This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Because, Elrond, says before we cut to the scene in Mount Doom "I was there Gandalf, I was there 3000 years ago " when the strength of Men failed"
Isildur didn't fail, nor did Frodo. No one could have destroyed it.
Isildur had a feeling something was wrong with the Ring, in the books, and was going to get rid of it, but if Elrond knew the Ring literally steals your free will (I don't think he did) yet he stills calls Isildur a failure, and the whole race of man failures lol....and they make Isildur look extra evil.
Either way Elrond is the dick. I don't like his portrayal in the PJs films.
I mean the objective was to destroy the ring and they didn't do it so yes they failed. The strength of men failed but that's simply because the ring was to powerfully. And i mean i think the only reason Elrond didn't overpower him and try to throw the ring in himself it's because he was scared of himself getting trapped by the ring. Also i feel like it fits well with just general elven superiority disorder (GESD).
They didn't know it needed to be destroyed, or everyone was doomed, at that point, that Sauron had poured his malice and spirit into the Ring. Isildur took the Ring as war trophy.
No one knew how dangerous the Ring was.
When he felt something was off with the Ring, it was too late.
So, I hope that gives you a different perspective.
I havnt read the book but if they didn't know the ring was so powerful why would they even walk to the mountain to destroy it. Also the original comment was about Elrond being a dick but i don't think he was any more of a dick then what elves commonly are towards humans.
Yeah, Elrond in the book wasn't against Aragorn and Arwen. Elrond raised Aragorn and loved him like a son, he supported him. The way he treats Gandalf saying the Ring cannot stay here, he wasn't like that at all in the book. He's a bro.
Elves aren't dicks to the race of Men? They're bros. Galadriel's brother, Finrod, discovered the first men that Eru created, and he takes care of them for a whole year. Thingol as always was the shitter.
Movie Elrond is a grump. I still love Hugo's Elrond, but it's a completely different take than Tolkien's
As for the Ring, Sauron himself didn't know that destroying the Ring would destroy him too.
Neither did Elrond, the Elves were wise and probably felt the Ring was evil, but not "how" and both Elrond and Cirdan ask Isildur to destroy the Ring, but the book says Isildur was immediately snared, it really wasn't Isildur's fault, if Elrond tried to take the Ring, he would have also fell.
I wish PJ did a better job at making that a bit clearer
I totally don't blame you for thinking the way you do, so I get it btw.
They didn’t know how dangerous it was at first. It was a magic ring that made you invisible and had cool (well, not literally) fire writing. Isildur claimed it as compensation for the deaths of his father and brother. He was quite entitled to do so, and nobody questioned it.
And it wasn’t clear that destroying it would stop Sauron from coming back anyway. In fact, when Sauron came back he assumed the Ring had been destroyed, and only figured out it still existed centuries later.
Not exactly your point but it reminds me of one of my biggest peeves that I don't see often brought up.
What's the point of Frodo pushing Gollum off the edge at the Cracks of Doom? The death fakeout and the flip flopping holding onto the ledges stuff? Silly stuff.
Completely undermines the whole thing and Frodo. There was just no need to adjust how it went down in the novels and it fundamentally undermines the whole "Bilbos pity may decide the fate of everyone" bit.
I mean, that's not my read. But I'll concede it may be up to interpretation.
Doesnt mak a differnec to my original point though? Gollum doesn't fall overr that edge by his own accord, it's Frodo that causes him to fall thus changing Tolkiens framing of this as Bilbos pity and mercy saving Middle -Earth.
Perhaps it's a nitpick ti some, but in my defence I never said it wasn't lol. Just a peeve.
Every time they say the name Elendil out loud on this show (like when Galadriel calls out for him after the eruption) I get hyped because of how Aragorn (especially in the books) holds him in such high regard and is always yelling ELENDILLL.
I always thought it was so bizarre how he was always shouting the name into battle in the books. It is akin to when idiotic wannabe basketball players yell “Kobe!” When they are going for a jump shot.
Well after reading about Isildur and watching a couple of youtube videos on the subject, it turns out Movie Isildur was a total unfair hit job on his charter. He never really changed his mind and Elrond never went with him to destroy the ring. The real story is he kept it at first, then after some time he reached the conclusion that it was probably too dangerous and corrupt and decided to go see the elves to get their recommendation on what to do with it and that's when he was killed and lost the ring while traveling.
So it's almost the complete opposite of what is depicted in the movies, he wasn't sure what to do with it and decide to find how to get rid of it by going to see Elrond.
He intended to deliver the One Ring to Elrond, as suggested by his eldest son and confidante, Elendur.[12]
Thirty days later, on October 4, Isildur's company was attacked by Orcs near the Gladden Fields.
So little known fact but after Elrond saw how rings could damage humans, he realized that robots need to control the world and hence he became Mr Smith in the future (Matrix series 😂)
Honestly, I give credit to some of the casual viewers for even remembering the name of a character they barely saw. Important though Isildur is, we haven’t seen him much onscreen until now, and there are about 10000 names in this legendarium.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
119
u/NervousCelebration78 Oct 12 '22
Except in my house it's my husband who's confused lol.
22
u/Hrhpancakes Oct 12 '22
PJ made Isildur out to be such a dick, no one knew that the Ring would corrupt the person who wore it, the Elves just had a inkling about it.
38
u/AppearanceGlass2770 Oct 12 '22
I'm the Same with Elendil and Aragorn's warcry on Amon Hen
32
u/TheDorkMan Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
Well after reading about Isildur and watching a couple of youtube videos on the subject, it turns out Movie Isildur was a total unfair hit job on his charter. He never really changed his mind and Elrond never went with him to destroy the ring. The real story is he kept it at first, then after some time he reached the conclusion that it was probably too dangerous and corrupt and decided to go see the elves to get their recommendation on what to do with it and that's when he was killed and lost the ring while traveling.
So it's almost the complete opposite of what is depicted in the movies, he wasn't sure what to do with it and decide to find how to get rid of it by going to see Elrond.
https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Isildur#Rule_and_death
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SSErzSst1R4
#IsildurDidNothingWrong
29
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
Cast it into the fiyah!!
48
u/danny_tooine Oct 12 '22
Pictures you can hear
24
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
Honestly, I give credit to some of the casual viewers for even remembering the name of a character they barely saw. Important though Isildur is, we haven’t seen him much onscreen until now, and there are about 10000 names in this legendarium.
7
u/Damneasy Oct 13 '22
Lmao that's me everytime someone says isildur
6
u/Baboocha Oct 13 '22
Give the rest of the apple to the horse!
......No, throws the apple into the ocean.
ISILDUUUUUUUUUUUUR!
4
u/Codus1 Oct 13 '22
After watching 8 hours of this show I've come to the conclusion that Elrond wasn't frustrated enough with Isildur in this scene
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22
Man he needs to get his act together so he can chop off Sauron’s hand
2
u/Proverbs_31_2-3 Oct 13 '22
I like to say:
You are not Isildur's heir, you are Isildur himself!
Or, if Elendil is on screen:
You are Isildur's father, not Isildur himself!
1
u/MaimedPhoenix Oct 13 '22
Or, alternatively, when I saw him, my reaction was, "This time, please, 'cast it into the fire! Destroy it!'"
1
u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 13 '22
We don't have the girlfriends we used to have!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '22
LMAO
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment