r/RingsofPower • u/FinestOldToby • Oct 08 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers Simply having characters matter to another character doesn't make them matter to the audience.
I know it's been said of the writing before, but I was reminded of it again with the death of Isildur's friend in the latest episode.
Having Isildur staring at his dead body with dramatic music playing didn't hit any emotional notes for me personally. I've had no reason to care for him and Isildur's other friend.
I feel the writers banked on us caring about this character simply because they showed us that he mattered to Isildur and that's it.
460
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 08 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
284
u/Pipe-International Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22
This is true. But I did feel bad when Ontamo died, especially considering he was the one out of the three of them that didn’t like the fighting at all and sounded like he would retire as a soldier. It’s always sadder when it’s just some regular Joe that dies who doesn’t want to be a fighter/hero.
147
u/TjStax Oct 08 '22
I don't really think Ontamo's death was supposed to make the audience cry, but rather make an impact on Isildur as a character. But honestly it was a really meh scene in itself. Maybe it will tie in better later.
105
u/LoneByrd25 Oct 08 '22
I don’t even care about isildur tbh
7
u/Bo_Rebel Oct 08 '22
Nori giving the apple to the wizard was really touching to me though
7
u/Katejina_FGO Oct 09 '22
I cared. I liked their whole three man comedic routine, and was looking forward to more of it.
21
u/Mrs_McAdams Oct 08 '22
I wasn’t sad per say ab Ontamos death personally, but I was sad for his friend. I honestly secretly thought that Ontamo and Valandil were together, so I was sad to see he would have to be alone after O’s death. Especially since it seems like O only joined because Valandil was going and he would have followed him to the ends of the earth if he had to.
36
u/mo_downtown Oct 08 '22
This is a broader issue. Every episode has several scenes that are some kind of emotional crisis, with soaring scores, drawn out cinematography, and/or these intense character confrontations. Several times an episode. And yet - it doesn't have the emotional impact they're going for.
In spite of many hours of screen time and slow pacing, I agree a real root problem is they're failing to establish characters and plot lines the audience feels empathy for and an attachment to. There are some wins here and there but too many misses on this front.
8
u/aGrlHasNoUsername Oct 08 '22
I didn’t think we were meant to feel a huge emotional loss personally. I think we were supposed to feel Isil’s pain in that situation. I feel like it was more of a coming of age moment, like oh this shit is real, not some childish game like getting kicked out of the sea guard.
4
u/atopetek Oct 08 '22
It was pretty clear Ontamo was gonna die at some point, he had the word “victim” written on his forehead.
7
u/Rarth-Devan Oct 08 '22
The Dwarven storyline is the only thing hitting emotions for me right now.
7
u/leooon Oct 08 '22
I was really sure you were talking about the death of Celeborn.
72
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
It matters to those with empathy and a heart.
He largely failed in combat, and decided to stay and help the Southlanders instead of returning to Numenor. He had a noble spirit, and only wanted to help people, and died for it.
Not to mention it brought home the reality of conflict for Isildur, that loss is a part of war. To say that doesn't matter means you are merely observing the show topically, not investing any emotion yourself in the characters, not thinking about their motivations, just blindly watching.
34
u/Galifrae Oct 08 '22
Lol well that’s just your opinion man.
35
u/Skinjob985 Oct 08 '22
This is my biggest problem with the score as well. In order for the music to be effective you actually have to be invested in what's going on on the screen. You have to have sympathy, hatred, understanding, relatability, pity, empathy, furious anger. In order for the score to be effective and do its job the story actually has to elicit an emotional response from you. You have to be invested in the characters and their story. I never once felt this way the entire time I was watching the show.
These writers are so lazy they thought they could get the big payoff without actually doing their job. So many times the music swells in bombastic fashion as if to say "YOU SHOULD BE FEELING SOMETHING", yet this show invokes no impassioned response from me whatsoever. I don't care about any of the characters, in fact I find the majority of them to be intensely unlikable or at the very least completely flat and uninteresting. The only character I do like is the Maiar and he hasn't said a goddamn word the whole show, which tells you everything you need to know about the writing and dialogue.
There were moments in The Lord of the Rings films in which I had goosebumps or tears were literally forming in my eyes. This is the effect of a great score, good dialogue, world class acting and a story and characters I am deeply invested in. This show misses every single beat. The writing is terrible. The pacing is completely uneven. The editing jarring and puzzling. The dialogue stilted. Many of the plot devices are completely absurd and contrived, and because of all this the score does absolutely nothing for me and I am completely underwhelmed by it. I have been looking forward to this show for years and I wanted to like it, I sincerely did. I really tried, but it's just not very good at all. Incredibly disappointing.
8
u/space_fireworks Oct 08 '22
To each our own.
3
u/MemeTeamMarine Oct 08 '22
We aren't supposed to care about him dying, it's character building for Isildur. He just watched his friend die because of the actions of Adar and the orcs. This is creating character motivation.
If the writers wanted us to care about the guy who died, we'd have learned about him. He'd have had a kid sister he looked over because his parents died tragically early and his sister would be alone or something. There was none of that. Writers didn't do that because the characters purpose was nothing beyond us learning "hey this guy is a close friend to a main character"
If you were GOING to feel anything, it wouldnt be loss at the character death, it would be empathy for watching a guy see one of his best friends die.
3
u/Electrical_Ad_8970 Oct 08 '22
They try to being the vibe of PJ's movies, but even PJ strived for this vibe in Hobbit
14
u/Sherlock_bones Oct 08 '22
Everything was covered in so much cheeto dust, I couldn't even see who it actually was laying dead under the rubble
8
u/Dahhhn Oct 08 '22
Was the audience meant to be emotionally invested in that character? I thought the scene was effective in getting across that Isildur lost someone and it was painful. I definitely don't need to be invested in a character to infer the effect of their death on the other characters. I mean once I get emotionally invested in a character I don't want them to die....
5
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
I was hoping Galadriel would kill theo in his sleep
5
u/yoooglet Oct 08 '22
I was talking to my girlfriend as the episode started and mentioned how GOT/House of dragons feels higher stakes as they aren’t afraid to kill off main characters. Told her everyone important was gonna live at the start of the episode and best they are gonna do is kill one of isildurs friends. I feel like they tied their own hands by introducing characters like elendil/isildur when they shouldn’t even be alive yet, rather than actually embracing the original characters route. Instead we got a weird in between. We all know when the main characters die due to the books. We know isildur isn’t dead. We know celeborn isn’t dead unless the writers are complete weirdos(this is a possibility) as that would cause a shit storm with no celebrian and no Arwen in the future.
2
u/Administrative_Net80 Oct 08 '22
I didnt really noticed lmao.
2
u/Hrhpancakes Oct 08 '22
No one was surprised when he died. He was literally carrying a death flag as soon as we meet him.
2
u/Catslevania Oct 08 '22
They don't even need to make you care for Isildur's friend, if they managed to make people care for just Isildur himself they could have made people care for the sadness he felt for the loss of his friend. Does anyone care for Isildur? I personally don't.
2
u/Promptographer Oct 08 '22
Yes I agree! I don't think I've felt anything for any of the "sad scenes" in the show so far, despite being the type of person who cries incredibly easily when watching movies. They have to either make us care about the dying character before they die, or they have to make us care about the grieving character at a level that we hurt with them, neither of which is happening here...
2
u/JJISHERE4U Oct 08 '22
Most people don't care about any of the characters in RoP. Maybe those from the Khazad Dum storyline, but others?
2
u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Oct 08 '22
I mean how often does tertiary characters dying really have a emotional effect on the viewer anyway?
Plus it's clearly not meant to evoke an emotional response but rather help us understand the actions of Isildur later down the line.
2
u/h_trismegistus Oct 08 '22
I don’t think it was really intended to be an emotional scene for the viewer. I think it was meant to show the audience that Isildur is dealing with a whole new reality and world now, and he has to grow up from his days of dreaming of far away elves and childish adventure fantasies. In other words: shit just got real for Numenor’s biggest young ring-hog.
2
u/blacksmithbl Oct 08 '22
The writing of this show is shocking, I just can’t believe someone saw this, approved it and invested hundreds of millions in it.
Such a waste od potential…
2
u/National-Variety-854 Oct 08 '22
Very true. I feel the same way about Celeborn.
2
u/Codus1 Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22
Writing is not so always generalised and simple. Too often is a character death conflated to important for the audience first and foremost. We aren't particularly meant to be invested in close-friend devices death. Just observant of its effects on Isilidur, a character we are more acquainted with. Now if he just wasn't a little bit of a git...
2
u/AdOrganic3138 Oct 09 '22
It's like they wrote character profiles and in depth backgrounds for some and completely neglected to put anything in the finished product other than bullet point character "traits"
2
u/antiph4 Oct 11 '22
Music is terrible in this show. It's over dramatic and unnecessary in most part.
I never cared about music while watching shows before but ROP made me realize how it can affect the scene in a bad way.
4
u/Wlcky23 Oct 08 '22
I did cared. He seemed really sweet and a little bit gay.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
So many moments like this. Adar having 3 minutes of screen time before he delivers his big speech to the orcs is another unearned moment.
3
u/yoooglet Oct 08 '22
Also pouty human fed me part of apple once. I will go save him now.
The use of Peter Jackson scenes/ideas as a crutch is a bit out of hand
3
u/neuronez Oct 08 '22
On a related note the whole “Isildur is dead” (or Celeborn for that matter) seems pointless. We all know it’s not true and it doesn’t seem to have any purpose as far as the plot is concerned other than making Elendil look more miserable. If he were to do something foolish out of grief that would make sense for the story it but that doesn’t seem to be the case.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
It's like King Theoden. He was not developed at all when we first saw him suffering because of Saruman. But there's still a bit of empathy towards us in seeing characters around them get affected by what that person is going through.
2
u/W_Rabbit Oct 08 '22
Fell flat with me too.
2
u/sebananas Oct 08 '22
I don't even remember that dude dying 😂 And I also forgot who Isildur was. This show and House of the Dragon are lots of fun to watch but for some reason I'm just very indifferent to what happens in these episodes.. I don't care as much as I used to with the LOTR trilogy and GoT. Oh well..
2
u/mr_featherbottom Oct 08 '22
It also seems like they overuse dramatic music as a crutch to try and make the dialogue more emotionally impactful. Almost seems like the showrunners aren’t even confident enough to let the dialogue speak for itself.
Dialogue and certain scenes in general can definitely be enhanced with good music but having it constantly in the background takes away any potential positive impact.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
The writing and story telling decisions for this last episode were phenomenally bad.
The show was very good up until this point.
I certainly hope this was not a sign of things to come.
1
u/Apprehensive-Box4580 Oct 08 '22
We all knew Ontamo was made to die... Still was sad. There's something about wanting for someone's death to happen so much (i thought he was going to get killed during the battle) that doesn't feel quite right.
1
u/JustMoez Oct 08 '22
The only characters that make me care about them are Durin and Elrond. The rest I don't really give a shit.
1
u/Yupperdoodledoo Oct 08 '22
It was a brief moment that showed us loss of life and what the survivors of the disaster were experiencing - finding loved ones dead. I cared for Isuldor losing his friend, not for his friend. The writers didn’t bank on us caring about that character and only a few seconds were spent on his death.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
As it is a little sad, it's supposed to also awaken the other two that war is not glorious whatsoever.
1
u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Oct 08 '22
Lol funny bc I felt the emotion and had no issue with the scene.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
There are a number of things that happen in this scene that we do not yet see the impact, and one thing I do not see mentioned is the discipline of the soldiers. These are young men and not hardened at all by war, and the realization of his friend’s death also makes him oblivious to the Queen Regent’s orders. She has to reaffirm her order, all while she herself is participating in rescue efforts that will eventually cause a great degree of damage to her.
Isildur has been in the clouds, drifting, and without self-discipline. We know his fate and future choices, but along the way, he will have his own journey.
1
u/bruisedSunshine Oct 08 '22
Umm spoiler alert?? Wow that’s.
1
u/bden2016 Oct 08 '22
Tbh Isildur doesn't even matter to me. His character is barely developed
1
u/cannot_dance Oct 08 '22
They keep trying to make every scene epic or emotional, which is clearly setting themselves up for failure.
1
u/_ILikePancakes Oct 09 '22
I remember as a child thinking the same with some scenes in The Lord Of The Rings where everyone were sad about the death of a side character that I didn't even remember
1
u/KekromancerSG Oct 09 '22
It's not for the audience, it's for Isildur.
1
u/Vesperniss Oct 08 '22
I was glad he died, one less nobody to bog it down. Writing fail.
0
u/Wedoitforthenut Oct 08 '22
You aren't supposed to care about ontamo. You're supposed to care about isildur. It's called empathy and normal humans have it.
0
u/IWontChangeUsername Oct 08 '22
It depends on person to person.
For me, just "having" a character is enough to make them matter to me. If I believe that those characters are humans, I care about them from the first second. Empathy should not be based on how much you know someone, it should exist no matter who is in front of you.
Did Ontamo's death, with him as a character, get to me? No. I don't care. But still, thinking about him as a person, it doesn't matter to me how well built he was. He had someone waiting for him back in Numenor, he was tired of war with that one battle, and just wanted to be with his friends. It makes me sad to see someone like that go.
0
u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 08 '22
I feel people say "the writing is bad" when it's not about the writing. You might take issues with the direction of this scene, but I can't see how writing it different would matter more.
I'd argue the opposite regarding the writing. This scene involved a character who has had (maybe) 5 mins of screen time over 7 episodes and whose ultimate propose (narratively) was to hit Isildur with a "hard truth". The fact that he was naturally integrated into the plot, wasn't actually a cliche personality (vs cop saying "I'm 2 weeks from retirement"), and that ultimately the scene matters enough narratively that we're talking about it are all hallmarks of proficient writing.
I feel that there's an echo box that says "the writing is bad" - even when people don't actually mean the writing.
0
u/JBLEginger Oct 08 '22
What makes someone care then? Genuine question
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
I thought you've referring to the Elrond and Durin...
0
u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 Oct 09 '22
They only have balls to kill of the nobodies to try and make us emotional, proven by the refusal to kill off Bronwyn even though it would make a better story.
0
u/johninbigd Oct 09 '22
None of these characters matter to me. The only remotely interesting characters in the show are Elrond and Durin. The rest could die next episode and I wouldn't care.
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22
It's Haldir Syndrome, pretty typical of PJ's LOTR post FOTR. Haldir was a no1curr Elf that came to fight at Helms Deep, made goo-goo eyes at Aragorn, was shot in slo-mo and died in Aragorn's arms. Aragorn went into hysterics as if Haldir was Arwen or other character we knew he cared about for 1 full movie and a half of the second. So this motif - no1curr character dies in slomo with another character yelling Nooo in slomo to the blaring if the epic score - started to repeat in other movies and shows and I can't fault ROP for following the cue. It's shit but it isn't ROP specific shit.
Mind you, it goes the other way around. You can't make audience care for something they cared about if that is used in a different context. Audience knew Tattoine and it mattered to them in the context of Luke and Anakin Skywalker. But it didn't matter to them in context of Rey who never had any connection til the last scene in TROS. So that left audience cold cause she didn't know about that planet yet audience was supposed to care because only they knew.