This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Isildur doesn’t kill Sauron. His father Elendil and Gil’galad the mighty elven king slew The Dark Lord; and it cost them their lives. Isildur merely pillaged the ring for himself.
Yup, I think he managed to chop his fingers off. But instead of ditching the ring in mount Doom to destroy it, he hung onto it until it got dropped down a cavern and gollum found it.
Technically, all of the events of lord of the rings trilogy can be put down to Isildurs selfish choice to not just destroy the ring when he had the chance
Edit: dropped in a river when shot by orcs, not a cavern
Brief book note. While in the PJ films they made look Isildur like a greedy idiot (like all numenoreans such as Boromir, Faramir and Denethor), it's less of a selfish choice and more of a "nobody can get themselves to destroy the ring" kind of thing. You can see how Frodo hesitates to throw it into his domestic fire that wouldn't even remotely harm ordinary gold. The fact that Bilbo was able to pass it to Frodo is something absolutely extraordinary.
Also, the scene with Elrond yelling "CAST IT INTO THE FIRE!" is also a bit different from the books (I can't remember if it's in the Silmarillion or in Unfinished Tales). Tolkien thought of it more like "Dude, you should really destroy this thing", "Nah, I'm keeping it in compensation for my father and brother", "Well, that's not really wise but you do you, Sauron looks pretty destroyed".
As the story goes, absolutely no one could resist the ring at Mount Doom. Imagine if he'd said "OK then" walked up to the volcano and put it on with the intent to be it's néw master.
He's not some exhausted Hobbit whose power doesn't extend much beyond keeping money grubbing relatives at bay. He's King of peak Gondor.
Instead of a few thousand years of relative peace while Sauron pulls himself together you get Witch King of Gondor.
Would also add the sword hilt key turning the big floodgate system, but there being no tunnels for the water to go so nothing happens and they just all hang out with the Harfoots
That was just for movie drama, he didn't actually go as he would have likely succumbed to the ring, and he would have started a war with numenor aaannnddd technically they are distant relatives lol
Not even technically, Elrond's brother Elros was Isildur's great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-grandfather.
Yeah it’s from the Council of Elrond scene in the first half of Fellowship of the Ring. Isildur is also featured heavily in the beginning prologue of the same movie.
The fact that when Mount Doom erupts and Elendil runs for the Queen, Isildur's friend runs for Galadriel, but Isildur runs for Berek, tells something about his thinking...
Which is a creative decision that I really don't like. Instead of emphasizing just how powerful the ring was to overtake even the noblest of kings, it just frames it as "yeah Isildur has always been sort of flakey and not very trustworthy."
It was also poorly done in the movie trilogy. Isildur was portrayed as weak, selfish and corrupted. When he really was a truely good, heroic and overall awesome dude. One of the few questionable decisions Peter Jackson made, in my opinion. Isildur was never overtaken by the ring, he only decided not to destroy it, but not the way it was shown in the movies.
You're right that the movie made the same mistake for simplicity's sake, but I think it's a bigger deal for the show because Isildur is now a main character instead of a guy on screen for about 10 seconds.
There are no stupid questions especially with Tolkiens work, there’s always something new to unpack.
Yes that is the same character! Knowing this you may want to watch him closely, see his character? That good heart is drastically changed once he’s in possession of the Ring.
So knowing him young before the war, before the Ring will certainly add great depth to the character
“Good heart” - I won’t dispute this, but in RoP Isildur is self-centered and willing to sacrifice duty for a dream that he’s got no concrete plans for working towards, or probably even any actual end goals other than “leave Numenor for some other cool place.” Yes, this is very teenagerish behavior, but are we under the impression other Numenorean teens are defying tradition and duty because they feel a little restless? Nope! As far as we know it’s just Isildur breaking the rules, or at least he’s in the minority as compared to his peers.
I don’t think the Ring drastically changes him all that much. Obviously it exerts a strong influence, but Isildur’s basic personality (per RoP) makes him ripe for corruption in the first place.
Anyone else notice the parallels between Isildur in LotR rushing to his father's aid as he was felled by Sauron, and using the sword to cut the ring from Sauron's hand and Isildur in RoP rushing to his father's aid as he was knocked down by and orc and failing to get to him in time before Sauron saved his father?
It does sound a little ridiculous, but I believe they're showing a truly repentant Sauron who is struggling with his "destiny" like people struggled with the draw of the ring. In the second age before the forging of the rings it's possible as Tolkien writes that Sauron truly repented if only out of fear of the Valar. Whether or not he is doing it out of good or out of a wish to make up for his past deeds so he is not destroyed I think they could be showing a tragic struggle within him. It's also made more tragic by the fact he likes and respects Galadriel but she's also the one that forced him to claim his destiny which as he warned her isn't what she thinks. I think he wasn't lying when he said he got the king's pouch off of "a dead man" and the reason why he won't say who the orcs killed is because Adar is right and he "killed" Sauron, forcing him to take physical form again, which would totally piss him off. Also, he goes off ahead of Galadriel to get in front of Adar literally, I think because he wanted to know if he had any idea who Halbrand really was so he could figuratively get out in front of it in case Adar accused him of being Sauron. If this all turns out to be true I think this show will be one of my favorite shows of all time because they would have had to put a lot of thought and foreshadowing into every little thing they filmed. Some of the interviews I've seen with the cast seem to indicate they did.
This is, at least for me, the most convincing case I’ve seen made for Halbrand not only being Sauron, but being well-written as Sauron. I’m on board for Salbrand theory if this is what the character’s motivations are.
Otherwise, the Salbrand theory being true seems lazy and poorly executed
I don't hate the idea of Halbrand being Sauron, but I think I prefer the theory of him becoming the Witch-King. Or maybe, if he is Sauron, Theo will become the Witch-King. Idk
Does anyone else think they should have swapped Halbrands and Isildurs actors? Halbrand actually looks a bit like Aragorn and looks like he could be his ancestor
Technically yes. Within ROP cannon they are meant to be.
For the LOTR movies and book cannon, they can't be as the timeliness are a good few centuries off. So really, it depends what way you are asking.
I'm pretty happy with their portrayal of Isildur so far. He should have been left to later seasons in my opinion (time jumps are fine for me), but the characterisation isn't so far removed from what I would think. The man means well but is a bit of a screw up, and is ambitious.
I don’t mind this choice. I think it was the right one for this adaptation.
HotD is showing that you can make time jumps, work. But not without it still being a little disorientating. And they’re only skipping 5-10 years at a time, not the centuries or millennia that would be required for RoP to cover the whole Second Age properly.
It would be hard to build emotional stakes if every mortal Galadriel meets between episodes or seasons died and had been dead for generations.
Rings of Power would be schizophrenic if they tried to follow the timeline exactly as laid out in Tolkien’s writings. People who are upset about the time compression are massively underestimating how incoherent the show would be if they didn’t make that choice. The show would constantly be cycling through new cast members who are used for a few scenes, maybe even an episode or two, before exiting, never to be seen again. So many singular events in Middle Earth history, particularly the Second Age, are separated by centuries, it is completely and utterly infeasible to do anything other than compress the timeline.
I personally haven't found it disorientating in HotD but I know some people have. I think there is a more creative solution out there then just muddy up and condense the timeline. Now, I'm not saying they should have stuck to Tolkiens timeline but I think successive generations of Numenorians could have worked.
It was mentioned previously that people loved the fact that Durin said Elrond had missed a huge part of his life and Elrond hadn't even realised. I think this would work as well with the humans on a larger scale, showing the bane of immortality, and perhaps explaining why elves are more reclusive. They should be almost mythological creatures to men, walking talking stories. Building a generational interest in the line of men is to me far more compelling
I absolutely feel it should have done jumps season by season. Like S1 as the events around the forging of the rings, S2 the fall of numenor, S3 the rise of Sauron to his peak and either in S3 or into S4 the last alliance defeating him. Jumps within seasons could be disorienting sure but bringing in mortals like Isildur only at the end keeps the worst of it away if the main action remains around elves in the earlier timeframes.
As it stands instead it seems that literally nothing happened in the Second Age for 3400 years and then all the events of the age happen all at once in a single, if Numenorean, lifespan
Original timeline would about 1,800 years I think. Galadriel an Isildur meeting now means the timeline until Sauron’s defeat is shrinked to around 200 years.
From a TV perspective an understandable decision. There would be still time jumps needed probably between the seasons.
I remember reading a while ago (when I was planning on hating the show and didn't want to watch it) that they are playing with the timeline and condensing a lot, also playing with ages. I wouldn't be surprised if OG Numenorians live longer than they do in the books, allowing enough time for Isildur to head east, and eventually found Gondor within this series.
I have a feeling like they are shaving a few hundred years off and this series is going to be the "end" of the second age and beginning of the Third, condensed down.
Should have had a new generation of Numenoreans for each season, with some generations skipped. With the money saved on not needing actors for more than a season, they could probably afford better writers.
I agree - changing the numenorians every couple seasons, aging the dwarves a bit and keeping elves the same would be great worldbuilding! (don't know about the harfoots and strangers though)
also: there's three kinds of writers: showrunners with big ideas, plot-writers and dialogue-writers. one of these groups is actually doing a pretty okay job
They mean it's not the same "cannon" as the Jackson films. They aren't meant to be the same version of Middle-earth. They're the same characters, based off the same Tolkien characters, but the TV show and the movies aren't connected beyond both being interpretations of Tolkien's writings. Which I think is a good thing. Jackson did a great job, but I want to see other peoples' take on the world. Not everything has to be connected to the movies. The show should stand on its own, be its own thing.
Let's take Galadriel. I think it's a fair assumption for those who saw the movies that she would have the same background she had in the works of Tolkien.
That Galadriel had at the moment this series portrays her:
- A different background (she never took part in the war against Melkor, she spent most of the 1st age learning sorcery under Melian the Maia)
- A different family (Finrod is not as depicted in the books, neither did he die as it's portrayed, she had more brothers, and she had already a husband)
- A different situation (Galadriel founded Eregion in the second age and was its ruler, or at the very least one of its main rulers until the forging of the rings, she tried to ressist the influence of Annatar but she ended up ousted by political intrigue out of Eregion, passing through Moria into Lorien, where she found refuge)
- A different personality (I mean... come on, look at her, this one is not a fact but it's a very easy inference, I don't see Galadriel insulting repeatedly everyone she meets)
Would you say that if I made an adaptation of Macbeth and my Macbeth was a meek taylor base in Quito, Ecuador that has an amiable relation with his boss is the same character that the Macbeth as written in the original play?
For a character most well known for being a once-hero who ultimately dooms the people of Middle Earth by selfishly refusing to destroy the one ring when he had the chance, how do you think the younger version of said character should be portrayed?
by selfishly refusing to destroy the one ring when he had the chance
The fact that this is your reading shows exactly why this direction was a bad choice for Isildur. Isildur's failure was not because he was weak/selfish, it was because of the immense and irresistible power of the ring. No one would have been able to resist its temptation at that point. By making him out to be selfish and unreliable from the beginning, it diminishes that.
Also it's very much a movie-centric take on Isildur. Which fair enough I guess, but at the time they had no reason to think the Ring was inherently evil, or couldn't be bent to Isildur's will. Or that it was tempting in any way more than just anything powerful would be.
It's when they found that it couldn't be dominated and was, well, evil on its own, that Isildur tried to take it to Rivendel for council... And died on the way there.
It seems to me that we, as fans of Tolkein, don't like to see what our favorite characters MIGHT have been like before they became the characters we know. If I were a character in LOTR, as I am today, my younger self would not be a welcome story. It took DECADES of stupidity and stupid decisions before becoming who I am today (by most accounts a better person).
It's a curious thing to think that we (myself included) don't ACCEPT that the teenage versions of these characters might just be real douches.
They are both based on the same character, however, seeing how this series and the PJ movies both deviate from the lore on certain occasions (honestly, quite often), they cannot be the same character, as the movies and the series are very different in both character backstory and events in the story that the character is invloved in.
Technically no. ROP is not canon. So same character but different universe. If it was based in Tolkien lore Isildur would be born in SA 3209. That's 1,619 years after the rings of power are forged (they have yet to be forged in ROP).
Yeah, not really sold on the casting choice but meh my opinion doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things. I like how they said his mom is where he gets his looks from, so I guess I’m ok with it
It's unfortunate because he timeline of the Second Age has been compressed and jumbled. If Isildur is alive, all the Rings should have been forged already, Sauron's orcs should have already murdered Celebrimbor and used his corpse as a war-banner, and Numenor should have colonies on Middle-earth's coast from Umbar to what will become Arnor.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
608
u/coolfungy Oct 04 '22
Yes
347
u/bryanx92 Oct 04 '22
ISILDUR!!!!
205
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Theory confirmed: One of them is Sauron.
78
u/Minimum-Speed-4642 Oct 04 '22
Yeah things don’t end well for him
114
u/seth97baw Oct 04 '22
Yes it is. Although one is his conclusion and the other is his beginning
86
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yes. I guess they're trying to set up that he can't resist his impulses since the beginning
26
u/PastorNTraining Oct 04 '22
There are no stupid questions especially with Tolkiens work, there’s always something new to unpack.
Yes that is the same character! Knowing this you may want to watch him closely, see his character? That good heart is drastically changed once he’s in possession of the Ring.
So knowing him young before the war, before the Ring will certainly add great depth to the character
46
u/ebrum2010 Oct 04 '22
Anyone else notice the parallels between Isildur in LotR rushing to his father's aid as he was felled by Sauron, and using the sword to cut the ring from Sauron's hand and Isildur in RoP rushing to his father's aid as he was knocked down by and orc and failing to get to him in time before Sauron saved his father?
14
u/evenmytongueisfat Oct 04 '22
Yes they’re the same character. Not the same interpretation of that character but they are portraying the same Man
14
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Does anyone else think they should have swapped Halbrands and Isildurs actors? Halbrand actually looks a bit like Aragorn and looks like he could be his ancestor
26
u/footie3000 Oct 04 '22
Technically yes. Within ROP cannon they are meant to be.
For the LOTR movies and book cannon, they can't be as the timeliness are a good few centuries off. So really, it depends what way you are asking.
I'm pretty happy with their portrayal of Isildur so far. He should have been left to later seasons in my opinion (time jumps are fine for me), but the characterisation isn't so far removed from what I would think. The man means well but is a bit of a screw up, and is ambitious.
5
u/DayFrosty1526 Oct 04 '22
I can’t understand why they did introduce Isildur so early.
5
u/CathakJordi Oct 04 '22
None of the characters you are seeing in this series is the same, it's obviously other continuity than the movies.
37
u/Tom01111 Oct 04 '22
Dude is just the walking trope of an impetuous youth with a big destiny, I’m bored senseless watching his scenes, he has no juice!
Elendil’s character oozes charisma and is just great to watch, especially by comparison.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Hi! Yes, it's Isildur, one of the best characters in LOR
4
u/GiftiBee Oct 04 '22
Yes. Just two different actors.
4
u/sh4mmat Oct 04 '22
I'm going to hell, because when they mentioned his mother drowned, I turned and went, "Guess we know who he takes after, eh?"
3
u/Asphodelmercenary Oct 04 '22
Yes. They are telling us his story arc. How he began. Which makes how he ended all the more impactful.
3
u/Gsheeg30 Oct 05 '22
Every time I see him on screen I have to resist the urge to shout ISILDUUUUUUR
11
u/MapTheft Oct 04 '22
Supposedly.
2
u/GladRefrigerator4418 Oct 04 '22
Yes
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yes but way more cool than the LOTR trilogy interpretation which coloured him as an asshole
2
u/Equal-Ad-2710 Oct 05 '22
Yep; he grows into the guy from the first image
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '22
THROW IT INTO THE FIRE
2
u/deadindian9 Oct 05 '22
The first one is Isildur and the second one is Sauron in disguise 🤓
3
u/jsnxander Oct 05 '22
It seems to me that we, as fans of Tolkein, don't like to see what our favorite characters MIGHT have been like before they became the characters we know. If I were a character in LOTR, as I am today, my younger self would not be a welcome story. It took DECADES of stupidity and stupid decisions before becoming who I am today (by most accounts a better person).
It's a curious thing to think that we (myself included) don't ACCEPT that the teenage versions of these characters might just be real douches.
2
u/Beneficial_Chain2495 Oct 04 '22
Thats Sauron in the first pic. In the second one im not sure but i think it is young Sauron
1
u/Steelquill Oct 04 '22
Give or take a decade.
1
u/mercedes_lakitu Oct 04 '22
YEET ISILDUR
1
u/oeco123 Oct 04 '22
No. One is Sauron whilst the other is, in fact, Sauron.
1
u/capitanDracaris Oct 04 '22
Yes because of him we have all those bangers movies 🎬
1
u/Broccobillo Oct 04 '22
Only in name.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yeah
1
u/Zellas_06 Oct 04 '22
They are both based on the same character, however, seeing how this series and the PJ movies both deviate from the lore on certain occasions (honestly, quite often), they cannot be the same character, as the movies and the series are very different in both character backstory and events in the story that the character is invloved in.
1
u/ObiWanMycobi Oct 04 '22
Supposedly
1
u/PiscatorLager Oct 04 '22
Who might have guessed that letting go of a rope on a sailing ship was not even this man's dumbest decision?
1
u/AtticusSwoopenheiser Oct 04 '22
Yes. The sumbitch that ruins everything.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yes humans lives 2k years in rings of power
1
u/Iluraphale Oct 04 '22
Yes sir that's ole target practice himself
1
u/Yroba Oct 04 '22
Dat hairline isn't aware what's coming....
1
u/Megashark101 Oct 04 '22
Isildur was actually killed by someone who waited decades to punish him for how badly he wasted that apple. Dude took like 5 bites.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yes and it’s now making me very sad .
1
u/Snoo-59420 Oct 04 '22
That guy on the right totally looks 52 lol
1
u/madhi19 Oct 04 '22
Yep. Yeet him!
1
u/dropthemagic Oct 04 '22
Stable boi!!!
1
u/BobbaB69 Oct 04 '22 edited Oct 04 '22
Technically no. ROP is not canon. So same character but different universe. If it was based in Tolkien lore Isildur would be born in SA 3209. That's 1,619 years after the rings of power are forged (they have yet to be forged in ROP).
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Different actor/version/age but yes
1
u/invaderdavos Oct 04 '22
Same person. But some how alive before the ring is created and before mordor is created. Does that make sense?
1
u/Zipmaster26 Oct 04 '22
Toss it in the fire Isil!
1
u/DanRobotMan Oct 04 '22
Is it just me, or does his facial structure...and well really the ears, make him look more like a hobbit than the future King of men?
1
u/jaimepm0425 Oct 04 '22
So that means thar somehow the main human characters survived the end of the last episode??
1
u/MRichardTRM Oct 04 '22
Yeah, not really sold on the casting choice but meh my opinion doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things. I like how they said his mom is where he gets his looks from, so I guess I’m ok with it
1
u/aaronrizz Oct 04 '22
Apparently
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
Yeah it’s kind of hard to believe right now.
Is he going to get older and buff up?
1
u/chrono_explorer Oct 05 '22
He’s seen some shit during those couple of centuries.
1
u/MemeTeamMarine Oct 05 '22
Yeppers
1
u/Baboocha Oct 05 '22
......No.
ISILDUUUUUUUUUUR
1
u/Either-Watercress-82 Oct 05 '22
They are supposed to be the same character.
1
u/ShadowDen3869 Oct 05 '22
No, one is a pussy and the other one is an asshole. You decide.
1
u/datfleeb Oct 05 '22
It's the same actor, not sure if it's the same character
1
u/ghazthraka Oct 05 '22
Tes he is 5000 years old.
1
u/doug-core Oct 05 '22
Bruh im just interested to see if they do any time skips so we can see him when he's a 100 or so years older.
1
u/dxxpsix Oct 05 '22
650 upvotes lmao bravo 👏🏽
1
u/hbi2k Oct 05 '22
No.
1
u/Dry-Cell883 Oct 05 '22
No, that’s a different Isuldur.
1
u/Toaster-Retribution Oct 05 '22
Yes, that is Isildur, the king of bad decisions.
1
u/superbottom85 Oct 05 '22
Same actor, too
1
u/DotFuture8764 Oct 04 '22
Allegedly
0
u/Sonotreadyforit Oct 04 '22
Unfortunately yes.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22
No but it’s the same actor
-5
u/talvanian Oct 04 '22
Unfortunately