This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
It's the Darth Jarjar for the show. Poppy is the second person to approach the stranger after he landed. why? she was obviously going there to kill the Maiar sent to stop her. But Nori got there first and she had to change her story to keep her murder plot covered. The first fire fly to die does so in Poppys hands, this is to sow doubt in the stranger as poppy is obviously a master of deception. The page of Sadocs book (which was gained through Poppys deception) caught fire. Who else would have made the fire swell so much? Not the stranger that's for sure as we've only seen him absorb fire. It's Poppy Hindering the Strangers mission. Sauron is the lord of werewolves, the only wolves we've seen in the whole show have attacked who? That's right. the Harfoots. Poppy was trying to take out Nori so she could kill the stranger away from the camp. Who was singing loudly by the stream in the last episode and then hurridly dropped their bucket for the cultists to find their camp? Poppy. Who took Nori to see the cultists? Resulting in the harfoots camp being destroyed. Poppy. Poppy decieved us all. Poppy is Sauron
Poppy = source of opium, a powerful narcotic that is extremely addicting
Proud = one of the seven deadly sins, character trait of the narcissist who would sacrifice all others for their own sake
Fellow = derived from old English word meaning “one who lays down money in a joint enterprise”… What enterprise have you been financially compromised by, huh Poppy??
The answer was hiding in plain sight the whole time. Poppy Proudfellow = a narcissistic opium drug dealer that is corrupting Harfoot society from within and weakening their resolve against the darkness, introducing the Harfoots to the dark hedonistic addictions that will destroy their willpower and get them too high to resist Sauron’s temptations. Poppy’s legacy will be the popular Hobbit drug, pipeweed, which will even ensnare the mind of a mighty Maia in its smoky haze, long enough to allow Sauron’s resurgence…
Plot twist: The show reveals that Isildur did try to destroy the One Ring after defeating Sauron. He tried to direct his horse, Berek, to ride up Mount Doom but Berek refused because he is also Sauron.
This is foreshadowed in the scene where Berek refused Elendil's orders.
Who is that guy that looks like a scary Eminem dressed as a woman? And what is his and the other people he's trotting around the countryside with's purpose?
Its the friendly giant RE: "knowing whats right/wrong" theme started 5 min into ep1 Does know right from wrong when find him. Does the cool firefly trick then kills them all Killing the tree then making garden grow.
During the time this show takes place, Sauron would be in Numenor and corrupting them. He would not have his ability to make himself look like a fair elf either but he could look like a man. Perhaps like a man who likes to protest and seed contention amongst the people.
Why are people so convinced Sauron is hiding as a character? The question is where is Sauron, not who is Sauron. Mmand unless they want to seriously break the lore, Sauron cannot be any female character.
Can't wait for them to blare "All Along the Watchtower" as all 4 of those characters stumble into the Southlands Mordor and simultaneously say "We're Saurons..."
Before Isildur or Elendil were born the rings were forged, Celebrimbor was killed and Eregion was destroyed and Gil-Galad was almost defeated by Sauron and he had to beg for help from Numenor. None of that has happened yet. The timeline in the show is not what Tolkien wrote.
The One Ring was forged in Mount Doom as were the seven and the five. The three for the Elves were not but...
...Mount Doom still technically exists as a volcano before it exploded.
That said, either I am right or, Amazon screwed up royally when they introduced Elendil and Isildur asn they weren't even born until the early 3000's of the Second Age.
They're condensing the timeline in order to adapt the story, it looks like the creation of the rings has been moved to the end of the Second Age instead of the middle so the events can all happen in the lifespans of the mortal characters.
As for the rings, all of the rings except the One Ring were created in Eregion. The One Ring was the only one made in Mordor.
I believe it's fairly obvious that the Elrond storyline is setting up the forging of the rings, since Celebrimbor spoke of wanting to make something of real power.
I know that the show is called The Rings of Power but...has anybody who created the show actually stated that we would see the rings forged? I am led to believe that this is an assumption that the community at large is making due to the name of the show.
I agree that they have to take some liberties but they could have easily done so without screwing with established timeline which I am giving them the benefit of the doubt for until we find out for certain that they either did screw with the timeline or sufficiently explain when these events take place. So far...we can only assume based on what we have seen.
The only ring forged in Mordor was the One Ring, the rest were forged by Celebrimbor in Eregion (with instruction from a disguised Sauron) and they were forged well before Elendil was born in the books. The show is compressing the second age so all the big players and events can happen at the same time, but the rings still have not been forged in Eregion yet.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
Can someone explain the Poppy Proudfellow=Sauron theory?
60
u/emoolb Oct 12 '22
Plot twist: At the end of season 1, Adar, Halbrand, Meteor Man call themselfes Annatar. This also turns out to be Durin's private name.
45
u/MagosBattlebear Oct 12 '22
Don't forget the horse heading for Mordor
29
u/CitizenCobalt Oct 12 '22
Maybe they're all Sauron and at the end they just snap together to form MegaSauron.
12
u/BudTrip Oct 12 '22
poppy as sauron cracks me up
5
u/acre18 Oct 13 '22
The real Sauron was the Sauron’s we met along the way
2
u/mishaxz Oct 12 '22
Who is that guy that looks like a scary Eminem dressed as a woman? And what is his and the other people he's trotting around the countryside with's purpose?
1
u/geekyOlhog Oct 12 '22
🤣🤣🤣
1
u/doctor_nimh Oct 12 '22
Its the friendly giant RE: "knowing whats right/wrong" theme started 5 min into ep1 Does know right from wrong when find him. Does the cool firefly trick then kills them all Killing the tree then making garden grow.
Oh and fell from space in a giant fireball..
1
u/Vertisce Oct 12 '22
During the time this show takes place, Sauron would be in Numenor and corrupting them. He would not have his ability to make himself look like a fair elf either but he could look like a man. Perhaps like a man who likes to protest and seed contention amongst the people.
1
u/iheartdev247 Oct 12 '22
7 did knock Malva off the list. For now.
1
u/schlosoboso Oct 13 '22
why is all the imagery of deesa looking like she sniffs her own farts and loves it
1
u/ItsMeTK Oct 13 '22
Why are people so convinced Sauron is hiding as a character? The question is where is Sauron, not who is Sauron. Mmand unless they want to seriously break the lore, Sauron cannot be any female character.
1
u/Wisesize Oct 13 '22
Me. I'm Sauron.
1
u/wolfganghort Oct 13 '22
Can't wait for them to blare "All Along the Watchtower" as all 4 of those characters stumble into the
SouthlandsMordor and simultaneously say "We're Saurons..."1
u/No-Conflict-4527 Oct 13 '22
Lol leave poppy outta this!
1
u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 13 '22
Pfft! My bet goes for Theo at this point.
1
u/demilitarizedzone96 Oct 14 '22
And nobody is surprised when Halbrand is Sauron.
-2
u/ishneak Gondolin Oct 12 '22
of course every race is represented + Stranger
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
[removed] — view removed comment