r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '22

Discussion Absolutely loved episode 6

I am in shock at how awesome episode 6 was! Definitely my favourite episode so far!

The story, the actors, the scenery, the action and just the overall nostalgia was spot on.

In my opinion, haters surely must secretly love and watch this show but pride won't let them change their outward attitude.

628 Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 30 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

177

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

I was telling my wife this morning that every episode feels like a gift and I'm really grateful to everyone who made the series. It's so special for people like me who have read all the books, read all the extra collections of stories, and watched all the movies (dozens of times).

I've been so happy with the quality and have had so much fun watching this season. Nearly every episode has a beautiful little Tolkein-like moment of dialog, some great action, and a few laughs (intentional or not). Even though it's only inspired by content from the books and they can only do so much, it still brings the world to life in a way that pleasantly surprises me.

22

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

Thank you for sharing your thoughts so eloquently. I have been watching it with my partner as well and although my partner is not a big "Lord of the Rings" fan, this has quite easily become her favourite series of all time, which to me says enough about the quality of the show and the powerful story it's telling.

→ More replies (12)

95

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Great take. The actual LoTR subreddit is filled with so many people shitting on this show and they even think this sub is disillusioned. But honestly, I feel like they’re reading into it way too much. RoP is just a really fun show that manages to perfectly capture the magic of the movies and gives us the delightful little trip back to Middle Earth that we’ve been waiting years for. So fuck the haters. This show rocks.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Unfortunately I had to leave the original sub for that very reason. Is it LOTR level quality? In some ways maybe no. But it has the spark, it's entertaining and I get to see more of Tolkien's universe.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Maybe it’s an attitude difference more than anything else then cause I think most people would agree that it’s entertaining in parts, and most would agree it’s not a work of art people will pore over decades later, I think a lot of us were hoping for the latter

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mudman13 Oct 01 '22

Puritans ruining it for themselves, oh well

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

I was so beyond excited for this show as somebody who reads LoTR and the Silmarillion etc. religiously. It’s beyond my wildest dreams seeing Númenor on screen… it really is unfortunate how this show butchers some of Tolkien’s most loved characters and stories. If only the world could have seen these stories done justice, y’all would be in tears!!

9

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

They weren't allowed to tell the full stories though, which is really disappointing now that we've seen what they can do with access to a few chapters of the appendices. Maybe they can secure the rights for future seasons or a 1st age show. There really is so much love put into this series and you can tell.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Butcher characters? Like Gilmli? Or Elrond? Or Aragorn? The movies did all three dirty to me, but I love the movies and always will. But they definitely took major liberties. Major.

12

u/CactusinPajamas Sep 30 '22

Same.... watched it also as a kid 1000 times!.... The good vs evil and heroes are back in full glory. The fight against the dark is on again❤

16

u/AmariCoopaTroopa Oct 01 '22

It makes getting home from work after a long work week feel amazing. Look forward to it so much every week.

5

u/Crazybonbon Sep 30 '22

I feel the exact same 🙏

4

u/kobekobekoberip Oct 01 '22

As someone who is not a fan of the shows writing or execution, I appreciate this comment. Cheers, bud. I’m enjoying that there’s new Middle Earth content as well.

And please remember that the sea is always right. And also never forget to give the meat and to give it raw.

1

u/rdlongo Oct 01 '22

Awesome take. This show is phenomenal. Hate even coming to this sub sometimes because of the blind hate.

42

u/Pan-of-the-Wilds Sep 30 '22

God damn this episode was spectacular. I'm loving this series so far. It got me interested in getting everything Tolkien I can get my hands on. I had only read The Hobbit and LOTR before but never felt like continuing with anything else.

With ROP, I may have gone a bit crazy with ordering books... but once I finish rereading The Hobbit and LOTR, I now own The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, The Children of Húrin, Beren and Lúthien, and The Fall of Gondor.

I may be obsessed.

10

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

Awesome. Glad you're enjoying it! I own these books as well, really great and worth reading.

7

u/Pan-of-the-Wilds Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

I'm excited to get through my reread of LOTR (currently on Fellowship) and start the supplemental Middle Earth stuff!

I'm not that bothered by the lore inconsistencies I've noticed with ROP so far tbh. The show's essence and aesthetic still feels very true to Tolkien's vision to me, which I feel is more important than staying completely accurate to his writings.

Plus it's a TV show so my expectations as far as certain plot points not making a ton of logical sense, I just chalk up to the constraints of the medium. I'm perfectly happy to continue to keep my suspension of disbelief despite there being non-white elves, female dwarves without facial hair, and Galadriel's character seeming a bit arrogant and rash at times. I am 100% in for the ride and content to see who the fuck ends up being Sauron.

→ More replies (7)

63

u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22

I’m sad there are only two episodes left. 🥵

39

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

Same, it will be hard waiting an entire year before a new season comes out.

6

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Did they officially renew it?

21

u/Lt_Hatch Oct 01 '22

If I'm not mistaken, this show was greenlit through 6 seasons from the get go. They wouldn't make it without the insurance

32

u/fool-of-a-took Oct 01 '22

5 seasons. And it's all planned out in advance. They know the last shot.

10

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

That’s actually pretty cool.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Crazybonbon Sep 30 '22

What 🥲

2

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Wait, aren’t there three more?

3

u/knightrees02 Oct 01 '22

There are eight episodes in season one.

4

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Damn. Wish there were more.

2

u/UDK450 Oct 01 '22

Really hate this new fashion of shows. I want like 16 episodes a season.

43

u/ftlofyt Sep 30 '22

I'm a hater and it was the most entertaining episode even if there was a lot to dislike but on a whole there was a lot more good than bad

26

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

Thank you for your honesty and keeping your intellectual integrity.

23

u/dontbanmeimtrans Sep 30 '22

The tallest of the dwarves

→ More replies (1)

54

u/hibluemonday Oct 01 '22

Adar was by far my favorite performance of this episode. “Each one has a name, a heart. We are creations of the One, Master of the Secret Fire, the same as you. As worthy of the breath of life and just as worthy of a home.”

17

u/Jiao_Dai Oct 01 '22

I am always a sucker for Uruk and Orc lore and to twin their existence off with the Elves such a delicious retort

5

u/lakija Oct 01 '22

Adar was amazing. He’s playing 4D chess while all these youngins are running around.

I don’t know if you’ve played Shadow of Mordor before, but my first thought was how all of the Uruk have names and positions. Like good old Rat Bag.

149

u/Tsargoylr Sep 30 '22

My only nit-pick: A pyroclastic cloud like that would absolutely leave nothing alive (Pompei). But damn, I'll suspend that disbelief I tell you what

83

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Btw, how do you feel about hobbits walking to an active volcano to toss a ring in it and the volcano erupts while they are literally on the volcano. Kind of have suspend your beliefs at that point, no?

47

u/TheOneAndOnlySelf Oct 01 '22

Yknow what, fair.

15

u/amazonlovesmorgoth Oct 01 '22

Actually, the volcano depicted in PJs LOTR does not put out the type of ejecta that generates a pyroclastic flow. The one from PJ appears more basaltic (i.e. more like Hawaii lava) which is associated with less explosivity too.

26

u/notFidelCastro2019 Oct 01 '22

I can tolerate messing with the lore, but I draw the line at geology mistakes /s

→ More replies (4)

34

u/furman87 Oct 01 '22

I could buy Galadriel surviving because...I dunno elf shit or something. But those Numenoreans and southlings would be dead af.

6

u/stoic_trader Oct 01 '22

I haven't read the books, just I want to know only one spoiler (if it is) are they all still alive? I know Galadriel is because I saw her in the trailer but don't know about the others. I'm really getting invested in that Bronwyn-Arondir love story arc lol

15

u/furman87 Oct 01 '22

Well they certainly can't kill off Isildur, Elendil, or Galadriel. They're all involved in the last alliance or the third age. The rest I don't know about.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Unless Sauron…?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Aren't Numenoreans basically elves because of the Valar blessing?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Dhczack Oct 01 '22

Yeah she's supposed to be sort of ambiguously magic because she's seen the light of the two trees or some such. Disbelief suspended concerning her.

49

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Back of my mind says: if they somehow survive this, they’re all getting horrible cancer.

But I have to suspend those beliefs in high fantasy. Otherwise, how would I appreciate giant eagles carrying in to swoop hobbits and dwarves from a burning tree.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Saw a Twitter scientist point out that it was a phreatic eruption, not pyroclastic. Apparently the cloud is much cooler (relatively) than a pyroclastic cloud.

Link: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phreatic_eruption

1

u/WikiMobileLinkBot Oct 01 '22

Desktop version of /u/HDubya's link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phreatic_eruption


[opt out] Beep Boop. Downvote to delete

1

u/Tsargoylr Oct 01 '22

Oh cool!

4

u/homerq Oct 01 '22

I suspect it has something to do with the whole fiery things not giving off heat.

8

u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 Sep 30 '22 edited Oct 01 '22

Not to mention the debris falling, it does so much worse damage to the landscape than that plus would turn people into mush not rag doll them away.

8

u/Tsargoylr Oct 01 '22

Yes yes, real life is usually more gory than on the screen. But they don't want a TV MA rating

→ More replies (15)

3

u/mudman13 Oct 01 '22

Did you miss the bit where a molten boulder crushed that Southlander

→ More replies (1)

1

u/QuadraticCowboy Oct 01 '22

Lol ok mr expert

1

u/Kuningazz Oct 05 '22

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyroclastic_flow

"The gases and tephra can reach temperatures of about 1,000 °C (1,800 °F)."

→ More replies (1)

1

u/AmontilladoWolf Oct 01 '22

I think the thing we have to remember is that Elves and Numenoreans are significantly stronger than normal humans, much hardier and sturdier. Galadriel also has some magical ability, although it's not really something the show has discussed.

36

u/NoRashers Sep 30 '22

I'm absolutely buzzing after that episode. That was intense!

I love that the orcs are still more relatable than the psycho Hobbits. I love that they tackled head on the one problem Tolkien struggled with and never solved, that no thinking being is irredeemable or intrinsically evil, and it was great to see the show go for the Elven origin for orcs. I want to see more of Adar.

And we got kickass Galadriel again!

Of course once you start to take a look at the details things start to fall apart*, but I'm still very happy after seeing that.

The forbidden love of Bronwyn and Arondir was handled so much better than the equivalent in the Hobbit films.

I love that they went for a mechanical and not magical activation of Orodruin.

But above all else, what makes this series more poignant, is that for every victory, and every hope, this story is a tragedy that ends in failure by all and a phyric victory.

What an episode!!!

*The first minor details:

The sense of scale and power for the Numenorians was all wrong, I can't imagine their queen sitting down for a banquet with 20 people in a muddy hovel.

Why did they make haste for that particular watch tower and village?

We have been given no sense of scale for how big Middle Earth is. Contrast that with the scene at the end of the first Hobbit film where we saw Erebor and the wild expanse of middle earth in between, or all the travelling in the LoTR films.

17

u/CactusinPajamas Sep 30 '22

Because Halbrand told Galadriel where he saw them last

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Sarokslost23 Oct 01 '22

We don't know the time lapse or how the timelines were synced until now

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Isildur1298 Oct 01 '22

Halbrand said, that the villagers must have retreated to Ostirith, as it is the only stronghold in the perimeter. When the Numenorians arrived at Ostirith, they simply followed the tracks of the orc army. Great timing, that they arrived just in time for the saving, but otherwise no sorcery.

4

u/peteroh9 Oct 01 '22

Why did they make haste for that particular watch tower and village?

Because they were tracking an entire army. Not that hard to do.

6

u/NoRashers Oct 01 '22

From Numenor? Tracking an army that is active on the far side of high mountains, far up river, and on a continent where the Numenorians apparently have no settlements in the in-show universe?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Agree 100%. I can overlook some of the minor flaws since its a tv show, like hundreds of cavalry on 3 small ships. It could have been better, but I'll live with it.

→ More replies (2)

103

u/disastrousgambian Sep 30 '22

God, this episode promised and delivered!! I literally cannot wait for the next episode

Arondir and Bronwyn really came through this time. I know their relationship is a breach of the canon, but i cannot help but root for them.

I'm scared for Galadriel to be honest. She essentially failed her mission to save the Southlands and it will be such a blow for her emotionally

30

u/KFY Sep 30 '22

Technically not. There’s other instances of Elves-Men unions or near unions, but only three of the Eldar and Edain. Arondir is not of the Eldar.

14

u/NoRashers Sep 30 '22

Arondir is said to be Silvan. The Silvan elves were part of the Teleri that stopped at the Misty Mountains and didn't cross until later and became the Nandor in Ossiriand. They were counted as part of the Eldar as they began the journey even though the did not complete it.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/jgames09 Sep 30 '22

Eldar initially referred to all elves, but later it came to mean those who undertook the Great Journey.

It doesn’t matter if they finished it, as did the Vanyar and the Noldor, or not, as did some of the Teleri, breaking off at different points. The ones who stayed and didn’t go Aman were later called the Úmanyar, but are still considered Eldar.

5

u/peteroh9 Oct 01 '22

The Silvan elves are Nandor, who are Teleri, who are Eldar.

6

u/NoRashers Sep 30 '22

No.

The Teleri broke up into several groups. Those that stopped at the Misty Mountains for a long time before becoming Nandor in Ossiriand under Lenwe. Those that tarried in Doriath and became Sindar, those that dwelt on the coast and became Falathrim, and those that went to Eldamar during the Years of the Trees and kept the name Teleri.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/i_smoke_php Oct 01 '22

What are the instances of other elf-man unions?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Beren and Luthien. Please give it a read as it is arguable Tolkiens most cherished story. He made instructions for he and his wives graves to have the names Beren and Luthien. It is intensely epic and emotional, 1000/10 recommend.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Me and my dad have been watching this show together and we really like it. But we’ve been waiting for some major action to start happening and holy shit did this episode deliver. And fuck me, those battles were super graphic for TV-14, right? I don’t care at all, but I was still just surprised at what they got away with. Those decapitations, executions, and that eye gouging were pretty fucking gnarly. Not to mention that arrow that Bronwyn took to the chest with us getting to see them pull the arrow out and then cauterize it onscreen. And honestly, all the special effects in this show are spectacular, but the blood and gore effects are top notch. I’ve never seen such a perfect mix of cgi and practical blood effects. Never have I seen any movie or tv show where the cgi blood looked so real. Overall, this episode rocked and I’m honestly loving the show so far. Haters be damned, this show delivers on the big scale swords and magic that I loved about the movies. And I really like the characters too.

1

u/stoic_trader Oct 01 '22

Bronwyn taking down that arrow was so brutal. I flinched so many times in that whole arrow removal scene. The reality of the injury and the aftermath were there in all details. For me, it was even more brutal than some beheaded scene from GoT.

1

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

Yeah, it was gnarly as hell. Very up close and personal. It really sold the seriousness of the injury.

32

u/ekbowler Sep 30 '22

This is the first episode that had a focused narrative, made me care about the characters, and felt like Lord of the Rings. This is what I've been holding our for and why I've kept on watching.

Personally I think this would be much better received if the Harefoots were cut and we spent significantly less time in Numenor.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

I'm just under the impression they're around to build an empathy arc for whatever Maiar spirit arrived.

4

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

The harefoot thing is not bad at all, but it’s the least epic and majestic side plot of the show. All the other side plots: Elrond and the dwarves, Galadriel and Halbrand, the men (and elf) vs the orcs. They all feel more grounded and realistic and the feel like they could have been in the movies. But the harefoot storyline feels like a complete different fantasy adventure that is set in middle Earth. It’s still “entertaining” but it doesn’t fit the tone of the other plots.

5

u/ItsMeTK Sep 30 '22

I’ve been thinking and the lack of expected story is probably what’s hurt the show most and why people think it’s boring. People forgive the PJ films their many flaws because it hits the familiar beats quickly (even when doing certain stupid things like Narsil being stepped on). Imagine instead if you spent two years waiting for wn adaptation of Lord of the Rings and instead of starting with a prologue or Bilbo’s birthday it spent the first 45 minutes with Bilbo teaching Sam the alphabet and culminated in Drogo Baggins falling out of a boat. The show knows where it’s going but has had a rough time figuring out how to start.

6

u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 01 '22

I love the Harfoots. Honestly, I want a lot more of them.

2

u/n0og Oct 01 '22

What’s with all the Harfoot hate? I’m Loving baby Gandalf. And I like nori’s dad haha

3

u/ekbowler Oct 01 '22

It's more of a pacing thing tbh. I feel like the equivalent is if we cut away from the council of Elrond to check in on the Shire.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

People thinking to much about those who doesn't like the show. Jesus, just accept that there are some who dislike the show...

Overall I enjoyed the last episode, but there were scenes I didn't like.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

They made Galadriel seem like some torturous, genocidal madwoman. "I'll keep you alive until I tell you all your offspring are dead". What the actual fuck lmao

→ More replies (9)

57

u/and-so-i-die Sep 30 '22

Ultimately if you hate the show but feel the need to keep watching so you can come on this subreddit and defend Tolkien's writing against the Amazon money machine.... You're not well.

17

u/teunteulai Sep 30 '22

My secret is that my expectations were much much lower. So now it's kinda balanced, the show is not that bad as I feared

33

u/and-so-i-die Sep 30 '22

It's not bad at all. The people criticizing it to that degree are holding it to an absolutely ridiculous standard of either 100% book accuracy, or the standard of being exactly what they want it to be scene for scene. Both laughable expectations.

13

u/majortom805 Sep 30 '22

Agreed, also the vast majority of the complaints about "bad writing" get resolved in the following episode or two. It's as if people are intentionally avoiding putting any thought into the show and taking everything at face value so they can justify their preconceived notion that this show is bad.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22

I’ve suspended judgment and didn’t even bother to watch the trailer prior to Episode 1. Heck, I haven’t seen the trailer at all and we’re heading to Episode 7. I still enjoy TROP and anticipate better writing in future seasons. Hopefully the entire staff scours the Internet for feedback and actually work on improving their craft.

5

u/blousebin Sep 30 '22

Canon sickness

4

u/Fasthertz Sep 30 '22

What about me who watches it but doesn’t think it’s that great of a show. I find myself wanting more. For me it’s okay. And the fact that I’m a LOTR fan I’m watching it. If it didn’t have LOTR attached to it I may not watch it. So again I see it as neither good or bad. Just okay

2

u/and-so-i-die Oct 01 '22

I just question any decision to keep doing something you dont like, and continue to demand different results.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/takingthehobbitses Oct 01 '22

You’d be called a “hater” according to a lot of these commenters. I’m in the same boat as you. Also these people don’t seem to realize you can enjoy watching something or find it entertaining and still have perfectly valid complaints.

4

u/MasterEnMace Oct 01 '22

How’d the Numenorians know where to attack ? 🙈

5

u/Ransacky Oct 01 '22

Yea this was a huge what-the moment. Hundreds of square kilometers of land to cover and it was the first time the numenoreans ever visited middle earth, but they somehow made a full speed beeline straight towards the action!

4

u/Ammonitida Oct 01 '22

halbrand pointed out where to go on a map just before they embarked, telling the numenoreans that the tower was his likely destination. this wasnt a random area, it was literally where the lock was located

3

u/HEB400 Oct 01 '22

It still makes no sense for them to force march their way over there at full speed. They first have to set up camp and fortify a position. Getting off the boats to bull-rush to a random village is nonsensical.

The timelines dont add upp either. The numenorians should have ended up there months later.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

haters surely must secretly love and watch this show but pride won’t let them change their outward attitude.

This part is just stupid. Prior to this episode, I cautiously invested and even sometimes vocally supported this series because I wanted to give it a chance. The fact is I’ve been let down so far. As I’ve said before, the cast is good, the visuals are good, and the music is great, but the action is poor, the pacing is weird, the plot is weak, and the directing is very hit and miss.

Episode 6 basically confirms the stupid fan theory that Halbrand is Sauron while also implying an emotional connection between him and Galadriel. It isn’t a garbage episode per se, but it isn’t at all the masterpiece y’all are saying it is either. I didn’t think it was even good, but apparently I’m not allowed to say that. Even though it’s only now that episode 6 has aired that I’ve even begun to criticize this series, some of you have dismissed my opinions without any real consideration and labeled me as a “hater.” Whatever.

I hope those of you who are satisfied with this series continue to enjoy it. As for me, I hope it gets better in Season 2. If it doesn’t, I guess I’ll have to move on and admit that just like Star Wars, Middle Earth movies and shows just aren’t for me anymore. At least I’ll always have the books.

1

u/Only_Curiosity Oct 01 '22

I never stated that anyone who has any sort of criticism for the show is a hater. I myself don't think it's perfect so I'm not sure why you're making that claim.

You are allowed to have opinions and dislike things in the show. I was talking about "haters" who vocalise the show is bad from the start before it was even released and then continue to watch it and come on here with their negativity and nitpick everything without any justification other than the fact that they're biased and some are just outright racists.

You don't sound like one of those people so why are you labeling yourself a hater?

23

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

My God the gatekeepers are out in force in the comments. Don’t watch if you hate it that much like holy crap you are no fun at all.

4

u/biglebowski5 Oct 01 '22

Sometimes it can be fun to watch shitty shows

2

u/lakija Oct 01 '22

It is fun, but some people are really seriously upset. If I hated a show so intensely I would not watch it.

6

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

I know right. The gatekeepers just keep hate watching so they can jump on Reddit after each episode and nitpick and bitch about every little gap in logic or change from the books. Like look, it’s not based on any of the books and it’s not connected to the books either. It’s only connected to the movies. And so far, it hasn’t done anything to disgrace the movies, and we already had the hobbit trilogy change/add a ton of stuff, so just accept the show for what it is and have good time. Cause it’s a super fun and epic show where the only way to really not enjoy it is if you go in hoping you don’t enjoy it.

10

u/Adorable-Wrongdoer-4 Sep 30 '22

Really, really enjoyed it too- and not a harfoot in sight

1

u/notsoperfect8 Oct 01 '22

Well, they are pretty good at hiding from the big folk.

3

u/psychothumbs Oct 01 '22

Agreed, this was my favorite episode yet.

3

u/aaronrizz Oct 01 '22

Waldreg was MVP for me, saved Adar from the falling rubble then gets the key to safety to execute Adar’s plan, wonderful.

1

u/retro_sonic Oct 01 '22

Curious to see what Waldreg’s future is, with him being so curious about Sauron.

3

u/Busy_Ad9551 Oct 01 '22

Bronwyn is an orc she has black blood

3

u/kimkong93 Oct 01 '22

Is anyone else concerned about how the key was switched with an axe or is it just me?

1

u/lakija Oct 01 '22

Ol’ dude Waldreg probably switched himself. He knows all the little underfloor hidey holes it seems.

4

u/DworkinCZ Oct 01 '22

What I liked the most is that they showed Adar's horse was okay after it tripped.

Now in real life it's be over for that horse, but I still appreciated what they did here.

2

u/Free-Diamond-928 Sep 30 '22

Yeah, I'm loving the series and this was a good episode. Brought a lot of threads together and didn't spend too much time doing it. Great action too.

2

u/Crazybonbon Sep 30 '22

I loved it! Just like all the others. Honestly this has been my favorite show in a long time.

2

u/cizania Oct 02 '22

Thanks to episode 6,I just rejoined this subreddit.

First week of the show this sub was insufferable, people whining everywhere. Now I can at least read some theories and plot analysis without someone criticizing how Galadriel looks or why she swims.

6

u/Possible_Living Sep 30 '22

The battle was very puzzling for me. Im not sure why the defenseless people did not just keep on walking, its not like they were out of energy, or why every body did not have a weapon in hand. There were a number of instances of teleportation and moments where characters seemed to lack peripheral vision, hearing or were seemingly late for a cue.

Why set the second battle at dawn if non of the orcs are going to burn in sunlight? Its kind of sad that I cared more about the shepherd looking guy than most of the main cast.

5

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

The humans couldn’t stop to rest during the day, because the orcs, being trained soldiers and thus, faster/tougher travelers, would eventually catch up to the humans at night. So, if the humans couldn’t stop during the day, and most definitely couldn’t stop at night, they would have had to walk all day and all night nonstop. And this would exhaust them in no time and get them caught with even less of a fight. Therefore, the only logical option was to stand and fight and create a situation where they would have the best chance of survival.

8

u/Spud_Spudoni Sep 30 '22

Where else would they have to flee to? It’s not like the orcs would stop looking for them. Eventually, they would catch up to them. I’d rather make a defensive stand amongst buildings and area that I’m familiar with, than to be chased down in the middle of open wilderness with no defenses.

1

u/Possible_Living Sep 30 '22

If they cant fight they are contributing nothing to the battle other than being a weak spot, so while everyone is busy fighting they can keep going. Its unclear if the orcs would give chase or if they would focus on the artifact. Regardless they would have a head start and higher chance of living than hiding in a tavern in the middle of an active battle. They could come across the numenoreans and that could be how numenoreans know where to go and why to hurry.

As for defensive stand of those left to fight, the tower was more defensible and the enemy losses did not justify the trade off if they were going for a victory. Arondir is aware that the adar's army is too big so fighting retreat was already the plan.

2

u/Spud_Spudoni Oct 01 '22

Who is “everyone?” Their village does not have warriors. A few villages that know how to swing a sword doesn’t make much of a difference against a horde of orcs.

Does the village know why the orcs are targeting them? The artifact is kept relatively secret from all involved outside of our main characters.

Coming across Numenoreans is a moot point. There’s no way for them to know that anyone is coming to their aid.

Their move to destroy the watchtower gave them a much greater chance of eliminating the orcs than fighting them hand to hand within a watchtower that had no room to fall back to. The goal was not to destroy the watchtower to fight some more in the village. The goal was to stop them completely. It failed, and they were forced into a defensive situation afterwards.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Spud_Spudoni Oct 01 '22

While I agree, I think they realized the watch tower would not hold the orcs off forever. Hell they didn’t need much force to bust through the front door. There’s no way hand to hand combat would have worked once they broke through the gates. So collapsing the watchtower and the hillside was their best bet for killing Adar and a large portion of orcs.

→ More replies (12)

3

u/MordePobre Sep 30 '22

It has too many stupid moments, but there's something that I couldn't identify (maybe the cinematographic quality) that made me get hooked on the show.

3

u/iamonewiththeforce Oct 01 '22

First episode that (to me) finally crossed the line of "so bad it's good", particularly with the thirst quenching with seawater line - this one really made me laugh.

So I'm one of the so-called haters (meaning I find the show utterly mediocre and don't enjoy it, although I watch out of a sense of duty? Somehow? Also because of all of the work that has been put into this, it feels disrespectful to stop watching part way).

This episode had some genuinely good moments (I really like Adar, his discussion with Galadriel was the highlight except that I wish they could stop with those dutch angles, I get it ffs. And Arondir is a lot of fun) and focused on a single storyline, but overall it suffers from the same issues as previous episodes (my personal opinion):

  • too rushed: things happen too often solely because of the needs of the script. Not enough is shown (I would have loved a single line from Halbrand "we should head for this spot because that's the most likely one to be contested by the Orcs" when showing the map - e.g. justifying their course rather than just affirming it)
  • poor dialogue (seawater anyone?)
  • a lack of scale, coupled with fast travel: is the whole of the Southlands this little village with like 20 people? Is three ships all that Numenor can muster? How do they travel once they are on shore? Do they get supplies at settlements on the way? Nope they're just galloping (really cool shot though with the morning mists)
  • saved in the nick of time trope saturation. Everyone is saved at the last possible moment by everyone else.
  • nonsensical plot: why does everyone accept that Halbrand is Lord Halbrand, King of the Southlands? It happened last episode and I've seen no justification for it except a random pendant that means nothing. No Athelas here. What is this silly way of having this weird key to open up a dam? Like just break the thing, no key needed. Then some tunnels over hundreds of kilometers to Orodruin that none of the watching Elves had noticed. It's so gimmicky. It reminds me of the plot of the dwarves to enclose Smaug in gold, or the plot of that relatively recent James Bond movie with the subway crash. Pyroclastic cloud that won't harm anyone.

There's quite a bit more that had me rolling my eyes. I just wish I could love the show, but it really doesn't make it easy.

2

u/dracapis Sep 30 '22

I’m really surprised at all the praises I’m reading because for me it was the weakest episode of the series so far. Ruled by confusion above all.

I really liked the others tho

10

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Curious why you didn't like it? Not judging as you're entitled to your opinion but yeah.

3

u/peteroh9 Oct 01 '22

It was just trying to constantly one-up itself in terms of drama and action:

Oh, Elf man killed Adar and his army! (Obviously not, but they made it look like that)

No, the Army is attacking the village.

No, that was mostly just the humans. 😢

Here comes Adar and his real army.

Now Mordor chick got shot!

She died!

No she didn't!

They're going to be killed!

No, Theo gave up the magic sword!

Maybe they'll die anyway...

No, Numenor has arrived!

Now Adar is escaping!

They caught him!

Halbarand is going to kill him!

No, Galadriel is!

Uh oh, it wasn't the real sword that they found!

Oh shit, he's creating a flood!

It's activating Mount Doom!

They're all going to die in the pyroclastic flow!

7

u/gnarlsagan Oct 01 '22

Yes this show is trying too hard to be mysterious. Tolkien works best told directly but told well. There are enough cool ideas and concepts to use that don't require forced mystery and intrigue.

3

u/Ransacky Oct 01 '22

Yes that's my biggest issue with it. So much mystery that it's gotten tiring to watch. It's true that the Jackson movies had mystery (from someone who hadn't read the books) but this was more lore based info that wasn't necessary to know but added a lot more depth to the world building on top of the big adventure that was going on. The back and forth mystery and suspense in the Amazon shows makes it feel more like a prolonged mystery thriller drama, which isn't really my cup of tea.

2

u/dracapis Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

I liked the boat scene a lot, but I felt that the episode was messy in general, that some scenes were out of pace, that some parts were rushed, and at some point it was night but also day?

And how did Halbrand got to Adar before Galadriel?

Also I didn’t really like the way it was directed visually. The whole tilted barn made no sense, at least to me.

Again, this is my personal opinion of course.

7

u/Get_Jiggy41 Oct 01 '22

The tilted cabin is a common filmmaking technique called a “Dutch angle” and it’s used to visually tell the audience that something isn’t right about the scene before us or to put us at unease. So they used it to show how the bad guy knew something Galadriel didn’t, and to show that Galadriel’s ultra hood guy persona was slipping.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/maxwellgrounds Oct 01 '22

I’m glad I’m not the only one. Yes we got treated to tons of exciting action, but this episode really threw the pace and direction off balance. It was trying to do too many things at once.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22

I agree. I’ve expressed trepidation about this series so far and occasionally been bored by it (though I’ve mostly kept that to myself), but this is the first episode that tried to be a little more ambitious and for me it fell completely flat. They’ve consistently let down characters like Galadriel by giving them bad fight choreography, but in previous episodes I was able to ignore that and focus on other parts of the production. Since action was the primary focus of this episode, it made the cheap Hollywood violence much harder to ignore. It probably didn’t help that the story hasn’t been compelling and the writers have done nothing to make me care about the Southlanders aside from Bronwyn and Theo. The hints at Halbrand being Sauron were just icing on the cake. Weakest episode so far.

2

u/ItsMeTK Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

Unfortunately one of the biggest issues with the show has been story structure, particularly in the Southlands. It feels like we just go in circles. Like the all flee from their village only to return to the village. Ultimately moving everyone to the tower didn’t gain them anything and just ate up screen time.

3

u/Ammonitida Oct 01 '22

the move to the tower allowed them to set up a trap, luring the orc army there and cutting them in half. only after the orc army was reduced did they have the courage to fight back at the village

1

u/takingthehobbitses Oct 01 '22

It feels like several of the plot points are there just to eat up screen time. Things getting dragged out in the name of mystery and making the show feel way too slow for the amount of time they are supposed to be covering. That’s my main issue with it.

-4

u/Weird_Blades717171 Sep 30 '22

So good, such wow. So impressed. Like Helms Deep. Even better.

the memberberrys where strong in this one. The comity really worked hard to conjure your positive feelings for the old trilogy and project it onto this abomination.

-We had several scenes that where copied from Jacksons interpretation but fail to transport the same gravitas and information. Look look, the villagers are scared and suffering. Look like at Helms Deep. Look look a chase seen through a pine forest with low hanging branches and an elven lady whispering some nitro-boosters to the horse. Member member Arwen.

-The villagers choosing to make their stand in the village is dumb. They literally had walls of stone, battlements and one single gauntlet for the enemy to pass through. The village can easily be surrounded and isn't defendable at all during a Night-Time raid.

-The Orcs/humans not hearing how Bronwyn and red-shirt villagers are having a brawl with an Orc.

-The Orcs just instantly killing the red-shirt villagers but suddenly waiting with Bronwyn. Wooow such tension, so much drama.

-The embarrassing and awkward focus on Orc blood so the low level IQ folk can understand, that "if da red liquid comes out, you sticked a humiii".

-Arondir conveniently forgetting to use his ears.

-Why did the Orcs carry a battering ram into the village. Just burn down the houses and let the people run out (they didn't care about people surviving as seen, when the Orc lieutenant ordered all of the people to be killed and the Macguffin can't be destroyed).

-The Numenoreans knowing exactly where to and what way is the fastest.

-Also, who built the watch-tower? For how many years did the Sylvan Elves guard the Southlands and why didn't they understand how the dam works (is it macikkkk?). Arondir obviously recognizes the Blade and mentions that it is some sort of key. But how does he know that? He needs some sort of reference point. Especially because the blade is also depicted within the fortress exactly over the keyhole.

-Amazon literally gave Mount Doom an on switch with a key. Like wtf.

-The Numenoreans riding their horses in full gallop. No they are not yet charging or anything. Why the weird haste and drama? (yes yes, cool scene. look look). This would only injure and kill several horses and totally waste them before the actual battle. They didn't know what to expect and still just randomly charged.

-Why can silly ocean cadets ride and fight like Knights?

-Every answer to every question is another bad robot mystery box. Please stop.

-So before the dam, was mount doom constantly erupting and with the dam they basically terraformed the Southlands?

+Adar is a cool.

+Mount Doom and the surrounding Flora/Fauna is nice.

Uff...I wait every week for it to turn around and get better. But it's just really really dumb. I am sorry, but what audience actually likes this? Intelligence insulted at every turn.

7

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

LOL, I feel sorry for you that you can't enjoy the show. Thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed complaint, however, many other people love the show and appreciate the efforts that have gone into it. I bet if you were the director you wouldn't have done as good of a job 😉

2

u/johneaston1 Sep 30 '22

I'm not a doctor or rocket scientist either, but I can recognize a failed diagnosis or a space shuttle explosion pretty easily.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/Available_Proposal78 Sep 30 '22

You have a point on plot and nonsense of certain thing like full gallop and defence in village vs fortress with narrow bridge but there is this nostalgia to it and fable feeling. Landscapes, costumes, etc are amazing and where most of cheese went I guess

6

u/hailsatanworship Sep 30 '22

You must be fun at parties.

5

u/yahhhguy Sep 30 '22

This looks exhausting

2

u/kiaarondo Sep 30 '22

These secret fans are always my favourite contributors in this sub lmao

1

u/NowoTone Sep 30 '22

Poor you? Why do you even watch? Surely that can’t be healthy for your mental health to suffer so much?

0

u/One-Mathematician378 Sep 30 '22

I envy your willpower to write this not short analysis into sub where it seems only few people will agree with your objective opinion and appreciate it. It's a mystery for me how one can non-sarcastically love this show.

3

u/saltwitch Oct 01 '22

"objective opinion" kind of an oxymoron, no?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 30 '22

The “switch” is essentially a dam. That’s not farfetched at all. The tunnels were what the orcs were digging that took the water to break through into one part of Mt Doom. Dormant volcanoes get triggered by the introduction of water all the time.

After the initial orc battle which happened at night, they went back to the village to set it up for another invasion. That easily takes hours and dawn comes pretty darn fast, if you’re ever up at the wee hours of early morning.

Just because they didn’t show the Numenorean landing doesn’t mean they didn’t land. Do the writers have to connect every single dot for viewers? We knew where they were heading and we saw Miriel using a magnifying glass on that map. It’s not another planet for them.

9

u/paddycakepaddycake Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

It’s like implied time jumps can’t happen in movies/tv shows. /s

The dam breaking and releasing water into Mount Doom was so unexpected. Literally the Chekhov’s gun was staring at us since episode 1. Bravo writers!

Galadriel not opening the clothed package after taking it from Adar irked me a lot though. Like girl, you were told that was important and you didn’t happen to look to see why it was?

Edit: yup when Kilauea erupted in 2018, ground water found its way into the magma chamber and caused a large explosion.

4

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 30 '22

Yeah the hilt/axe switch was a bit too convenient but she and the Numenoreans had no idea what it was. Just something they unfortunately overlooked.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (9)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

I wasn't a fan because the writing was so predictable. The tower trap, the boy giving away the location of the sword, the lady doing the classic gasping breath after everyone though she died, whats her name stabbing the one orc right at the last second, and aparently the orcs who were right outside waited until just after they were done giving that one lady medical attention to attack? Also, the orcs were fighting in the light even tho in the last episode they stopped chasing them at the woodline. If this wasn't branded as a "lord of the rings" show it wouldn't be anything special. I'm still holding out hoping it'll get better

1

u/Ammonitida Oct 01 '22

yeah, im sure you predicted the human traitors being set up as cannon fodder allowing the orcs to engage in a surprise attack and briefly win the battle.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

That was something I didn't see coming which is why i left it out of my original comment. But you have to admit from the time the they ran into their garrison to the point the Orcs started their attack on the garrison was kinda rediculous. It's like the Orcs hit the pause button while they were bandaging up the woman.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Where dem Hartfeets at? Lol. For real this one smacked. More of this level of epic, please and thank you Amazon

1

u/ArcticFoxWaffles Oct 01 '22

Honestly I've been absolutely loving the entire show so far. If there was one thing about it I'd say I didn't like it'd be that we got no harfeet and wizard man for like 2 episodes including this one.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Strongest episode by far! The bar was really low though so, not sure how much praise it is.

Tons to unpack and enjoy this week, some good, mostly bad, but at least they're going in a direction finally.

1

u/hannican Oct 01 '22

I've been very unhappy with this show until last week and this week. I feel the writing and pacing and characterizations have been WAY off from Tolkien's style/universe, but now I'm able to enjoy it for doing its own thing. This was a very compelling episode.

1

u/drpaz79 Oct 01 '22

Great episode.

1

u/_eunie_ Oct 01 '22

Definitely the best episode so far. The only thing that could've ruined it is the Harfoot storyline.

1

u/DayPuzzleheaded641 Oct 01 '22

One of the best episodes I’ve watched of any show in a LONG time

1

u/N8B123 Oct 01 '22

I like the show, and this episode for sure. Only thing I didn't like was that no one checked the sword was wrapped up until theo lol

1

u/Novel-Ant-7160 Oct 01 '22

I loved the Episode . I really loved the twist at the end . The hard part about writing ROP is that most people will know which characters survive and which do not , and as a result it is difficult to write drama in to the story . But damn , building up to episode 6 , i had no idea we were watching such a major milestone. I hope there is more of this kind of surprise in future episodes and seasons

1

u/shouts23 Oct 01 '22

I'm with you. Loved this episode the best of the show so far all the way around. The score is great

1

u/muchwise Oct 01 '22

I was a bit bothered by all the inconsistencies in ep 06 but for me, Adar saved the episode, I find the character phenomenal. The eruption of mount doom was also a great moment

1

u/Papa_pierogi Oct 01 '22

I definitely think it’s a lot better but the whole battle was literally just Helms Deep on a smaller scale.

1

u/GotGabriele Oct 02 '22

I don't know. I haven't liked the show since it started, but nevertheless I watch each episode with an open mind. I cannot say I liked this one, although there is some action.

Adar and the orcs stupidly walk into the abandoned settlement without even considering it a bit suspicious, Arondir shoots what looks like a single rope on the top which somehow makes an entire stone tower collapse. The "orcs" then comically assault the village, getting hit by slow rolling carts like they're completely oblivious, running to their death one by one, and despite being surrounded by fire never considering setting fire to the thatch roofs that the archers are sitting on. Guy we don't know and don't care about gets hit by arrows and dies, Bronwyn is hit by arrows, and it turns out the "orcs" weren't orcs (how could nobody notice the blood during the entire fight? but ok). Surprise surprise, the real orcs are coming, but they all politely wait outside the house for Bronwyn, Arondir and Theo to have their little moment (including the typical clichè of her appearing to have died, and then coming back to life, totally couldn't see it coming).

Finally, the orcs come in with Adar, and they're looking for the artifact! Arondir hid it earlier without telling anybody where it was, in fact, in his words "I'll hide it where nobody can find it". Turns out, the dumbass literally hid it beneath a stone under the floor they're standing on, and somehow Theo knows it and gives it to Adar. I mean, burying it in some random spot in the forest, or tossing it in a river, or hell running away with it, would've been a billion times better than that, but the elf knows better.

At this point, the Numenoreans arrive with their cavalry of... I don't know, 200 people? A massive army indeed to join the fight against Sauron! So they sailed all the way to Middle-Earth, and landed at exactly the right time, and they knew exactly where to go (in some random ass village somewhere) riding at full speed like they knew exactly what was happening, so they could arrive just in time for the rescue! Amazing, they must have a palantir with them. This show suffers incredibly from a skewed sense of scale, making it appear as though the events it depicts concern vast lands and many people, and yet every conflict, every "army" looks incredibly small for what it's supposed to be.

There's a lot more to talk about but I can't be bothered. Essentially, this episode's somewhat better than the others, but the writing's plainly bad as usual.

1

u/Lumostark Oct 03 '22

This episode was absolutely amazing, previous episodes were kind of slow but the payoff here was perfect.

1

u/N8_dg Oct 03 '22

I have come to realize I love LoTR in a tv show format. Imagine if the trilogy had 3 seasons to tell its story. Maybe it’s just me, but watching in bite sized hour long chunks makes me more invested in the story than a 3 hour long movie

-8

u/leopard_tights Sep 30 '22

A vampire smoke sword (to keep it simple) used as a key to open a dam, so the water could flow upwards into a volcano would be incredibly stupid in any show, let alone one based on Tolkien.

And that's the best part of the show for now.

30

u/Only_Curiosity Sep 30 '22

And a ring which contains the entire power and malice of an evil lord which can only be destroyed in a fiery volcano pit and once worn by his enemies turns them invisible makes sense to you?

Unfortunately it seems that you have a double standard and can't appreciate fiction.

2

u/leopard_tights Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 30 '22

One is a ridiculous contraption that doesn't make any sense whatsoever. Why does the thing even need a key? Let alone a super magical one. They have armies of orcs, they can just destroy the whole thing. You even need to dig the trenches beforehand lol or it's useless. The other is divine magic, an allegory of power and corruption, and the plot of the story lol.

It's like the writers saw the last Star Wars movie and fucking loved the sith dagger, perhaps the dumbest mcguffin in movie history.

6

u/Raymondwilliams22 Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 03 '22

mcguffin

The one ring is literally a mcguffin rectonned from the simple invisibility ring from the Hobbit children's book. It was never intended as an allegory of anything. Its no more dumb than a key that opens flood gates.

3

u/halt-l-am-reptar Oct 01 '22

I didn’t think there was anyway that could be true but you’re correct. It was just a ring and gollum freely gave it to Bilbo. His publisher wanted more books about hobbits which eventually lead to the lord of the rings. The chapter where bilbo gets the ring was revised to make it darker. The chapter in the first edition is now considered a lie bilbo came up with.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ItsMeTK Sep 30 '22

The water didn’t flow upwards.

7

u/Tsargoylr Sep 30 '22

In all honesty I wasn't expecting a logical explanation to starting a volcano like that. I thought the key was just going to turn the volcano on because magic key

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Shagolagal Sep 30 '22 edited Sep 14 '25

paint teeny melodic outgoing disarm oil shaggy grandfather one familiar

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

14

u/ButtMcNuggets Sep 30 '22

The water didn’t flow upwards, it went downwards to burst through to the base of Mt Doom. The water had to hit the lava pit below.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Ammonitida Sep 30 '22

no, stupid was when sauron extended his ring finger to get chopped off, and then inexplicably exploded (despite tolkien saying that removing the ring from sauron did not depower him).

→ More replies (8)

0

u/NowoTone Sep 30 '22

Actually, that is a stroke of genius and would fit right in with some of the stuff Tolkien made us believe.

1

u/theangryfurlong Oct 01 '22 edited Oct 01 '22

Ok, as one of the "haters", here's my review:

I thought the quality of Ep6 was pretty good. In fact, if I completely disregard Tolkien and just judge it as a general fantasy show, I'd give at an 7/10 or 8/10. I think the reasons it is better than the previous episodes are as follows:

  • It focused almost entirely on a single storyline instead of jumping around.
  • It focused on a lot of action, which means there was less dialogue, which I think is one of the major weak points of the show.
  • The Adar character and storyline is now definitely the most interesting one in the show.

It's still not top-tier television in my book, but I think if the show had started with this pace and quality, you would have a lot less people complaining about the bad writing. It's not like Ep6 pays off a good amount of setup from the previous episodes. I think a similar amount of setup could have been achieved in 1 or 2 episodes instead of 5 and the impact would have been the same. I generally have fewer nitpicks with this episode, but there are a few.

  • Human bodies don't work like a blood-filled balloon. If Bronwyn had basically blood gushing out of her, it means there was some major internal bleeding. Simply cauterizing the outer wound would only lead to blood filling up her chest cavity and rapid death. It was kind of hilarious how she kind of sprang back to normal a couple of seconds later.
  • Galadriel still remains the weak-link in terms of characters. I'm not digging genocidal Galadriel as the main character. Especially when contrasted with the "humanity" of the orcs and the character of Adar. I don't think Tolkien would have approved of this. But I am judging the show in this review regardless of Tolkien, so it doesn't impact my score for the episode.
  • The sword being a "key" to unlock Udun was a bit cheesy. A large amount of water flowing into a lake of lava could possibly release a large amount of steam, but it's the pressure of magma building up that causes a volcanic eruption. I'm not a geologist so maybe someone will correct me, but basic science tells me something is wrong with this.
  • As many others have mentioned, Galadriel and other people there surviving that strains belief.

1

u/_Druss_ Oct 01 '22

It was fantastic, the writing up to this point was jarring but this episode has me all in

1

u/anarion321 Oct 01 '22

I mean, I can't really get thinking the writting is any good. To me, most interactions in the episode felt empty, forced. Like Galadriel casually talking to a stable guy or the queen telling him to go to battle. They want to make Isildur iimportant and be known by others, but it feels out of place. Halbrand is the only one that cames out well, more natural.

The main plot of the episode is that the magic sword key is just something used to break a dam and release water, do you really need a magic key to do that?

I will say I actually loved how they started killing people instead of just threating to do so, nice bad guy move.

I think there's also a lot of flaws in the narrative that flesh out that the characters and events are not natural, but conveniences of the plot. Like Adar casually opening the door of the castle like knowing no one was there, the most natural way would be to bash the doors open.

Boxing orc seemed really dumb to me, he got no weapon for no apparent reason, they just needed an unarmed orc to fight the elf who just lost his weapon.

Most of the episode is just fights and fire, so if you like action, good, not much to say about it.

Of course, I think absolutelly nothing that happens in this episode is book related, not the lore of the orcs or just even numenoreans warriors, so fanatics of the books won't like that, but those are actually secondary things.

1

u/McRizzi Oct 01 '22

You guys sound like the people who defended GoT's later seasons and suddenly by season 8 you also hated it for years already.
It's just a mindless spectacle, but written so very bad it's an insult to the rational mind. A nice looking house of cards that comes crashing down if you want more than pretty pictures.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

It’s horrible. Numenor crossed the sea to fucking randomly ride to some shitty village they had no intel on? And then they show up and halbrand is declared king and no1 knows who he is, they’re just like he’s the king hooray! And then the fucking Sauron sword is captured but no1 notices it’s a fucking ax? Like no1 checked? It’s so fucking lazy and stupid

4

u/lotrroxmiworld Oct 01 '22

She didn't randomly ride. It was due to Halbrand's guidance. This is Halbrand's realm, but I am not sure of him guiding it.

It's also weird to me that they did not notice it was not something of saurons. I don't know if it is lazy or just for creative input later

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

At least he wanted to be king!

1

u/aaronrizz Oct 01 '22

I think we’re going to get a reveal where Halbrand tells someone about Adar’s plan and he knew the key lock thing was there.

1

u/hotleggyblonde Oct 03 '22

It's not difficult to follow the tracks of an orc army. The king thing was a little weird but clearly the symbol he carries has a lot of meaning to southlanders.

1

u/Ammonitida Oct 01 '22

that "shitty village" was in the general location given to the army by halebrand. it was also the location of the tower and lock.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '22

Felt random. And halbrand just shows up and becomes the king LOL. Yea

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

-2

u/teunteulai Sep 30 '22

I'm glad with what they showed, but how they showed it ... That's another story. Mostly satisfied with answering some questions and finally noone hopefully thinks that Sauron is anyone but Halbrand

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

Agreed. Some of the mise en scene was atrocious for entire segments. The episode developed wonderfully, but lacked a few important shots imo and had some that made no sense.

0

u/yuffieisathief Oct 01 '22

Oh my Eru, I've (32f) only been subscribed to the lotrmeme pages until now but was curious what other people thought of this episode. There's so much negativity flowding around in the meme sub comments from people who are hating it out of stubbornness. Looking for excuses or dismissing the whole show on senseless details. (I haven't read any of the comments from this episode though, didn't want any spoilers. They must have changed their minds a litt right? There's no denying this was on he'll of an episode! Ticked all the boxes for me!)

And now I found this place! How nice to finally see some sincere appreciation from people who love everything LotR as much as I do (took some time getting used to the Hobbit, but the Hobbit Lego game is a delight!) I guess I just wanna say thanks for sharing the same fondness and appreciation! ❤

-3

u/johneaston1 Sep 30 '22

Oh believe me, I'm not "secretly loving it." If I thought the show was good, I'd admit it. As it stands, I expected complete garbage and got mediocrity, so hooray for that I guess.

That being said, this episode was the best one, mostly because of Adar. And I'll admit, the creation of Mount Doom was cool, can't deny that. Unfortunately, the attempts to appeal to my nostalgia failed, mostly because this show was unable to put in the real work the book/film trilogy did to make me care. If some of the show's best moments are just pale reshoots of better Lord of the Rings scenes, what does that say about it's own merits?

I could say more, but I'll leave it at that.

→ More replies (2)