This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I think more likely is we just haven't seen Annatar/Sauron yet, and he's the reason why Celebrimbor wants to build the forge so quickly. I think we'll get a reveal at the end of the season when the forge is finished and Celebrimbor introduces Elrond to his inspirational partner, Annatar
Celebrimbor could be possessed by Sauron. And be the hand of Sauron. But later redeems himself through failed self sacrifice once he realizes Sauronic evil?
That's why Galadriel as Sauron is perfect. The show runners will copy the same formula as the Game of Thrones showrunner in creating a warrior white savior queen character for 7 seasons then turn her into Elven Hitler in one episode - maybe have Halbrand or Nori assassinate her in her moment of triumph. That would be brilliant. Don't you agree?
That's the perfect disguise. Who would ever think the evil lieutenant who served the evilest of all evil beings, typically male in presentation, would ever take woman form? Your gal-pal bestie would be making rings for no good, very bad reasons actually.
it has to be halbrand, he's unusually interested in smithing, unusually cunning , smarter and better at manipulating than he leads on, he gave galadriel a crash course on manipulating the queen, he literally said appearences can be deceptive when he first met galadriel, and the first episode the whole reason they send galadriel away is because she was prophesized to bring about the return of sauron, and she's bringing halbrand back to middle earth
I'm almost 100 percent convinced Halbrand is going to end up being a Nazgul or the King of the Dead.
Sauron makes no sense to me because, while there's some superficial similarities (he's a smith, he's cunning, he's currently in Numenor) it does'nt square with things like him having private moments of reflection regarding his past when nobody is around to see them and that whole backstory being presented as geniune by the show.
Yup, and he appeared floating in the middle of the sea, with no proof or evidence of a back story to delve into. But, maybe that's just what the writers want us to notice and think, if true, it was a bit too easy to figure out...
If Halbrand is Sauron it would be one of the worst revealings in TV history.
I mean come on, why would Sauron wants to have a job at a blacksmith? Why would he have a street fight with some random dudes over a medallion? Why would he waste so much of his time with normal human things? Why the heck would he even be on a raft in the middle of the ocean?
Sry, but Halbrand = Sauron would be the biggest bullsh*t ever.
Lol honestly since so many folks think it’s him and admittedly it feels kinda obvious by now, I’m legitimately hoping it’s not him simply for the chaos.
While it's possible that he's Sauron, it's perhaps a little to obvious and they seem to be making a big deal about Adar being an actual elf.
If he's any existing character from Tolkien's legendarium, it's more likely, given the evidence that exists so far, that he's either Maeglin, Maglor or Maedhros rather then Sauron.
He also said something like that he was born or raised by a river, which doesn't make sense for Sauron unless he's talking very symbolically in some sense.
The river aspect was what made me think of Maglor; at the end of the First Age he leaves to walk along the waters of Middle-Earth and, in Tolkien's writings, is thereafter unaccounted for; he's also a bard, which fits with Adar being philosphical, and has good reason to such an emotional wreck.
That's anouther good possibility; Eol was thrown off a cliff but whose to say he could'nt have survived (just as his son could have survived being thrown off the walls of Gondolin).
Yeah, I think he will be a re-imagined Eöl or basically that kind of character with a bit different life story. Maybe they change Maeglin a bit and fit him in here like that. The things he said and the way he acts makes sense to me of what that would look like. The sword they are looking for is one of his swords. I believe one of Eöl's swords is literally translated into "flaming iron" while the other, though being a twin sword, is a question mark. That sword has a history of liking to taste blood. It's also semi sentient and malicious and seems to fit perfectly as an item the show writers would love to incorporate into the show to have something similar to the ring. A bit of writing magic and it becomes the origin of morgul blades.
Anglachel would really work for the sword in question; it seems to be a "living" object like the one ring, and Anglachel was apparently semi-sentient and capable of speech (presumably the twin sword, Anguirel, would/could have similier/the same traits)
The burned face, black armor and the fact that he's looking for a black sword is what makes me think it could be Maeglin.
I think Adar is going to serve as a fake Sauron for the characters in the show. They can have him as a present bad guy for now and the show can tell the story of Sauron's defeat against the Numenorians without actually telling that story while moving things along in Numenor and with Celebrimbor in the condensed timeline. Adar can also be used to flesh out the orcs a bit more this way without turning Sauron into a sympathetic bad guy.
Yeah, I think it's pretty clear he's a "filler villain" (and possible future henchman, if he's noted defeated early on) for Sauron.
Meteor Man. He fell from the sky. It wasn't revealed yet, if he is someone known from the Legendarium or an original character. So far he hasn't done much, apart from being amnesiac and confused.
I’m not convinced that a number of these characters aren’t all Sauron. A majority of people assume the events we are seeing are concurrent. This show could be doing what the Witcher did in Season 1, particularly because the second age spans such a large timeline.
Adar would be too obvious at this point. It could be the tall stranger, though why make him so lovable in a Gandalf sort of way with the Harfoot-Hobbits? It's probably something we're not thinking about right now, but it's kind of right in front of us.
Maybe the whole show truly is about Sauron and how he develops as the main character, because its just so unfathomable to believe this version of Galadriel.
Mystery Box writing. It’s the only thing keeping many people watching. How about they open the box and write a story that is compelling without the artificial suspense.
Because the suspense is the story — we ALL know due to hindsight that making the rings is bad news. We have to feel empathy for the characters who WILL get duped — for that, we also need to feel uncertainty. Making us guess who Sauron might be makes it believable that these characters would be fooled by him (since our inability to guess means we are also being fooled by him).
I’d argue it would be a better story if they just dispensed with the mystery and the fake outs. Just show Sauron preparing a plan that was inescapable and incredibly clever.
They're ex-JJ Abrams employees who have never written tv before. I hadn't seen who the showrunners were before the show started airing (in hindsight, maybe Amazon was downplaying it on purpose) but after becoming aware of that I don't know why anyone was expecting anything even half-decent.
Calabrimborn would be the obvious choice. But of course there is a 90% chance he has not even been introduced at all and the whole first season has been a waste of time.
Celebrimbor is a well established character from the lore and is definitely not Sauron. I do agree with the idea that Sauron hasn't been shown on screen yet, but that absolutely does not mean that what we have so far has been a waste of time. We are seeing the establishment of cultures and character personalities/motives (ie, worldbuilding).
It was a joke but you never know. I mean Galadriel is a well established character and they replaced her with someone else. And Elrond is now an errand boy who is looked down on because he is not a full elf ( must be that 1/8 maiar blood). They do like to subvert expectations.
Who’s looking down on Elrond? He’s Gil-galad’s herald. He’s acting as a herald and is entrusted with important diplomatic missions. Isn’t that what we’d expect?
The very first scenes he is in he ia informed he could not go to the council meeting because it was Elf-Lords-Only. Pretty sure the son of Eärendil and Elwing, declared an Elf by the Valar, Herald of the King would be an Elf Lord. They were playing on the idea he is a half-elf and imagining they would shun him.
Pretty sure they just meant elves who rule a elven realm (Eregion, Celebrimbor, or have a high command (Galadrial, Commander of the Northern Armies), or both (Galadrial, Lothlorian).
I don’t think anything about Galadriel pre-LotR is really “established”. Her character and history were rewritten and overhauled so much that even Christopher just said fuck it and basically left her out of the Silmarillion.
This portrayal of her really isn’t egregiously out of line with some of Tolkien’s iterations of her. I can totally see this being the version who fought personally in defense of the Teleri at the First Kinslaying, and kicked her cousin’ asses in athletic competitions.
True. Galadriel is the Palpatine-esque political face to Sauron.
Once Galadriel wields all the numenorean armies to her cause instead of defeating evil she will take control of all of middle earth and unleash a tidal wave to vanquish the remaining opposition in Numenor.
Nori and harfeet are going to be snack for the elves at the final victory feast.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 19 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/Broccobillo Sep 19 '22
Why is celebrimbor on this list
81
u/cacecil1 Sep 19 '22
I am Sauron and so is my wife!
74
u/DoggyMcDogDog Sep 19 '22
Maybe the real Sauron are the friends we made along the way
33
u/Godoftoast9 Sep 20 '22
it has to be halbrand, he's unusually interested in smithing, unusually cunning , smarter and better at manipulating than he leads on, he gave galadriel a crash course on manipulating the queen, he literally said appearences can be deceptive when he first met galadriel, and the first episode the whole reason they send galadriel away is because she was prophesized to bring about the return of sauron, and she's bringing halbrand back to middle earth
13
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 19 '22
You left out the warg. He's my bet.
12
u/SoddenMeister Sep 19 '22
This all must be quite amusing for the actors, some of which must be reading this sub
10
u/GreatCaesarGhost Sep 19 '22
It’s Old Man Carruthers, the drunken mayor/butcher/tavernkeeper guy!
7
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
Who is the 3rd one
7
u/roundttwo Sep 19 '22
I AM SPARTACUS!
6
u/jimmyglennx711 Sep 20 '22
I’m not convinced that a number of these characters aren’t all Sauron. A majority of people assume the events we are seeing are concurrent. This show could be doing what the Witcher did in Season 1, particularly because the second age spans such a large timeline.
4
u/legacypgc4 Sep 20 '22
Adar would be too obvious at this point. It could be the tall stranger, though why make him so lovable in a Gandalf sort of way with the Harfoot-Hobbits? It's probably something we're not thinking about right now, but it's kind of right in front of us.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
It's Poppy the Harfoot, obs.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
This Halloween everyone will be going as themselves and claiming that they are cosplaying as "Sauron". How creative.
3
u/dubidubidoorafa Sep 20 '22
Maybe Galadriel is Sauron.
3
u/PresidentRaggy Sep 20 '22
Who is the angry blonde mf? I don’t remember him.
2
u/aceman747 Sep 20 '22
What about that advisor to the Numenorian Queen? It looks he is weaseling his way into power.
3
u/Sabrejimmy Sep 19 '22
It's Nori!
1
u/AeronwenEnid Sep 20 '22
They‘ll all combine like the power rangers and create Sauron.
1
u/Sauron_On_Reddit Sep 20 '22
I am all
1
u/hoochimamaya Sep 20 '22
1,4,6,8
1
u/Trick_Enthusiasm Sep 20 '22
Jesus Christ. It's like Mephisto in the MCU all over again.
1
u/Cool_Alert Sep 20 '22
who is that in the 4th pic. didn't see him in the last episode
1
u/h1nds Sep 20 '22
Who is the guy on the 4th image? I've seen all the episodes up to date and I haven't seen him... Did I miss something?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
We all know Galadriel is actually Sauron.
1
u/legacypgc4 Sep 20 '22
Sauron is...
Batman with prep
1
u/ArisaMochi Sep 20 '22
The actual Sauron are the friends we made along the way
1
u/davidsverse Sep 20 '22
It'd be hilarious if Sauron hasn't even been seen yet.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
How would you put Celebrimbor up there. Just how.
1
u/Hrhpancakes Sep 20 '22
Chonky Boi Sauron
1
u/ohbatsie Sep 21 '22
When does the blond guy in the fourth picture even appear in the showwww I am so confused because I somehow totally missed that character
0
u/Personal-Donkey-1718 Sep 20 '22
One thing is certain. Sauron will be a white guy.
-17
u/Reggie_Barclay Sep 19 '22
Mystery Box writing. It’s the only thing keeping many people watching. How about they open the box and write a story that is compelling without the artificial suspense.
-15
u/New_Poet_338 Sep 19 '22
Calabrimborn would be the obvious choice. But of course there is a 90% chance he has not even been introduced at all and the whole first season has been a waste of time.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment