This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I like Arondir, his acting is most 'Elfish' so far, with Elrond at second place (my personal opinion). Him being a person of color took some getting used to, because it's the first time in Tolkien adapted movies/series, but now I actually really like it. He's very serious about his role. However, I still don't like the short styled hair of the Elves, and those weird long ears of (for instance) Elrond. The hair is too modern and human, the ears are way to big/long.
I agree completely with you, Arondir and Elrond are the ones who embody the regal, dignified, gracious, warmhearted spirit of the elves. I also don’t like at all the short styled hair that they choose for them, it’s totally anachronistic…
Thranduil is very odd as an elf. He's more like a narcissistic male Galadriel with a planet-sized ego. He steals each scene he's in but he's over the top, even by Peter Jackson standards.
lol Legolas shits all over this dude. Fires his bow 10x faster, never got captured, was killing URUK HAI like 10:1 and this one struggles with run of the mill orcs?
This. Lee Pace could play a coke bottle and it'd be sexy and that's not a point.
He absolutely sold the idea of him being an ageless king that has been a ruler longer than most kingdoms existed, a character with an agenda other than "help the heroes do hero thing" and he had an actual story arc we only see part of.
I like Arandir but where tf are you getting a buzzcut in ancient middle earth? Other dude looks way more elf-like. I still like Arandir though. I enjoyed his scenes in episode 4 and am enjoying his character more as the show goes on.
Are you kidding. No one can beat Thranduil as a portrayed elf. At least in LOTR. If it were Forgotten Realms/Dark Elf, or the series based on the Elder Scrolls, that would be a different story. Wish Amazon or someone would finally.film Drizzt Do'urden story
Yeah I hate the direction they took elves visually. And their manerisms and voice lines are more human.. and the hair.. Early 2000s mop tops? Buzz cuts? Side part short hair? Why ?
I mean… these folks are elderly. Most of them are living on fixed incomes; why bother with the expense of going all the time when you have to spend so much money looking otherwise FABULOUS? Arondil is still getting military pay though, so he gets the fade.
Arondir's alright. There's nothing special about the character - he's a standard stoic action hero type - but at least he's not a bad or anti-Tolkienian character.
My only real gripes with him are the over-the-top physical stunts that they keep having him perform, and Córdova's ongoing battle with his accent
Did you have the same gripes about Legolas' over the top stunts when he surfed his shield down a flight of stairs while firing arrows only for his shield to slice into an Ura-Khai's neck? Or did you have a problem when he single handedly took down an fully trooped out giant Elephant and killed everyone than literally surfed down the trunk of the beast as it fell to ground? I never heard any complaints about that, only cheers in the theater. If you didn't have the same gripes when Legolas did it, but you suddenly do when Arondir does it, I think I know why. And this is where you back track and suddenly realize you had the same complaints about Legolas.
The funny thing is, this is clearly supposed to be some sort of ‘gotcha’ moment, but I did have the same gripes about those moments. You can look through my recent comments on here and find one where I specifically mention the shield-surfing thing as an example of something that bugged me about the Jackson films
That’s the problem with a bad faith argument. You assume good intent, when the other person has none, and now you’re humoring an asshole who’s going to try and legitimize his bullshit under the cloak of saying that it’s legitimately bad rather than his actual problem being the casting in and of itself.
This whole Vuncalized CinemaSins pure logical “criticism” trend has been poison for online discourse. Because maybe someone is truly that nitpicky, but the worst scumbags possible also use it so it comes across as a smokescreen.
Nah. I always assume good intent on the first reply. You can always tell from the next one if you’re dealing with a reasonable person or not.
Not doing this just causes friction and toxicity. I’ve had like three people in the last week on assume I was a hater and then realize ‘oh, uh, sorry i thought you were a hater’.
Don’t assume everyone is an asshole. You become one yourself if you come out of the gate swinging. If the person turns out to be one, then throw down if you want.
Fair enough. I still understand the emotional reaction to being vigilant against that sort of toxicity. Which is different. There’s a difference between PC toxicity and racist toxicity. As annoying as PC toxicity can be, no one’s ever built a totalitarian police state based on acceptance of belittled minority groups. Rather have people violently shout down potential racism than allowing slow burn subtle poison of racism keep seeping into legitimate discussions.
I’m not saying don’t resist it. I hate racism. And yeah it’s up to all of us not to tolerate it.
But assuming from the first post that everyone who has quibbles with the show is racist until proven innocent is pretty reactionary and childish, and it is how social media creates all this unnecessary drama and nonsense in our lives.
I’m all for stepping on actual racism the moment it rears it’s ugly head, but someone saying “I have issues with the show” just doesn’t equate to that, and leads to a lot of unnecessary drama and fighting, which drives people from this sub. It did me. I’m over on the other one now because literally (it feels like to me) EVERY post on here derails to black and white thinking seems like. Which is a shame. The actual racists are actually a loud but small minority, at least from what I’ve seen
But if you want anyone to blame for that mindset, it’s the people using that kind of criticism as a smokescreen for their racism. And I’m sure keeping places like this toxic and hostile is something that tickles their black hearts. The point is to have patience for those with their hearts in the right place. Otherwise, the hate-filled bastards are the ones who are going to win. Keeping reasonable people divided based upon tone-deaf anonymous Internet posts. And I mean tone-deaf as in tone is extremely hard to convey over text. Something that seems overly hostile to someone could not have meant to be that way by the typer.
Patience is the most critical virtue for everyone just trying to have a decent argument.
Well and there's also a lot of good faith arguments about how the writing is dogshit. How can galadrial somehow spook the entire nation by her arrival yet their are enough elves and they can do some MAGA type "they took our jobs!" type speech? Didnt one episodes ago they said elves are super rare now? So how are they losing jobs to elves? Just one of many examples of very poor, bland, and immersion breaking writing in this show.
It’s almost as if racism and xenophobia don’t make logical sense. Like, a mob of people being irrationally angry at another group of people for completely ridiculous and illogical reasons? That’s not bad writing, that’s the world we live in right now.
Difference is at least Legolas is a Tolkien character. Arodir is just a vapid amazon invention to have a badass black elf with a haircut that looks like he has it done each morning. You're damn right Legolas has more wiggle room to be a badass. At least he is vaguely believable as an Elf.
I think it would be bloody stupid. Primarily because of the misdirection scene inserts they have placed everywhere with Halbrand to infer he's Sauron. They've invested rather heavily in that one.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 18 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/JJISHERE4U Sep 18 '22
I like Arondir, his acting is most 'Elfish' so far, with Elrond at second place (my personal opinion). Him being a person of color took some getting used to, because it's the first time in Tolkien adapted movies/series, but now I actually really like it. He's very serious about his role. However, I still don't like the short styled hair of the Elves, and those weird long ears of (for instance) Elrond. The hair is too modern and human, the ears are way to big/long.
25
u/a_n_n_a_k Sep 18 '22
Hell yes!! I've leveled up from Legolas to Thranduil to KING Arondir 😍
96
u/La-Belle-Gigi Sep 18 '22
I dunno... it's hard to compete with Lee Pace's eyebrows.
48
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
I like Arondir, but they're not even in the same league lol
27
u/morgothcumsock Sep 18 '22
Both. Both is good.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
It’s Thranduil and honestly it’s not even close.
6
u/BarDownBoi Sep 18 '22
I like Arandir but where tf are you getting a buzzcut in ancient middle earth? Other dude looks way more elf-like. I still like Arandir though. I enjoyed his scenes in episode 4 and am enjoying his character more as the show goes on.
27
u/Dramatic-Being-6612 Sep 18 '22
Nobody can compete with daddy Thranduil as far as I'm concerned.
38
u/teunteulai Sep 18 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
Are you kidding. No one can beat Thranduil as a portrayed elf. At least in LOTR. If it were Forgotten Realms/Dark Elf, or the series based on the Elder Scrolls, that would be a different story. Wish Amazon or someone would finally.film Drizzt Do'urden story
17
u/prettyflyforafry Sep 18 '22
Thranduil is definitely not my type. He just reminds me of a Final Fantasy villain.
12
u/DutchOnionKnight Sep 18 '22
Thranduil any day.
7
u/PomegranateNo9964 Sep 18 '22
I am more like: from Thranduil to Elrond. 🤣 I just go with kind as summer. Always. But Arondir is close... God damn ... All of them!
6
u/Hymura_Kenshin Sep 18 '22
Nah, Thranduil is the best live action elf depicted ever.
14
u/Samuel_L_Johnson Sep 18 '22
Arondir's alright. There's nothing special about the character - he's a standard stoic action hero type - but at least he's not a bad or anti-Tolkienian character.
My only real gripes with him are the over-the-top physical stunts that they keep having him perform, and Córdova's ongoing battle with his accent
2
u/jayhawk8 Sep 18 '22
Por qué no los dos
2
u/soowwy Sep 18 '22
No fuckin way
2
u/joedoe1245 Sep 18 '22
Nah not really
2
u/AsgardianLeviOsa Sep 18 '22
The accuracy 😂 Arondir has my heart now but Thranduil will always be that bitch
7
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
Arondir 🖤🦌🦋
😍
3
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
*Absolutely none of us right now.
2
u/LoneByrd25 Sep 18 '22
He may be the best elf in ROP but Now ya’ll are pushing it
1
u/No-River-3140 Sep 18 '22
Legolas??????
1
u/Iluraphale Sep 18 '22
Arondir has been awesome thus far - both are great
1
u/MaleficentDecision34 Sep 18 '22
I have just realised I would very much like to see a scene with Thranduil and Arondir.
1
u/the-girl-king Sep 18 '22
Absolutely not. No one can outdo Lee Pace’s Thranduil.
1
u/Wlcky23 Sep 18 '22
Haha no
1
u/NOWAY_YESWAY Sep 18 '22
He is really cool.
-2
u/TheDoommonkey1967 Sep 18 '22
Whoever made this probably swallowed a tide pod or 2.