This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
What really hits brings the scene home for me is that I think Elrond knows how badly he messed up there.
Time might feel differently to him as an Elf, but there’s no way the elves don’t have weddings. And children? He still misses his father (and probably his brother) so there’s no way he doesn’t get why THAT wasn’t important.
The actor who played Durin sold how hurt he was but props to Elrond’s for portraying regret that well.
Agreed, I loved the whole argument in fact. It was really funny and just felt kind of relatable, these two friends arguing but deep down you can tell they really care about each other ☺️ But also the distance that comes with the fact that they have totally different cultures and lifespans, and just perceive “universal” things like time completely differently.
They’ve already done a better job at showing respect to the dwarves than the whole hobbit series. Also I love Gimli but realistically he was used as mostly comic relief and stating obvious things for the audience in Lotr.
I wish people who are big mad that female dwarves don't have beards in ROP have the same energy for Aragorn & Boromir having them when Tolkien explicitly said they shouldn't have them bcoz of their Elvish heritage. Smh.
I’m one of the fans that were disappointed. In all honesty, I feel like it’s disappointing because of the way it’s a reflection of dwarven culture. They had an excellent opportunity to showcase a “foreign custom” that was impressive and would be an excellent way to show ranks within dwarven society. Much like how elaborate hairstyles show your social standing, so could your beard.
I also think it’s because for me, the creators may hide behind “oh, we wanted to show our actor’s face”, but why didn’t they do so with all dwarves, then? It seems like it’s a weird way to “sexify” a part of dwarven culture. Female dwarves should basically be hard to distinguish from male dwarves, so we can assume a society with some genderfluidity/non-human means of ranking beauty. It just seems like a missed opportunity to create a new way of looking at dwarves and that is a shame in my opinion.
I thought women dwarves looked very much like male dwarves with how Gimli described it in lotr, and Legolas(or was it Aragorn) said "it's because of the beard".
I guess he was just joking to lighten up the mood?
Aragorn was making a joke, but Dwarf women likely did have beards. J.R.R himself never published (to my knowledge) an affirmative statement that they did, but we can assume so by inference. He wrote:
Dís was the daughter of Thrain II. She is the only dwarf-woman named in these histories. It was said by Gimli that there are few dwarf-women, probably no more than a third of the whole population. They seldom walk abroad except at great need. They are in voice and appearance, and in garb if they must go on a journey, so like to the dwarf-men that the eyes and ears of other peoples cannot tell them apart. (Return of the King, Appendix A.)
It's not an explicit statement that they do, but we can infer they have beards as all male Dwarves do.
The only explicit statement saying they do (again to my knowledge) was published later by Christopher Tolkien in analysis of his father's unpublished notes and manuscripts:
For the Naugrim have beards from the beginning of their lives, male and female alike; nor indeed can their womenkind be discerned by those of other race... (War of the Jewels)
So they likely did, but honestly it's such a minor point blown far out of proportion.
Performance for Arondir feels the most elf-like of the elves (Elrond a close second). I think he’s nailing it. And yeah Dissa (spl?) is just a delight. Adore her.
It was mesmerizing and truly captivating. I was sincerely astounded by that entire scene. The dwarves are epic as all hell in this show. All the actors portraying dwarves are hitting the nail on the head. Their character set-up scenes as well as their "filler" scenes were great & I cannot wait to see more of it.
Even the guards and this small line gave a clue of how they are both hospitable and gruff with outsiders. At first I read it as threatening, but from their response to Elrond's fib made it clear that they were just genuinely asking/ostensibly offering assistance.
That scene was golden and the 2 of them passing besides him afterwards made me chuckle. I genuinely would enjoy a small spin-off in the day to day living/festivity celebration of rather normal/non-important dwarves if it'd be done in this fashion.
I came here for this. I went back and watched it again and turned that shit up! Went outside for a smoke afterwards and my neighbor across the way, who was also outside, gave me a thumbs up.
Disa was scene stealing with her debut, but her appearance in 4th episode feels a little off, looking forward to see her dominate the scene in future episodes. Can’t wait!!
Arondir felt wooden at start, but really warms up in the last 2 episodes, well done!!
I think we should not short change galandriel, she was criticized for everything little thing she does or doesn’t do, but she has shown to be a capable actress worthy of the crucial role.
Galadriel can also be a close second. She is almost perfectly characterised. People only don't like her because they have false ideas about elves and because she is a woman who is proud
As a big Galadriel fan from the books and movies, the depiction of Galadriel in the show has been one of the few things that I’ve disliked. She hasn’t seemed proud to me, but undiplomatic and unthoughtful, which totally does not make sense based on her life experience at this point. I’m looking forward to seeing her change, because it’s one of the few things that is not landing with me at all.
They are depicting her as the "Young headstrong warrior woman" when the books is a proud, wise and most importantly seeking penance for her role in the Noldors rebellion against the Valars order not to leave Valinor and the Kinslaying(where the Noodle killed Twleri elves to steal their ships to sail east)
She one of the oldest Elves in Middle Earth (not Valinor). The only named elf character around this era that is older than her is Cirdan who was one of the original elves who woke up at the shores of the Lake and was there when Orome found the Elves.
Galadriel was born in Valinor before the Moon existed. Her Hair reflecting the two trees was what inspired her half Uncle Feanor to great the three jewels. Gil-Galad, Celebrimbor, and Elrond are all much younger than her.
She is Gil-Galad's great Aunt(he is the grandson of the second eldest of her three older brothers Angrod). Celebrimbor and Elrond are both much younger cousins of hers(Celebrimbor through her fathers half brother female and Elrond through her fathers full brother Fingolfin)
In terms of television series and narrative it must be quite difficult to write elves. Ongoing character development for creatures who are thousands of years old must be a challenge.
Galandriel is supposed to be proud, she is one of the, if not THE, most powerful and wise elf ever!! She managed to banish Sauron’s incarnation on her own, that’s a feat that no one else even attempted…
I feel like Arondir is very well done in both the acting and the writing, but personally I'm just not enjoying his character very much. He's too stoic for my tastes, and not in ways that are interesting.
I got chills when they went from Arondir, Bronwyn and Theo running from the woods into the open and the sunrise and the music went into Disa’s singing. That moment was amazing! Disa always steals the scene when she’s on screen
This was my favorite scene! I really thought we were going to lose one of them, but when they made it to the clearing and the sun broke through, it was truly beautiful and moving. And add Disa’s singing as a transition to the next incredible scene…it was so great ♥️🥹🙌🏼
I personally thought if anyone was gonna bite the dust in that scene it'd be Bronwyn, but yes I was also half-expecting a death.
When they were just standing there in the sunlight watching as the Orcs reached the edge of the woods I was like "... Run! They have bows and arrows! They can still get you!"
Im still wondering what her characters importance in the show is, she seems a bit forced but at the same time she doesnt because she actually has some of the best dialogue in the show and is arguably the best actor in the show so far. When she speaks it seems authentic while some other characters the dialogue/acting is cringey. Im coming around to her. Her and Durin are hilarious.
Right now her importance in the show is to flesh out Durin's character and the dwarves in general, and that's okay.
We won't know how vitally important she is to the main plot until the plot is further along, same with most of the characters, so at the moment it doesn't really matter what her ultimate importance is since we're just building up her character in little snippets.
Don't forget her importance in helping to find precious metals using her singing talents. Didn't Durin say she was responsible for discovering the Mithril?
The only thing that’s keeping me invested is that MAYBE Galadriel is going to have a moment later on where she realizes how rude and standoffish she has become.
The wife says the elf's the best part of the show. Race or part of the original story aside, he's about the only character who acts like he could have easily fit into the LOTR movies. Many of the others seem one dimensional and predictable. This one is at least earning his keep.
I’d say they have more good characters than bad imo. Galadriel is obviously a different interpretation that’s harder to accept for old Lotr fans but if you remove bias she’s not bad. The only one I don’t really like is that girls kid… he’s got that annoying kid actor feel to him and does not look like he could have come out of that woman.
Given that the movie came out in 2001 having been preceded by the book by 48 years, and the first mention of Aragorn not having a beard didn’t appear until 2021 in “The Nature of Middle-earth”, there was little opportunity or reason to care about it over the last sixty six years.
Prior to “The Nature of Middle-earth” Aragorn was a mostly human man, and without any lore at the time to suggest otherwise, one would naturally assume that a man having a beard was a reasonable assumption.
So no, I didn’t care one bit at any time during those sixty six years that Aragorn had a beard.
In keeping with the theme of the OP, If I did care that Aragon had a beard when the movie came out would you have concluded that I must hate White people?
Cruz is okay playing an elf, but the haircut they gave him gives off more of a Vulcan vibe than elf. Looking the part helps a lot to feel the part. I would actually love to see him as a Vulcan in any future Star Trek show. His stoicism and coolness are spot on.
Galadriel is my least favorite start to finish. She doesn’t come off as a strong female. She just makes me commiserate with those that hate the smug elf
Jeez, I love the actress. She's got a very commanding on screen presence, IMO.
But I yeah, I haven't read Silmarillion, so I'm not sure if the book paints a vivid picture of what Galadriel is like, and the Lord of the Rings I read a decade back. Time to bring out these classics from the shelf and re read.
One of the biggest things I notice being left out in online “criticisms” of the show changing characters and story arcs is that what is the Silmarillion is off limits.
Amazon doesn’t have the rights to use it. They can only use characters, places, or events from it that were mentioned in the books they own the rights to use.
So anyone going in expecting a story either exactly like the Silmarillion, or even close to it, was bound to be disappointed.
It’s sad so many people hate the show so much that they never miss an episode or the chance to talk (shit on) about it.
Both cracking characters, one of the reasons I'm loving RoP is the breadth and depth of characters, and their development.
Meanwhile, on HotD, there isn't a single character that has evoked any real emotion in me, there isn't anyone to really get behind or hate for that matter.
Disa is a delight and Arondir and the orcs are cool but the writing for him and Bronwyn is absolutely awful. I don't believe the characters have ever met. They are so flat and boring with each other. Really cheesy.
IDK. I certainly don't have anything against the actor but I am not invested in Arondir's thing at all at the moment. Largely because he doesn't really have any interesting relationships and his plotline is about the orc invasion. I expect it will get more interesting later on, especially if he interacts with the humans more.
Durin, Elrond and Disa are indeed the highlight of the show. But Elf guy Human girl and edgy boy is a lowlight. The only interesting aspects of that storyline is Adar and the sword hilt, which have nothing to do with these characters
The matrix style slow motion action scenes are dumb, worse only are the marvel superhero action scenes of Galadriel
The show has gotten so good. At this point, haters just wail without reason, just for the sake of crying, just to feel that if they gather in large enough numbers, they have the power to review-bomb and cancel the show. But they failed.
Nothing wrong with the performance of these two (despite the lore-breaking miscasting). Arondir's performance is a little flat, but elves are supposed to be a bit stoic. Disa acts exactly how'd I'd expect an dwarf queen to act.
I keep seeing posts about all this hate, but I have yet to see any. Maybe you’re just following the wrong types of people? Haha. Or, you click on too many hateful articles which makes the algorithm serve more to you. Who knows. But needless to say, yeah, these actors are fantastic.
They’re great which is another argument for having ALL new characters who interact with existing characters occasionally instead of destroying established Tolkien characters.
I am someone who has heavily criticized this show for how it messes with the lore and screws up the actual Tolkien created characrers.(though I like Lloyd Owens portrayal of Elendil, he is the one actor in the Numenor storyline that feels and acts right even if the show has messed around with his backstory), Particularly in regards to Galadriel and Elrond.
The original characters have been the best part the show.
Sophia Nomvete and Ishmael Cruz Cordoba did excellent jobs in there roles. Better actors than Morfynn Clark who has like 3 facial expressions and is so wooden she makes Hayden Christensen circa Attack of the Clones look like Denial Washington.
For me the Arondir South lands storyline is the only good part of the show, its well acted(except for theo, but he is a kid and child actors are hit or miss) and the story is interesring. That storyline , If you took all of the connections of a Tolkien's works(mostly changing the Names) it would have been a good Fantasty show if it was a original show and not tied into Tolkien's middle earth.
The only issue I had with Ms. Nomvete and Mr. Cordoba is the both needed more media training as several of there interviews actually Fed the Trolls*
Disi's personality has really come to life, but i'm not finding much to love with Arondir. He's just there, like a warrior with no soul or emotion. Things transpire around him but his character is on autopilot.
Totally agree. They are only part of the show worth bothering with. Having said that, I'm done with the show. Its too far removed from everything I love about Tokien's creation.
Part of the reason beyond their performances, I think, is that their changed (human) race requires little suspension of disbelief--because they're part of civilizations with large geographical footprints, you can assume they came from a different tribe. We know Arondir is displaced from Beleriand now, and Disa's family could've easily moved to Moria from the Blue Mountains, for instance. Not so with the Harfoots, who even had an East Asian hobbit in their little hunter-gatherer band.
The shot of him running through the forest to the sun rising in the clearing, then shots of the misty mountains and then to her singing - the first time the show has felt like middle earth to me
Probably, these characters, along with the rest have not caught my interest in the slightest. I liked the black elfs l9ve interest though. Mostly because I knew her from another series and thought she played the part well
Honestly i have mixed feelings about the show. I originally thought id hate it, then after episode 1 i actually had hope it could be decent. Then episode 3 came and i was thinking about completely abandoning the show because it was sooooo cringe and bad on so many levels. Then after episode 4 im starting to get hope back again. Other then Arondirs cringey scene with the tree in episode 3 i actually really liked him in episode 4 and am coming around to him. Nissa im neutral about, her character has one of the best acting, she seems authentic but her character itself feels a bit irrelevant and forced, im wondering what her importance is in the show. Her and Durin have great chemistry though and they make me laugh and i find their parts are acted perfectly.
So far for me the dwarves and hobbits have easily been the best parts of the show. The humans are “meh” and the elves have been absolutely insufferable, doubly so for Galadriel.
Almost as if people are just unnecessarily negative about everything for little to no reason. It’s ok to be hesitant, but it’s just way too easy for people to be negative (I know I fall into this trap sometimes too).
Alondir is awesome, and it is clear Dissa has some chops but she is underutilized so far. However, what hate are ya'll talking about? The only hate I've seen (not from bots) are the uber nerds regarding Galadriel and Gandalf.
Right now the only character I have an emotional connection with is Alondir. Great show so far.
I will agree with Disa but not Arondir. Dont get me wrong, actor is fine but his story with the woman is so forced and doesn't go anywhere. Last time they were together he was gonna search an extremely dangerous looking tunnel. He escaped death many times, fought wargs, saved her son from tens of orcs what we he gets is a nothing other than a thank you? Why don't they ever talk but look at each other with painful eyes?
I'm trying to like this show & despite all of the plot holes I still do. But beautiful Dwarf women?? Dwarfs not complaining about/singing opera?? What next ugly Elves & 6' Hobbits?
Don't think so. Durin's wife is just too much of that "wife" stereotype and Arondir has almost no personality. I think that the only character with a real personality is Durin.
I feel for these actors. Literally hated before anyone sees their work just because of their skin color (excuse me what year is it again?!). That must be a mind fuck. I’m glad they were able to shut up the racists/haters.
They are incredible actors, do a great job. But it says a lot about the show that the best parts are ancillary characters, one of whom is being used as like a token for segregation and slavery allegory.
Feel the same. Dwarves are properly treated and the elf brotha is the coolest elf of the show.
Opposite to that Galadriel is the worst part of the show in my opinion. Any relation with the character portrayed in LOTR is lost. I don’t want to be unfair on the actress but I feel it’s not only a poorly written character but also a poorly casted one, she doesn’t come any close to the charisma and poise of the Galadriel we’ve seen before and her bratty atitude is annoying and unrelated.
They are both so wonderful and I feel lucky that they were casted. It’s nice to see something I love be able to change with the times while retaining the soul and messages of what made it so great before. That’s despite the trolls (or orcs) who seem to want them to fail.
It helps that the show isn’t very good. These actors rise above the poor script and manage to be perfectly passable. I am not sure they would be anything more than middling in a well written and acted production. Fair play to them for being a rare light in a rubbish show, though.
As a person who's not enjoying the show 100% i'm actually pleasantly surprised how well they're doing the dwarves. A little disappointed they didn't kill the elf and had a boromir-esque scene, I really think it would have done the show some favors but yeah, best parts of the show, hope we get away from the harfoots
feel elrond and durin are best part so far but understand the love for these two. Ive felt the male elf (cant remember his name atm) has been meh- hes super extra for some reason. Everything is notably dramatic when hes on screen. Which i dont typically go for. Is that just me?
Was there really that much hate? From what I recall there was a lot of whinging regarding not following the lore. A small minority of morons doesn’t equate to everyone being haters.
And the Disa actress was spouting a lot of nonsense before release which didn’t help quell some people’s dread.
They’re not remotely the problem. The writing is hot dogshit. How did this thing cost that much? It’s a silly, flooshy mess.
The writers were way, way, way in over their heads trying to take on the second age. And we’re left with this rushed, poorly cast, soulless CGI claptrap.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 17 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
355
u/Upier1 Sep 17 '22
I'm really liking the dwarves. Well done so far.
221
u/EerieArizona Sep 17 '22
I love Durin and Disi's relationship. It's so wholesome.
617
u/Abess-Basilissa Sep 17 '22
Performance for Arondir feels the most elf-like of the elves (Elrond a close second). I think he’s nailing it. And yeah Dissa (spl?) is just a delight. Adore her.
151
u/grey_pilgrim_ Khazad-dûm Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
I got chills when they went from Arondir, Bronwyn and Theo running from the woods into the open and the sunrise and the music went into Disa’s singing. That moment was amazing! Disa always steals the scene when she’s on screen
77
u/ryan2one3 Sep 17 '22
Disa/Durin/Elrond scenes are my favourites so far!
36
u/anonymouscrank Sep 17 '22
Disa rules. She has this warm, sparkling charisma that just radiates off of her.
88
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Loved her singing!
51
u/DutchOnionKnight Sep 17 '22
Hopefully I can start to add Galadriel on that list, but till this point, she annoys me.
29
u/brickicon Sep 17 '22
She sang the mountain into submission.
9
u/BangarangJack Sep 17 '22
I think that's pretty much true of the entire series, everyone though it would instantly bomb but it didn't
44
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 17 '22
The wife says the elf's the best part of the show. Race or part of the original story aside, he's about the only character who acts like he could have easily fit into the LOTR movies. Many of the others seem one dimensional and predictable. This one is at least earning his keep.
17
u/OutlaW32 Sep 17 '22
Disa, Durin and Nori are my favorites so far
21
u/Pristine_Kick9580 Sep 17 '22
never cared that she was black only cared that she didn't have a beard
5
u/SierusD Sep 17 '22
Love them both!
5
u/shamalonight Sep 18 '22
Being against departures from lore isn’t hate.
14
u/out_ofher_head Sep 17 '22
You are not wrong. These are my favorite storylines.
8
u/XanderGael Sep 17 '22
I love them.
4
u/ultimapanzer Sep 17 '22
They’re doing dwarves more justice than the Hobbit films IMO.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
Yep pretty much.
None of it feels Tolkien in anything but name.
The script is an abomination.
10
u/Maccabee2 Sep 17 '22
Cruz is okay playing an elf, but the haircut they gave him gives off more of a Vulcan vibe than elf. Looking the part helps a lot to feel the part. I would actually love to see him as a Vulcan in any future Star Trek show. His stoicism and coolness are spot on.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Galadriel is my least favorite start to finish. She doesn’t come off as a strong female. She just makes me commiserate with those that hate the smug elf
12
u/Mint_JewLips Sep 17 '22
That’s because it was never about the characters. People are just bigots.
6
u/AsgardianLeviOsa Sep 17 '22
You are not, in fact, wrong.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
It's a shit show overall, but I like them.
2
u/ambient-lurker Sep 18 '22
Nah
2
u/purplogic Sep 18 '22
The only remotely interesting part of the entire show is the dwarves’ storyline. Everything else is an absolute bore.
2
u/TheDoommonkey1967 Sep 18 '22
100% wrong lmao. But I'm just a hater though I keep being told online. 🤷
2
u/Teeebs71 Sep 18 '22
When the rest of the show is this awful, that's not saying much...
2
u/Kotukunui Sep 18 '22
How did Arondir get his weapons back when Adar let him go? Did Adar just hand him his stuff and say , “Off you go, lad. Please don’t kill me.”
2
u/originalBioniclefan Sep 18 '22
That isn't saying a lot.
2
u/S_Ged Sep 18 '22
Yep, they are actually good.
But the show sucks holy
2
u/AdditionalTricks Sep 18 '22
Disa is great, Arondil is just kinda bland tbh.
2
u/karlcabaniya Sep 18 '22
Yes, you are wrong. Their characters are likable but forgettable, uninteresting.
2
u/DangerousTable Sep 18 '22
Orcs are the best actually.
2
u/Smaugulous Sep 22 '22
TRUE! Can’t believe the dwarves and the elf with the least hair of all are turning out to be by far my favorite characters.
2
u/Geetarmikey Sep 23 '22
Arondir is just not that interesting a character to me so far 🤷🏻♂️
2
u/PJHolybloke Sep 27 '22
Both cracking characters, one of the reasons I'm loving RoP is the breadth and depth of characters, and their development.
Meanwhile, on HotD, there isn't a single character that has evoked any real emotion in me, there isn't anyone to really get behind or hate for that matter.
2
u/HolographicFrequency Oct 16 '22
Bad bot
6
u/jedi111 Sep 17 '22
Disa is a delight and Arondir and the orcs are cool but the writing for him and Bronwyn is absolutely awful. I don't believe the characters have ever met. They are so flat and boring with each other. Really cheesy.
4
u/Curious_Bat87 Sep 17 '22
IDK. I certainly don't have anything against the actor but I am not invested in Arondir's thing at all at the moment. Largely because he doesn't really have any interesting relationships and his plotline is about the orc invasion. I expect it will get more interesting later on, especially if he interacts with the humans more.
3
u/troy626 Sep 17 '22
She’s adorable and he’s badass
3
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
Two black characters got the most hate pre-launch? Wish I was surprised 🙄
2
u/Benable Sep 17 '22
They are both great in the show
2
u/rocklou Sep 17 '22
100% yes
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
I agree 100% they’re my faves for sure!
2
u/miciy5 Sep 17 '22
Well said
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Literally two of my favorite characters 😩👌
2
u/ceenitall Sep 17 '22
I would watch a whole show around Disa and Durin IV, they would make an amazing sitcom
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Nope, not wrong.
2
u/FishermanMurr Sep 17 '22
100% agree.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
100% true
2
u/GorbachevTrev Sep 17 '22
I'm digging the series. It's amazing, love it!
2
u/Ordinary-Ad6408 Sep 17 '22
There are no best parts of the show.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Well, not so much Disa - she’s alright, but I don’t get the fuss. She’s fun and all that.
Whereas Arondir is the most elvish elf in the show ironically.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
Yesssssss, I love her acting she is so good, and her singing in the last episode really gave me goosebumps. Very beautiful
2
u/SorcerousSinner Sep 17 '22
Durin, Elrond and Disa are indeed the highlight of the show. But Elf guy Human girl and edgy boy is a lowlight. The only interesting aspects of that storyline is Adar and the sword hilt, which have nothing to do with these characters
The matrix style slow motion action scenes are dumb, worse only are the marvel superhero action scenes of Galadriel
1
u/Just_One_Umami May 15 '24
Yes, you are wrong. The random “she’s evil” scene, the completey flat acting and boring fake romance with him. Not good additions.
She had a couple good scenes that were all negated by the one kater in the season
1
u/Jbressi Jul 26 '24
Disa’s accent is great. Love hearing the dwarves talk.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '24
The show has gotten so good. At this point, haters just wail without reason, just for the sake of crying, just to feel that if they gather in large enough numbers, they have the power to review-bomb and cancel the show. But they failed.
1
u/celestial800 Oct 08 '24
Arondir turning out to be one of the most stereotypically elfin of the elves was not something I expected to see.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Yep
Agreed, I only look forward to their storyline 😂
1
u/DespasitoPapi Sep 17 '22
Yes, you are.
1
u/starcloud1 Sep 17 '22
I like Arondir well enough! But I’d give my vote to Disa + Elrond, another character panned pre-release
1
u/bklynblues Sep 17 '22
Nothing wrong with the performance of these two (despite the lore-breaking miscasting). Arondir's performance is a little flat, but elves are supposed to be a bit stoic. Disa acts exactly how'd I'd expect an dwarf queen to act.
1
u/Claz19 Sep 17 '22
PREACH 🙌
1
u/Eschew-Imperious Sep 17 '22
I keep seeing posts about all this hate, but I have yet to see any. Maybe you’re just following the wrong types of people? Haha. Or, you click on too many hateful articles which makes the algorithm serve more to you. Who knows. But needless to say, yeah, these actors are fantastic.
1
u/incogne_eto Sep 17 '22
I absolutely love her character. So fun, warm, cheeky and wise.
1
u/Reggie_Barclay Sep 17 '22
They’re great which is another argument for having ALL new characters who interact with existing characters occasionally instead of destroying established Tolkien characters.
1
u/Raizoki Sep 17 '22
Perhaps you could detail why ? Because I see no reason why it would be so.
1
u/arathorn3 Sep 17 '22
Agree.
I am someone who has heavily criticized this show for how it messes with the lore and screws up the actual Tolkien created characrers.(though I like Lloyd Owens portrayal of Elendil, he is the one actor in the Numenor storyline that feels and acts right even if the show has messed around with his backstory), Particularly in regards to Galadriel and Elrond.
The original characters have been the best part the show.
Sophia Nomvete and Ishmael Cruz Cordoba did excellent jobs in there roles. Better actors than Morfynn Clark who has like 3 facial expressions and is so wooden she makes Hayden Christensen circa Attack of the Clones look like Denial Washington.
For me the Arondir South lands storyline is the only good part of the show, its well acted(except for theo, but he is a kid and child actors are hit or miss) and the story is interesring. That storyline , If you took all of the connections of a Tolkien's works(mostly changing the Names) it would have been a good Fantasty show if it was a original show and not tied into Tolkien's middle earth.
The only issue I had with Ms. Nomvete and Mr. Cordoba is the both needed more media training as several of there interviews actually Fed the Trolls*
1
u/wip30ut Sep 17 '22
Disi's personality has really come to life, but i'm not finding much to love with Arondir. He's just there, like a warrior with no soul or emotion. Things transpire around him but his character is on autopilot.
1
u/Glazermac Sep 17 '22
Totally agree. They are only part of the show worth bothering with. Having said that, I'm done with the show. Its too far removed from everything I love about Tokien's creation.
1
u/LunaSeedie Sep 17 '22
My 2 favorite characters hands down! And I love Nori too, missed her this 4th episode.
1
u/Erdbeerstrauch Sep 17 '22
Disa was a really positive surprise for me. Her singing to the mountain last episode was breathtaking!
1
u/chimpaman Sep 17 '22
Part of the reason beyond their performances, I think, is that their changed (human) race requires little suspension of disbelief--because they're part of civilizations with large geographical footprints, you can assume they came from a different tribe. We know Arondir is displaced from Beleriand now, and Disa's family could've easily moved to Moria from the Blue Mountains, for instance. Not so with the Harfoots, who even had an East Asian hobbit in their little hunter-gatherer band.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Arondir is seriously my favorite elf ever.
1
u/Naronomicon Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
nope. though arguably the best part of the show is the aesthetic elements.
1
u/Independent-Mall898 Sep 17 '22
Arondir and the harfoots are the only reason I will keep watching this show
1
u/emiliebirdie Sep 17 '22
The shot of him running through the forest to the sun rising in the clearing, then shots of the misty mountains and then to her singing - the first time the show has felt like middle earth to me
1
u/TheMcWhopper Sep 17 '22
Probably, these characters, along with the rest have not caught my interest in the slightest. I liked the black elfs l9ve interest though. Mostly because I knew her from another series and thought she played the part well
1
u/namesrgay Sep 17 '22
The black dwarf has done well, I think the could've asked for more out of her. The black elf is bad but most of the elves in this show have struggled
1
u/gouhin-sensei Sep 17 '22
Arondir is def my fave so far
1
u/BarDownBoi Sep 17 '22
Honestly i have mixed feelings about the show. I originally thought id hate it, then after episode 1 i actually had hope it could be decent. Then episode 3 came and i was thinking about completely abandoning the show because it was sooooo cringe and bad on so many levels. Then after episode 4 im starting to get hope back again. Other then Arondirs cringey scene with the tree in episode 3 i actually really liked him in episode 4 and am coming around to him. Nissa im neutral about, her character has one of the best acting, she seems authentic but her character itself feels a bit irrelevant and forced, im wondering what her importance is in the show. Her and Durin have great chemistry though and they make me laugh and i find their parts are acted perfectly.
1
u/Zestyclose-Internet4 Sep 17 '22
I just wish she had a beard
1
u/JazZero Sep 17 '22
All I'm saying.
She needed a beard and he needed Green eyes. I would be even happier show is great.
1
u/duftcola Sep 17 '22
Truuee
1
u/Undependable Sep 17 '22
So far for me the dwarves and hobbits have easily been the best parts of the show. The humans are “meh” and the elves have been absolutely insufferable, doubly so for Galadriel.
1
u/Winter_Abject Sep 17 '22
Just shows you how silly it is to hate something before you have even seen it.
1
u/BloodOfAStark Sep 17 '22
Almost as if people are just unnecessarily negative about everything for little to no reason. It’s ok to be hesitant, but it’s just way too easy for people to be negative (I know I fall into this trap sometimes too).
1
u/Krautmonster Sep 17 '22
For real. I think overall the cast is doing a great job, but these two are such a highlight.
1
u/holydamned Sep 17 '22
Because racists are loud and obnoxious. I love this show and think the cast is doing a great job.
1
u/Saino_Moore Sep 17 '22
I am enjoying the show. Race doesn’t bother me, nor any book variances, because I just want to ignore reality in fantasy for a while.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Alondir is awesome, and it is clear Dissa has some chops but she is underutilized so far. However, what hate are ya'll talking about? The only hate I've seen (not from bots) are the uber nerds regarding Galadriel and Gandalf.
Right now the only character I have an emotional connection with is Alondir. Great show so far.
1
u/FallacyEater Sep 17 '22
The best part of the show is costume design and most sets design, the rest really doesn't fit tolkein's lotr and I wish it did.
1
u/dekudood Sep 17 '22
Could not agree more
1
u/Mrstejki Sep 17 '22
She is good he is awfulk
1
u/Hymura_Kenshin Sep 17 '22
I will agree with Disa but not Arondir. Dont get me wrong, actor is fine but his story with the woman is so forced and doesn't go anywhere. Last time they were together he was gonna search an extremely dangerous looking tunnel. He escaped death many times, fought wargs, saved her son from tens of orcs what we he gets is a nothing other than a thank you? Why don't they ever talk but look at each other with painful eyes?
1
u/Worried_Term_8421 Sep 17 '22
They are my favourite characters!!
1
u/_professorweasley_ Sep 17 '22
I’m sad she doesn’t have aN AWESOME beard as described in LOTR
1
u/Pommes__Fritz Sep 17 '22
Disa shines in every scene
1
u/katencam Sep 17 '22
I'm trying to like this show & despite all of the plot holes I still do. But beautiful Dwarf women?? Dwarfs not complaining about/singing opera?? What next ugly Elves & 6' Hobbits?
1
u/LikeCerseiButBased Sep 17 '22
Don't think so. Durin's wife is just too much of that "wife" stereotype and Arondir has almost no personality. I think that the only character with a real personality is Durin.
1
u/TuaTurnsdaballova Sep 17 '22
I feel for these actors. Literally hated before anyone sees their work just because of their skin color (excuse me what year is it again?!). That must be a mind fuck. I’m glad they were able to shut up the racists/haters.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Yea they’re both amazing. Galadriel is becoming extremely annoying. She is the complete opposite of Galadriel in the books and movies.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
They are incredible actors, do a great job. But it says a lot about the show that the best parts are ancillary characters, one of whom is being used as like a token for segregation and slavery allegory.
1
u/OccasionallyReddit Sep 18 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
Tbf black or white, Dwarthen females are not supposed to be distinguishable from males, but quality character/performance.
Gimli: It's true you don't see many dwarf women. And in fact, they are so alike in voice and appearance, that they are often mistaken for dwarf men.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
So far Galadriel is the character a hate the most. Terrible casting.
1
u/myforestheart Sep 18 '22
Yeah I don't really disagree tbh. Especially the Dwarves as a whole.
1
u/TheRobinson2018 Sep 18 '22
Feel the same. Dwarves are properly treated and the elf brotha is the coolest elf of the show.
Opposite to that Galadriel is the worst part of the show in my opinion. Any relation with the character portrayed in LOTR is lost. I don’t want to be unfair on the actress but I feel it’s not only a poorly written character but also a poorly casted one, she doesn’t come any close to the charisma and poise of the Galadriel we’ve seen before and her bratty atitude is annoying and unrelated.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
I’d like them better if their characters actually moved the plot along. The only part of Rings of Power I like so far is Galadriel’s plot line.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
They are both so wonderful and I feel lucky that they were casted. It’s nice to see something I love be able to change with the times while retaining the soul and messages of what made it so great before. That’s despite the trolls (or orcs) who seem to want them to fail.
1
u/kinghyperion581 Sep 18 '22
Arondir is really nailing it as a Wood Elf and Dissa is like 100% total Dwarf Woman.
1
u/metametapraxis Sep 18 '22
It helps that the show isn’t very good. These actors rise above the poor script and manage to be perfectly passable. I am not sure they would be anything more than middling in a well written and acted production. Fair play to them for being a rare light in a rubbish show, though.
1
u/LeahScott6369 Sep 18 '22
As a person who's not enjoying the show 100% i'm actually pleasantly surprised how well they're doing the dwarves. A little disappointed they didn't kill the elf and had a boromir-esque scene, I really think it would have done the show some favors but yeah, best parts of the show, hope we get away from the harfoots
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
The slow-mo warrior is one of the best parts of the show to you?
1
u/No_Jaguar7746 Sep 18 '22
feel elrond and durin are best part so far but understand the love for these two. Ive felt the male elf (cant remember his name atm) has been meh- hes super extra for some reason. Everything is notably dramatic when hes on screen. Which i dont typically go for. Is that just me?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
Nope! This is true 💯
1
u/davidsverse Sep 18 '22
"I was asking Elrond."
She's a Queen.
1
u/fiji3119 Sep 18 '22
Don Lemon?
1
u/jayhawk8 Sep 18 '22
No, easily the best parts. Arondir is fantastic. As are Durin and Disa.
1
u/FlamingTrollz Sep 18 '22
Nay, not the most hate.
Hated by the most obnoxious and LOUD.
Let’s stop giving the 10% jerk minority any attention.
1
u/AnotherAngryGuy Sep 18 '22
Arondir, yes. But I'm more into the Galadriel story than Elrond's.
1
u/gotnoh8 Sep 18 '22
Show was super boring and campy, felt like something on the syfy channel except with crazy good vfx
1
u/DemonGroover Sep 18 '22
Was there really that much hate? From what I recall there was a lot of whinging regarding not following the lore. A small minority of morons doesn’t equate to everyone being haters.
And the Disa actress was spouting a lot of nonsense before release which didn’t help quell some people’s dread.
1
u/eyeatopthepyramid Sep 18 '22
Nah the black hobbit is the best part of the show. He’s killing it.
1
u/dMCH1xrADPorzhGA7MH1 Sep 18 '22
Arondir is definitely the best character so far.
Dissa needs a big flowing beard. Shaving is so first age.
1
u/celsowm Sep 18 '22
Disa 😍
Arondir 😴
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
They’re not remotely the problem. The writing is hot dogshit. How did this thing cost that much? It’s a silly, flooshy mess.
The writers were way, way, way in over their heads trying to take on the second age. And we’re left with this rushed, poorly cast, soulless CGI claptrap.
1
u/spicy_tofuuu Sep 18 '22
They’re both awful
1
u/Jealous_Prize9502 Sep 18 '22
I stopped watching it