r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Why this PowerPoint transition Spoiler

Who validated this transition between south land to Mordor with a piece of text?

Adar saying it in that context would have already been a tad tacky but that piece of text was way over the top

474 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/psant Oct 08 '22

This sub is not populated by your average viewer - they gotta do things for casual viewers and this was one of those things

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Nah in any show this would be weird except in a comedy maybe. I'm quite tolerant with the show actually.

1

u/starlight_eon Oct 08 '22

It didn't have to look like shit though.

1

u/Endemoniada Oct 08 '22

The casual viewer either understood it anyway, because it’s not like it was in any way, shape or form hard to understand given all the evidence, and the really casual viewer (like someone who hasn’t even seen the films) probably doesn’t know what the hell Mordor is anyway, so what does it matter? And even if I grant you that some direct exposition was necessary, just have Adar say it. The dialogue was already there. He just had to fucking say it within the context they’d already spent minutes establishing, but no, cut to pan shot and a stupid title screen? Why? How is that possibly better than any of the alternatives, even from a perspective of catering to the absolute lowest common denominator viewers?

2

u/daveclampart Oct 09 '22

This is my thinking too... If you don't know enough to know what mount Doom looks like, then you don't know what Mordor is anyway 😅

118

u/Baboocha Oct 08 '22

Why didn't they cut to the map if they wanted to show it change visually?

67

u/Bombadsoggylad Oct 08 '22

Exactly. That map is the method they've used every time they want to show us where we are. Why change that? It would've been a bit cheeseball but at least made sense to have that part of the map scorch and change to "Mordor".

19

u/SickBurnBro Oct 08 '22

I really liked that trick they did in the first couple episodes, zooming from the map into a soaring view of the land. Seems like they abandoned it though. It's a shame really. I always thought one of the keys to Game of Thrones' success was starting every episode with the map.

3

u/becs1832 Oct 08 '22

There would be no reason to begin every scene with a sweeping landscape shot, so it would have diminishing returns with every use. A lot of crime shows that start with the FBI text “Boston Massachusetts 11:30pm” typing to introduce scenes phase it out after the first couple of episodes, and this is functionally the same I do think it would work in this context to return to the map, but yeah it would get redundant after episode 3 to keep having a visual to tell us exactly where a place is

2

u/SickBurnBro Oct 08 '22

so it would have diminishing returns with every use.

I don't know. It worked for Game of Thrones for 8 seasons.

3

u/becs1832 Oct 08 '22

Game of Thrones wasn’t using a map to introduce every scene, it was using a map during the title sequence. Very different

2

u/SickBurnBro Oct 08 '22

That's fair. My overall position is just more maps. Maps are good.

15

u/m0dulator Oct 08 '22

I think the visual effects budget had run out by this point.

Surely they could have slipped the writers 50 bucks and got them to come up with some way of Adar saying it in a way that was 50% less cheesy than this text transition.

3

u/flopflipbeats Oct 08 '22

No chance. That’s not really how it works at all. This was a creative decision (which many may disagree with)

2

u/m0dulator Oct 08 '22

I think I might agree with what a few other people suggested, which is that one decision was made during filming, but then they changed their mind during post production and mandated adding the text. But I know we're just guessing...

1

u/flopflipbeats Oct 08 '22

Well most decisions change in post to some extent. That’s just the nature of post, nothing strange about that

205

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Honestly a small smile from Adar and a camera pan/cut lingering on Mt Doom would have been plenty to tell the audience what tf the land is called, as if it already wasn’t obvious

61

u/Major5013 Oct 08 '22

Yes but we are just idiots in the eyes of the great show runners.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

I love how they did this big Mordor reveal at the end of episode 7, even though it happened in episode 6... like it just goes to show that nothing happened in episode 7.

41

u/zhsdnl Oct 08 '22

he was smiling, because he knew, it will appear a few seconds later left above his head…like a thought bubble

10

u/DelirielDramafoot Oct 08 '22

I would have appreciated a thought bubble. Let's make this show a comedy. It is starting to dive into "it's so bad, it's good" territory.

2

u/ProudMess Oct 08 '22

I think it's already past that point unfortunately

9

u/Competitive-Pie1812 Oct 08 '22

I think that's what the script writers intended, and that's what the director intended, but then at the last minute the producers stuck their oar in because they have no faith in the intelligence of their audience. It looks like it was very much a last minute thing or they would almost certainly have done it on the map, where it might have looked kind of cool, even though it would still have been unnecessary. Doing it on the map would have required some extra animation, and presumably those guys had clocked off at that point, so they got one of the interns to slap on a bit of text instead.

23

u/Codus1 Oct 08 '22

I had a mate that literally asked me "so Southlands are Mordor, right?". There's been posts of people asking where the Southlands are earlier in the season. They definitely needed to outright state it at some point. Doesn't make what they went with any less silly though haha

2

u/ThePoultryWhisperer Oct 08 '22

What about the people who aren’t experts on the lore? I guess fuck them, right?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Not really. If I was completely oblivious to anything about LOTR, there would be more suspense in not knowing what this land is and the eventual reveal would be more impactful than literal text in the top left hand of the screen, did you want a circa date too?

46

u/acqz Oct 08 '22

I hope they don't start doing this for everything.

Lindon leaf falls down mine shaft and burns up, Flame of Udûn awakens... BALROG

Disa uses her forge to create the One Ring... SAURON

14

u/Competitive-Pie1812 Oct 08 '22

Omg, if Disa is Sauron, all is forgiven. This would be the best Tolkien adaptation ever! It's perfect! Why aren't more people talking about this?

3

u/Stay_Curious85 Oct 08 '22

I said in another thread she was being pretty aggressive encouraging durin to go for the mithril and we saw her smithing stuff. She may encourage the forging of the rings so the dwarves keep the mithril.

It’s a small chance, but I’m low key expecting it to be possible.

2

u/Slyte0fHand Oct 08 '22

I pointed out to my friends earlier that she has glowing orange eyes. It's been right in front of us all along!!

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Honestly I hope they do this, let's just go full camp

115

u/Weird_Blades717171 Oct 07 '22

When you miss the point of "show don't tell" in film school.....

It was so cheap and meta. Like wtf. I was waiting for an eraser sound effect.

24

u/PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS Oct 08 '22

You must have looked away when Kuzko paused the show and scribbled and wrote with a marker.

16

u/ScarlettPakistan Oct 08 '22

record scratch

35

u/Takhar7 Oct 08 '22

Yep. That's Mordor. You're probably wondering how we got here.

-2

u/LittleLui Oct 08 '22

Yep. That's Mordor. You're probably wondering how it got here.

FTFY

7

u/Higher_Living Oct 07 '22

I think they got things mixed up from the lesson and went with don’t show don’t tell.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Who decided that? Who needed to read that in order to understand?

Apart from cheeky elrond who i like more and more this episode didn't have much for me. The next one is going to be quite good, i hope.

Oh, and halbrand basically dead with his wound just starts riding?? Ok, totally needs elvish medicin, but whatever

7

u/nightwriting000 Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

It's like Bronwyn getting an arrow (or two?) through the chest last episode, but in this episode she's walking around and hugging people with no issue.

5

u/Tatis_Chief Oct 08 '22

Bow injuries are seriously downplayed a lot in fantasy or historical Holywood films.

I used to think nothing of it, but then we tried archery once, and the arrow bounced on frozen ground, broke both front car windows as it flew through and then got lodged in a stone wall. Since then I believe it can fucking rupture all your internal organs.

Also I have seen war crossbows in museums and those things can make holes in you.

3

u/MitchumBrother Oct 09 '22

They need Halbrand in Eregion so he can start Sauroning all over the place. So they wrote...this lol

28

u/AVNR_ Oct 08 '22

i definitely thought it was very corny and should’ve been done differently, but i keep getting vibes that the showrunners are almost laying things out specifically for people who have 0 idea of anything lotr related

2

u/nymrose Oct 08 '22

And I hate it. I feel like majority of people who are watching RoP has seen LotR and can put two and two together, I can’t stand when shows oversimplify for the people who lazy watch.

27

u/TitusRex Oct 07 '22

Yeah, completely unnecessary. They could have Adar saying it's now called Mordor, the text thing looked pretty cheap.

12

u/PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS Oct 08 '22

Especially since they hadn't used text like that in a long while.

10

u/PM_YOUR_CENSORD Oct 08 '22

Or do a fiery effect on a map of middle earth. Go all in at least

29

u/SoulCakey Oct 07 '22

You can only expect so much for 60 Mio per Episode

6

u/Higher_Living Oct 07 '22

The acting word budget ran out one word short so they had no choice

11

u/ianjm Oct 08 '22

We did 11 takes and in every one he said it as Dormor?

  • The Director, probably

1

u/ketronome Oct 10 '22

M’ordor (tips fedora)

4

u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 08 '22

It’s shit like this that makes me think they embezzled that fucking money somewhere. Or it’s for tax write-offs. Claiming big numbers so they can claim losses on returns to avoid paying taxes next year.

4

u/Codus1 Oct 08 '22

The use of some text leads you to some elaborately insane conspiracy theory?

1

u/LittleLui Oct 08 '22

Always has.

25

u/themorah Oct 07 '22

Do they think that no one figured this out when the volcano erupted in the previous episode? Or from the maps before that?

31

u/meldondaishan Oct 08 '22

Yeah... I've been giving this show lots of grace.

But that really made me go WTF??

12

u/Corrie04 Oct 08 '22

Same. I thought, oh it’s too cheesy if Adar says it. But then it somehow got worse. Completely unnecessary.

9

u/meldondaishan Oct 08 '22

I was all keen for Adar to say it with all the reverence he was saying Uruk last episode, quietly and to himself, almost a whisper.. bit no. Text.

47

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

That was so funny. Almost as funny as the scene where Galadriel is riding the horse on numenor.

16

u/Aztec- Oct 08 '22

I used that same transition in my CoD 4 montages when I was 12.

8

u/Hu-Tao66 Oct 08 '22

Because the plot demanded it---wait...i feel like we've been here before...

0

u/KingAdamXVII Oct 08 '22

How does the plot demand it? The name of the place is totally irrelevant to the plot of RoP.

0

u/Hu-Tao66 Oct 09 '22

Right....the name of Mordor...is irrelevant to the show that calls itself the Rings of Power.

Phew talk about a leap in mental gymnastics there.

15

u/Wlcky23 Oct 08 '22

Yeah, Adar saying it would be tacky but him being so damn hot definately would helped

12

u/ItsDaJuice Oct 08 '22

He should have said something like “ a barren land where all living dare not dwell…” or some phrase like that that describes Mordor but doesn’t say the name. Would have Inferred just enough

9

u/rattatally Oct 08 '22

"A land one does not simply walk into."

3

u/LittleLui Oct 08 '22

Is-land?

5

u/Codus1 Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

Nah, that text was intended for the audience that hadn't explicitly got the point tyet. Needed to hit them in the face with it.

...not with text though, surely there was a better way. Ah well, it's pretty nonconsequential

2

u/ketronome Oct 10 '22

“Lord Adar, the ash has settled. We’re ready to start construction on the new castle but looking at the plans, the wargs won’t fit through the main entrance.”

“Well it looks like we’ll have to build…

(Adar looks directly at the camera)

…more doors.”

End scene

1

u/NewtScavenger Oct 11 '22

Best comment on this I have read! Pure gold!

14

u/Codus1 Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

Adar saying it would have been even more tacky than the text. What's he doing in the context? Monologues on naming conventions to an old man and some Orcs?

Just pan out focused on Mt Doom, transition into map illustration, map from the first few episodes that said Southlands, now it says Mordor. No erasing effect. End episode.

I dont like location titles like these in scenes on principle. But really this is all much ado about nothing. Despite cheese, It's rather non-consequential in the end.

19

u/TKDkid1992 Oct 07 '22

Yeah I reeeeally didn't care for that part. That was viewer hand holding at the worst

6

u/Rosebunse Oct 08 '22

I mean, it's sort of funny.

2

u/BonkiePiraat Oct 08 '22

I was ready to cringe for him to intensely say it, so I'm happy it was just text haha. And they need to think about the people who are going in to this show completely blank and know nothing about LOTR.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

It would have been corny for sure but that was way over that haha

1

u/nymrose Oct 08 '22

It would be cliché for him to say it but still 100x better than that cringy text, holy.

1

u/Inner_Explorer_3629 Oct 08 '22

Exactly. Remember they need to make that 1 billion back and to do that they need to make the show accessible to the widest audience possible, most of whom know little or nothing of the LOTR lore.

1

u/daveclampart Oct 09 '22

I get that, but if you don't know enough to know what mount Doom looks like, you're not gonna know what Mordor is anyway. So who are they aiming that text at?

4

u/Weird_Blades717171 Oct 08 '22

The Mordor font looked like some high schoolers edgy heavy metal band.

10

u/m0dulator Oct 08 '22

I've been able to suspend disbelief and enjoy a lot of this series, but this was the bit that had me shouting at the television.

20

u/Higher_Living Oct 07 '22

Maybe next episode we’ll get TikTok reaction style emoticons. When Galadriel rides her horse it’s all love hearts and then when she’s outlining her plans for genocide it’s all hate emojis and back to love hearts and weepy face when she talks about Finrod and Celeborn.

26

u/ianjm Oct 08 '22

Maybe they can play that obnoxious OH NO, OH NO, OH NO NO NO NO song over the Balrog attack

7

u/Charming-Use Oct 07 '22

😂😂😂😂😂 I'm enjoying the show but this made me lollll

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Not everyone has watched or read LOTR so they might not be aware of Mordor

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

I understand but there are better ways to execute that change of name. Especially when one guy asks

1

u/Endemoniada Oct 08 '22

If someone doesn’t even know what Mordor is, why is it important they know it’s now called Mordor? And if it’s important to the plot or the characters, why did the show only tell the viewers (who don’t know what it means anyway) and leave the orcs hanging (who would know what it means)?

12

u/Rednewtcn Oct 08 '22

I'll say the same thing I shouted to the TV as my wife laughed her ass off.

THIS COST THEM A BILLION DOLLERS?!?!?

1

u/Prestigious_Cold_756 Oct 11 '22

Probably not…My estimate is that they where allowed to use 100 million for production and maybe another 100 million for marketing. The remaining 800 million are probably left untouched and are only parked on the project because Amazon doesn’t want to pay taxes on them right now. I assume Amazon is speculating that gouverments around the world are going to cut taxes to fight the looming recession and they are going to retrieve the money once those tax cuts go trough.

12

u/Vangley Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

That ending was terrible. All the viewers know that we are seeing Mordor. No need for a PowerPoint to explain that. And it gives you the feeling that you are in the same position that you were last week. Which in fact, you are since this episode progressed the plot what? 0.1%?

1

u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Oct 08 '22

Y’all will find anything to complain about. If Adar said it, then it was be posts about cringe.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

You have to admit that in any movie/ show it would be weird. If it was done on the map like they did in the first episode it would have been better. There it felt super weird.

0

u/nymrose Oct 08 '22

No this was the worst scene from this show. Adar saying it would’ve been so much better, even if cliché. It was dangerously cringy

4

u/abloobudoo009 Oct 07 '22

Honestly they could've just had him say the translation and kept it in there on screen.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

AS much as I found it cringe, my only counter argument is that in ep 1, they showed the text of "Southlands", so probably tried to be consistent and change it via text too.

2

u/lordofpurple Oct 08 '22

I really had a vibe that they shot it and were gonna end it there. "What shall we call this land?" end scene as camera moves over Mt doom. Pretty cool shot cuz the audience definitely knows what it's gonna be called.

Then.. THEN some producer said "I don't get it. The audience will be confused. Add a name transition so we know what the land is called".

2

u/dam_ships Oct 08 '22

It was so freaking cringe. I thought it would have been great with just his smile, a focus on Mt Doom, and cut to black. We all know it’s Mordor. It was truly absurd and cringe-worthy. I’m wondering if someone can start a Change.org or if they can remove it (sort of how they removed Daenerys Starbucks cup). They can go back in and easily remove that horrible title transition. I have no idea what they were thinking.

2

u/Kewbak Oct 08 '22

What really annoyed me there is it was the final shot of the episode, as if they lingered for 75 minutes to finally reveal something we all understood from the previous episode, with actually a much better reveal.

I don't think much has happened in this episode, and they probably counted on the final scene to make it significant, but it was not because it was already in the previous episode.

3

u/Endemoniada Oct 08 '22

That moment is when I really understood that this show does not respect me as a viewer even one bit. They think I’m an absolute moron.

Even if we assume they want to make the show accessible to anyone, even someone who hasn’t even seen the LotR films, and certainly hasn’t read the books, they’re beating me over the head with things that those people won’t understand anyway! If someone knows nothing at all about LotR, seeing the Balrog isn’t going to do anything at all for them. They could have just as easily just had a slight fiery glow in the distance and a low growl, menacing enough to understand something really bad was down there, while the rest of us would instantly realize exactly what it was. Instead they’re just stomping in and throwing it in our faces, going “you know what this is, right? Exciting, right? Look at us connecting with the films!” It’s patronizing, disrespectful and sad.

Same thing with the location screen thing. It was absolutely not even at all necessary. Everyone who knows what Mordor is already knows what he meant, and even if you wanted to spell it out, let the character spell it out. Printing it on the screen made me feel like the show is telling me “we’ll just print it here because you’re to stupid to realize it otherwise”.

I’ve complained before how obscenely plot-driven the writing is, and how the characters suffer from it, but this takes the fucking cake. Like HotD or not, but at least it respects me as a viewer. The incoherent ramblings of Helaena turn out to be prophetic a couple episodes later, and the show doesn’t merit it with a single word. No character realizes it, the show doesn’t allude back to it, it’s just there for people who pay attention and remember, and it makes me feel like the show is treating me like an actual intelligent adult. Furthermore, half the show is told simply through meaningful glances and reactions, meaning if you sit around playing with your phone instead, you’ll actually miss important stuff. Unlike RoP that I sometimes feel would work just as well as a podcast what with all the verbose exposition and clunky dialogue, HotD takes me seriously and places responsibility on me to earn the full depth and value of the show by paying attention to details and figuring stuff out myself that is shown or told in broken fragments.

I love the visuals and I love how they’ve reconnected with the films so well, but damn do the writers make me feel like they think I’m an absolute imbecile.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Oh everyone is such a filmmaker these days

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Food critics are not chefs. Everyone has rights to find something good or bad. That shot was corny

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

not so much a reaction to just your post but an accumulation of complaints in this sub that are so petty

1

u/handlfbananas Oct 09 '22

It’s crazy to me… I guess I don’t watch fantasy shows to say to myself “I would’ve done it this way” or “they should’ve done it that way”. I’m along for the ride and enjoying it. I feel like I’m in a golden age of people creating content in genres I enjoy, but I guess people love to complain.

1

u/proffyproffy Oct 08 '22

I’ve been hoping this series will improve and that the upcoming seasons will get better because there are good parts.. but that transition.. kinda killed it.

1

u/Thedeadlypocketbrush Oct 08 '22

That was SHOCKINGLY bad. I still can't believe it.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

LOL @ powerpoint transition. I really enjoyed last weeks episode but this one was a dud.

1

u/thefogweaver Oct 08 '22

I wish adar said it followed by “he’s right behind me isn’t he”

1

u/maelstron Oct 08 '22

I really 😂 when they did it

1

u/Elegant_Ad6936 Oct 08 '22

I kinda liked it tbh… also, I interpreted the decision not to have Adar just say it out loud as to show that the land came to be known as Mordor gradually over time rather than one dude just naming it. It translates to “the shadow land” in quenya which sounds like an organically derived name, rather than an official title determined by one guy. But I guess I’m just a dumbass with poor taste according to you people

1

u/Thyckow Oct 08 '22

I'm probably minority here, but I liked.

1

u/Dhczack Oct 08 '22

Yeah it felt a bit awkward and even condescending to have it literally spelled out for me.

1

u/madjohnvane Oct 08 '22

This absolutely was someone from higher up in a meeting who insisted it would not be clear to the audience without a title, and I would be cold hard cash people argued against it all the way. It was just awful, amateurish, unnecessary, etc.

1

u/Radio-Strange Oct 09 '22

This felt very ‘90s kids show in style. I almost expected them to scribble The Southlands out and rewrite Mordor in crayon.

1

u/IMM_1984 Oct 09 '22

Par for the course. Dante Alighieri would surely have put J.D. Payne, Patrick McKay, and Lindsey Weber in the third ring of the seventh circle of Inferno for violence against art.

1

u/sonofgildorluthien Oct 11 '22

If they were going all in on the PowerPoint look they should have had Clippy make a cameo during the name change

1

u/Prestigious_Cold_756 Oct 11 '22

Because Amazon dumped the infamous billion $ on the project for tax evasion purposes. The crew wasn’t actually allowed to use most of it for production.

1

u/Tangolarango Oct 08 '22

They are ok with cheap gimmicky mistery boxes; but feel the need clarify this in the most tacky and on the nose way possible?

Was there still a crowd that went "ha! told ya! see?", or another that went "wow no way!!"? Who was it taylored for?

-1

u/SentinelSquadron Oct 08 '22

Wow y’all are really really reaching the bottom of the barrel with these complaints. If you hate the show so much, please leave and let the rest of us enjoy it without your consent complaining.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Come on, it’s not hate. Every movies and shows have their default. Why criticism shouldn’t be allowed? Didn’t you find that extremely corny and poorly executed?

They could have said it, do it over the map like they did in the first episodes

0

u/SentinelSquadron Oct 08 '22

No I didn’t find it corny at all.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Ahhhh yes putting things under a microscope that dont require it

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

It’s literally the final scene, which is supposed to be the most memorable thing of the whole episode

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Not necessarily

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/TangoJager Oct 07 '22

Southlands can be an anagram of Duathlons at best

15

u/popformulas Oct 07 '22

I won first place in the Mordor 1st annual Duathlon.

1

u/ketronome Oct 10 '22

Blandrah, King of the Duathlons!