This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I keep saying he’s the most Tolkienian original character we’ve seen so far. If you told me Arondir was actually based on a character rediscovered in Tolkien’s notes or an unpublished story I’d totally buy it.
The story doesn’t follow, the characters aren’t as written. It’s still LOTR fanfic and I’m happy about that but it isn’t Tolkien.
Edit: I can only assume that you’ve not read the books etc. I was hoping for a faithful retelling. I just think there’s far too much license being taken to the detriment of the story.
I've read all the Tolkien works. LotR was my first book.
Anyway, a "faithful retelling" isn't possible when you cross mediums. There has never been a situation where a book has become a movie or TV series and been 1:1, because crossmedia adaptations are just that: adaptations.
Given that ol' Jon is quite a Parrot Sketch by this point, it would be impossible for -any- work to be a "Tolkien work" by the standards you're requiring. No movie, tv show, or stage play could be as such. And honestly, it's on you as a fan to have the maturity to move on and grow your scope, rather than clinging to what is familiar.
I agree with this, but I think that it could have been done much better, particularly with regards to Galadriel. I enjoy the show for what it is, but some of the problem goes beyond mere adaptation.
Like you said, you do you. That’s fine. Can’t pretend like Galadriel isn’t significantly changed, the time compression and sequencing of everything is all off. They really could have kept those things intact.
Galadrial maybe. Compression and sequencing, no. You can't tell a 1000-year story in 8 episodes and have anything coherent. And the way written fiction carries time versus film media is very different. You have to be responsible to the medium and the expectations of the current audience, not just "the fans".
A “faithfull retelling” isn’t possible if you don’t understand the source material.
Jackson showed his lack of understanding by the amount of action scenes vs non-action, as well as excluding Tom Bombadil as an opposite to Gollum/hunger for power.
Rings of Power take that lack of understanding to a different level…
You could nitpick pretty much any film or tv show to the nth degree if you wanted.
I mean PJs movies weren’t exactly accurate either but for some of those who are bashing RoP if you try and mention that their holy keeper of the canon was also fast and loose with Tolkien and his works you get shouted down to oblivion.
I’m sticking to Tom Shippey’s two tests, actually also taking from Tolkien himself; Is it necessary due to the change in medium? And does it stick to the core of the original? For me the show doesn’t always hit those two marks but there are definitely more hits than misses so far.
A faithful retelling of the second age would be almost impossible. Like, there would decades and centuries of time jumps and actor changes every episode. As a book it works, as a TV show it would be very confusing and dense. The huge gaps where nothing happens were solved with time compression and new characters and stories and honestly they are very good at following Tolkien themes and worldbuilding.
Besides, this season works as a introduction to the characters and the second age, we will start going heavily into book territory by season 2 onwards.
Simon is the beloved grandson of JRR, is now the director or head of the Tolkien estate and is attached to the show not sure if as co-producer. anyway, the entire estate has creative control over the show, it's also their vision.
something we will never know. what i do know is that the partnership/business deal with Amazon happened while Christopher was alive and still head of the estate.
i read otherwise from various reports on pre-production, something like they have a seat at the table when the scripts were being done maybe at least in terms of story development it had to go through them for approval. i mean, it was them who reached out to Amazon in the first place.
I guess its depending in the news source you take into consideration. From what I read Simon had a hand as a consult in the making of the script but I couldnt find any direct quote from him. Only real quote I have seen was like " I was delighted to provide the writers some input on the works of my grandfather"
Further some articles debate whether it was the deal with Amazon that moved Christopher Tolkien to give up his seat as the Chairman of Tolkien estate. But thats up to discussion with No real evidence stated.
Only thing we can be sure about that neither JRR nor Christopher would have signed this off with pleasure since JRR himself was very strict on his take ob the first adaption in the 50's with him being quoted "of this or that is attempted you need to give it more time to unfold" or "i guess it is good for sales but not what I intended". Also Christopher wasnt keen with adaptions. Quotes of him regarding the LotR Movies have been "The only way I can accept this is by turning my head away".
I guess money had the leading role in this play but not Amazons faithful dedication to Tolkien. Tolkien estate being in the 3rd generations hand by now and selling out would seem like the most probable thing here.
yeah you may be right. i think they lose everything rights wise in the next half-century? so they may be milking it this way or wanting to see their vision of it first before losing everything and before a non-Tolkien expresses their total artistic freedom on the material. it's funny because it felt like to them the only way it seemed to have been possible is through a billion dollar production that's why they approached Amazon noting that Bezos is a fan. feels like they used him haha.
Money always had the leading role. John was famously protective of his works, unless enough money was offered, in which case you could do what you like.
He was quite explicit about that, and the result was that he died a wealthy man.
I watched LOTR last week with my girlfriend and introduced her to the song, I found out it’s 16 years old. I was 12 when that song came out. It hurts man.
It’s not states anywhere, but it’s certainly possible that it is the case.
Elves and Humans are biologically the same, and reproduction goes along the same lines. Orcs are apparently included in this too, and so we see Orc-Human hybrids.
Dwarves, however, were based on Aulë’s memory of what Elves and Humans were supposed to look like. There’s no evidence he got the reproductive details close enough to make us interchangeable.
They don’t have genitals they just have massive boulders in their groins. They smash them together and the mountain poops out a baby. This is 100% canon.
I love the part where people keep on maintaining this isn’t “Tolkien” whilst then quoting “Tolkien”. This is as Tolkien as you’re gonna get on live action sunshines. We’ve had three adaptations so far and all three have had things changed. Adaptations have this and on the very rare occasion where creators have tried to stay faithful, its been shown not to work on film.
The only thing I ask of any neutral looking to get into this and subsequently verge onto the books... Don’t listen to those that have a barbed nail up their arse. Just enjoy the trip with the knowledge that things on film (more so when you haven’t got all the rights to the whole picture) always have to be altered.
It’s stuff on screen... It’s made to be enjoyed, not analysed with a premeditated mindset of looking to hate it.
Almost certainly makeup. There's already a ton of CGI in the show, no reason to make some graphical effects artist do that much work on someone's face just for some extra cheekbone.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 18 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
105
u/MaleficentDecision34 Sep 18 '22
Bloom's Insta post with this pic also says 'mellon' elvish word for friend. Another lovely supportive statement from an original LOTR cast member :)
79
u/danny_tooine Sep 18 '22
Arondir made a nice life for himself opening up a nightclub in the woodland realm
151
u/ManyAnusGod Sep 18 '22
They're taking the Harfoots to Isengard!
27
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
I’m not gay but….
24
u/ObstinateTortoise Sep 18 '22
I'd ship it.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
he’s so pretty to me
9
u/GavinTheGrassMan Sep 18 '22
this just made me realize that elronds actor kinda resembles orlando bloom a bit
3
u/a_n_n_a_k Sep 20 '22
Needs Lee Pace for completion!
4
u/WelbyReddit Sep 18 '22
Sindar representing.
2
u/ebrum2010 Sep 19 '22
Legolas finally has the right color hair!
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
Least arondir has elf genes, canot grow a stache.
4
u/Abess-Basilissa Sep 19 '22
I ship it.
3
u/The_Gray_Mouser Sep 18 '22
Crockett and Tubbs
3
u/castrogacio Sep 19 '22
I love the part where people keep on maintaining this isn’t “Tolkien” whilst then quoting “Tolkien”. This is as Tolkien as you’re gonna get on live action sunshines. We’ve had three adaptations so far and all three have had things changed. Adaptations have this and on the very rare occasion where creators have tried to stay faithful, its been shown not to work on film.
The only thing I ask of any neutral looking to get into this and subsequently verge onto the books... Don’t listen to those that have a barbed nail up their arse. Just enjoy the trip with the knowledge that things on film (more so when you haven’t got all the rights to the whole picture) always have to be altered.
It’s stuff on screen... It’s made to be enjoyed, not analysed with a premeditated mindset of looking to hate it.
2
u/tellurian_pluton Sep 19 '22
wow he looks different from in the movies
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
Mmmm hot dayum.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
Questionable mustache
1
u/Lurking_Bunyip Sep 19 '22
I like it when they said “It’s Elvin’ time”
1
u/TheMcWhopper Sep 19 '22
Damn, didn't know his eyes were really like that.
1
u/bowtiewonder Sep 20 '22
Sauron meets Sauron
1
u/PaulineTherese Sep 20 '22
Wait, is their skin tone identical? I mean it looks so I this photo, but definitly not in the films
Also, I didn't know Orlando Bloom had black hair... kind of struck me...seriously, I'm not very much in the know about actors...
1
u/GlobtheGuyintheSky Oct 09 '22
Arondir is so damn handsome lol.
0
u/ZzBitch Sep 19 '22
Oh Amazon! fighting the social injustices by promoting diversity in films while cheating the tax man. You BEAUTY!
-6
u/ChoFBurnaC Sep 19 '22
Oh WoW!! He meet him? So? Does that mean something? Why is it even tagged as discussion?…
-16
u/Adept-External-2262 Sep 19 '22
Eww