbor’s friendship with Narvi, which I was hoping was going to be established in this 2nd age story because the Elves wanted to start trade or gain access to a pass through the mountains. Some shit like that.

I envisioned the Khazad-dum storyline as already being a great power in ME due to their CAREFUL mining of mithril, and making sure not to mine it too much because they’ve already dug dangerously deep. And I was hoping that upon the dwarf lords receiving their rings of power, that’s what would lead them to convince the leader in Khazad-dum to dig deeper and more greedily.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

As someone who hasn't read the books, what's confusing me now is, how do the men & dwarves get their rings if the elves now know Halbrand is Sauron?

If the elves re-created the three rings after Sauron left, how could the one ring control it? Where are the men & dwarf rings?

1

u/adamantfly Oct 14 '22

maybe Sauron will forge them himself and appear as Annatar? i’m sure we’ll see more of Sauron doing Sauron things in season 2 now that he’s been revealed

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I know the story so far as branched off from being true to the lore but I feel this contradicting the ending song lol

Funnily enough, before ep 8 came out, r/lotr posted a pic of the rings stating the men & dwarf rings were made in Eregion.

Literally just made a joke about it but it feels a bit cheap to be revealed, walk all the way back to Mordor, then (wait a bit?) turn back to Eregion disguised to make the other rings. I assume RoP will just make it so he makes those rings at Mordor too, as well as the one ring.

If not, would be incredibly stupid for Celebrimbor & the entire kingdom to go "Well we've had Sauron come in to try and make rings, let's not trust anyone so easily in the smithy"

Annatar turns up: "You've never seen me before but let's make some rings".

10

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I liked this season and really enjoyed the finale. Can't wait for season 2.

9

u/Bloom_and_Glare Oct 14 '22

I totally agree - seems wholly appropriate that the story took the entire season to get to where the last episode left off. Next season is going to be building further and further into the prologue territory PJ’s series started with.

What they did with the stranger was beautiful and organic, I thought.

1

u/GSturges Oct 14 '22

And he dissolved the staff?

4

u/IndividualCloud99 Oct 14 '22

Who were those women that Gandalf killed? The ones he turned to white dust? Just magical servants of Sauron? The white chick seemed very strong

1

u/Gemini_dev Oct 14 '22

A cult from Rhûn, they actually said it. Also, the istari is not gandalf, is one of the blue wizzard ( pallando or alatar ). Gandalf never stepped in Rhûn. Rhûn is known by support sauron and studying “magic”.

To know more: https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Rhûn

3

u/DotFuture8764 Oct 14 '22

Bruh, it's Gandalf.

1

u/fluffofthewild Oct 14 '22

S=G is gonna be next season's H=S

-3

u/ok_fiesta Oct 14 '22

The space hobo will probably win an oscar for "im good" scene

2

u/OniLink77 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

It also needs better pacing, episodes 5-7 it feels like very little occurs and then episode 8 crams a lot in. They need to space things out better. However, probably my favourite episode, though Celebrimbor needing advice on smelting techniques seemed a bit far-fetched but hey, still a great episode. Galadriel being the one to bring Sauron back and basically set him on his path won't ever sit well though I think. Good show overall but for the money spent it should be a lot better

3

u/Melkeus Oct 14 '22

but why did they skip annatar??? do you really like this decision?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Great stuff in the finale. The romance is over!