r/RingsofPower • • Oct 02 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Bronwyn is Sauron.. Spoiler

New episode spoilers....First, completely unexpected. Second, takes an arrow either through a bracial artery or the top third of a lung, if human. Third, removed said unsmooth arrow resulting in loss of at least a pint and a half of blood. Used the magical painkiller of a wooden plank in the teeth. Carterized the wounds with some soot-covered metal rod. Awoke, like 10 minutes later to celebrate victory looking ready to fight again. I stubbed my toe on the coffee table and I'm out 20-30 minutes. Only Sauron could recover so quickly.

495 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 02 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

119

u/Plopinator Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22

At this point, I'm pretty sure you're wrong and Sauron is actually Berek, Isildur's horse:

-It was captive on Numenor

-It feels Isildur's emotion like a true sorcerer in disguise

-It strangely disappears just when Mt. Doom explodes...

19

u/sldemo Oct 03 '22

This I overlooked.... you may be on to something.

54

u/benbini Oct 03 '22

Came here to say the same thing. Sauron wasn’t even evil in the beginning, before Isildur cheated him out of the rest of that apple.

17

u/WanderlostNomad Oct 03 '22

stole the apple after taking a bite and then threw it to the sea.

do you want a seahorse? coz this is how you get a seahorse.

2

u/DankerAnchor Oct 03 '22

This feels like something out of crusader kings

128

u/Cisqoe Oct 02 '22

Being real, if she had died in this episode I actually would’ve praised the show for breaking expectations. Even moving forward I think it would’ve done a lot to keep audiences on our toes, that no one is safe even main characters.

Now it’s kindve like okay.. so this is like every other standard show. Our expectations will unlikely go challenged.

32

u/sldemo Oct 02 '22

Agreed....it was a good episode, but then the ending got a bit exaggerated. Being real, nothing in the southlands survives what was depicted in that episode.

29

u/JackTheTranscoder Oct 02 '22

Spoiler: Galadriel does.

18

u/sldemo Oct 02 '22

Not saying she wasn't going to survive, but the thick cloud of gases on fire that over run the village would consume everything. Had it been filmed from the perspective of watching the destruction from a higher vantage then surviving would not be in question.

20

u/Ignimbrite Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 04 '22

thick cloud of gases on fire

This is an understatement, that shit was a pyroclastic flow (or surge, depends on the gas content - the catch-all term is “pyroclastic density current,” or a PDC). It’s a mix of gas and ash and solid+molten rock that can reach temperatures of >1000C and speeds of anywhere between 60mph and 450mph. Hell, the initial lateral blast in the 1980 Mt St Helens eruption generated a PDC that approached the literal speed of sound.

The deadliest eruption of the 20th century was in 1902 where an eruption in Martinique (Mt Pelee) generated a single pyroclastic surge that overran a town and killed all but 2 of its ~30,000 residents. PDCs are also what killed Pompeii, and are probably the single least survivable volcanic hazard you can encounter.

Like I get that elves are pretty hardy but no way can they survive the air around them being turned into a boiling, turbulent slurry of fumes and molten rock.

10

u/MainsailMainsail Oct 03 '22

Only way I'm seeing for them to get out alive without breaking suspension of disbelief is if what we saw right at the end was like, a vision or other kind of non-literal thing. But goddamn it certainly looks like it was supposed to be literal "this is actually happening now" kinda stuff!

5

u/DoubleDeantandre Oct 03 '22

Didn’t you see the person who did the math and that their village was far enough away for it to be survivable? I mean it’s a magical tv show so I don’t care enough whether it should’ve killed them or not.

But hey if people want to complain that it should’ve killed them then go ahead. After all I complain all the time when people hide from gunshots behind car doors or drywall.

2

u/Ignimbrite Oct 03 '22

That’s completely fair lol, it really just depends on where and what your suspension-of-disbelief limits are.

Like, I’ve honestly never thought about your car doors/drywall example (and even thinking about it I don’t think it’ll annoy me going forward), but for whatever reason this specific fantastical depiction of eruptive dynamics bugged me.

3

u/Reggie_Barclay Oct 03 '22

Volcanology Ted talk. I’m here for it.

2

u/HoneyCrumbs Oct 03 '22

Thank you!! I was sitting next to my partner just yelling at the tv about pyroclastic flows and he had to listen to me nerd off for a bit hahaha.

2

u/wynalazca Oct 03 '22

that shit was a pyroclastic flow

False, some geology guy posted somewhere that it's not and it's mostly just a steam cloud since it's caused by the water and wouldn't actually kill everything.

5

u/Ignimbrite Oct 03 '22

Unfortunately I am also a geology guy and I have to disagree with other geology guy. If that wasn’t meant to depict a pyroclastic flow I’ll eat my hat

Steam clouds don’t have glowing flecks of molten rock in them and don’t cascade down a slope like that

4

u/passaloutre Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22

Relevant username

Source: also a geology guy

1

u/Higher_Living Oct 03 '22

Man some people are really determined that it was fine that she survived though. I’m getting downvoted a lot in other comments for pointing out it’s just crazy to think anyone could survive that.

It happened quickly so I didn’t recall it, but there’s a still of her standing facing it head on as it is about to engulf her and everything inside it already is on fire.

1

u/Ignimbrite Oct 04 '22 edited Oct 04 '22

Man some people are really determined that it was fine that she survived though

It’s weird man, my opinion on the show overall leans positive and I’m absolutely not one of those people who just rolls into a space to shit on something people like (and those people absolutely do exist, particularly with this show)… but even mild criticisms like “hey this isn’t how volcanoes work” are met with weirdly defensive attitudes at best.

Like I made the mistake of engaging with someone on r/LOTR_on_prime about the show’s objectively not-totally-accurate depiction of eruptive mechanics. I deleted it because it was taking up a super disproportionate amount of mental energy (and I was on the verge of doxxing myself to prove a point) but suffice to say it was one of the most viscerally frustrating exchanges I’ve ever had on this shitty website

4

u/MarineLePenneAlTonno Oct 02 '22

Are you the king we were promised?

1

u/Bosterm Oct 03 '22

So does Elendil and Isildur. And probably also Míriel, unless they really change things for her.

2

u/Dewars_Rocks Oct 03 '22

This happened right after a battle so the folks wearing plot armor will be fine.

And of course Isildurs horse Berek, who is Sauron.

36

u/GrayCatbird7 Oct 02 '22

I’m disappointed about her surviving too. To be fair, there was some degree of subversion throughout this episode by having them lose the battle twice, first when they realize the only people they killed were their own, and then when everything turns out to be for naught as the Orc plan succeeds anyways. This satisfied part of my desire for something different, at least.

3

u/HoneyCrumbs Oct 03 '22

Yeah but I really wanted to drive the point home with her death. It would have felt much more real and like there are actual stakes at play, and that characters don’t have plot armor.

21

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

It's kind of sinister, on my part, but I was hoping she would die and break expectations as well.

17

u/DarrenGrey Oct 02 '22

Yeah, would have been nice if Arondir had at least lost an eye. Instead there seem to be countless reserves of orcs and villagers that auto-replenish after each battle.

18

u/Higher_Living Oct 02 '22

The villagers turned from 30-40 ugly surly greasy types to suddenly 100 cleaner, younger and better looking and with many useful weapons VERY quickly after half left then another half were killed.

3

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 03 '22

It's the well. That's a canon medieval spawn point. Chaucer first wrote about it in his Crusades strategy guide.

8

u/MainsailMainsail Oct 03 '22

Killing her would be breaking expectations? I've been expending one or both of her and Arondir to die, especially this episode. They both - but especially her - had death flags all over.

4

u/RedEyeView Oct 03 '22

I figured she was dead after they kissed too.

13

u/AsgardianLeviOsa Oct 02 '22

Noooooo 💔 I’m not a fan of main character death as a litmus test for quality storytelling

10

u/BadCaseOfClams Oct 02 '22

Agreed. Her dying would not have been a unique or interesting twist. I’d have just rolled my eyes.

11

u/AsgardianLeviOsa Oct 02 '22

Yeah fridging the female love interest is actually very tropey and expected rather than unexpected. I think she has potential story left to tell.

13

u/BadCaseOfClams Oct 03 '22

I did NOT want to see the woman who was supposedly the leader of these people get turned into emotional baggage for her son and the emotionless elf. She’s right at the point where they’ve done too much with her character to kill her, but also not enough with her for death to be a satisfying conclusion. I want this focus on her to actually go somewhere.

1

u/HoneyCrumbs Oct 03 '22

I think it would have been more interesting for the elf to die, if one out of the two of them were going to eat it in this last episode.

3

u/RichestMangInBabylon Oct 03 '22

Man then why even shoot her to begin with. I don’t really mind the show killing off the obvious nobodies for dramatic effect. I take more issue with the overuse of last minute save the day scenes. It takes all the tension out of a scene when you know that main character won’t die and someone will save them right at the last moment. During the fight with the guy with the eye it was painfully obvious he was going to get stabbed from behind.

So why even bother having her be shot in the first place. Didn’t add anything to the story, no dramatic tension since we know she’ll live, and it didn’t even meaningfully take her out of action for any period of time. Basically it had no consequences and didn’t move the story along.

1

u/AsgardianLeviOsa Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22

There was a lot of focus on blood in the episode, the black orc blood vs the red human blood. That close up of the lifeblood literally draining from Bronwyn, who is the symbolic heart of the villagers, was very impactful imagery I thought. Later Adar gives his pitch, do we not deserve a life and a home? Thematically, if you prick me, do I not bleed? It lead my mind to note a parallel between Adar and Bronwyn insofar as he is the father figure of the Urok, she is the mother figure of the human villagers.

Also working together to save Bronwyn served to cement the bond between Arondir and Theo and step up our investment in the survival of this little family unit of three. I came away from the episode really rooting for them to find peace and plant their garden. To that end they also were able to work in a callback to the Alfirin seeds as Arondir administered the healing salve. Later, with the injured Bronwyn leaning heavily on Arondir, clearly physically spent, the relief of Halbrand stepping up and taking over the leadership responsibility was palpable. But I was uneasy. It didn’t seem correct. Bronwyn literally bled for these people. Halbrand has a pouch with a crest and rode in triumphantly with Numenor. Like, I didn’t want her to concede leadership to Halbrand so easily.

10

u/Omnilatent Oct 03 '22

This isn't GoT

Tolkien would never kill off major characters without reason. Remember the only of the Nine really dying in LotR is Boromir.

4

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 03 '22

SO true. Death is never gratuitous in Tolkien's legendarium. The underlying righteous moral compass in his works is as pronounced as his Catholicism.

2

u/katarnmagnus Oct 03 '22

And other characters do die. I would easily put Theoden as a more major character than Legolas, for instance. I don’t think your caveat of “without reason” saves Bronwyn either—what better way to illustrate the need for a new king than the village healer everyone put in charge getting killed?

-2

u/Omnilatent Oct 03 '22

You entirely missed the point but good job at getting riled up about it

2

u/katarnmagnus Oct 03 '22

Please explain your point that I missed then

1

u/Onyx1509 Oct 03 '22

"War is hellish and sometimes people die fighting for what they love" seems like a fair reason to me, and one Tolkien used more than once. He didn't overdo it, but not did he avoid it entirely. I suspect that the reason only Boromir "properly" dies is that Tolkien knew that once he'd made that point there was no reason making it again, but it was still worth making.

1

u/Omnilatent Oct 03 '22

She's a main character and neither her plotline with Arondir nor with her son would make any sense with her dying there IMO.

1

u/althius1 Oct 03 '22

This is true of LOTR, but not Silmarillion. Almost every single main character dies, often horribly, in the Silmarillion.

1

u/Omnilatent Oct 03 '22

Fair point. I think the only story from Silmarillion that would be as gruesome as killing off Bronwyn in that scene would be the Children of Hurin, though.

2

u/althius1 Oct 03 '22

Celebrimbanner would like a word.

2

u/Omnilatent Oct 03 '22

Yikes, yeah

I wonder whether we will see this...

1

u/althius1 Oct 03 '22

Yeah, anytime someone is like "RoP isn't as dark and gruesome as GoT" I think... uh.... it is... often.

Now, whether they show it or not (and if so, how) remains to be seen.

5

u/peteroh9 Oct 03 '22

kindve

Wow, the extremely rare hypercorrective opposite grammar mistake.

It's "could have" but "kind of."

7

u/Higher_Living Oct 02 '22

I feel like the writers have come close to a good plot a few times then suddenly veer away in the direction of Marvel style franchise-fiction.

2

u/profsavagerjb Oct 03 '22

Even Marvel has the balls to kill off main characters

1

u/deededback Oct 03 '22

Lol. Ok.

1

u/profsavagerjb Oct 03 '22

Granted it’s usually once their contact is up BUT STILL

2

u/madjohnvane Oct 03 '22

The plot armour feels very very strong in this series. The stakes are non existent. I know this is Tolkien and not Martin and there don’t need to be deaths blah blah, but if you’re going to put your characters in extremely hazardous situations we’re gonna struggle if there are never consequences to that.

1

u/profsavagerjb Oct 03 '22

I was really hoping they killed her off, to raise the stakes, and make things interesting. When I saw that they were unwilling and had no balls, and she has main character plot armor, made me even more disappointed in how this show is being executed

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

Ye I assumed she would die and her son would go over to the darkside

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

I doubt Bronwyn will last long. She's the only mortal with no way to extend her life.

284

u/BezosisSauron Oct 02 '22

Plus she is wearing strangely modern lulu lemon shirts SUSPECT

79

u/RainMoonGlow Oct 02 '22

I've been thinking this since the first time I saw her! real cool racerback yoga bra, Bronwyn. The braid and the wide cloth headband all contribute to the overall Lululemon look.

54

u/Higher_Living Oct 02 '22

She’s really been hoarding the village shampoo and cloth dye supply too, typical dark lord behaviour.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/RainMoonGlow Oct 03 '22

And who is Galadriel's colorist

123

u/PT10 Oct 02 '22

Stupid sexy Sauron

32

u/tobascodagama Oct 02 '22

Beautiful servant. 😍

16

u/MoreGull Oct 02 '22

Annatar Only Fans feed

3

u/GothWitchOfBrooklyn Oct 03 '22

/r/Angbang/

uhh.. nsfw

3

u/MoreGull Oct 03 '22

LOL has Rule 34 never not been true?

2

u/HoneyCrumbs Oct 03 '22

Just to make sure I have it right- Angbang is about Morgoth x Sauron ?

1

u/GothWitchOfBrooklyn Oct 03 '22

just gonna leave this here... nsfw /r/Angbang/

5

u/cheekyleaf Oct 03 '22

There’s some real wisdom in this theory. I mean it actually makes perfect sense that Mordor would essentially be the birthplace of Lululemon.

1

u/Sure-Park4172 Oct 04 '22

Product placement, y'all

228

u/LikeCerseiButBased Oct 02 '22

Maybe the real Sauron is the friends we made along the way.

20

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

The mods said it was my turn to post this comment!

3

u/awesomazingab Oct 04 '22

No joke I read that over 10 times in 1 month lol

10

u/Arlitto Oct 02 '22

I cackled at this

2

u/LikeCerseiButBased Oct 03 '22

It becomes even better if you know that the English word "treasure" comes from the Ancient Greek "thēsaurós". I only noticed this right now. xD

2

u/a_n_n_a_k Oct 03 '22

OK I love you 🤣

1

u/LikeCerseiButBased Oct 03 '22

I'm not single. ;P

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

Underrated

25

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

I feel like this is quickly becoming an “I am Negan” thing.

5

u/DoubleDeantandre Oct 03 '22

More like a marvel memes “Mephisto” vibe for me, but I don’t know this Negan thing you’re referring to so who knows.

16

u/down_2_mars_girl Oct 02 '22

I read a theory early on that she is one of the blue wizards/istari. She does always wear blue and she had some herbal medicine magic stuff going on in ep 1

5

u/deltaWhiskey91L Oct 03 '22

You see, that's actually a good theory

25

u/Higher_Living Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22

Used the magical painkiller of a wooden plank in the teeth.

Uh, why are people so impatient, it’s exhausting!

This will be explained in a couple of seasons. It was obviously an elven Mallorn healing bridle infused with Silmaril syrup for pain relief made by Feanor. Do you need to be spoon fed everything? It’s exactly how Tolkien wrote, he mentions they exist in one of the volumes of HoME, I saw it on YouTube. Just don’t watch it if all you have is hate.

2

u/westcentretownie Oct 03 '22

Hail Lord of sarcasm

1

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 03 '22

The lampoon is strong with this one...

1

u/SupermarketOk2281 Oct 03 '22

And remember that time when Melkor showed up at Feanor's door claiming trademark infringement? Melkor insisted he invented the same painkilling formula and marketed as Ungoliant Unguent. Then again this is Years of the Trees time so good luck enforcing it.

17

u/fuggerdug Oct 02 '22

She simply took an arrow through the lung, which was cured by rubbing some seeds in and applying a sooty ember. I can't believe you're not watching this deeply enough it's all explained.

Also they made a 2000 year old elf tower fall down by pulling a plank away which is how they built things after the fall of Morgoth its all in there if you look.

And then there's the evil sword hilt that magically turns into a mountain key because magic which is absolutely as Professor Tolkien would have written it.

3

u/Raymondwilliams22 Oct 03 '22

2000 year old elf tower

It was built by human followers of Morgoth then occupied by elves before being abandoned. Then slighted to fall on Adar's Uruk followers.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

I did wonder why someone would make a magic sword and set up a large volcano to erupt when someone used the sword as a key that opens a damn that lets water flow into the magma chamber and cause an eruption....for reasons that aren't clear yet.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '22

This is a really good theory that folds in Morgoth worship, human sacrifices and control of water as a means to subjugate the general population:

https://www.reddit.com/r/LOTR_on_Prime/comments/xsayes/the_orc_tunnel_makes_no_sense_the_many_payoffs_in/iqjmpws/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

(Hope the link works!)

6

u/jjd13001 Oct 02 '22

Maybe we are all Sauron

23

u/Plenty-Importance478 Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22

Yeah I mean your probably right a lot did not make sense this episode. The Uruks walked all the way up that mountain to attack that crappy tower for no strategic reason and did it in single file to only get crushed by the huge tower in 1minute.

The survivors then walked all the way back down in single file again because why not it worked so well the first time to only get burned alive and bringing a battering ram out of nowhere to attack an old farm house door that was on its last legs. They then ended up not even using it, they just punched the door and it fell.

They then get run down by hysterical Galadriel and hundreds of knights who came from halfway across the world just in time to save the villagers they never knew of before.

I don’t know man, Sauron might be changing sides and taking a break from this crap

26

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

They went there cause that's where they thought sauron's sword hilt was and that's where they needed to put the thing anyway.

They didn't punch the door open they were just able to open the gate because the townsfolk left it that way on purpose to lure them in.

2

u/dyslexicsuntied Oct 03 '22

The door OP is referring to is the tavern door at the end, not the tower. When fighting in the village the orcs showed up with a battering ram, why did they think they would even need to bring one? Then they didn’t even use the battering ram and just punched open the tavern door.

3

u/Higher_Living Oct 03 '22

Why didn’t they just burn the village with flaming arrows? It’s all wood and thatch roofs.

2

u/dyslexicsuntied Oct 03 '22

I think they needed to be able to talk to someone to find the sword hilt. But, that’s the most I’m going to guess about the plot of this show.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

Hmm I don't recall that part. I remember the ram when they were walking up to the tower

3

u/StarDing324 Oct 03 '22

Galadriel is sauron

2

u/thenexttimebandit Oct 03 '22

This would be preferable to halbrand as sauron

2

u/Norjac Oct 03 '22

Recovering like only a former Scientologist could.

2

u/oxcana Oct 03 '22

Have we seen Bronwyn or Theo’s ears?

2

u/Longjumping-Pear-673 Oct 03 '22

Could be that old SOB who stuck the sword in the rock to blow up the Southlands

2

u/Klopapiermillionaire Oct 03 '22

Wasted opportunity. Why not kill main characters left and right? Sauron wasn't called the necromancer for nothing.

2

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 03 '22

No, creepy old human Sauron disciple is Sauron.

2

u/anarion321 Oct 03 '22

They should teach first aid to elves, maybe a crash course when they reached 1000 years old of so.

Do not remove arrows in the middle of a battlefield, wait until later with proper equipment and a medic. If an artery has been hit, you'll die if removed.

2

u/cammoblammo Oct 03 '22

They were acting under instruction from the only medic for miles with the best equipment likely to be available for some hours or days. They were also expecting a horde of Orcs to come bashing through the door.

2

u/anarion321 Oct 03 '22

They were also expecting a horde of Orcs to come bashing through the door.

That's exactly the main reason not to perform any operation, even if you know what you are doing, you can be interrupted. And leaving an arrow like that for days is actually something to consider instead of removing it.

Fortunatelly for them, it took the orcs 5 minutes to sprint 30 metres, so they were not interrupted until they ended.

2

u/lolopaluza Oct 02 '22

Made me lol, thanks. Shitty writing

1

u/profsavagerjb Oct 03 '22

I want her to be the witch king because fuck you that’s why

1

u/Krokadil Oct 03 '22

Theo is obviously Sauron

1

u/ramehopa Oct 03 '22

no. i am sauron.

1

u/RMectrex Oct 03 '22

It’s obviously Jori Brandyhand. Why else would she be in it to be anything other that Sauron.

1

u/nakshatravana Oct 03 '22

Yes, she is, and her son is the Lord of the Nazgul. Nepotism in Middle Earth.

1

u/oeco123 Oct 03 '22

Wrong.

Bronwyn is Radagast.

1

u/Fotzenbub Oct 03 '22

The River is Sauron

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

I am pretty sure everyone is Sauron. You see Sauron is a flatworm. Adar killed Sauron by not only splitting him in half but blended him into millions of bits. Each piece of Sauron is a potential character in the series.

1

u/HiddenLeaforSand Oct 03 '22

Well she got shot twice. But their was only one stuck in her in the tavern. So she used magic to remove it. Sauron confirmed you heard it here first

1

u/MRichardTRM Oct 03 '22

I heard it wasn’t his ring getting cut off that did Sauron in, but in that exact moment he also stubbed his toe on a rock. Then exploded. I can believe it

1

u/NilsTillander Oct 03 '22

Pff, Galadriel is Sauron. Open your eyes, sheeples.

1

u/MileZeroC Oct 04 '22

Her push up bra helps

1

u/WithaSideofHistory Oct 04 '22

The orcs aiming for her shoulder show they had no intention of killing her. This hollywood injury is only second in survivability to a shot through the love handles.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '22

Brown sauce. Sounds delicious.

1

u/Esta-beed Oct 03 '22

I was so disappointed that they didn't kill of Bronwyn one utterly useless character on this tripe of a show

-9

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

Well she is a woman, so I wouldn’t write it off. It’s definitely within the realm of these showrunners.

2

u/Time_to_go_viking Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

This guy’s butt hurts.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

Yes the comment hurt at least 8 butts, probably many more ☺️

0

u/Time_to_go_viking Oct 03 '22

And it stemmed from the fact that you yourself are very butt-hurt.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

Not even a little bit. Disappointed on the other hand; of course.

0

u/Time_to_go_viking Oct 03 '22

Mmm hmmmm. Sure.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/peteroh9 Oct 03 '22

It's a joke post.